[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Considering that the pole was hit by an airplane doing several hundred kilometers an hour, I have no problem imagining the pole flying and spinning into the air for a few moments.
Here's another pole that was hit by an airplane, that's what the government tells us.
Here is pole 2 standing after the 'attack'
84-911polepuzzle.jpg
 
I don't know, but you don't have to worry about it...safe behind your computer, believing only what you can Google.
I'll be in New York on 9/11, if not in body, I'll be there in spirit.
I'll be watching Alex Jones' back, me and a million other people.
 
So, I explain that military men use the term "missile" to describe a flying object that causes damage and you recycle ancient rubbish that deliberately distorts Rumsfeld's meaning. Nobody sane thought that Rumsfeld was denying that a plane hit the Pentagon for a very good reason: a plane did hit the Pentagon. Have you read Jim Fetzer's debates with the military historian J.R. Dunn?
Edited by chillzero: 
Moderated thread


http://www.americanthinker.com/2006/09/911_a_hoax_scholar_for_911_tru.html

http://www.americanthinker.com/2006/09/the_911_pentagon_conspiracy_th.html
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm not sure why someone who just a couple of posts ago, denied that 9/11 was an inside job, now wants further and better details of how it was done? Was the revelation that lamp pole 5 was still standing, therefore the one over the hedge had to be a plant, your road to Damascus? Or was it one of the many other examples of a staged attack you saw on this webpage,
http://www.911studies.com/911photostudies1.htm


Malcolm, do you know anything about Jack White? Did you even bother to do any research on him before you cited his work as a source? Are you aware that White claims to have proven the Apollo moon landings were a hoax based on his photo analyses? Do you believe the NASA moon missions were faked? If not, why do you cite Jack White as a source?

Also, do you know that White was thoroughly discredited during his testimony before the [US] House [of Representatives] Select Committee on Assassinations, when he attempted to demonstrate that two photographs taken of Lee Harvey Oswald holding his rifle were fakes? Photos that Oswald wife repeatedly admitted to having taken, and that were shown by qualified experts to have been unaltered first-generation prints from negatives taken with Oswald's camera, to the exclusion of all other cameras?

From the Clavius page on White:

Jay Windley said:
Jack White first made a name for himself by trying to show that the famous photographs . . . of accused Kennedy assassin Lee Harvey Oswald holding a rifle in his back yard had been falsified. Claiming, among other things, that he had found discrepancies between the measurements of that rifle taken from the photo, and other photographs of the rifle recovered from the Texas School Book Depository, White maintained that Oswald was holding a different rifle than the one believed to be used to shoot President Kennedy.

Unfortunately under examination before the U.S. House Select Committee on Assassinations White's evidence completely fell apart. He demonstrated almost no understanding of the mathematical and geometrical principles of photogrammetry. He admitted to having received no training in photogrammetry or the forensic analysis of photographs.

His embarrassment before Congress did not stop White from continuing his research on the Kennedy assassination, although his findings remain questionable. . . .

Jack White's skill, methodology, and training in photographic interpretation are relevant to his recent study of the Apollo photographs. The best evidence of that skill, methodology, and training are his own statements given under oath, and the reactions of those who heard those statements. . . .

White's approach to Apollo photography is especially clumsy. While we are not Kennedy assassination experts, we are Apollo experts, and his assertions regarding the Apollo photographs are frequently absurd. In many cases White demonstrates he doesn't understand what various Apollo equipment is or what it's used for. And in a few cases he has edited and composed the photos in a way that creates "anomalies" that weren't there otherwise. . . .

For example, White cropped and resized two photos of the same lunar mountain in order to argue that the mountain "changed size" between the two photos, suggesting the same studio backdrop was used in two different occasions. In fact, when the unaltered photos are examined the mountain is proportionally the same size.

Jack White sometimes alters photographs, creating "anomalies" which he then argues proves the photos were faked. . . .

He holds a bachelor of arts degree in journalism with a minor in history from the Texas Christian University. (Proceedings of the House Select Committee on Assassinations vol. 2, p. 322.)

We concede that White's work with Witherspoon and Associates establishes he is an expert in photographic compositing and duplication. But we hasten to emphasize that these are not the same skills required to reliably characterize objects that appear in photographs, and their relationship to each other and to the camera. White's demonstrated skills may aid in the detection of forgery based on artifacts of photographic composition. But we dispute his expertise at identifying forged photographs on such grounds as lighting, parallax, perspective, and photogrammetry.

White's allegations regarding Apollo photography do not correspond to his demonstrated area of expertise. They instead tend to derive from photogrammetric analysis, shadow analysis, and perspective analysis -- topics White admits are not within his expertise. . . .

Someone who is so frequently wrong should not normally enjoy credibility. However, because White's embarrassment was handed to him by elected representatives of the U.S. government, White has acquired a sort of folk hero status with the anti-government conspiracy theorists. They apparently see him as a sort of "little guy" who was inappropriately squashed by the Goliath of the United States Congress, and who bravely continues the fight.

Except that Congress properly rejected his testimony. Other experts whose credentials are not in question testified that White's analysis of the Oswald backyard photos is wrong and did not consider factors White would have probably understood had he been properly trained. It's hard to argue that White was being "suppressed" when he himself admitted he didn't have the appropriate knowledge. [emphasis added]
 
So, I explain that military men use the term "missile" to describe a flying object that causes damage and you recycle ancient rubbish that deliberately distorts Rumsfeld's meaning. Nobody sane thought that Rumsfeld was denying that a plane hit the Pentagon for a very good reason: a plane did hit the Pentagon. Have you read Jim Fetzer's debates with the military historian J.R. Dunn?
Edited by chillzero: 
Moderated thread


http://www.americanthinker.com/2006/09/911_a_hoax_scholar_for_911_tru.html

http://www.americanthinker.com/2006/09/the_911_pentagon_conspiracy_th.html

You mean like UFO = Unidentified Flying Missile.
 
Yikes. sn't Jack White the one famous for his "brilliant" photo analysis of the moon landing images?

Malcom please, please for God's sake apply a little objectivity to things, even if they support your world view? You know, Jack White thinks the Apollo landings were faked. His 'photo' analysis of the event is even laughed at by janitors in scientific institutions.

Can I assume you think the Apollo landings were faked?
 
Malcolm, do you know anything about Jack White? Did you even bother to do any research on him before you cited his work as a source? Are you aware that White claims to have proven the Apollo moon landings were a hoax based on his photo analyses? Do you believe the NASA moon missions were faked? If not, why do you cite Jack White as a source?

Also, do you know that White was thoroughly discredited during his testimony before the [US] House [of Representatives] Select Committee on Assassinations, when he attempted to demonstrate that two photographs taken of Lee Harvey Oswald holding his rifle were fakes? Photos that Oswald wife repeatedly admitted to having taken, and that were shown by qualified experts to have been unaltered first-generation prints from negatives taken with Oswald's camera, to the exclusion of all other cameras?

From the Clavius page on White:
Did Jack White get the doctor to hold up the drip feed bag?
 
Yikes. sn't Jack White the one famous for his "brilliant" photo analysis of the moon landing images?

Malcom please, please for God's sake apply a little objectivity to things, even if they support your world view? You know, Jack White thinks the Apollo landings were faked. His 'photo' analysis of the event is even laughed at by janitors in scientific institutions.

Can I assume you think the Apollo landings were faked?
We're not argueing the toss with regard to the moon landings.
Everything is faked with you isn't it. Everything except 9/11 itself.
What about your vaunted NIST report, page 35, image 6.1.
Only one engine, no marks on the wall, no broken windows
http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/build03/PDF/b03017.pdf
Now address the question of lamp pole No 2, if you don't mind.
http://www.911studies.com/911photostudies1.htm
 
You mean like UFO = Unidentified Flying Missile.

Thanks for putting Dunn up. I've had a great laugh. I laughed so much, I nearly bought the bride a takeaway.
I quote Dunn, wit hregard ro the Pentagon,
"The wings, tailplane and rudder are irrelevant".
Begging the reply, "How did the plane fly then?"
or
"Very true when you're describing a missile".
 
Thanks for that, I understand now. In an elevator, 0 = the first floor and 1 = the second floor. I won't get lost so much in future, now that I know that.

I was only in Europe once and that was in the 1970's so I don't recall what I actually saw in the elevators i experienced there.

However in Canada and the USA every elevator I have been on has the button that will take the elevator car to the ground floor marked as "G" (ground0 or "L"(lobby) or indeed as "1". The next button that will take one to the level above that is marked "2" and sometimes as "M" (mezzanine, dependant upon there being a walkway overlooking the first floor(ground level).

There, I hope this clears up the utter idiocy you have displayed concerning this well known bit of difference between how we do things on this side of the pond and how you believe things are done in a place you have never visited. Do you think we are all just having you on, pulling your leg, or simply lieing?
 
Yikes. sn't Jack White the one famous for his "brilliant" photo analysis of the moon landing images?

Malcom please, please for God's sake apply a little objectivity to things, even if they support your world view? You know, Jack White thinks the Apollo landings were faked. His 'photo' analysis of the event is even laughed at by janitors in scientific institutions.

Can I assume you think the Apollo landings were faked?
Only a fool would shoot the messenger, without checking out the message.
 
1. For every site you show me that says the plane went in at around column 17, I'll show you one that says around column 10. That's why I told you,
"move the goalposts anywhere you like across the front of the Pentagon" = Pick your entrance spot. Wherever you pick, either the left wing hasn't touched the wall or the right wing hasn't touched the wall. No 757 hit the Pentagon.
2. What about the fake photos in this webpage? What do you say about them. Also the lamp pole tha tis still standing when NIST said it was down.
3. Talking about NIST. Go to their own vaunted report, pg 35, fig 6.1
See anything wrong? In order for them to get their idea of the plane in the cuilding, they've had to chop one engine off.
Even wit hall their baloney, they can't get a two engined plane in the building.
Anyway, what about all the facts on this page?
http://www.911studies.com/911photostudies1.htm


that has totally avoided my point again??

i'll make it simple

1. is the light in the fireman photo fire or molten metal?

2. why did you post a cropped photo of the pentagon, the one with the fence and white car?

3. why not post a full version of this photo, it is in the performance building report?

4. what fake photos are you on about?

5. what about the poor paintshop job on the picture of letter "n" from the plane?

dont avoid it this time malcolm
 
Only a fool would shoot the messenger, without checking out the message.

Only a fool would believe another fool's message without checking it, and him, out first.

Face it. You are everything you accuse us of being, and more. You believe EVERYTHING you hear as long as it supports your world view and dismiss out-of-hand anything that just may not show the US government in the worst light possible.
 
some six stone hung over wastrels


You've said this before, Malcolm, and several people have posted the evidence that the hijackers were trained pilots and so on.

Please provide your evidence that they weighed only six stones.

(For comparison, my 90-year-old mother, who is only 5 feet tall, not at all fat, and has a degree of osteoporosis, topped the scales at 7st 5lb yesterday.)

Oh yes, and your evidence that they were suffering from hangovers on 11th September.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
that has totally avoided my point again??

i'll make it simple

1. is the light in the fireman photo fire or molten metal?

2. why did you post a cropped photo of the pentagon, the one with the fence and white car?

3. why not post a full version of this photo, it is in the performance building report?

4. what fake photos are you on about?

5. what about the poor paintshop job on the picture of letter "n" from the plane?

dont avoid it this time malcolm

1, Both, there has to be molten metal for the glow to be white, but molten metal has its own flames and will burn most everything it comes into contact with. Are there any foundries near you? If so, take a stroll in.
2. I posted that paticular photo to highlight the fence and the wall. I have told you repeatedly to pick your entrance spot. I have also posted or referred to wider photos of the facade.
3. It is not possible to copy from the Performance Report. Simply post the page number and I'll refer to it.
4. The ones on this webpage,
http://www.911studies.com/911photostudies1.htm
5. All your questions regarding this piece of 'wreckage' will be answered after you have looked at the web site referred to in answer 4.
 
You've said this before, Malcolm, and seleral people have posted the evidence that hte hijackers were trained pilots and so on.

Please provide your evidence that they weighed only six stones.

(For comparison, my 90-year-old mother, who is only 5 feet tall, not at all fat, and has a degree of osteoporosis, topped the scales at 7st 5lb yesterday.)

Oh yes, and your evidence that they were suffering from hangovers on 11th September.

Rolfe.
The point being what?
 
I lived in the Horizon House Apartments, Army Navy Drive, Arlington.


And yet you didn't know that in the USA, the ground floor is numbered 1 and referred to as the first floor, while what the UK calls the first floor is referred to as the second floor.

Yeah, right. :nope:

Rolfe.
 
Anything but face the truth, eh.
Have it any way you want. Immediately before the pole was 'pulled' from the windshield, where was it?

Stranger things most certainly have happened and all on the same day.

Malcolm, it seems you are stubbornly refusing to admit that some things DO happen that seem strange or implausible. Now you are admitting they happen, but only on 9/11. Just between you and me, is it possible that you're trying to convince yourself that you don't believe the "OT" ?

A jetliner in New York dropped a skyscraper, twice if you don't mind.

How is that odd ? If the south tower fell, why would you suddenly expect the north one to stand ? It withstood similar damage, didn't it ?

A steel framed 47 storey steel skyscraper dropped like a shot cow, without being touched, aint that a doosey.

I think you're still trying to convince yourself. You know very well that people here are aware that large sections of 1 WTC fell onto 7 WTC, and you've seen the damage and the smoke from the fires, too. So why are you saying it was untouched ? I don't think for a second that you believe that. Now, what's the other alternative, Malcolm ? You wouldn't be lying, would you ?

Now we have half the population calling for an proper investigation and Whackjob

And you still can't back up that number.

This IS stranger than fiction.

No. This is exactly fiction. It's fiction because perfectly understandable and explainable, albeit complex, events happened but you choose to interpret them in a Hollywood way.

Or is it just an act ?

After all you know these things I mentioned above.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom