[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

As mentioned above we are part of the commonwealth, so the statement about Capitol ships is null and void. At one time we had the best fighter called in delvopment, but tanked and bought faulty american missles to defend the north, then we bought plane we nicknamed widowmaker, both from the US.

Are you now claiming that the Soviets did not invade Canada because of the possible reprisal from the Queen?
 
Kageki, the real reason for genocide was to unite the jews all together into one group.:D

JEROME, speak as a Canadian, WE ARE NOT A PROTECTORATE OF THE UNITED STATES.

Try not to let Jerome get to you, David.

He has been arguing along with MagZ that Hitler and the Nazis were not the bad guys in WW2.

Jerome, clearly embarrassed and humiliated at the brutal ass-kicking his side suffered at Juno Beach, The Liberation of Holland and the Battle of The Atlantic is now trying to taunt and belittle us.

His precious "master race" got it's aryan ass handed to them by this "protectorate" and he's just being a sore loser.

EDIT: I almost forgot to add that Sir Winston Churchill even called Canada "The Aerodrome of Democracy", so you can add Goerings precious Luftwaffe under Doenitz's vaunted U-boat fleet under Canadas kill list.
 
Last edited:
FDR and his Jew backers wanted a war with Germany. American ships fire upon German ships in the North Atlantic hoping to provoke an incident like the Maine or the Lusitania. The Germans did not take the bait.


S. S. Robin Moor, May 21, 1941 - 0 dead.

The Robin Moor carried no munitions, no material of a military character. On her side, the U.S. ensign was clearly painted. . . .

The fact that no lives had been lost somewhat salved U.S. feelings. But at no point had U.S. feelings run very high. The U.S. was not even greatly stirred when a Nazi spokesman in Berlin defiantly announced that Germany intended to continue such sinkings.

But if feelings were not aroused, the sinking of the Robin Moor had nonetheless brought a crisis on the U.S. The Robin Moor had not been bound for any war area, was far even from the huge war zone which Germany herself laid out—an area extending from Norway to Greenland, almost to Spain. If such sinkings continue, U.S. ships bound for other places remote from fighting fronts, will be in danger.[emphasis added]


U.S.S. Greer (DD-145), September 4, 1941 - 0 dead.

At 0840 that morning Greer, carrying mail and passengers to Argentia, was signaled by a British plane that a Nazi submarine had crash-dived some 10 miles ahead. Forty minutes later the DD's soundman picked up the German U-boat, and Greer began to trail the submarine. The plane, running low on fuel, dropped four depth charges at 1032 and returned to base, while Greer continued to dog the U-boat. Two hours later the German boat began a series of radical maneuvers and Greer's lookouts saw her pass about 100 yards off. An impulse bubble at 1248 warned Greer of a torpedo and she rang up flank speed and bore rudder hard left. Lookouts watched the torpedo pass 100 yards astern and the warship then charged in for an attack. She laid a pattern of eight depth charges which missed, and less than two minutes later a second torpedo passed 300 yards to port.

Greer lost sound contact during the maneuvers, and began to quarter the area in search of the U-boat. After 2 hours, she reestablished sound contact and laid down a pattern of 11 depth charges before discontinuing the engagement. Greer had held the German raider in sound contact 3 hours and 28 minutes; had evaded two torpedoes fired at her; and with her 19 depth charges had become the first American ship in World War II to attack the German Kriegsmarine.[emphasis added]


S.S. Steel Seafarer, September 5, 1941 - 0 dead.

U.S.S. Kearney (DD-432), October 17, 1941 - 11 dead.

S.S. Lehigh, October 19, 1941 - 0 dead.

U.S.S. Reuben James (DD-245), October 31, 1941 - 115 dead.

S.S. Astral, December 2, 1941 - 37 dead.

S.S. Sagadoc, December 3, 1941 - 1 dead.

Darn, MaGZ, the Germans started sinking US ships first. Darn, MaGZ, you don't know what you're talking about. Darn, MaGZ, your swastika is showing again.

FDR’s plan B was to provoke Japan, bringing Germany into the war.

The rest is history.


Why don't you take that issue to the Pearl Harbor thread?
 
Here is a description of the commonwealth because JEROME and Kageki, need a lesson on international politics.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commonwealth_of_Nations

In the Balfour Declaration at the Imperial Conference in 1926, Britain and its dominions agreed they were equal in status, in no way subordinate one to another in any aspect of their domestic or external affairs, though united by common allegiance to the Crown, and freely associated as members of the British Commonwealth of Nations.

Members of the commonwealth have pledged allegiance (the fidelity (faithful; like a dog) owed by a subject or citizen to a sovereign or government) to the Queen.

Protectorate: the relationship of superior authority assumed by one power or state over a dependent one



OK, this is enough picking on those that choose to neglect their individual sovereignty.

Back to the topic at hand.
 
He has been arguing along with MagZ that Hitler and the Nazis were not the bad guys in WW2.

Have not.

Jerome, clearly embarrassed and humiliated at the brutal ass-kicking his side suffered at Juno Beach, The Liberation of Holland and the Battle of The Atlantic is now trying to taunt and belittle us.

My side won.

His precious "master race" got it's aryan ass handed to them by this "protectorate" and he's just being a sore loser.

Firstly; you know not what "race" I am.

Second; "race" is a false human construct.
 
Try not to let Jerome get to you, David.

He has been arguing along with MagZ that Hitler and the Nazis were not the bad guys in WW2.

Jerome, clearly embarrassed and humiliated at the brutal ass-kicking his side suffered at Juno Beach, The Liberation of Holland and the Battle of The Atlantic is now trying to taunt and belittle us.

His precious "master race" got it's aryan ass handed to them by this "protectorate" and he's just being a sore loser.

EDIT: I almost forgot to add that Sir Winston Churchill even called Canada "The Aerodrome of Democracy", so you can add Goerings precious Luftwaffe to Doenitz's vaunted U-boat fleet to Canadas kill list.

Well Aerodorme of Democracy probably beacuase one his advisors Lord Beaverbrook Minister of Aircraft Production came from Canada (actually grew up in my province New Brunswick).
 
S. S. Robin Moor, May 21, 1941 - 0 dead.




U.S.S. Greer (DD-145), September 4, 1941 - 0 dead.




S.S. Steel Seafarer, September 5, 1941 - 0 dead.

U.S.S. Kearney (DD-432), October 17, 1941 - 11 dead.

S.S. Lehigh, October 19, 1941 - 0 dead.

U.S.S. Reuben James (DD-245), October 31, 1941 - 115 dead.

S.S. Astral, December 2, 1941 - 37 dead.

S.S. Sagadoc, December 3, 1941 - 1 dead.

Darn, MaGZ, the Germans started sinking US ships first. Darn, MaGZ, you don't know what you're talking about. Darn, MaGZ, your swastika is showing again.




Why don't you take that issue to the Pearl Harbor thread?

Were they in response to something? Did Germans lose any ships?
 
An aggressive stance against facts do not disrupt the facts.

True, but you need facts first. Can you state who PPCLI is without googling for example? Or since this thread is discussing an act of WWII When did PPCLI land in Europe during WWII?
 
Last edited:
An aggressive stance against facts do not disrupt the facts.

Jerome,

You have been called out on your faulty understanding of Canadian, US relationships.

Asked to show that Canada is subordinate to the US, you have now started to claim that Canada is subordinate to Queen Elizabeth the Second.

You were completely wrong about the US relationship with Canada and you are now completely wrong about the Canadian relationship to QEII (google the Queen of Canada). Even if you were right about the Canadian relationship to QEII it would have no bearing on whether your claims about the US relationship to Canada were correct and the topic would still be completely irrelevant to the Holocaust.

Why don't you start a new thread if you want to prolong this.
 
Jerome,

You have been called out on your faulty understanding of Canadian, US relationships.

"Calling out" is not the same as presenting evidence against the assertion.

Asked to show that Canada is subordinate to the US, you have now started to claim that Canada is subordinate to Queen Elizabeth the Second.

No; someone else's argument against Canada being a protectorate of the US was that Canada was a protectorate of the Queen.


Why don't you start a new thread if you want to prolong this.

I tried to be done, it seems as if there is always someone wanting "call out" and have the last word.:)
 
Were they in response to something? Did Germans lose any ships?


Did you even read what I wrote? The Robin Moor was sunk months before the first time a U.S. warship ever attacked a German warship. You can read the entire Time Magazine article by following the hyperlink. Come to that, you can read all of the stories of all the ships; that's why I included the links.

As to whether any German ships were sunk by the US before December 11, 1941, I don't know of any. It is possible, however, that at least one U-boat was sunk by an American destroyer, but the kill wasn't confirmed, and the actual circumstances of the boat's loss ended up being unknown.
 
Last edited:
"Calling out" is not the same as presenting evidence against the assertion.

No. You still do not get it.

YOU made an assertion.
YOU provide evidence to show that your assetion is correct.

Now you should know exactly what you need to do.

Either you start a thread where you present your evidence that Canada is, in some way, a protectorate or you retract your assertion.

If you choose not to provide evidence or provide a retraction, then I suspect everyone who reads this thread (with the probable exception of Kageki and MaGZ) will realise that you have no evidence and no real understanding of the issues.
 
Did you even read what I wrote? The Robin Moor was sunk months before the first time a U.S. warship ever attacked a German warship. You can read the entire Time Magazine article by following the hyperlink. Come to that, you can read all of the stories of all the ships; that's why I included the links.

As to whether any German ships were sunk by the US before December 11, 1941, I don't know of any. It is possible, however, that at least one U-boat was sunk by an American destroyer, but the kill wasn't confirmed, and the actual circumstances of the boat's loss ended up being unknown.

Well let's see what did you decide not to include? This is the only thing you quoted about the Robin Moor:

http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,851128,00.html

S. S. Robin Moor, May 21, 1941 - 0 dead.

Quote:
The Robin Moor carried no munitions, no material of a military character. On her side, the U.S. ensign was clearly painted. . . .

The fact that no lives had been lost somewhat salved U.S. feelings. But at no point had U.S. feelings run very high. The U.S. was not even greatly stirred when a Nazi spokesman in Berlin defiantly announced that Germany intended to continue such sinkings.

But if feelings were not aroused, the sinking of the Robin Moor had nonetheless brought a crisis on the U.S. The Robin Moor had not been bound for any war area, was far even from the huge war zone which Germany herself laid out—an area extending from Norway to Greenland, almost to Spain. If such sinkings continue, U.S. ships bound for other places remote from fighting fronts, will be in danger.[emphasis added]

What else did the article say?

The submarine's commander gave the Robin Moor half an hour to abandon ship. The passengers were roused. Three more boats were lowered. As the sun rose, after the boats were in the water, the submarine fired a torpedo into the Robin Moor amidships, shelled her for 23 minutes. She went wearily down by the stern.

The submarine circled about the captain's boat. A Nazi sailor gave the men four tins of ersatz bread, two tins of butter. Said the Nazi commander: "I'm sorry, but you were carrying supplies to my country's enemy." The German promised to radio the Robin Moor's position. Then he slid away into the sea.

They even gave them time to get off! Can you be more dishonest?
 
Members of the commonwealth have pledged allegiance (the fidelity (faithful; like a dog) owed by a subject or citizen to a sovereign or government) to the Queen.

Protectorate: the relationship of superior authority assumed by one power or state over a dependent one



OK, this is enough picking on those that choose to neglect their individual sovereignty.

Back to the topic at hand.

Yes off course a nice little passing shot a group of countries - you go hard, tell me can you see sunlight from the bottom of that hole you have dug for yourself?
 
Yes off course a nice little passing shot a group of countries - you go hard, tell me can you see sunlight from the bottom of that hole you have dug for yourself?


Still can see, just can't get out of it.
 
Well Aerodorme of Democracy probably beacuase one his advisors Lord Beaverbrook Minister of Aircraft Production came from Canada (actually grew up in my province New Brunswick).

He was actually referring to the Commonwealth Air Training Plan. Canada's wide open spaces and location far outside the reach of the Luftwaffe and IJN air arm made it the ideal location to train aircrews where they couldn't be shot at before they were ready to shoot back.

The majority of British, Australian and Canadian aircrews recaived their training in Canada during the war.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom