[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, because of the overwhelming evidence that show that 175 hit the WTC. Your would have to prove that not only was that plane in the sky (I hope you would provide as much evidence for that as you are asking us for to prove that 175 had taken off), but that it was in the area. Futhermore, you would have to prove that it was painted to look like a UA plane, since that is the plane in the photos and identified by eyewitnesses. Remember that evidence is required to prove probable cause, so far you've produced none.

Here's an analogy for you.
Three guys are standing in the middle of a basketball court, during halftime to an NBA game. They are part of the cleaning crew and are just dry mopping the court. One is wearing a hat with the team logo on it, one is wearing a bandana, and the third is wearing a hat with the local baseball teams logo on it. Suddenly, the guy with the baseball hat shoots the other guy with the hat in the head, using a 9mm hidden in his coveralls. Not all the spectators were paying attention, but some saw the first shot. Since it was halftime the feed from the cameras were not live and the cameras were not pointed at the location of the killing. Everyone is now watching the middle of the court, and the Technical Director of the game instructs his camera crew to get a shot of the action for the news division of the network. Before security has time to react, the gunman then shoots the guy with the bandana, in the chest. Almost all the spectators, numbering in the thousands, saw this. The shooter then turns the gun on himself, placing the gun in his mouth and pulls the trigger. The back of his head explodes in a shower of blood and brains.

In David Simon's book Homicide: a Year on the Killing Streets this would be regarded as a "dunker" (short for "slam dunk case"), an obvious suspect and plenty of witnesses. However, Will Peterson and his crew (CSI, for those who are unfamiliar with American TV) arrive, and still have to map out what happened at the scene and collect forensic evidence. The coroner does an autopsy, to determine cause of death. Detectives look into the backgrounds of the victims and shooter, to find a possible motive. Bullets are found in the two victims, along the track of the wounds. Unfortunately, the bullet that killed the shooter can't be found. It traveled (according to witnesses and video playback) at an upward angle, most likely going into the rafters of the building, and may have struck one of the steel supports above it been spent and fell to the ground. Thus probably lost in the crowd as it left the building. According to the coroner, all three died of gunshot wounds. According to the forensics team, the guy in the baseball hat was the shooter. According to the detectives, there was bad blood between the shooter and the victims. Apparently, the guy in the basketball hat was sleeping with the baseball hat wearer's wife, and the guy in the bandana knew this was going on for sometime and didn't tell baseball hat. Two days before there had been an altercation between the men in the locker room. The case is closed.

However, soon after all the findings are published in the newspaper, a dentist finds some unanswered questions. Why did the bullet go through the shooter's head and not the first victim's head? Why was the fact that the second victim had a pacemaker never made public? Why was the third bullet never found? The explanation to him and others he enlists is obvious. A vast conspiracy on the part of professional sports to raise ticket prices.

The dentist, refered to as a "Doctor" by his supporters, explains that only explosives placed within the logo of the hat of the first victim can explain the wound not being a through-and-through. He finds an explosive expert who tells him the "yeah an explosive could cause a wound like that..." Leaving out the rest of the statement, "but to propel the bullet into the skull would require an explosive package size that would be noticeable to the victim and the people around him." He also shows that an explosive could be placed in the pacemaker of the second victim, without doing research into when the victim's last operation was. "Isn't it obvious that the absense of the third bullet is proof that an explosive charge was placed in the man's head." Also, some of the eyewitnesses (including off-duty cops, and soldiers on leave) described some of the "gunshots" as "sounding like small explosions." There is no other possible explanation.

Further, who benefitted? Since the event all major league sports have raised their ticket prices, to pay for extra security.

Why hasn't the investigation been reopened? The sport teams have the city and state officials in their pocket.

Finally, isn't it suspicious that the suspect was identified so quickly? Obviously a patsy.

Brilliant :)
 
So anything going at 500 mph will penetrate corrugated steel, is that what you are saying?
No, I'm saying that the example you were using, to prove that something going 500mph couldn't penetrate the side of the WTC, was a flawed one. Like many of your other ideas.

I thought I made that clear.
 
Last edited:
How is thin aluminium stronger than bone?
Put your finger on a table, press just the one finger down and then hit it with a tin can. Any tin can will do, beans will do fine. Now hit the finger with a sharp blow with the tin can. You won't feel a thing, yet the can will be dented. That proves that bone is stronger than tin. The tin of a tin can, is on a par with the thin aluminium of a civilian airliner.
Ergo, bone is stronger than thin aluminium sheeting.
If you did the same thing with a piece of steel, you would break your finger.
Ergo, steel is stronger than bone.
It now follows, that regardless of the speed involved when thin aluminium sheeting (rounded like a tin can) argues with corrugated steel, backed by a concrete and steel floor, backed by massive core columns, then the thin aluminium sheeting loses. The greater the speed, the faster that happens.


Edited by chillzero: 
Edited for civility

First, a sharp blow from a tin can actually can break a finger bone - easily - in many cases.

Second, have you ever touched a plane, Mally? You might be able to crush a tin can with your hand - might, some are awfully strong - but you'll be very unlikely to crush an airplane wing with your bare hand.

We're not talking about aluminum foil here, guy.

Get a clue - you're WAAAAY out of your league here.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Unless I'm mistaken, the fastest the "jumpers" could fall is 120mph (terminal velocity).
depends on position, i beleive with legs together and straight, arms at your sides and chin tucked you can get to 400mph, however the maximum possible speed of anyone or anything falling from the roof of the WTC would be about 200mph (9.8m/s^2 for 9.2 seconds)
 
How about the first step being to get 175 from Logan to Manhattan, via a hijack, has that been forgotten? Because so far, no one has remotely come close to putting up a viable scenario, not even remotely.
ive seen at least 3 quite viable scenarios in this thread, you have rejected them, but failed to provide any adequate reason for doing so
 
Very good, however,
http://www.whitehouse.gov/history/presidents/ht33.html
http://www.wargamer.com/ww2timeline/1945western.asp
Italy had long since surrendered.
Von Kleist surrendered to the Third Army on the 4th.
Jodl surrendered to Russia on the 7th.
The Channel Islands, St Nazaire and La Rochelle didn't officialy surrender until the 9th.
However, as I have already stated a collection of surrenders were involved.
The guns fell silent and all hostilities ceased by 3pm on May 5th.
Ergo, WW2 ended on May 5th.


The first link is irrelevant. The second link supports my claim, not yours. And your revision of history based on your redefinitions of terms is irrelevant. The war in Europe ended May 7, 1945. World War II ended with the ultimate surrender of Japan.
 
A list of the victims of flight 175, does not constitute evidence that 175 hit tower 2.
I maintain that 175 was a part of the cover up, not the attack.
Here are some other photos of the attack plane. I just want to concentrate on the length of the fusilage from nose to leading edge of the wing and the clean cut of the wing into the steel of the building. Read the account of a Boeing employee with 30 yrs experience.
http://www.rense.com/general68/poss911.htm
Here are three others,
Col George Nelson USAF
Glen Standish, pilot
Nila Sagadevin, pilot
and others
http://home.att.net/~south.tower/STengine1.htm
 
I will do no such thing until you address the basic evidence of the visual record and either show that it is not consistent with UA Flight 175, or concede that the visual record shows no discrepancies.


Stop trying to shift the burden of proof

This is not relevant to the discussion of UA Flight 175, nor to 9/11 as a whole. If you wish to discuss WWII I highly suggest you do so in a different thread.

The visual record is not consistent with 175. There are many discrepancies, the engine for example, that was found at the scene could not have been fitted to 175. Allow me to refer you to my previous post, which contains further evidence to that effect.
I have yet to see any evidence to the contrary from yourself.
All the evidence that I have seen points away from 175. Can you kindly produce some evidence that doesn't point away from 175.
 
Should I presume at this point that we are never to return to settling the navigation issue?


I think Malcolm was never all that interested in the navigation issue, as the important thing for him appears to be the argument that "since it's possible that the hijackers' plan might not have worked, it is not possible that it actually did work."
 
corrugated steel


Point of definition here. What exactly do you believe the word "corrugated" means? Because your usage of the word doesn't seem to square with the definition I'm accustomed to, which has to do with strengthening sheet metal by rolling a rippled texture into it.
 
I have further produced evidence that it could not have been 175 that hit the south tower, because the photographic evidence says so. Here that is also,
http://www.amics21.com/911/flight175/dud.html
I did my own analysis to counter that silly claim, that the dimensions of the plane could not have been a 767-200. The measurements detailed at your page were made on a photo from slightly in front of the plane, but if you do the exact same analysis of a photo taken from slightly behind the plane, you get very different numbers. In fact, if you average those two numbers from the different photos, to effectively be what you should expect from a picture that's square to the plane, then that number agrees with a 767-200 (like UAL175) very closely, and is very far from the dimensions of a 767-300.

Further, if you estimate the plane's length from photos taken right up next to the South Tower, the length agrees very closely with that of the -200 model, and disagrees with your claim that it's a -300.

You can read the paper I wrote here: http://911myths.com/Flight175.pdf
Go ahead - it's only three pages, including pictures.
 
BTW, malcolm, I'm somewhat of an expert planespotter myself, and in my somewhat expert opinion on the matter - the aircraft was indeed a 767-200 in UA's "Stealth" paint scheme. And if you doubt my aviation geek cred, feel free to quiz me on airliner identification. You can even use thumbnail size pics and I'll be able to give you type(ie 757), subtype/variant(ie -200PF) and airline(ie UPS).


Also, if you'd like a clearer shot of the very plane that hit the tower, N612UA, sitting on an airport tarmac in happier times, there's one on this page.
 
There are also more photos of N612UA here, including some from the 1980s/early 1990s using an older UAL paint scheme.
 
I agree and I'd just like to suggest that malcolm drop by the jetphotos.net and/or airliners.net fora, or even pprune and ask the resident planespotters/pilots/airline people what hit the South Tower. If he can find a single one that insists that the plane isn't a UA 767-200 - then his claims might have merit. What do you think, mal? How does presenting your evidence to plane geeks sound?

BTW, malcolm, I'm somewhat of an expert planespotter myself, and in my somewhat expert opinion on the matter - the aircraft was indeed a 767-200 in UA's "Stealth" paint scheme. And if you doubt my aviation geek cred, feel free to quiz me on airliner identification. You can even use thumbnail size pics and I'll be able to give you type(ie 757), subtype/variant(ie -200PF) and airline(ie UPS).

Could it have been a "military bad boy" painted up in UA's colors. Certainly. Are military tankers(KC 767's for example) made of materials different than that of their civilian couterparts - steel for instance? No, they are not. They may be strengthened in some areas, to accommodate increased landing weights, but they are by and large the same airplanes. And since steel is around 3X heavier than aluminum per unit of volume, a 767 made from steel would weigh close to 500 tons at takeoff and would need at least 2 more of the same powerplants to get it in the air, or much more powerful engines. But, I only see two engines of standard size/nacelle shape for a Pratt & Whitney JT9D powered 767.
My pleasure, where did this engine come from?
http://home.att.net/~south.tower/STengine1.htm
 
Let's see, now: the remains of the passengers identified by forensic pathologists don't constitute "real" evidence because all forensic specialists work for "Rothschilde [sic]/ Rockefeller."

The fragments of Flight 175 can dismissed by the same process--anyone who identified them necessarily works for the super-villain/s.

The disappearance of Flight 175--a commercial airliner took off and vanished--is not a problem a fantasist need concern himself with.

Your fabrication regarding armored Boeing 767s having been exposed as a falsehood does nothing to damage your speculations.

Tell us, Malcolm, is there any evidence that you wouldn't simply define out of existence? You are, after all, the ultimate arbiter of what is real and what isn't, right?
Is this engine real?
http://home.att.net/~south.tower/STengine1.htm
 
Should I presume at this point that we are never to return to settling the navigation issue?

I've put you in the driving seat, now what heading is it for New York?
Carry on without turning and we'll soon be in Canada. Anything from 340 to 10
degrees will still put us in Canada.
You are now in the pilot's seat. What will be your heading for New York.
All I know is that 180 or so will see over Texas eventually, so that's no good.
The best I can offer is somewhere more than 90 and less than say, 170.
Don't forget, because of the simplistic 'follow the smoke' that went on before, we are now flight 11 and we have no GPS.
I don't know how long we've been since take off, or what the speed of the plane has been, I'll guess if you like. Meanwhile, kindly give me a heading, once you have managed to turn the plane around.
 
Allow me to refresh your memory.
1.
Raytheon, in Aug 2001, flew a passenger jet, take off – flight around – landing. (Der Spiegel).
2.
Raytheon deal in small executive jets, there is no reason for them to fly large passenger planes by remote control.
3.
There is a very good reason for Raytheon not to interest themselves in flying passenger planes by remote control, because it is against the law.
4.
The law requires that the passengers on any flight, have the flight crew present themselves to the passengers, by standing by the entrance door. This is to reassure the passengers, that the crew are not hung over or worse.
5.
No flight crew by the door = no flight.
6.
Raytheon could have no legitimate reason, for flying a large passenger plane by remote control.
7.
Offutt AFB, is a joint civilian/military installation.
8.
Boeing and Raytheon were there.
9.
Boeing has been the subject of RICO law suits for over a decade.
10.
The military prefer daylight take offs.
11.
Any commander of an Air Force Base who closed his airport for ‘civilian’ reasons during massive war games, would face disciplinary action.
12.
For the first time in history, a civilian politician was placed in direct command of Norad and other parts of the USAF.
13.
In order to get a night-time take off from a military airfield, some compelling reason must be given.
14.
Private civilian executive jets began arriving at dawn on 9/11, because of a celebrity golf tournament that day.
15.
Warren Buffet was persuaded out of retirement to host one last celebrity golf tournament.
16.
Neocons are involved in paedophilia.
17.
Offut AFB is twenty minutes away from Boystown, Omaha.
18.
Boystown is steeped in allegations of paedophilia.
19.
Things occurred (criminal convictions) in the Twin Towers apartment block in Omaha, which is midway between the executive jet landing at Offutt and Boystown, ten minutes from either location.
20.
So many planes or non-planes were in the sky that morning, that air traffic controllers didn’t know a real plane from a blip on their screen.
21.
Air traffic controllers deal only with planes that are about to land in their area.
22.
All take offs from Offutt, for both Northern Vigilance, Vigilant warrior and any other reason, would have to be during the night of 9/10 – 9/11.


In all this gibberish, there is not the slightest indication that you have troubled yourself to read Apathoid's paper (he is a regular on this forum), which corrects the errors you persist in promoting:

http://911myths.com/Remote_Takeover.pdf

Please tell us where Apathoid goes wrong.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom