Split Thread Monopolies and Government Regulation

Oh, so you're unaware of the existence of monopolies and trusts?

No wonder you think eliminating all regulations is somehow a miracle cure. You don't know squat about the topic.

Im very aware of monopolies which is why I'm confident in my side. There have not really been sustained monopolies unless the government propped them up. Even the most famous ones lost market share before government intervened.
 
Are you arguing that monopolies don't emerge in the private sector or that they don't continue forever?

They do not continue forever, and they seem to often already to be on their way out by the time antitrust laws are used.
 
So your logic is that if monopolies can result from too much regulation, they cannot result from too few?

Correct-ish. I'm not saying it hews close to free market theory, but only that it clears the very low bar of being better than the government regulation scenario. In the case of monopoly, the question is are monopolies sustainable longer than the length of time of an anti trust case.

For monopoly, we are looking for price setting and locking out competition. For standard oil, prices plummeted by 2/3rds during their rise to 90% market share. At their peak in 1901 at 90%, to before their breakup in 1911, their market share plummeted down to 60%. That looks a lot like losing to competitors (your mileage may vary on the impact of other regulation during that time).

Someone above mentioned making the laws better to have them intervene earlier. To paraphrase an a-hole, you make law with the government you have, not the government you want. I just don't think that is a reasonable expectation. I think these cases will just be as disable as the Microsoft Internet explorer fiasco.
 
Ah, that's very convenient, then. It allows you to ignore the lessons of history and the stuff we know from experience and instead favour any crazy theory that suits your fancy.

As I said, good luck with that.

Your knowledge of the history is right there with "Columbus proved the earth was round." I know why you think that, but it isn't an accurate picture.

I gave you the standard oil and Microsoft example. What part of the history there do you disagree with?

Heck. Pick a monopoly, any monopoly.
 
Last edited:
Your knowledge of the history is right there with "Columbus proved the earth was round." I know why you think that, but it isn't an accurate picture.

I gave you the standard oil and Microsoft example. What part of the history there do you disagree with?

Again, you're operating under a black-and-white mentality, where if monopolies are made possible with government regulations, they are impossible without them. The truth is that there's a healthy middle there, and straying to much for it creates fertile ground for abuse in both cases.


And Columbus was an idiot.
 
Again, you're operating under a black-and-white mentality, where if monopolies are made possible with government regulations, they are impossible without them. The truth is that there's a healthy middle there, and straying to much for it creates fertile ground for abuse in both cases.


And Columbus was an idiot.

Please give an example in the healthy middle.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom