[Moderated]"We just want a new investigation"

What world are you living in right now?

You know what the alternative explanations for those collapse initiations are. It doesn't seem that NIST or anyone else has an innocent explanation for the unusual flame and molten metal pouring out of the corner of the South Tower just before it collapsed. It also doesn't seem like there is an innocent explanation for the molten metal in the rubble yet either.
I said realistic hypothesis. Got one?

Find that "Histories mysteries" program yet?
 
Last edited:
Maybe they didn't save everything because they didn't plan for the silly questions put forth by complete lunatics?

Or maybe somebody figured they could pull the wool over the eyes of the public. It isn't lunatic thinking that expects a failure analysis to use the physical evidence.
 
Last edited:
Maybe I missed something here. I am not aware that flight 93 had a controversial collapse. You are comparing apples to oranges.

This is post hoc reasoning.

The investigators couldn't possibly know what was going to be trawled over on the internet several years later.

If they had all the steel in a big box with a ribbon on it, people would focus on something else.

If five planes had flown into one of the towers and sliced it clean in half, people would still say the collapse was anomalous.

They got as much information as they deemed necessary at the time. As we have an explanation accepted by ~100% of engineers worldwide, the working hypothesis is that they got enough information, or wasted their time and got too much.
 
This is post hoc reasoning.


They got as much information as they deemed necessary at the time. As we have an explanation accepted by ~100% of engineers worldwide, the working hypothesis is that they got enough information, or wasted their time and got too much.


A proper failure analysis requires the physical evidence. NIST said the amount they got was not representative which means they didn't think they got all of the physical evidence they needed to draw conclusions from it.
 
The real shame is the continued perpetuation of myths by people with far less training and education then those who contributed to NIST.
 
The real shame is the continued perpetuation of myths by people with far less training and education then those who contributed to NIST.

NIST itself doesn't feel they got all the physical steel evidence they needed to draw conclusions from.

Who got rid of over 99% of the fire affected area steel and why?
 
Last edited:
You do know that WTC steel is still around, right? Try hanger 17 at JFK Airport.

Sure I know there is some WTC steel in that hangar, but it isn't the steel from the fire affected areas, which would have been pertinent in the failure analysis.
 
Sure I know there is some WTC steel in that hangar, but it isn't the steel from the fire affected areas, which would have been pertinent in the failure analysis.
Could that be because it couldn't be positively identified (it's location in the building that is)? NIST said that didn't they Tony?
 
Could that be because it couldn't be positively identified (it's location in the building that is)? NIST said that didn't they Tony?

The columns had their location numbers stamped in them and they had unique wall thicknesses depending on their vertical location in the towers. It strains credulity to think the stamped numbers were obliterated but even if they were you have the wall thickness to go by.

There simply isn't any excuse for NIST not getting all of the steel from floors 93 through 98 in WTC1 and 78 through 83 in WTC2. I don't believe it was NIST themselves who were responsible for not saving the steel. Who was should be the subject of an investigation.
 
The columns had their location numbers stamped in them and they had unique wall thicknesses depending on their vertical location in the towers. It strains credulity to think the stamped numbers were obliterated but even if they were you have the wall thickness to go by.

There simply isn't any excuse for NIST not getting all of the steel from floors 93 through 98 in WTC1 and 78 through 83 in WTC2. I don't believe it was NIST themselves who were responsible for not saving the steel. Who was should be the subject of an investigation.
So Tony, when is the "truth" movement going to tell us how it was done? You've had lot's of time to work out the same details the perpetrators must have figured out. I'd love to know why they chose to crash the planes into different floors.
 
So Tony, when is the "truth" movement going to tell us how it was done? You've had lot's of time to work out the same details the perpetrators must have figured out. I'd love to know why they chose to crash the planes into different floors.

You should ask when those responsible for holding a real investigation are going to find out and tell us how it was done. The first thing I would like to see examined, with individuals put under oath, is why the steel, from the fire affected areas, wasn't saved for NIST.
 
Last edited:
You should say when are those responsible for holding a real investigation going to tell us how it was done.

They already did to the best of their ability with what information could be collected. The burden of proving something isn't on NIST anymore, it's on you.
 
You should ask when those responsible for holding a real investigation are going to find out and tell us how it was done. The first thing I would like to see examined, with individuals put under oath, is why the steel, from the fire affected areas, wasn't saved for NIST.
Should I take this as a "I have no idea how it could be done just not the way it's been explained so far, don't ask me why"?
 
They already did to the best of their ability with what information could be collected. The burden of proving something isn't on NIST anymore, it's on you.

Are you saying that an investigation shouldn't be done to find out who made the decision to recycle the fire affected area steel without saving it for NIST to evaluate?

That decision violated protocol of the fire code and those responsible for enforcing that should investigate the matter. See NFPA 921.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFPA_921

Also see the sub link about Fire Investigations and conducting them

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Origin_and_cause_investigation
 
Last edited:
Are you saying that an investigation shouldn't be done to find out who made the decision to recycle the fire affected area steel without saving it for NIST to evaluate?

That decision violated protocol of the fire code and those responsible for enforcing that should investigate the matter. See NFPA 921.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFPA_921
That only applies to arson investigations when the cause of the fire is unknown. Nice try though.

FYY; NFPA is not a regulatory agency they only make recommendations.
 
Should I take this as a "I have no idea how it could be done just not the way it's been explained so far, don't ask me why"?

I have my own thoughts about it of course. However, I am not an empowered investigator am I? I don't have subpeona power do I? Your comments can't be taken as genuine here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom