[Moderated]"We just want a new investigation"

When people are investigating certain events there is likely to be disagreements over the most likely explanation.

Unfortunately, EVERY singe truther has a different conclusion. None of them can come to a consensus, and they don't actually make any effort to validate their opinions. It's less like investigations and more like inquisitions.
 
BTW, there is sufficient evidence (pre-9/11) that the fireproofing as it was originally applied was, shall we say, not very well installed. That's what happens when you hire a subcontractor owned by John Gotti
 
Last edited:
LC what is the matter with you? Is this what you do when you run out of material? Hell, after going through this Quintiere stuff AGAIN and how his concerns about the NIST report have NOTHING to do with CD, perhaps we can talk about 'Pull it' some more.

Do you ever come with anything other then your pretend debunking of CD? Talk about running out of material. All you have is this CD argument that has never really been debunked. Now I never mentioned CD. I said the NIST investigation was inadequate. Is Quintiere giving a shining review of NIST like you like to do? Does Quintiere agree with your apologies for NIST?

I think all of you are the ones out of material. Time to start posting pictures of cats. Do something you’re good at.
 
LastChild:
Dr Quintiere thinks that the fires were hotter (than NIST thought) and the towers would have failed with no insulation damage. He thinks they let the developers of the hook on having to pay for more fire protection.

LIVE WITH IT!
 
Do you ever come with anything other then your pretend debunking of CD? Talk about running out of material. All you have is this CD argument that has never really been debunked. Now I never mentioned CD. I said the NIST investigation was inadequate. Is Quintiere giving a shining review of NIST like you like to do? Does Quintiere agree with your apologies for NIST?

That's a nice attempt at being disingenuous. The problem is, this is the Conspiracy Theories forum, not the Criticising Results of Government Sponsored Investigatory Bodies forum. Now, your comments on the validity of the NIST report fall into one of two categories.

(a) They are connected with some theory in which the collapse mode of the towers is relevant to the existence or nonexistence of a conspiracy, in which case you are being dishonest when you imply that your never having mentioned CD is somehow relevant.

(b) They are not connected with any theory in which the collapse mode of the towers is relevant to the existence or nonexistence of a conspiracy, in which case they are off-topic for this forum and shouldn't be discussed here.

So either admit that you're trying to undermine the credibility of the NIST report in order to bolster the credibility of a conspiracy theory concerning the collapse mode of the twin towers, or take your discussion to a more appropriate forum.

Dave
 
Originally Posted by LastChild
Now I never mentioned CD. I said the NIST investigation was inadequate
______________________________________________________________________

In all sincerity, what are you looking for here at JREF? You don't convince anyone and no one convinces you. What exactly are you hoping to gain?
 
Originally Posted by LastChild
Now I never mentioned CD. I said the NIST investigation was inadequate
______________________________________________________________________

In all sincerity, what are you looking for here at JREF? You don't convince anyone and no one convinces you. What exactly are you hoping to gain?
Attention
 
Last edited:
Do you ever come with anything other then your pretend debunking of CD? Talk about running out of material. All you have is this CD argument that has never really been debunked. Now I never mentioned CD. I said the NIST investigation was inadequate. Is Quintiere giving a shining review of NIST like you like to do? Does Quintiere agree with your apologies for NIST?

You are using Quintiere's disagreements with NIST as evidence your disagreements with NIST are valid. His are rational and in no way, shape, or form evidence of ANY 'inside job' by the government. Your disagreements, however, are based on ignorance and ideolgical bias.

Your views are well known; you don't have to 'mention' anything for us to know what you are doing. You want to argue on this forum that the NIST was TOO conservative in its treatment of fireproofing and that part of it needs to be re-investigated? Sure thing, have at it. Use Quintiere.

Otherwise get your own experts; Quintiere isn't on your side at ALL.
 
Last edited:
Twinstead:
I think Dr Quintiere is suggesting an inside job of sorts (not like the "truthers" hoped). He believes NIST was pressured to down play the importance of stricter fire codes (costly to developers) due to the strong lobby the developers have. He suggest the towers could have failed by fire alone and thinks much stricter codes should be recommended. This would of course add millions to building costs and would make NIST very unpopular to the people they need to relate the most. He thinks they missed the perfect opportunity to get the codes in place while the attention was on the disaster. Classic missed opportunity as far as he's concerned.
 
Last edited:
Twinstead:
I think Dr Quintiere is suggesting an inside job of sorts (not like the "truthers" hoped). He believes NIST was pressured to down play the importance of stricter fire codes (costly to developers) due to the strong lobby the developers have. He suggest the towers could have failed by fire alone and thinks much stricter codes should be recommended. This would of course add millions to building costs and would make NIST very unpopular to the people they need to relate the most. He thinks they missed the perfect opportunity to get the codes in place while the attention was on the disaster. Classic missed opportunity as far as he's concerned.

Thanks. That's a good way of summarizing it for me. I find it funny that either LC doesn't understand Quintiere's issues at all and thinks he is evidence of the truther type inside job, or knows exactly what Quintiere's issues are but thinks that it must be a slippery slope from the politics Quintiere is accusing the NIST of playing to covering up the mass murder of thousands of people by the government.

Either way is wrong, IMO.
 
Originally Posted by LastChild
Now I never mentioned CD. I said the NIST investigation was inadequate
______________________________________________________________________

In all sincerity, what are you looking for here at JREF? You don't convince anyone and no one convinces you. What exactly are you hoping to gain?

There is nothing to gain from the so-called debunking here at JREF. It's a waste. I’m just doing the same thing I’ve always done. The debunkers claim to know what happen on 9/11. They base this claim in a large part on the 9/11 commission report and the NIST report. Both of which I claim are inadequate as far as getting to the bottom of exactly what happen leading up to and on 9/11.

I have posted quotes from insiders of both the 9/11 commission as well as NIST to support this claim. I have posted statements from experts who also have a problem with the official explanation into 9/11. I am continually told here that a vast consensus of experts agrees with these reports. I have asked for public statements from said experts to support this vast consensus. I get nothing but lame excuses and apologies for these investigative bodies. That and the occasional cartoon or cat.

Now I don’t have an alternative theory as to what happen on 9/11 nor do I need one to point out why your theory is inadequate. However I will commit to this. There was a concerted effort by this present administration to first deter from any investigation at all and even when they did finally give in it was only in support of a limited investigation. I feel they were mostly concerned with both avoiding accountability for not protecting the US on 9/11, as well as trying to limit any kind of litigation that could arise because of the attacks. In my opinion these investigations you point to as an explanation mostly exist only to serve those interests.

A tactic I use here a lot is to take the debunker argument on just about anything and put a mirror up to it. None of your theories seem to do well under your own standards and that is what bothers you most about me. I am called a troll when I give the debunker back the equivalent of what they offer.

Pretending to debunk an uninvestigated theory does not make your conspiracy theory valid by default. It’s a waste of time.
 
There is nothing to gain from the so-called debunking here at JREF.

Boy ain't that the trooth! Debunking is like trying to teach my dog poker, it dosen't matter how long I go at it or how hard I try it's never going to understand.
 
There is nothing to gain from the so-called debunking here at JREF. It's a waste. I’m just doing the same thing I’ve always done. The debunkers claim to know what happen on 9/11. They base this claim in a large part on the 9/11 commission report and the NIST report. Both of which I claim are inadequate as far as getting to the bottom of exactly what happen leading up to and on 9/11.

I have posted quotes from insiders of both the 9/11 commission as well as NIST to support this claim. I have posted statements from experts who also have a problem with the official explanation into 9/11. I am continually told here that a vast consensus of experts agrees with these reports. I have asked for public statements from said experts to support this vast consensus. I get nothing but lame excuses and apologies for these investigative bodies. That and the occasional cartoon or cat.

Now I don’t have an alternative theory as to what happen on 9/11 nor do I need one to point out why your theory is inadequate. However I will commit to this. There was a concerted effort by this present administration to first deter from any investigation at all and even when they did finally give in it was only in support of a limited investigation. I feel they were mostly concerned with both avoiding accountability for not protecting the US on 9/11, as well as trying to limit any kind of litigation that could arise because of the attacks. In my opinion these investigations you point to as an explanation mostly exist only to serve those interests.

A tactic I use here a lot is to take the debunker argument on just about anything and put a mirror up to it. None of your theories seem to do well under your own standards and that is what bothers you most about me. I am called a troll when I give the debunker back the equivalent of what they offer.

Pretending to debunk an uninvestigated theory does not make your conspiracy theory valid by default. It’s a waste of time.

We don't have a conspiracy theory, we have research by many , many people to arrive at the best possible conclusion available. If you don't think the conclusions reached so far are accurate then why aren't you trying to do something about it other than just tell us that our conclusions are wrong? Telling someone they are wrong but not being able to tell them why is arrogant. I don't believe that there will ever be another investigation as no one has ever been able to bring forth anything that warrant it. Could it happen? Yes, if something substantial comes to light but nothing has so far and it doesn't seem that you are interested in really looking for anything along those lines. I have seen many a JREF member admit when they are wrong on a topic when it was pointed out to them. I ask you, is there anything you and JREF's agree about concerning 9/11. Maybe common ground on just one thing may help us both.
 
Now I never mentioned CD. I said the NIST investigation was inadequate.

Oh OK. I get it now.

All this time it sounded like you were arguing that a CD took place on 9/11, when it fact you simply want better fireproofing codes. :rolleyes:
 
Oh OK. I get it now.

All this time it sounded like you were arguing that a CD took place on 9/11, when it fact you simply want better fireproofing codes. :rolleyes:
Well he's got one hell of an up-hill battle ahead, Just ask Dr Quintiere. Them money men (developers) are the ones that dictate how buildings are constructed now-a-days.:jaw-dropp
 
Last edited:
There is nothing to gain from the so-called debunking here at JREF. It's a waste. I’m just doing the same thing I’ve always done. The debunkers claim to know what happen on 9/11. They base this claim in a large part on the 9/11 commission report and the NIST report. Both of which I claim are inadequate as far as getting to the bottom of exactly what happen leading up to and on 9/11.

I have posted quotes from insiders of both the 9/11 commission as well as NIST to support this claim. I have posted statements from experts who also have a problem with the official explanation into 9/11. I am continually told here that a vast consensus of experts agrees with these reports. I have asked for public statements from said experts to support this vast consensus. I get nothing but lame excuses and apologies for these investigative bodies. That and the occasional cartoon or cat.

Now I don’t have an alternative theory as to what happen on 9/11 nor do I need one to point out why your theory is inadequate. However I will commit to this. There was a concerted effort by this present administration to first deter from any investigation at all and even when they did finally give in it was only in support of a limited investigation. I feel they were mostly concerned with both avoiding accountability for not protecting the US on 9/11, as well as trying to limit any kind of litigation that could arise because of the attacks. In my opinion these investigations you point to as an explanation mostly exist only to serve those interests.

A tactic I use here a lot is to take the debunker argument on just about anything and put a mirror up to it. None of your theories seem to do well under your own standards and that is what bothers you most about me. I am called a troll when I give the debunker back the equivalent of what they offer.

Pretending to debunk an uninvestigated theory does not make your conspiracy theory valid by default. It’s a waste of time.

Don't let me stop you from alerting the authorities.
 
LastChild:
Dr Quintiere thinks that the fires were hotter (than NIST thought) and the towers would have failed with no insulation damage. He thinks they let the developers of the hook on having to pay for more fire protection.

LIVE WITH IT!

Well, we certainly can't do anything about the president of the company that installed the fireproofing, he was wacked in the garage of the WTC in the early 80's. fugetaboutit.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom