[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
You mentioned £500 in one of your longer rants. Do you want to change your mind about that now, or later?
http://www.audio4fun.com/

Okay Malcolm I'll bite.

That software is what? £20. Small change to a loads of money kind of guy like you.

I'll need another volunteer. We will separately record ourselves reading out a 500 word section of a play, a book, or script. You can can choose. We'll give you a MP3 or a WAV or whatever you need. You then go, and use that magic piece of software, and fiddle around, and morph our voices to sound like the other one, and ask the rest of the forum to guess which one is which.
 
Yet another hot dog, who turns up with all the quali's etc.
You talk total baloney, otherwise planes would not have put in their own on board cell phone masts.
For outright lies and false credentials, you are consigned to the 'ignore' bin permanently.

Brave Sir Malcom, he bravely ran away.. bravely ran away, away...

FFS. The specs are there. I even pointed out *which* spec to star looking at.

But hey, why let reality get in the way, when it is so easy to spout nonsense, then ignore those who corrects one, eh?
 
Because the machine already knows the song that being sung.
You don't want to add to Rolfe's £500 do you. I have the info ready and waiting.
You've just granted real time pitch shift technology, so I guess your answers no.

Oh, and two things.

1) False credentials. Yeah, thats a nice one to come from you Malcolm.

2) The reason why companies installs specific BTSs in tplanes is that while the specs show that calls are *possible* on a plane, that doesnt mean it's 100% reliable. There's a difference.
 
<.... Snip lots of stuff about the history of karaoke machines, and what the early models did and didn't do....>

OK, and I mean this. If Malcolm can find absolute proof that "the original karaoke machine" back in the 1970s or 1980s was able to make an out-of-tune voice emerge from the speakers in-tune, in real time, by altering the voice and not the backing track, I will donate £500 (more than the $1,000 he offered to donate if it could be proven that Dubya, as President, had attended a photo-op with primary school kids prior to 11th September 2001) to the registered charity of his choice.

Get to it, Malcolm.


You mentioned £500 in one of your longer rants. Do you want to change your mind about that now, or later?
http://www.audio4fun.com/


If anyone can see what a web page about a modern digital voice morpher has to do with the challenge I posted, please let me know.

Malcolm, you stated categorically that the original karaoke machines had, from the first, the capability to correct wrong pitch sung into the microphone, and output the note from the speakers at the correct pitch, in real time.

That was what I was calling you on. You made it up. The original karaoke machines of the 1970s and 1980s had no such capability. Trying to claim that the existence of a digital instrument capable of altering voices in 2007 satisfies my challenge is about as honest as anyone posting a picture of GWB visiting an old folks' home in 2003 and claiming that satisfied your challenge to find a picture of him visiting a primary school in January-August 2001.

So no, try again.

You're thrashing in the dark here. First it's some top-secret voice-morphing technology, then it's something someone mentioned in an article which turns out not to be realtime, then it's old karaoke machines, then any karaoke machine will do so long as it tells you if you're flat, then we shoot off at a tangent to impressionists, and now we're being shown a modern kids' toy.

Nowhere have we seen any sign of a device that's capable of changing a stranger's voice so that it appears to a mother to be that of her own son, when that son is not a celebrity and sample recordings of his voice are not available.

And have you made up your mind yet whether it was done in real time, or by pre-recording? Because I'll tell you, pre-recording won't cut it. There's no way to ensure phrases are available to answer any unforeseen question.

And still Malcolm persists in claiming that it was impossible that the calls could have been made as claimed.

Malcolm, the only way the very idea of faking calls is plausible, is if it's so well-known that calls can and are made from aeroplanes that complete voice silence from the four planes would have been noticed and commented on as suspicious (dammit, it wouldn't even have been that suspicious, maybe all the passengers had been terrorised into submission or even killed, who would have known?).

There's NO WAY this over-cautious Rothschilde of yours would have dreamed of doing anything so risky or so pointless as faking these telephone calls, and doubly so if it was so easy to verify that it was impossible the calls could even have been connected.

You didn't even have any idea WHY he might have ordered something so pointless, so ridiculous as that, until I asked you! First, it was just to make the story more convincing. Yeah, right, making impossible phone calls is a very good way to make your story convincing, I don't think. Then you had a think. No, it was to plant in everyone's minds that Arab terrorists were to blame. Don't be ridiculous, the idea was in everybody's minds long before the phone calls were reported! Indeed, all Rothschilde has to do is to prime his media buddies to make the suggestion on TV and radio. Simple as that. Don't you think that's what he'd have done, and not risked the whole plan by faking impossible phone calls that were almost guaranteed to go wrong (because a fake could never have produced the effect of a real call)?

Rothschilde's clever, Malcolm. He'll give any plan the thumbs down that has the slightest chance of failing. The faking of phone calls doesn't just have a huge chance of failing, it is almost certain to be spotted (as the calls are actually impossible), and it's COMPLETELY UNNECESSARY.

Why do you think the calls were faked again?

Just finding a kiddies' toy that can make a voice sound like a celebrity, in 2007, doesn't make this argument any more sensible.

Rolfe.
 
This continues to make no sense.

Why on Earth would you expect anything he-who-used-to-be-Malcolm-Kirkman says to make sense? Has he not impressed you so far with is complete lack of knowledge in every subject area into which he's ventured?

Personally, I'm waiting for him to "connect the dots" and declare UA93 crashed because of an inadvertent leak in the passenger cabin that let all the gravity in.
 
So this software, available new in 2007, somehow helped them to fake voices six years ago in 2001?

Well, let's just see what AV Voice Changer Software Diamond can do ...

Yeah, it says it can change the pitch and timbre of your voice in real time. Here's what it doesn't say it can do: change your voice to match some real person's.

And here's what people have to say about the software:

The software is horrible the voice changes are far from normal human voices. I tried so many different tones, pitches, and everything else and could not get the darn thing to create a realistic sounding voice.

source

I have no doubt this software helps disguise your voice. But recreate somebody else's? Nonsense.

And even if it could, where are the people who worked the software? Where are the programmers who created the software six years before it was invented? Where are the guards who beat the passengers until they agreed to give normal-sounding voice samples? Where are the technicians who determined the pitch and timbre of the passengers' voices so they could reproduce them? Where are the men in black who actually pretended to be the passengers? And where are the passengers today?

You see, every time you have to change your story, the conspiracy just gets larger and more complicated. That's what paradigms do just before they deflate and die.
Grow up.
 
Okay Malcolm I'll bite.

That software is what? £20. Small change to a loads of money kind of guy like you.

I'll need another volunteer. We will separately record ourselves reading out a 500 word section of a play, a book, or script. You can can choose. We'll give you a MP3 or a WAV or whatever you need. You then go, and use that magic piece of software, and fiddle around, and morph our voices to sound like the other one, and ask the rest of the forum to guess which one is which.
You mean like this,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OGhMZ_31gW4
 


Lordy, lordy, lord.

So that no one else has to click the link: This is Avril Lavigne's video for "I Don't Like Your Girlfriend" over which Barrett105 has used voice morphing software for ... well, no discernable reason.

Several things are evident:

1. This video was posted on July 12, 2007 which does nothing to help Malcolm's argument that real-time voice morphing was available in 2001.

2. The software was applied to a pre-existing soundtrack which does nothing to help Malcolm's argument that such technology could be used in real time on live voices.

3. Barrett105 does succeed in making Avril's voice sound different. At the high end, she sounds like a chipmunk. At the low end, she sounds kind of like a guy or a really deep-voiced woman. This does nothing to help Malcolm's argument that one voice could be made to sound like a specific person's voice or that it could be done well enough to fool someone's mother.

4. The video sounds ... horrible. Really. Whenever Avril's voice departs from normal, all of the other sounds become muted and distorted. I couldn't tell but it seemed like the sound sped up with the high voice and slowed down with the low one but maybe not. In any case, when things returned to normal the sound quality improved dramatically. This does nothing to help Malcolm's argument that such voice morphing could be done so well as to be indistinguishable from the real thing.

5. A grown man - an adult of more than five decades and proud subject of the British Crown - posted an Avril Lavigne video.
 

It's remarkable. Not the video, but the fact that you think those pitch-shift effects resemble natural voices. Even with the crummy audio quality of streaming video and the crummy quality of the speakers connected to this computer, the fact that the vocal has been pitch-shifted is painfully obvious. It bears out what I learned through experience using these effects in the studio- if you try to shift a vocal by more than about a major third, it comes out sounding obviously unnatural.

Here's another video that uses some significant pitch shift effects on the background vocals (there are four effects, pitch up, pitch down, distortion and flanging, each used on an individual line with the order mixed up between verses): This is Your Cat on Drugs. The artifacting on the pitch-shifted lines should be obvious.

I could easily use DSP-based pitch shifting to make myself sound just like someone else- if I limit my choices to Alvin, Simon or Theodore it would be no problem. OTOH, if I wanted to be David Seville I'd be SOL. Apart from the obvious effects that shifting my bass-baritone to his vocal range would produce, there's no such thing as a DSP plug-in that can make someone from Philly sound like he grew up in Fresno.

Don't ever think of working in the audio industry, Malcom. You haven't got the ears.
 


Malcolm, no--ZERO--calls from the hijacked planes were faked. Existing voice-morphing technology, to say nothing of the technology that was available six years ago, does NOT permit conversations. It will be quite a while before such magic comes to pass.

Your mathematically-impossible conspiracy does not exist.

Your "military bad boys" do not exist.

The crash of Flight 77 into the Pentagon was confirmed by aircraft wreckage and human remains.

The crash of Flight 175 into the South Tower was confirmed by aircraft wreckage and human remains.

There were no remote-controlled planes, no explosives in the Twin Towers, no flyovers of the Pentagon.

Your evil movement is dying, Malcolm. Nothing you have posted here is reality-based. Soon you will need to find a life.
 


Yes, very impressive - NOT.

But how are you getting on with finding that evidence to meet the challenge I set you? I'm sure you have very worthy charities that could use a bit of cash.

Remember, this challenge (emphasis slightly altered to highlight the bit Malcolm seems to be forgetting):

If Malcolm can find absolute proof that "the original karaoke machine" back in the 1970s or 1980s was able to make an out-of-tune voice emerge from the speakers in-tune, in real time, by altering the voice and not the backing track, I will donate £500 (more than the $1,000 he offered to donate if it could be proven that Dubya, as President, had attended a photo-op with primary school kids prior to 11th September 2001) to the registered charity of his choice.

You know, evidence about what the original, Real Karaoke machines did as standard, before all these cowboys came and hijacked the brand name so that something that was once commonp;ace became an esoteric secret known only to hundreds of thousands of incompetent musicians....

No, you don't even need to prove the second part. Maybe the feature fell into disuse because people preferred the fun of listening to their mates sing as flat as a flounder, I don't know. Just evidence that the original analogue machines, that were the first Real Karaoke devices, could do this.

Forget 2007-vintage digital kiddies' toys, whether or not they work. If you want your pub darts team to get the money (assuming they're a Registered Charity that is :D ), find your evidence.

Rolfe.
 
Maybe if I post this as a separate post, Malcolm will take more notice. I think his attention span needs a bit of work.

WHY WAS IT NECESSARY TO FAKE ANY PHONE CALLS IN THE FIRST PLACE????

Remember, making someone's voice sound enough like another person's, that person not being a celebrity with lots of recorded examples to work from, so that it fools his own mother, has not been shown to be possible, not by you, not by anyone. So there is a chance the simulation won't be good enough and the mother will realise she's being set up.

If you think you might improve your chances of getting away with this by recording the script in advance, remember that introduces even more possibility of being caught out, as you may well not have a suitable clip to play in response to an unexpected question. A string of er.... um.... won't cut it. Your "passenger" may even have an agreed code he uses to identify himself to his family.

So deciding to make these calls rather than maintain audio silence from the passengers needs a helluva motivation.

The only one which even begins to be plausible is that it's so well-known that telephone calls from airliners are possible, that people might start to question why nobody in any of these planefuls of passengers managed to get through at all. (And even that isn't all that compelling, because most people might easliy just have assumed the passengers were either terrorised into not trying anything, or possibly simply killed.)

But there you are, Malcolm, killing your own case by insisting that it was actually impossible for anyone to have made real calls! (I keep asking for a foot-in-mouth smilie...)

So, the obvious reason won't do for you.

You've just made it even more insane for Rothschilde even to contemplate a complicated and risky setup of call-faking. Not only might the voices be recognised as fakery, or the non-sequitur pre-recorded replies cause the relatives to smell a rat, it's even more of a rule8-ing insane plan, because you're faking something which is impossible, and will surely be spotted as impossible!

No, Malcolm, Rothschilde said go away, it's a stupid plan, you're fired.

Your two tries so far. It made the whole thing seem more authentic. Hell and damnation, it doesn't get more authentic than seeing freaking great airliners crash into New York on live TV - or even live in front of you in the case of a lot of people. You ain't going to make that seem more real by faking phone calls which are impossible.

You may even have realised this, because you tried again. To plant in everyone's mind the picture of Arab hijackers taking over the planes. No, we all remember that the whole affair was assumed to be Arab hijackers long before the phone calls became public. If you need to reinforce that, just get some of your media buddies to push the idea in a few news bulletins. That'll do until the passports and the DNA you planted, and the security videos you faked up, get into the public domain.

There is no way in hell Rothschilde needed these phone calls. Not even if the connections were perfectly possible, everyday technology (as in fact they were). Not for realism, not for fleshing out the story, not for anything. And I already outlined the risks.

You said Rothschilde would always go with the clean, simple, foolproof plan. That's been your main standpoint from the beginning. There's nothing clean, simple or foolproof about these phone calls. Such a huge undertaking, with so much risk, for no necessary objective. And if it really was the case that calls couldn't have been made from the planes, rule8-ing suicidal.

Why did he do it again, Malcolm?

Rolfe.
 
The previous exchange ended with one of you conceeding that getting a plane airborne with no one on board was old stuff.
Are you disputing that?


Is this an admission that Raytheon did not, in fact, do what you have been claiming........or is it yet another dodge?

And that's not what I said. What I did say was if you could modify the autopilot for auto-takeoff - you can get a stock 767 to do pretty much anything your "remote control ex-military bad boys" can do and much more......making the need for heavily modified drones from Offutt completely unnecessary. Moreover, I was trying to help you make your theory much less complicated while trying to get you informed on a topic which, frankly, you really shouldn't be opining on. But apparently, you'd rather repeat yourself, be willfully ignorant, and have your theory be as unnecessarily complicated as possible....
 

Oh in the name of all that is sweet pure and holy.

Malcolm mate, I'm not a engineer or a physicist or any of the incredibly intelligent boffins on this site. I have not got a doctorate or PHD like many on this site. I have a simple BA in film production, which proudly adorns the wall in my mum's living room. I work as an assistant editor on film and tv.

Right now, I'm kicking back and waiting for a test audio conform to see if it works. We have a process in film called ADR that stands for Automatic Dialogue Replacing. Its when while they are filming a piece of dialogue spoken by an actor, is muffled or fluffed. For example most of the Dialogue on Excalibur was ADR'd (or Looped) because the clanking of the armor worn by actors ruined the lines. Getting actors back in for ADR is often a pain, it's months after the shoot, they're on new jobs, and actors find this process laborious and tedious (Peter O'Toole described it as a special kind of hell). Friends of mine spent three months on full pay kicking on their heels waiting for Robert Downey Jr to get paroled so they could do a session. It's an expensive time consuming process.

Do you really think that if there was a way to make some anonymous voice actor sound like Tom Cruise, or Brad Pitt, productions wouldn't leap over it. That it wouldn't be part of the box of tricks of my job?

Your you tube "demonstration" was nonsense, as other people noted, whomever did this just messed around with the pitch and tone, but didn't produce a credible alternative. You also don't know if the process was real time. If the person had taken the song, and made Avril sound like Madonna, or Alanis Morrisette or Grace Jones, or Nina Simone and you'd have a point. Instead you've got someone stretching and altering a song. Kudos to them on making a piece of obnoxious drivel even more unlistenable though.

So the bet still stands. Take a recording of two users of this forum, and alter them so you they each sound like the other one. And do it real time.
 
To close down the Karaoke discussion:
1. Karaoke was invented in 1971, and originally used casette tapes. No digital ANYTHING.
2. In 1984, there was a demonstration of high tech digital signal processing done at the school I attended at the time. They were trying to interest college bound students in math and engineering, and the DSP demo was one of the things they did. The demo consisted of a real time pitch changer. It was built into a 19 inch rack, and was as tall as the guy running the demo. The equipment had been assemlbed out of commerically available units, and specially programmed by the engineers running the demo. It took several really sharp engineers to assemble the thing for the demos at each school.

You've read what others say about the limitations of pitch changing. If you've got any honesty in you, you've tried tried some of the freely available software. You should know by now that pitch changing won't match your voice to someone else's, and that pitch change alone is inadequate as a "voice morphing" technology. Along with that is the stupidity of making fake phone calls. Phone calls from the aircraft were possible with both cell phones and airfones at the time of the attacks.

The "voice morphing" argument was busted when it came out. Drop it, it only makes you look clueless.
 
You're not coming out with that foreshortening BS again are you?


I told you not to take my word for it; go post a link to the photo on a photography forum and ask for comments about foreshortening from the photographers there. Are you going to do as I suggest, Malcolm? Why not? Are you too busy proclaiming the existence of a US government conspiracy to bother about inconvenient details such as evidence??

Before you do that tell me the properties of a right angled triangle.


Very well, but I'll expect you to answer a few direct questions in return. For a given right triangle,

a2 + b2 = c2
where a and b represent the lengths of the sides adjacent to the right angle, and c represents the length of the side opposite the right triangle (the hypotenuse)

Queen Elizabeth controls absolutely zilch with regard to the general population. Call me out on that one, why don't you?


You seem to have missed my point, which is that the web site from which you lifted the claims about the Oklahoma City bombing contains articles advocating all sorts of hare-brained conspiracy theories.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom