[Moderated]"We just want a new investigation"

There are many people investigating the events of 9/11; Steven Jones, David Ray Griffin, Richard Gage, Jim Hoffman, Paul Thompson, Nafeez Mosaddeq Ahmed, Barrie Zwicker, Peter Dale Scott etc.
You picked the people in the world, and their followers, who have zero evidence to back up or prove the lies and false information they spread. It does take some knowledge of 9/11 to understand these guys have no evidence. Where does that leave you? You have chosen poorly.
 
Nevertheless, I hope we can do better than NIST. The NIST report states that their report, "does not actually include the structural behavior of the tower after the conditions for collapse initiation were reached..."

They also stated in a response to a Request for Correction that, "We are unable to provide a full explanation of the total collapse."

Because that's not what their job was.

They determined what caused the collapse to begin, that's the important part. Providing a detailed analysis of what happened during the collapse would be nearly impossible.
 
tanabear you aren't even understanding what your arguing. NIST isn't saying they don't know why the collapse initiated, they're saying they didn't study the behavior during the collapse itself. Once the collapse started, the building, well, COLLAPSES, right?

Exactly why to you think NIST would try to study something they weren't tasked to study in the first place? To satisfy future irrational conspiracy theorists, just in case?
 
Who are they?

Well, Jones mentioned a few names in the interview. It can be found on 911blogger, 3rd page I think. I must admit he isn't very transparent about "the investigative team". I still haven't finished watching it though.
 
They also stated in a response to a Request for Correction that, "We are unable to provide a full explanation of the total collapse."

Kinda like how aircrash investigators figure out why a plane crashed but don't spend their time looking into what happened to the plane when it hit the ground.

Although if interested in the collapse itself, I suppose you can start with the work of Frank Greening.
 
Last edited:
NIST also didn't prove how gravity works in their investigation. Until we figure that out, we can't really be sure what happened.
 
Oh brother, I forget what a newbie you are. Anyway, there are numerous discussion of this on this site. Educate yourself.

THey take us all the away through the initiation of the collapse, and establish the cause of the collapse and the inevitability of total failure.

Anyway, why don't you explain 1. what further modeling will prove and 2. how much it would cost.

They speculate as to what initiated the collapse and then assume, without evidence, that it would be global. Their collapse initiation theory is that the perimeter columns bowed inward due to the sagging of the floors. This is fine. But what tests did NIST do to determine that it would be global. If NIST is going to create a model of the collapse, then the model needs to mirror, as closely as possible, the observable reality of the actual collapse. If it can't do this, it remains an untested hypothesis. Further modeling would allow NIST to test their hypothesis and see if the inward bowing of the perimeter columns would lead to a collapse that resembled the destruction of WTC1 and 2. The cost would be a lot less than what we spend on this phony War on Terror.

Because that's not what their job was.

They determined what caused the collapse to begin, that's the important part. Providing a detailed analysis of what happened during the collapse would be nearly impossible.

NIST stated as one of the goals of their investigation was to determine, "why and how the WTC 1 and 2 (the WTC towers) collapsed after the initial impact of the aircraft, and why and how WTC 7 collapsed."

They came up with a hypothesis as to "why" the buildings collapsed, inward bowing of the perimeter columns, but they did not explain "how" the buildings collapsed. As 9/11 widow Monica Gabrielle once said, "How could skyscrapers just like crumble to the ground in 10 seconds?" NIST never fulfilled their obligation to explain "how" the towers collapsed.
 
NIST never fulfilled their obligation to explain "how" the towers collapsed.

NIST claims that when the top section of each tower started to come down it easily overwhelmed the ability of each floor to carry the load and smashed its way through the building. This conclusion has been corroborated by several peer-reviewed papers that have explored the dynamics of the collapses themselves.

Meanwhile the other side of the argument posts crap on their own websites.

I suppose we'll just have to let history judge who was right on this one.... :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
They speculate as to what initiated the collapse and then assume, without evidence, that it would be global. Their collapse initiation theory is that the perimeter columns bowed inward due to the sagging of the floors. This is fine. But what tests did NIST do to determine that it would be global. If NIST is going to create a model of the collapse, then the model needs to mirror, as closely as possible, the observable reality of the actual collapse. If it can't do this, it remains an untested hypothesis. Further modeling would allow NIST to test their hypothesis and see if the inward bowing of the perimeter columns would lead to a collapse that resembled the destruction of WTC1 and 2. The cost would be a lot less than what we spend on this phony War on Terror.

No. Total collapse was already demonstrated by Bazant and Zhou before the preliminary report was even issued. This early paper has been refined several times, confirmed by others (e.g. Dr. Seffen) using different approaches, and now even Truth Movement member GregoryUrich has a corroborating paper. It's a done deal.

You would have us sit on our hands and do nothing until a full-up dynamic simulation replicating the entire collapse evolution, from start to finish, was possible. This isn't technically feasible. Even the static analysis was at the limit of our ability, and substantial uncertainty remains at the microscale due to the assumptions we have to make about the state of the structure prior to impact. This will never change.

What you've committed here is a fallacy of false precision. It doesn't matter that we can't predict exactly how fast the Tower will fall, or whether a given exterior panel will come loose or get folded under the collapse wave. That has absolutely no bearing on the base conclusions, which are unanimously accepted by the scientific community, that the aircraft impacts and fires caused the collapses, and nothing else.
 
No. Total collapse was already demonstrated by Bazant and Zhou before the preliminary report was even issued. This early paper has been refined several times, confirmed by others (e.g. Dr. Seffen) using different approaches, and now even Truth Movement member GregoryUrich has a corroborating paper. It's a done deal.

You would have us sit on our hands and do nothing until a full-up dynamic simulation replicating the entire collapse evolution, from start to finish, was possible. This isn't technically feasible. Even the static analysis was at the limit of our ability, and substantial uncertainty remains at the microscale due to the assumptions we have to make about the state of the structure prior to impact. This will never change.

What you've committed here is a fallacy of false precision. It doesn't matter that we can't predict exactly how fast the Tower will fall, or whether a given exterior panel will come loose or get folded under the collapse wave. That has absolutely no bearing on the base conclusions, which are unanimously accepted by the scientific community, that the aircraft impacts and fires caused the collapses, and nothing else.


Bazant and Zhou's analysis is secondary, as they need a pass on collapse initiation to even make their case. Without a freefall through one or two stories they have no case.

Where is the physical evidence for the 650 degree C steel temperatures required to buckle the columns?

Where is an investigation into why NIST wasn't provided with all of the 4,000 to 5,000 tons of fire affected area steel from the towers? Had they gotten that material there would be no question today as to how those collapses actually initiated. It was at a minimum criminal negligence for them not to have gotten that steel.

Additionally, why was none of the steel salvaged from WTC7?

The fact that over 99% of the physical evidence from the towers was not kept, and none from WTC7, is diametrically opposed to the way a proper investigation and failure analysis would normally be done and anyone with any sense can see that there is something wrong with this entire picture.
 
Last edited:
So, realcddeal, please provide a better, more thoroughly researched alternative to what happened on 9/11. Please use peer reviewed, cited research and not speculation. I'll check back in 6/7 years and see how much progress you've made.
 
Where is an investigation into why NIST wasn't provided with all of the 4,000 to 5,000 tons of fire affected area steel from the towers? Had they gotten that material there would be no question today as to how those collapses actually initiated. It was at a minimum criminal negligence for them not to have gotten that steel.

Do you know how much 4-5,000 ton(nes) actually is?
 
Bazant and Zhou's analysis is secondary, as they need a pass on collapse initiation to even make their case. Without a freefall through one or two stories they have no case.

Where is the physical evidence for the 650 degree C steel temperatures required to buckle the columns?

Where is an investigation into why NIST wasn't provided with all of the 4,000 to 5,000 tons of fire affected area steel from the towers? Had they gotten that material there would be no question today as to how those collapses actually initiated. It was at a minimum criminal negligence for them not to have gotten that steel.

Additionally, why was none of the steel salvaged from WTC7?

The fact that over 99% the physical evidence from the towers was not kept, and none from WTC7, is diametrically opposed to the way a proper investigation and failure analysis would normally be done and anyone with any sense can see that there is something wrong with this entire picture.

Oh come on Tony! Your movement would call it fake and ignore it anyway. 95% of flight 93 was recovered and you guys dismiss that. Everyone on fl 77 was ID through DNA and you still say it didn't hit the Pentagon.

Stop lying and admit nothing will falsify your believes.
 
Do you know how much 4-5,000 ton(nes) actually is?

The "it is too much" excuse doesn't work. Of course, I know how much steel 4-5,000 tons actually is. It is a volume of approximately 20,500 cubic feet or in analagous terms less than half a football field one foot high.

Are you saying they wouldn't have a field or a large aircraft hangar to store the material?

Why wasn't the steel from the fire affected areas saved? Everyone should ask themselves that question.
 
Oh come on Tony! Your movement would call it fake and ignore it anyway. 95% of flight 93 was recovered and you guys dismiss that. Everyone on fl 77 was ID through DNA and you still say it didn't hit the Pentagon.

Stop lying and admit nothing will falsify your believes.

Maybe I missed something here. I am not aware that flight 93 had a controversial collapse. You are comparing apples to oranges.
 
The "it is too much" excuse doesn't work. Of course, I know how much steel 4-5,000 tons actually is. It is a volume of approximately 20,500 cubic feet or in analagous terms less than half a football field one foot high.

Are you saying they wouldn't have a field or a large aircraft hangar to store the material?

Why wasn't the steel from the fire affected areas saved? Everyone should ask themselves that question.

If you read the NIST report you would know the answer to your question.
 
Why wasn't the steel from the fire affected areas saved? Everyone should ask themselves that question.

Maybe they didn't save everything because they didn't plan for the silly questions put forth by complete lunatics?
 
Last edited:
Maybe I missed something here. I am not aware that flight 93 had a controversial collapse. You are comparing apples to oranges.
Who's said the towers were controversial? I've never met a single person in my industry that has any problem with the collapse.

Do you know of any realistic alternative hypothesis?
 
If you read the NIST report you would know the answer to your question.

Where do they address why they did not get all of the steel from the fire affected areas of the towers and none from WTC7?

They only talk about what little they did get and then dismiss that as not being representative.
 
Who's said the towers were controversial? I've never met a single person in my industry that has any problem with the collapse.

Do you know of any realistic alternative hypothesis?

What world are you living in right now?

You know what the alternative explanations for those collapse initiations are. It doesn't seem that NIST or anyone else has an innocent explanation for the unusual flame and molten metal pouring out of the corner of the South Tower just before it collapsed. It also doesn't seem like there is an innocent explanation for the molten metal in the rubble yet either.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom