[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

What's your point?

You want to equate historical revisionism of the nazi atrocities with the accepted history of atrocities carried out by other nations in history?

I'm not in denial, you are.

Maybe we should turn your argument around. If we can accept the terrible things done in the past by ours and other countries, why can't you accept that terrible things were done by nazis?

No one other than you are making excuses for past atrocities. The difference is that you're trying to defend a political ideology by trying to find a parallel with a 'country'.

There is no british empire and no one here appears to be trying to promote the argument in favour of there being one now.

Similarily, there is no nazi movement (to speak of) but you do appear to be promoting the argument in favour of there being one now.

But nazis aren't very bright.

Right we're not condoning what "we" did, but then you deny there even is a British empire? I think some of you need to learn history.

No denial that Nazis and for that matter the Japanese have done cruel things.

We are debating here specifically if Jews were burned alive in ovens. The denial and deflection in here is unbelievable.

No ovens.
 
[qimg]http://www.rockingham.k12.va.us/EMS/History_Pages/Holocaust/atrocopening13.gif[/qimg]
Not much labor going on here, Are they waiting for the deportation bus?

Off course you promoters never get original. I was waiting to sink my teeth into this standard BS demagoging.

What does this prove? That they died? How? Disease? Shootings? They died of gassing? Well actually I doubt that because bodies that died of lethal gas is dangerous to be around.

[qimg]http://www.rockingham.k12.va.us/EMS/History_Pages/Holocaust/krema4auschwitz.gif[/qimg]

Sure looks like a death factory to me, Why such huge chimneys for such a small factory building? Whatever they "made' sure didn't take up much floor space but sure produced an awful lot of smoke. The rear of this building is where they had to "shower up" before starting production for the day

Hey have you been to a regular factory before? There seems to be a row of death factories near my house. Did you know they made synthetic rubber goods at Auschwitz amongst other things? This proves nothing.


[qimg]http://www.rockingham.k12.va.us/EMS/History_Pages/Holocaust/pit.gif[/qimg]


Must have been the morning fog then, wake up. wake up Juden. Time to go to work.

This is the only picture ever that exists supposedly showing burning pits. It looks fake to me.

Well then where did they vanish to then? lemme guess. Miami?

To summaries. I don't even think hell has a place for such cretins as holocaust deniers. Even that is too good for them. Thankfully nature and the human species through selection discards such freaks and they are forced to live a life of ignorance. Ostracized by society, they hide in their caverns of blatent stupidity to die off with a whimper. Blaming their failure and shortcomings in life on those who are more adept to compete in society.

Can you start linking to the sources of these numbers so we can examine it closer?

Hmm how can some Jews not be accounted for? Well how do you count someone who is Jewish? How is the census taken? What about Jews who change their last name or went into hiding? What about the many Jews who emigrated to other countries?
 
Right we're not condoning what "we" did, but then you deny there even is a British empire? I think some of you need to learn history.

No denial that Nazis and for that matter the Japanese have done cruel things.

We are debating here specifically if Jews were burned alive in ovens. The denial and deflection in here is unbelievable.

No ovens.

I think you need to learn past tense and present tense

And now you are just lying. It is quite disgraceful to be honest. We are not debating whether they were burned alive in ovens we are debating whether the Nazis systematically murdered Jews just because they were Jews.

yes, they did, millions of them
 
Hang on a minute, you nearly got away with that one. Sorry for replying twice to the same point, but this is a patently false claim. If you want to kill someone and I refuse to lend you my gun, I am not aiding your enemy, I am simply refusing to aid you. Japan had no basic right to buy oil from the USA, so by refusing to sell oil to Japan the USA was not infringing Japan's rights in any way, it was simply refusing to be complicit in a crime. This whole "Oil embargo is an act of war" argument is dishonest, distorted and morally indefensible. Not to mention idiotic.

Dave

Dave, let's discuss this in my Pearl Harbor thread. Not here anymore.
 
I think you need to learn past tense and present tense

And now you are just lying. It is quite disgraceful to be honest. We are not debating whether they were burned alive in ovens we are debating whether the Nazis systematically murdered Jews just because they were Jews.

yes, they did, millions of them

That is one of the points about the Holocaust so stop trying to ignore it. Do we all not still believe the Nazis burned Jews alive in Auschwitz? No death factory.

No it does not appear it was just the Jews, but your statement is still partially true.

Not sure exactly how many million of Jews. 5 million.
 
Second time, kageki: please respond. Thank you.

Specifically what evidence would convince you that the Nazis systematically killed millions of Jews (not to mention all the other civilians they killed for various reasons)?
 
Last edited:
The exact number of 6 millions JEWS that died in the Holocaust is being debated. Not the actual total deaths in the Holocaust.
Strawman, as you should know by now.

Auschwitz? This day camp?
You have a very bizarre idea of what a day camp is. A million people were killed at Auschwitz-Birkenau. Not what I would consider normal for a day camp.

I wonder how Japanese people would react if someone would refer to the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in the same disgraceful way you refer to the murder by the nazi's of millions of innocent people.

Racism is disgusting and demeaning, whatever color it takes.
 
Second time, kageki: please respond. Thank you.

Specifically what evidence would convince you that the Nazis systematically killed millions of Jews (not to mention all the other civilians they killed for various reasons)?

Here's a simple question since it's apparently difficult for you.

Did Nazis burn Jews alive in ovens?
 
Strawman, as you should know by now.

You have a very bizarre idea of what a day camp is. A million people were killed at Auschwitz-Birkenau. Not what I would consider normal for a day camp.

I wonder how Japanese people would react if someone would refer to the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in the same disgraceful way you refer to the murder by the nazi's of millions of innocent people.

Racism is disgusting and demeaning, whatever color it takes.

It's not a strawman and you know it. The specific question is whether 6 millions Jews really died in the Holocaust. Ok?

I don't know about you if it turns out the gassing and the ovens were made up I would be a little pissed.
 
Kageki,

I posted a similar question in post 1180 which I will now rephrase and repost to save you the trouble of scrolling back.

Does it strike you as odd that none of the Nazis when brought to account for their actions at Nuremberg or since argued the same case that you now are?

AFAIK there was no-one in the witness box screaming "its all embellished! There was no-one put into a gas chamber! The Final Solution was mainly about transport to the Happy Green Fields in the East!". Faced with a mountain of documentary and witness evidence they all went for the "we were just following orders" or "I knew nothing about that".

Can you explain why?

Thanks.
 
Good point, Pushkin.

The Nazis never used "it didn't happen" as a defence.

I certainly would have objected to being falsely accused of mass murder.

Wouldn't you, kageki?
 
Last edited:
It's not a strawman and you know it. The specific question is whether 6 millions Jews really died in the Holocaust. Ok?
Of course your fixation on the 6 million Jews is a strawman.

This is what the website of Yad Vashem has to say about the number of Jews murdered in the Holocaust:

There is no precise figure for the number of Jews killed in the Holocaust. The figure commonly used is the six million quoted by Adolf Eichmann, a senior SS official. Most research confirms that the number of victims was between five and six million. Early calculations range from 5.1 million (Professor Raul Hilberg) to 5.95 million (Jacob Leschinsky). More recent research, by Professor Yisrael Gutman and Dr. Robert Rozett in the Encyclopedia of the Holocaust, estimates the Jewish losses at 5.59–5.86 million, and a study headed by Dr. Wolfgang Benz presents a range from 5.29 million to six million.
(bolding mine).

So, if you have any evidence that will help get a better estimate, feel free to provide it.

I don't know about you if it turns out the gassing and the ovens were made up I would be a little pissed.
Like many Jews I have personnaly heard the testimony of family members WHO WERE THERE. (And they didn't consider it to be day camps.)
Both the gassing and the ovens are well-documented.
I do get a "little pissed" by people who are so blinded by prejudice that they systematically ignore all the evidence that contradicts their pet theories.

But, since this is the CT-subforum, I have only myself to blame for being confronted with this disgraceful nonsense.
 
Not sure exactly how many million of Jews. 5 million.

Oh well, that makes all the difference in the world. 6 million would have been serious, but 5 million only merits a slap on the wrist. And of course, the industrialisation of genocide that would have been required to kill 6 million would be totally unnecessary to kill only 5 million.

Some day, Kageki, you may grow up, and develop the capacity for embarrassment at what you've been saying here. I don't envy you, because it's all archived here to be looked back over, and you're going to have to live with it. The longer it takes, the worse it'll feel.

Dave
 
Kageki,

I posted a similar question in post 1180 which I will now rephrase and repost to save you the trouble of scrolling back.

Does it strike you as odd that none of the Nazis when brought to account for their actions at Nuremberg or since argued the same case that you now are?

AFAIK there was no-one in the witness box screaming "its all embellished! There was no-one put into a gas chamber! The Final Solution was mainly about transport to the Happy Green Fields in the East!". Faced with a mountain of documentary and witness evidence they all went for the "we were just following orders" or "I knew nothing about that".

Can you explain why?

Thanks.

Because it doesn't answer the question whether Jews were really burned alive in ovens or not. Besides many were probably tortured by the Allied.
 
Oh well, that makes all the difference in the world. 6 million would have been serious, but 5 million only merits a slap on the wrist. And of course, the industrialisation of genocide that would have been required to kill 6 million would be totally unnecessary to kill only 5 million.

Some day, Kageki, you may grow up, and develop the capacity for embarrassment at what you've been saying here. I don't envy you, because it's all archived here to be looked back over, and you're going to have to live with it. The longer it takes, the worse it'll feel.

Dave

Get a new line. I'm done with the demagoging and the industrialisation is exactly what's being disputed.

Historians mull over numbers. It's nothing new and it's done for the sake of accuracy and you know it.

5 million.
 
Good point, Pushkin.

The Nazis never used "it didn't happen" as a defence.

I certainly would have objected to being falsely accused of mass murder.

Wouldn't you, kageki?

Does that prove Jews were being burned alive in ovens?

The answer is yes or no. It's quite simple.
 
Of course your fixation on the 6 million Jews is a strawman.

This is what the website of Yad Vashem has to say about the number of Jews murdered in the Holocaust:

(bolding mine).

So, if you have any evidence that will help get a better estimate, feel free to provide it.

Like many Jews I have personnaly heard the testimony of family members WHO WERE THERE. (And they didn't consider it to be day camps.)
Both the gassing and the ovens are well-documented.
I do get a "little pissed" by people who are so blinded by prejudice that they systematically ignore all the evidence that contradicts their pet theories.

But, since this is the CT-subforum, I have only myself to blame for being confronted with this disgraceful nonsense.

Show me the evidence that Jews were burned alive in ovens.

The fixation on 6 million is from the Jews who take it out of the story from the Talmud.
 
Show me the evidence that Jews were burned alive in ovens.
One more strawman. Why should I provide evidence for something I haven't claimed? :confused:

The fixation on 6 million is from the Jews who take it out of the story from the Talmud.
Now, that's a claim you make! Care to provide evidence?

(ETA: of course, the link to the Yad Vashem website I gave above proves you wrong.)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom