[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Of course it does. Which is why a few moment's of Googling - not even real research - would have shown you immediately that your ideas about vacuum and gravity (and IV bags) were wrong.

As I said before, this sort of stuff seriously undermines your credibility. The claims belie a very poor understanding of basic physical principles and a poor set of observational skills, and your stubbornness in clinging to them despite repeated explanations speaks poorly of your willingness to admit errors and actually learn something. Is that the impression you want to give? Do you think you'll convince anybody that way?

I'm trying to help you here. You can wave it off if you want, but don't say I didn't try.

You'll have no difficulty waving off the points I've made about the video then will you?
 
Erm, are you claiming there must have been a fake triage site where the guardrail is, otherwise "they" wouldn't have "Photoshopped" the guardrail out?? :confused:




Sigh. Malcolm, why do you continue to embarrass yourself? The object is not a dumpster. It's a large diesel generator, which is shown close-up (and still on fire) starting about 7:34. The generator's fuel supply and lubricating oil burned fiercely for many minutes after the impact.




Which describes fairly accurately the upper part of the hole, made by the fuselage. There are many still photographs that show the lower part of the hole, made by the engines and the inner part of the wings. Pugh undoubtedly couldn't see the lower part very well because of all the smoke, plus the foam and water, and having his view blocked by the fire apparatus. This is obvious from the video.




Malcolm, you are hopelessly prejudiced in favor of a conspiracy and will ignore or rationalize away any and all evidence that doesn't fit your predetermined conclusion, as the unbiased reader of this thread will now realize. Clear and logical reasoning is a skill you have quite frankly utterly failed to demonstrate.
1. I am not claiming to know what was in the mind of the faker, only that the photo is clearly faked.
2. You agree then that the pall of smoke over the Pentagon was burning oil that was nothing to do with the building itself. Can you find an MSM report that tells us this.
3. You say the hole on the first floor only. Please, he is describing the ONLY hole in the Pentagon in answer to the question that was asked him.
 
I have asked posters to concentrate on specific photos and not Jack White.
The post you replied to specifically mentioned lamp pole No.2.
In probably over 800 words you avoided it completely.

You are using Jack White and his dubious photo analysis skills as source material, which opens his ability to produce said material to scrutiny. As to "concentrating", you've shown a remarkable tendency to meander aimlessly around the distant corners of the 9/11 conspiracy universe, choosing a new topic each time your "facts" prove to be baseless claims and opinions. During your wandering you've managed to make some ridiculous claims concerning such wide ranging topics as world history and physics. So if I'm slightly off your current tack, its because no navigator could possibly figure out where you're attempting to go. IN fact, within 2 posts of chiding me for being off topic you were droning on about missing guard rails (which aren't) and the triage area, which I discussed.

To even get to the page on light poles you have to scroll through 40 pages of hyperbole, and what's the payoff? A picture of a lightpole on the grass and one standing nearby with Jack's screaming about "is it the same?" and "photoshop" and "almost undamaged!!"

So... that's it? This one shot is what we're supposed to be convinced by? A standing light pole and a downed light pole? That... supposedly are the same... or were planted? Or were... I don't know, dragged in on a semi truck with all the fake plane debris and pyrotechnics?

Maybe they used their antigravity tubes...
 
Nothing else works for a truther.



Who cares about the guard rail ? What's so important about it ?



A dead givaway of what ?



This one disagrees with him.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_6080469e66ec2fb25.jpg[/qimg]



Because the guard rail wasn't there in the picture ????

Edited by Darat: 
Content removed - Not in Moderated thread - sorry I didn't check the gif before I approved the post, assumed it was linked ot the thread topic

You agree that the photo you have posted is the entrance hole - Yes?
 
All this and you are not in a position to pass an opinion on a lamp pole?


I said I'd look at your pictures once you'd explicitly agreed that i/v sets work as described, with no need for any size of hole in the top of the bag to let anything in, and that gravity acts normally on objects in a vacuum.

Still not seeing such agreement.

Rolfe.
 
It's all circumstantial, of course. But it's a hell of a lot more substantive than a Jack White photo analysis.
I'm assuming that you posted this before seeing theBob Pugh video and the points I made. Would you care to comment on that?
 
You are using Jack White and his dubious photo analysis skills as source material, which opens his ability to produce said material to scrutiny. As to "concentrating", you've shown a remarkable tendency to meander aimlessly around the distant corners of the 9/11 conspiracy universe, choosing a new topic each time your "facts" prove to be baseless claims and opinions. During your wandering you've managed to make some ridiculous claims concerning such wide ranging topics as world history and physics. So if I'm slightly off your current tack, its because no navigator could possibly figure out where you're attempting to go. IN fact, within 2 posts of chiding me for being off topic you were droning on about missing guard rails (which aren't) and the triage area, which I discussed.

To even get to the page on light poles you have to scroll through 40 pages of hyperbole, and what's the payoff? A picture of a lightpole on the grass and one standing nearby with Jack's screaming about "is it the same?" and "photoshop" and "almost undamaged!!"

So... that's it? This one shot is what we're supposed to be convinced by? A standing light pole and a downed light pole? That... supposedly are the same... or were planted? Or were... I don't know, dragged in on a semi truck with all the fake plane debris and pyrotechnics?

Maybe they used their antigravity tubes...
You agree then that you have seen two lamp poles No.2.
To be clearer, you agree that lamp pole No.2 is photographed lying on the grass bank and also, in another photo standing on its foundation untouched.
Both photos taken after after the attack. Yet you forego any comment on this except a couple of lines of wandering gibberish.
 
I said I'd look at your pictures once you'd explicitly agreed that i/v sets work as described, with no need for any size of hole in the top of the bag to let anything in, and that gravity acts normally on objects in a vacuum.

Still not seeing such agreement.

Rolfe.
No, this is what you said and I quote,
"... photographs of an area I've never seen in my life and have no way of verifying."
This is a clear indication from you that you are not in a position to pass an opinion on a photograph, unless you are familiar with the area by personal sight.
 
You'll have no difficulty waving off the points I've made about the video then will you?


Malcolm - You've continued to ignore comments I, jsiv and Spitfire made about White's page 8 and the "helicopter operations" signs. At the same time, you've chastised other readers for ignoring the points you wanted to focus on.

These two pictures of the "helicopter operations" signs were brought up by you. A challenge was made to debunk them by you. An attack was made upon the photos at your request.

You have not responded to these points. Will you respond in any way? If not, shall I add this to the list of claims made by you which have been successfully refuted.

[spolier]Although, by now he "helicopter operations" signs have probably all floated away as there was no hole in the top of them to let gravity in.[/spoiler]
 
No, this is what you said and I quote,
"... photographs of an area I've never seen in my life and have no way of verifying."
This is a clear indication from you that you are not in a position to pass an opinion on a photograph, unless you are familiar with the area by personal sight.


The relevant quote of what I said was

If you continue to be intransigent on these points, I fail to see why I (or anyone else for that matter) should oblige you by looking at any photographs.


Now I also said in that post that I preferred to pontificate about matters I had some knowledge about. I have no personal knowledge about the area around the Pentagon, so I'm a little surprised you seem to want my opinion so badly, when you rejected my statements about i/v infusions, which were not only within my area of expertise, they were also correct.

However, I'll repeat the offer. If you explicitly agree that i/v sets work as described, with no need for any size of hole in the top of the bag to let anything in, and that gravity acts normally on objects in a vacuum, I'll look at the pictures. Whether there's enough information there to allow an opinion without any knowledge of the place where they were taken is impossible to tell, without looking.

And I've explained several times under what conditions I'll look. Up to you, I should coco.

Rolfe.
 
1. I am not claiming to know what was in the mind of the faker, only that the photo is clearly faked.

Well, since nobody here agrees with you, I'd say it's a far cry from being clear.

You agree that the photo you have posted is the entrance hole - Yes?

I agree that the damaged section of the Pentagon was fairly the same width as a 757.
 
No, this is what you said and I quote,
"... photographs of an area I've never seen in my life and have no way of verifying."
This is a clear indication from you that you are not in a position to pass an opinion on a photograph, unless you are familiar with the area by personal sight.

Do IVs work as we said they do, Malcolm ?
 
You agree then that you have seen two lamp poles No.2.
No. I saw two different lamp posts. Additionally I've seen lamp posts in other photographs around the Pentagon at the time of the attack. Some were standing. Some had been knocked over.
To be clearer, you agree that lamp pole No.2 is photographed lying on the grass bank and also, in another photo standing on its foundation untouched.
No.
Yet you forego any comment on this except a couple of lines of wandering gibberish.
:rolleyes:

Let's see, I criticized your source material. I patiently explained why I criticized your ridiculous source material and I pointed out that your concept of focusing on an issue involves meandering aimlessly into topics with which you have but the most tenuous grasp of understanding. I then explained how underwhelmed I was by Mister White's overblown expose on a fallen light pole and his lack of any sort of analysis. From this you've decided that I agree with your assessment of the pole and then accused me of writing "wandering gibberish".

But please, do explain to us what this (claimed) duplication of light poles means. Then explain how it relates to your theories on Warren Buffet, WWII history, penetration analysis and gravity.
 
No. I saw two different lamp posts. Additionally I've seen lamp posts in other photographs around the Pentagon at the time of the attack. Some were standing. Some had been knocked over.
No.

:rolleyes:

Let's see, I criticized your source material. I patiently explained why I criticized your ridiculous source material and I pointed out that your concept of focusing on an issue involves meandering aimlessly into topics with which you have but the most tenuous grasp of understanding. I then explained how underwhelmed I was by Mister White's overblown expose on a fallen light pole and his lack of any sort of analysis. From this you've decided that I agree with your assessment of the pole and then accused me of writing "wandering gibberish".

But please, do explain to us what this (claimed) duplication of light poles means. Then explain how it relates to your theories on Warren Buffet, WWII history, penetration analysis and gravity.

My "ridiculous source" as you call it is the US government.
I have repeatedly emphasised that Jack White's interpretations are not my interpretations.
The duplication of light poles tells me that someone planted the felled pole and forgot to remove the original.
Perhaps you have a better explanation?
 
The relevant quote of what I said was




Now I also said in that post that I preferred to pontificate about matters I had some knowledge about. I have no personal knowledge about the area around the Pentagon, so I'm a little surprised you seem to want my opinion so badly, when you rejected my statements about i/v infusions, which were not only within my area of expertise, they were also correct.

However, I'll repeat the offer. If you explicitly agree that i/v sets work as described, with no need for any size of hole in the top of the bag to let anything in, and that gravity acts normally on objects in a vacuum, I'll look at the pictures. Whether there's enough information there to allow an opinion without any knowledge of the place where they were taken is impossible to tell, without looking.

And I've explained several times under what conditions I'll look. Up to you, I should coco.

Rolfe.

Don't bother, I'm not that desperate.
 
Well, since nobody here agrees with you, I'd say it's a far cry from being clear.



I agree that the damaged section of the Pentagon was fairly the same width as a 757.
Is the photo you posted of the entrance hole or not?
 
My "ridiculous source" as you call it is the US government.
I have repeatedly emphasised that Jack White's interpretations are not my interpretations.
The duplication of light poles tells me that someone planted the felled pole and forgot to remove the original.
Perhaps you have a better explanation?

Could you give me a direct link to White page that has the pictures you're talking about (I'm not going to go hunting through hundreds of pages to find them)?

I'll give you my opinion on this "pole no. 2" stuff if you respond to my earlier comments first.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom