<.... Snip lots of stuff about the history of karaoke machines, and what the early models did and didn't do....>
OK, and I mean this. If Malcolm can find absolute proof that "the original karaoke machine" back in the 1970s or 1980s was able to make an out-of-tune voice emerge from the speakers in-tune, in real time, by altering the voice and not the backing track, I will donate £500 (more than the $1,000 he offered to donate if it could be proven that Dubya, as President, had attended a photo-op with primary school kids prior to 11th September 2001) to the registered charity of his choice.
Get to it, Malcolm.
You mentioned £500 in one of your longer rants. Do you want to change your mind about that now, or later?
http://www.audio4fun.com/
If anyone can see what a web page about a modern digital voice morpher has to do with the challenge I posted, please let me know.
Malcolm, you stated categorically that the
original karaoke machines had, from the first, the capability to correct wrong pitch sung into the microphone, and output the note from the speakers at the correct pitch, in real time.
That was what I was calling you on. You made it up. The original karaoke machines of the 1970s and 1980s had no such capability. Trying to claim that the existence of a digital instrument capable of altering voices in 2007 satisfies my challenge is about as honest as anyone posting a picture of GWB visiting an old folks' home in 2003 and claiming that satisfied your challenge to find a picture of him visiting a primary school in January-August 2001.
So no, try again.
You're thrashing in the dark here. First it's some top-secret voice-morphing technology, then it's something someone mentioned in an article which turns out not to be realtime, then it's old karaoke machines, then any karaoke machine will do so long as it
tells you if you're flat, then we shoot off at a tangent to impressionists, and now we're being shown a modern kids' toy.
Nowhere have we seen any sign of a device that's capable of changing a stranger's voice so that it appears to a mother to be that of her own son, when that son is not a celebrity and sample recordings of his voice are not available.
And have you made up your mind yet whether it was done in real time, or by pre-recording? Because I'll tell you, pre-recording won't cut it. There's no way to ensure phrases are available to answer any unforeseen question.
And still Malcolm persists in claiming that it was impossible that the calls could have been made as claimed.
Malcolm, the only way the very idea of faking calls is plausible, is if it's so well-known that calls can and are made from aeroplanes that complete voice silence from the four planes would have been noticed and commented on as suspicious (dammit, it wouldn't even have been
that suspicious, maybe all the passengers had been terrorised into submission or even killed, who would have known?).
There's NO WAY this over-cautious Rothschilde of yours would have dreamed of doing anything so risky or so pointless as faking these telephone calls, and doubly so if it was so easy to verify that it was impossible the calls could even have been connected.
You didn't even have any idea WHY he might have ordered something so pointless, so ridiculous as that, until I asked you! First, it was just to make the story more convincing. Yeah, right, making impossible phone calls is a very good way to make your story convincing, I don't think. Then you had a think. No, it was to plant in everyone's minds that Arab terrorists were to blame. Don't be ridiculous, the idea was in everybody's minds long before the phone calls were reported! Indeed, all Rothschilde has to do is to prime his media buddies to make the suggestion on TV and radio. Simple as that. Don't you think that's what he'd have done, and not risked the whole plan by faking impossible phone calls that were almost guaranteed to go wrong (because a fake could never have produced the effect of a real call)?
Rothschilde's clever, Malcolm. He'll give any plan the thumbs down that has the slightest chance of failing. The faking of phone calls doesn't just have a huge chance of failing, it is almost certain to be spotted (as the calls are actually impossible), and it's COMPLETELY UNNECESSARY.
Why do you think the calls were faked again?
Just finding a kiddies' toy that can make a voice sound like a celebrity, in 2007, doesn't make this argument any more sensible.
Rolfe.