[Moderated]"We just want a new investigation"

Who says it wasn't real? I am not saying for one minute that planes did not hit those towers nor that they weren't AA11 and UA175. What I am saying is that there are a lot of fishy things involved in what occurred on 911 and that they don't seem to all be explainable in an easy innocent way. For instance, the molten metal in the rubble, the collapse of WTC7, etc.

My point here should not be offensive. I would say that sadly your friend was murdered. The question is by whom.
19 terrorist did 9/11. If you deny this without real evidence, are you being disrespectful?

19 terrorists did it (evidence proves it), and you blame other people (do not deny this, you are a member of a group who blames other people for 9/11), and you do that with zero evidence. You disrespect those who died by publishing an error ridden (you still have errors when they have been pointed out), politically biased paper in a journal that is promoted by a people who spread disinformation on 9/11. What outstanding professional qualities are you displaying?

Your point that you promote is you have no evidence to point out the fishy stuff, you just make it up without evidence to do so.
 
"Spoliation of a fire scene is a basis for destroying a legal case in an investigation. Most of the steel was discarded, although the key elements of the core steel were demographically labeled. A careful reading of the NIST report shows that they have no evidence that the temperatures they predict as necessary for failure are corroborated by findings of the little steel debris they have. Why hasn't NIST declared that this spoliation of the steel was a gross error?" - James Quintiere, Ph.D., former Chief of the Fire Science Division of the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
So we're back to Dr. Quintiere again, are we? I think I have the Troof movement figured out - it's the same set of arguments, lies, deceptions, half-truths, non-truths, non-events, and mined quotes recycled so that each one comes back up as the primary argument for the day about once every six or seven months.

ZZzzzzz.


Is Dr. Quintiere a Troofer? Does he subscribe to even one conspiracy fantasy? No?
 
So we're back to Dr. Quintiere again, are we? I think I have the Troof movement figured out - it's the same set of arguments, lies, deceptions, half-truths, non-truths, non-events, and mined quotes recycled so that each one comes back up as the primary argument for the day about once every six or seven months.

ZZzzzzz.


Is Dr. Quintiere a Troofer? Does he subscribe to even one conspiracy fantasy? No?

Well it's not a conspiracy theory that the NIST investigation was inadequate and needs to be reviewed. It's just a fact. Try to keep up.
 
SO I see LastChild is another one who obviously didn't bother to even read the NIST report which he is is blasting.

Man, if these guys would bother to read, they would see how absurd some of these claims are.
 
SO I see LastChild is another one who obviously didn't bother to even read the NIST report which he is is blasting.

Man, if these guys would bother to read, they would see how absurd some of these claims are.

Oh I read it and I suppose you did also and now you know better then Quintiere huh? Does NIST employ many people who are prone to be wrong?
 
...Man, if these guys would bother to read, they would see how absurd some of these claims are.
Not necessarily, he would need to be smart enough to understand it. But if he was smart enough to understand it, he wouldn't be a CTist.

Oh, there is no way LC read NIST, none.

Notice his comment about Quintiere? The real issues Quintiere has with NIST have been pointed out to him numerous times. He just ignores them. Reading comprehension problems? Intellectual dishonesty? Troll? Maybe, probably, definitely.
 
Last edited:
I think I have the Troof movement figured out - it's the same set of arguments, lies, deceptions, half-truths, non-truths, non-events, and mined quotes recycled so that each one comes back up as the primary argument for the day about once every six or seven months.



Yes, you've got it. The twoof movement meets the shampoo industry:

Rinse
Blather
Repeat
 
Oh I read it and I suppose you did also and now you know better then Quintiere huh? Does NIST employ many people who are prone to be wrong?

See... this is where I get confused. Are the authors of the NIST report shills or not? Was the NIST report a whitewash or not? Can we trust anything that Dr. Quintiere says, considering his role in the cover-up?

How come CTers are always citing people and organizations that they have elsewhere claimed to be complicit or somehow compromised?
 
Wow, LC actually has the nerve to claim that he read it after the statement he made which is so easily refuted by the report he is making a claim about? That's kinda like me saying the Bible doesn't address Jesus.

I hereby claim this thread as an official state of Shenanigans. All those in favor say aye.
 
Oh I read it and I suppose you did also and now you know better then Quintiere huh? Does NIST employ many people who are prone to be wrong?

What does Quintiere say caused the towers to collapse, LC?

C'mon....you can say it :D
 
I agree with LastChild. I demand that NIST recruit a panel of top experts in structural engineering, fire protection engineering, dynamic modeling, metallurgy, and numerous other relevant disciplines, to evaluate building performance issues related to 9/11.

Oh, wait...

Okay, then, I demand that NIST publish the entire report and make it available free of charge, so that any expert in a relevant field anywhere in the world can review it and, if they see fit, challenge its findings.

Oh, wait...

Okay, then, I demand that universities, independent researchers, technical journalists, and the popular press conduct their own independent investigations of such aspects of the disaster are within their purview.

Oh, wait...

Okay, I demand that reality be adjusted to match my beliefs!

(Whew, I wish I'd just said that in the first place. It would have saved a lot of trouble and arguing.)

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Okay, I demand that reality be adjusted to match my beliefs!

"I think the official conclusion that NIST arrived at is questionable," explained Dr. Quintiere. "Let's look at real alternatives that might have been the cause of the collapse of the World Trade Towers and how that relates to the official cause and what's the significance of one cause versus another." - James Quintiere, Ph.D., former Chief of the Fire Science Division of the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST),

What was that you were saying?
 
Last edited:
What does Quintiere say caused the towers to collapse, LC?

C'mon....you can say it :D

Just read what he says...

"Dr. Quintiere then presented his and his students' research that contradicts the NIST report and points to a different cause for the collapses; the application of insufficient fire-proofing insulation on the truss rods in the Twin Towers. "I suggest that there's an equally justifiable theory and that's the trusses fail as they are heated by the fire with the insulation intact. These are two different conclusions and the accountability for each is dramatically different," "

How many equally justifiable theories are there to the NIST theory? Why so open for discussion?
 
Last edited:
the application of insufficient fire-proofing insulation on the truss rods in the Twin Towers

Hmm that sounds remarkably like the NIST theory that there was insufficent fireproofing on the trusses due to it being dislodged by the shock of the impact.
 
"I think the official conclusion that NIST arrived at is questionable," explained Dr. Quintiere. "Let's look at real alternatives that might have been the cause of the collapse of the World Trade Towers and how that relates to the official cause and what's the significance of one cause versus another." - James Quintiere, Ph.D., former Chief of the Fire Science Division of the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST),

What was that you were saying?

"This collapse mechanism conclusion has profound influence on the recommendations brought from this investigation. The airplane-caused column collapse theory yields significantly, and almost diametrically, opposed recommendations than the fire induced truss collapse mechanism." - James Quintiere, Ph.D.​

I think he was saying something about how reality is Quintiere arguing that NIST has not satisfactorily resolved the question of whether the collapse was primarily caused by airplane-caused column collapse or fire induced truss collapse, and alteration of reality is you implying that the fact that Quintiere has narrowed his analysis down to these two possibilities supports your belief it was neither.​

Dave​
 
Last edited:
LC what is the matter with you? Is this what you do when you run out of material? Hell, after going through this Quintiere stuff AGAIN and how his concerns about the NIST report have NOTHING to do with CD, perhaps we can talk about 'Pull it' some more.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom