[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
You should take it as "WTF has that got to do with the price of tea in China?"
As a response to the post you quoted, it is an absolute non-sequitur.

This is WTF it has got to do with it.
On the one hand (9/11) you scream that only absolute proof on all and every point will suffice.
Yet with regard to a pre-emptive strike, such as bombing Iran back into the stone age, the least suspicion will do.
If this were a boxing match, the ref would have stopped the fight ages ago.
 
Please answer the question, Malcolm:

"I disagree. If you claim it's impossible that aluminum airplanes can sever the columns - this should be obvious to physicists. Do you agree?"

Also, what about Seth MacFarlane ?

I refused to communicate with you some time ago. As I have just done with koala bear for repeatedly calling me a liar.
You are wasting your time, goodbye.
 
I'll say three engineers to draw up all the modifications, five to install an autotakeoff system and other associated mods(ability for Satcom or ACARS to communicate with the Flight Management System, GPS/LAAS/JPALS, etc) and test the system once complete. Two to modify the autopilot computers (3 per plane) and three to modify the aircraft and wiring. And I'd guess an additional 10-12 painters to paint the aircraft in UA/AA colors and any kind of timely manner.

As for your missile, that's also unnecessary - I'd put a bomb, or an extra fuel tank inside the aircraft as there's plenty of room inside a 767. No need to risk people seeing a missile, nor is there a reason to needlessly install a ordnance hardpoint.

So far that makes 18-20 just to modify the airplanes, not counting the participation of all the organizations I mentioned in my previous posts.

You see, the biggest hurdle isn't turning a 767 into a cruise missile - it's disappearing the four flights and orchestrating the ensuing coverup. You'd need the cooperation of everyone from coroners, FBI and NTSB investigators, to air traffic controllers, the airlines, and let's not forget about your part planters.

And how did they make the 4 flights and all the passengers and crew disappear? Airlines are in constant communication with their planes via datalink systems called ACARS and ACMS. The operations centers at AA and UA would know exactly when their planes landed as ACARS automatically generates "on" and "in" reports through aircraft sensors(I forget, it's either the parking brake or oil pressure for the "in" report and ground sensing from squat switches on the strut for the "on" report). Surely AA and UA would be surprised to see that their aircraft which were supposedly destroyed by terrorists - actually landed.

I'm most impressed by your aeronautical knowledge.
For the moment can we just concentrate on the alleged attack.
The alleged cover up is a separate issue which I would like to leave until we have nailed the alleged attack planes.
Forgetting the cover up completely for now.
How many people to alter and then get two unmanned planes in the air, forty?
 
This is WTF it has got to do with it.
On the one hand (9/11) you scream that only absolute proof on all and every point will suffice.
Yet with regard to a pre-emptive strike, such as bombing Iran back into the stone age, the least suspicion will do.
If this were a boxing match, the ref would have stopped the fight ages ago.
1. You have yet to provide proof of anything. You have innuendo and opinion, but no proof.
2. You brought up pre-emptive strikes. The first mention of the term is in a post you made.
3. How did Iran get brought into this?

If this were a boxing match, you would not have been allowed into the ring. No gloves, no shorts, and your trainer is out having a beer.
 
Dishonourable with regard to the donation maybe, it depends on who I am dealing with. Some people think that christians can't wait to do a good turn, a bit like boy scouts. Some people think that christians are at a permanent disadvantage because they will always 'do the right thing first' no matter what.
That is a naive and mistaken assessment.
A liar I am not.
With regard to this current state of affairs, you are at such a disadvantage that it's very difficult for me to sound anything other that disdainful.
I am at the slight disadvantage of not being able to post too lengthy a reply, because it might hit the bin.
I could be conversing with an american patriot who is only partially au fait or a neocon who is fully au fait and fighting a rear guard action.
Either way, other people are viewing, so I am getting a message across.
Today's problems are home made and they come from the age old notion of superiority, of ruling, of belonging to a group that does not agree that no one person is any more important than the next.
I could start anywhere, I'll start nearly a hundred years ago with the Titanic.
Brevity being the order of the day.
They got the toffs off the Titanic by locking up families down below in steerage to drown before the ship sank. They put 16 toffs in a life boat that could hold 60. They did this perfectly rationally and after discussion. They did it because they believed in 'superiority'.
Only then did they allow the maxim "Women and children first" to have some airing. I thought that mentality had died, it hasn't. It's a mentality that is food and drink to the likes of me and I will take pleasure in crushing it.
This is nowhere near a complete answer, but it's a start. As I say, brevity is the order of the day.

You are a liar. You made an offer. You said you would provide $1,000 dollars to a charity of a posters choice, if they could provide proof of Bush in a kindergarden class, pre september 11th. When Spitfire X provided ample prove that such events were common place, you introduce the most tortured, filmsy rational, to try and justify your about face.
 
Last edited:
You are a liar. You made an offer. You said you would provide $1,000 dollars to a charity of a posters choice, if they could provide proof of Bush in a kindergarden class, pre september 11th. When Spitfire X provided ample prove that such events were common place, you introduce the most tortured, filmsy rational, to try and justify your about face.
C'est la vie, I refer you to my previous post.
 
1. You have yet to provide proof of anything. You have innuendo and opinion, but no proof.
2. You brought up pre-emptive strikes. The first mention of the term is in a post you made.
3. How did Iran get brought into this?

If this were a boxing match, you would not have been allowed into the ring. No gloves, no shorts, and your trainer is out having a beer.
Quite funny.
I have already explained that posters on here permanently require absolute proof of any sentence, any notion. Suspicion is not part of their vocabulary.
Yet the doctrine of a pre-emptive strike is all about suspicion.
I suppose you can see no inconsistency in that.
Are the neocons and the MSM not, right now, clamouring to bomb Iran back into the stone age. On what grounds of absolute proof?
Why was Afghanistan invaded? Why are troops still there?
Why was Iraq invaded? Why are troops still there?
There is no war. Only in the mind of the neocons. The 'war' against Iraq ended when Bush declared 'Mission Accomplished'.
When, if ever, all troops are pulled out of Iraq, then the Iraqis will set about deciding their own destiny. What is going on now is a dog and pony show in oreder to purloin the oil that rightfully belongs to the Iraqi people. It's called theft.
Where is the threat from Iran? There isn't one.
If left alone these Banksters, that have a grip on the US MSM will think nothing of setting the world on fire, never mind just the middle east.
The USA has cancer and needs to scrap the MSM monopoly, abide by the constitution, start immediately impeaching the dozens of fascists that are currently running free and that's just for starters.
 
C'est la vie, I refer you to my previous post.

Forum rules and common civility forbid me from expressing my opinion of someone who offers money to charity, and then recants on a whim.

Everyone else however can use this to establish your inherent dishonesty, and the torturous logic you apply to justify it.
 
Some people think that christians are at a permanent disadvantage because they will always 'do the right thing first' no matter what.

Are you planning to fight those strawmen at one point, or are you just collecting them ?

I am at the slight disadvantage of not being able to post too lengthy a reply, because it might hit the bin.

Coward.

I could be conversing with an american patriot who is only partially au fait or a neocon who is fully au fait and fighting a rear guard action.

False dichotomy.

Either way, other people are viewing, so I am getting a message across.

Not necessarily. People may just be tuning in for a laugh.

They got the toffs off the Titanic by locking up families down below in steerage to drown before the ship sank. They put 16 toffs in a life boat that could hold 60. They did this perfectly rationally and after discussion. They did it because they believed in 'superiority'.

Reference ?

I refused to communicate with you some time ago.

Yes, indeed, when you realised you had no pre-cooked reply to my points.

So,

If you claim it's impossible that aluminum airplanes can sever the columns - this should be obvious to physicists. Do you agree?

Also, what about Seth MacFarlane ?
 
I have already explained that posters on here permanently require absolute proof of any sentence, any notion.

Ridiculous, since such a thing is impossible.

Suspicion is not part of their vocabulary.

Suspicion is not evidence, not is it sufficient for a conviction. Hell. Without evidence, suspicion isn't even enough for a trial.

Yet the doctrine of a pre-emptive strike is all about suspicion.

Yes, but you don't pre-emptive strike in a court of law or in a lab. Who cares about pre-emptive strikes ?

I suppose you can see no inconsistency in that.

No, I don't. You're the one who's inconsistent. So some people decide to strike first before having any evidence that the enemy may be planning their own attack. What does this have to do with the scientific burden of proof ? Nothing.

Why was Afghanistan invaded? Why are troops still there?

To break a country that openly aided terrorists.

Why was Iraq invaded? Why are troops still there?

Because Bush senior didn't succeed.

When, if ever, all troops are pulled out of Iraq, then the Iraqis will set about deciding their own destiny. What is going on now is a dog and pony show in oreder to purloin the oil that rightfully belongs to the Iraqi people. It's called theft.

Well, that's a matter for another, politics thread, and has nothing to do with the evidence (or lack thereof) that 175 hit the south tower.

Where is the threat from Iran? There isn't one.

Nukes come to mind.

The USA has cancer and needs to scrap the MSM monopoly, abide by the constitution, start immediately impeaching the dozens of fascists that are currently running free and that's just for starters.

Imprisoning people on suspicions is constitutional ?
 
Forum rules and common civility forbid me from expressing my opinion of someone who offers money to charity, and then recants on a whim.

Everyone else however can use this to establish your inherent dishonesty, and the torturous logic you apply to justify it.

Only God is perfect.
 
Only God is perfect.

Who's asking for perfection? We're only asking you to be a honest man, do the honourable thing and not welch on your bet. Alternatively you could go away seeing this as a perfect example of the depth of your ignorance, which is matched only by the magnitute of your arrogance. You potificate and speculate on matters and events that you don't even bother to make even a cursory fact checks about. You offer large sums on money to be proven wrong, and don't even bother to check if you are right, because when you made the bet, you had no intention of ever honouring it.

What you know about aircraft maintance, 911, the work of government, science, and politics could be written on the back of a stamp. Malcolm, take the immense pwnage that Spirefire X, as a gift, a chance to go to this community "Yup you're right I don't know squat" and go and educate yourself about 911 before you start making any more wild spurious flat out wrong claims.
 
Who's asking for perfection? We're only asking you to be a honest man, do the honourable thing and not welch on your bet. Alternatively you could go away seeing this as a perfect example of the depth of your ignorance, which is matched only by the magnitute of your arrogance. You potificate and speculate on matters and events that you don't even bother to make even a cursory fact checks about. You offer large sums on money to be proven wrong, and don't even bother to check if you are right, because when you made the bet, you had no intention of ever honouring it.

What you know about aircraft maintance, 911, the work of government, science, and politics could be written on the back of a stamp. Malcolm, take the immense pwnage that Spirefire X, as a gift, a chance to go to this community "Yup you're right I don't know squat" and go and educate yourself about 911 before you start making any more wild spurious flat out wrong claims.

Remember Bob Woodward? He and Carl Bernstein rooted out a previous bent president.
Seeing as you have no faith in my accumulated knowledge, let's see you say the same about him.
Check out 36mins to 37mins here,
Four years of lies from Whackjob, 100 attacks per day on troops.
You're bleating about one lie/retraction from me, How about complaining about this,
Programme 9,
American Perspectives, Woodward and Bernstein, Discussion on VP's and Jewel.
If you haven't time to listen to it all, then 36 - 37 mins.
 
To quote,
"It can't possibly be aluminium".
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jDiL_q1m67k
Trumped again eh, this is getting monotonous.
Nice try, but you fail again. Dr. Jones experiment doesn't include what else the melted aluminum picked up on the way to that one window. Even Dr. Jones' thermite cutter didn't produce streams of molten metal that flowed anywhere or even remained red hot for more than a few seconds. So why don't you provide any proof that thermite will burn for weeks. Even the fire bombing of Germany and Japan didn't burn for weeks and thermite was used there. Also, provide and video of remote controlled airliners that behave in the same erratic way the aircraft did on 9/11.
 
Malcolm, now that you have conclusively demonstrated your dishonesty and intellectual laziness, I think this would be a good time to revisit you original claims.

175 did NOT hit the South tower. A remote controlled flight from Offutt AFB did.
1.
Raytheon, in Aug 2001, flew a passenger jet, take off – flight around – landing. (Der Spiegel).


Presumably you meant to write "flew by remote control." This has been conclusively refuted; the Spiegel article is simply wrong.

2.
Raytheon deal in small executive jets, there is no reason for them to fly large passenger planes by remote control.


Even granting for the sake of argument that this is true, the point is moot due to the refutation of the previous point.

3.
There is a very good reason for Raytheon not to interest themselves in flying passenger planes by remote control, because it is against the law.


Also moot due to point 1, but even if it were not, carrying passengers aboard a 787 is currently illegal, yet you'll see Boeing make many 787 flights in the next several months.

4.
The law requires that the passengers on any flight, have the flight crew present themselves to the passengers, by standing by the entrance door. This is to reassure the passengers, that the crew are not hung over or worse.

5.
No flight crew by the door = no flight.


Here is a link to the Federal Aviation Administration regulations governing the operation of airlines carrying more than 10 passengers per aircraft (14 CFR Part 121). This version was current as of 1999. Please indicated the section where flight crew members are required to present themselves to passengers by standing at "the" door.

6.
Raytheon could have no legitimate reason, for flying a large passenger plane by remote control.


Questionable, but in any case a moot point, as the flights were not remote-controlled.

7.
Offutt AFB, is a joint civilian/military installation.


According to airport information from airnav.com, Offutt's average air traffic is 168 flights a day, all military. Please provide evidence that there was any civilian use of Offutt's air facilities on or near September 11, 2001.

8.
Boeing and Raytheon were there.


In what capacity? Did they have maintenance technicians at the base? Maintenance or testing facilities? Please elaborate. Also, Raytheon's presence is moot, again due to point 1.

9.
Boeing has been the subject of RICO law suits for over a decade.


The only two I could find related to alleged anticompetitive practices in bidding on contracts to launch US Air Force satellites. One was dismissed; Boeing was sanctioned by the Air Force for the other. The RICO statute, though intended to combat organized crime, has some ambiguous provisions that have resulted in its attempted application to some large businesses that no reasonable person would consider to be criminal enterprises, including Wal-Mart, Best Buy, Lockheed Martin, Atlantic Records, Microsoft, and Major League Baseball. Are they all in on the conspiracy, too?

10.
The military prefer daylight take offs.


I imagine this is a minor consideration, but I'll grant it for the sake of argument. However, it's a moot point, as will be shown.

11.
Any commander of an Air Force Base who closed his airport for ‘civilian’ reasons during massive war games, would face disciplinary action.


Uninformed speculation. Further, what about a base commander "who closed his [or her] airport" during important war games in order to prepare for a possible emergency landing by a stricken civilian airliner? Would that commander face disciplinary action? According to your statement, he or she would.

12.
For the first time in history, a civilian politician was placed in direct command of Norad and other parts of the USAF.


Cheney was not "in direct command of Norad [sic]" on September 11, 2001, or at any other time. See here. However, this is also a moot point, as Cheney still could have issued orders to NORAD in his capacity as Vice President.

13.
In order to get a night-time take off from a military airfield, some compelling reason must be given.


A compelling reason such as "that's when the plane is supposed to take off?"

14.
Private civilian executive jets began arriving at dawn on 9/11, because of a celebrity golf tournament that day.


Do you have any evidence that these jets actually landed at Offutt, rather than Omaha's Eppley Airfield, which is only 11 miles away, and where Warren Buffett's jet fleet was based? Further, even if this did happen, what evidence do you have that the airport was closed to military flights at any point?

15.
Warren Buffet was persuaded out of retirement to host one last celebrity golf tournament.


Buffett had hosted the tournament every year for the previous several years. Please provide evidence that he was "persuaded out of retirement," rather than 2001's just being the last year he planned to participate.

16.
Neocons are involved in paedophilia.


Libelous and irrelevant.

17.
Offut AFB is twenty minutes away from Boystown, Omaha.


True, but irrelevant.

18.
Boystown is steeped in allegations of paedophilia.


This is at best debatable, but in any case irrelevant.

19.
Things occurred (criminal convictions) in the Twin Towers apartment block in Omaha, which is midway between the executive jet landing at Offutt and Boystown, ten minutes from either location.


Again, please provide evidence that any civilian aircraft landed at Offutt on September 11, 2001. But even if true, this is irrelevant.

20.
So many planes or non-planes were in the sky that morning, that air traffic controllers didn’t know a real plane from a blip on their screen.


Air traffic was normal for the date and time of day.

21.
Air traffic controllers deal only with planes that are about to land in their area.


Patently false, and also irrelevant, except insofar as it serves further to illustrate your gross ignorance of aviation.

22.
All take offs from Offutt, for both Northern Vigilance, Vigilant warrior and any other reason, would have to be during the night of 9/10 – 9/11.


Yet again, please provide evidence that any civilian aircraft landed at Offutt on September 11, 2001, and also any evidence that the airport was closed to military traffic at any time that day.
 
Nice try, but you fail again. Dr. Jones experiment doesn't include what else the melted aluminum picked up on the way to that one window. Even Dr. Jones' thermite cutter didn't produce streams of molten metal that flowed anywhere or even remained red hot for more than a few seconds. So why don't you provide any proof that thermite will burn for weeks. Even the fire bombing of Germany and Japan didn't burn for weeks and thermite was used there. Also, provide and video of remote controlled airliners that behave in the same erratic way the aircraft did on 9/11.
This is like taking candy off a baby.
You mentioned 'burn for weeks', so don't try and ship this one around on me.
What could possibly cause the piles to burn for weeks?
 
Remember Bob Woodward? He and Carl Bernstein rooted out a previous bent president.
Seeing as you have no faith in my accumulated knowledge, let's see you say the same about him.
Check out 36mins to 37mins here,
Four years of lies from Whackjob, 100 attacks per day on troops.
You're bleating about one lie/retraction from me, How about complaining about this,
Programme 9,
American Perspectives, Woodward and Bernstein, Discussion on VP's and Jewel.
If you haven't time to listen to it all, then 36 - 37 mins.

What does this non sequitur have to do with the price of cheese?

Bob Woodward didn't promise 1,000 dollars to charity here. You did.

Just because you agree with Bob Woodward on something doesn't make you any less of a liar.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom