Split Thread Monopolies and Government Regulation

And there we have it: you're asking me for evidence that the world isn't black-and-white.

Have fun with your high-contrast reality.

And I had to prove to someone yesterday that obstruction of justice doesn't include lying to the press. Part of being here is the agreement that we sometimes have to back up claims we find self evident.
 
And I had to prove to someone yesterday that obstruction of justice doesn't include lying to the press. Part of being here is the agreement that we sometimes have to back up claims we find self evident.

The problem is that you're asking for something that's nonsensical. You said that monopolies don't exist outside of government regulation, and now you're asking me to show that they are less likely in a well-regulated environment. Which is it?
 
The problem is that you're asking for something that's nonsensical. You said that monopolies don't exist outside of government regulation, and now you're asking me to show that they are less likely in a well-regulated environment. Which is it?

I would like to see something that supports your assertion that this isn't black and white. I'm not just going to take your word for it.
 
Yeah, how about we see something that supports your assertion that it is?

I mentioned two specific classic anti trust cases arguing that they simply are not monopolies in the length of time as an antitrust case.

It's not a lot of evidence (this is still a forum for fun, after all). But it is more than zero.
 
Did you just admit that you presented bad evidence?

Of course. Anyone can rate my evidence however they want. I'm not going to argue with them about that. I may argue if they make an argument about my evidence. But people calling my evidence bad doesn't hurt my feelings. See the torture thread where I repeatedly point out it is fine to call my evidence bad.
 
Even in standard neoclassical models which assume prefect competition, rational expectations, absence of intrinsic differences among agents, perfect capital markets etc., it's formally shown that when lifting any of such unrealistic assumption concentration tend to increase, often rapidly. Stiglitz formally showed as much already in the 1960s and -70s.

Empirically it's shown that the wave of deregulation beginning in the 1990s has led to an increase in market concentration of publicly traded firms. Just look, for example, at the trend in the banking sector since the 90s; where in the 1980s top 10 bank holding companies held about 20 percent of bank assets… a share which after deregulation rapidly grew to about 50 percent.
 
No, it does not.

Actually, it does. The natural trend of normal market will be to get a monopoly over time. Once that monopoly get big enough it can entrench , simply when a new comer is there, it can under price the new comer until it dies, then go back to normal prices. So even if you lived in an utterly government free utopia, monopoly would still happen.
 
Even in standard neoclassical models which assume prefect competition, rational expectations, absence of intrinsic differences among agents, perfect capital markets etc., it's formally shown that when lifting any of such unrealistic assumption concentration tend to increase, often rapidly. Stiglitz formally showed as much already in the 1960s and -70s.

Empirically it's shown that the wave of deregulation beginning in the 1990s has led to an increase in market concentration of publicly traded firms. Just look, for example, at the trend in the banking sector since the 90s; where in the 1980s top 10 bank holding companies held about 20 percent of bank assets… a share which after deregulation rapidly grew to about 50 percent.

Banks, even under current laws, have large barriers to entry created by the government (my point in post 4). Of course deregulating the banks will allow existing banks to concentrate while maintaining the government barriers to starting new banks.
 
Actually, it does. The natural trend of normal market will be to get a monopoly over time. Once that monopoly get big enough it can entrench , simply when a new comer is there, it can under price the new comer until it dies, then go back to normal prices. So even if you lived in an utterly government free utopia, monopoly would still happen.

But when and where has that actually happened? Someone cited luxottica as a monopoly, but warby Parker is valued at 1.2 billion in 5 years of operation and seems under no threat from predatory pricing.
 
Banks, even under current laws, have large barriers to entry created by the government (my point in post 4). Of course deregulating the banks will allow existing banks to concentrate while maintaining the government barriers to starting new banks.

Why do you think the entry barriers remained the same during the period of bank industry deregulation? Moreover, that's only one industry. Market concentration has been ongoing across most industries.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom