[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Consider a floor at any one of the twins.
You have tubular spandrel steel beams 39 inches apart.
You have 12.5 ft between floor and ceiling.
At floor level, you have 209ft of 4in thick concrete in a 22 gauge steel pan.
You're hitting it with a 16ft 9in aluminium cigar tube.
It penetrates two sets of spandrels not one.
That's some cigar tube.

A cigar tube going 500mph IS some cigar tube.

It has to enter the building, if not your story of mortally wounding the tower is in tatters. Not only does the fusilage get right in, but also the wings.

Nobody denies it gets in. We all saw it getting in with our own eyes (some of us via TV). You cannot assume, however, that it got in in one piece.

In fact the rounded nose gets right through the building, something not possible with a regular plane.

No. What exited was temporarily shaped roughly like the nose, however when viewing the footage, it quickly becomes clear that it was not a structure, it was merely a burst of smoke, flame and debris.

Your fellow truther Ace Baker has (unintentionally) proved that it was not the nose cone. In his video analysis where he focuses on apparant fluctuations in speed, he happens to demonstrate that it exists at a speed much lower than that of the plane.



Most of them carefully cropped so you don't see the alleged nose cone dissolve into smoke and flame. Dishonest.

Hans
 
Evidence-I do not think that you really understand what this word means. Would you feel comfortable as a defendant in a court of law with the prosecution using your standard of evidence?
 
Factor? explained to me?
We are indeed yet again going over old ground.
Would you like to proceed to Offutt or are you going to insist that an egg travelling at a thousand miles an hour will go through a brick wall?

Sure let's got to Offut, why not?

BTW: A better analogy would be a full, unopened, beer can hitting a brick wall at 1,000 MPH, and it wouldn't surprise me at all if it did. I know a scuba tank will go through one.
 
I see, Malcolm you do realise that the material damage alone was close to 90 billion on 911 don't you ? So how does this work when off set against a 5 billion they saved ?

Add that to the 450 billion the War on Terror has cost, I cannot actually see the return, maybe you could fill in the blanks. Maybe you can explain how a saving of 5 billion against a cost of something like nearly 600 billion is a good deal.

Do you actually beleive that there are Islamic terrorists BTW ?
My pleasure, the owners of the Port Authority saved $5 billion = they didn't have to spend $5 billion.
Then they drew billions in insurance payments and billions more in grants.
Warren Buffet, for example dropped $2.2 billion on 9/11.
As soon as I found out how much Buffet had dropped, I realised that he was a patsy. He had been very cleverly set up.
His celebrity golf tournament, even one of 'his' executive jets followed the Shanksville plane and watched it crash. By 'his', I mean an executive jet that belonged to a company he owned. The claim was later pulled from the net, but it was about for a while.
His brewakfast date who had her life saved etc.
All there for some future Noam Chomsky to show his students how smart he was. All reported in the MSM, except the bit about the $2.2 billion.
So I know how deep MSM involvement in 9/11 is.
I'm just waiting for others to catch up, then I'll make sure those in the MSM are brought to book as accessories and accessories after the fact.
The longer this 'catch up' goes on, the more thorough the clean up will be.
I believe that there are Islamic 'terrorists' now, of course, why not?
Don't you think the NWO/neocons have manufactured todays 'terrorists'.
Or do you expect people to lie down and take the kind of constant kicking that has been handed out to the Palestinians over the years.
Here's an example of that,
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-6604775898578139565&q=palestine+israel&hl=en
Don't confuse the money the Banksters saved and actually profited by due to 9/11, with the cost to the US taxpayer of the Banksters insatiable appetite for war.
 
A cigar tube going 500mph IS some cigar tube.



Nobody denies it gets in. We all saw it getting in with our own eyes (some of us via TV). You cannot assume, however, that it got in in one piece.



No. What exited was temporarily shaped roughly like the nose, however when viewing the footage, it quickly becomes clear that it was not a structure, it was merely a burst of smoke, flame and debris.

Your fellow truther Ace Baker has (unintentionally) proved that it was not the nose cone. In his video analysis where he focuses on apparant fluctuations in speed, he happens to demonstrate that it exists at a speed much lower than that of the plane.




Most of them carefully cropped so you don't see the alleged nose cone dissolve into smoke and flame. Dishonest.

Hans
You could have put up the vid, I would be interested to see it.
 
Evidence-I do not think that you really understand what this word means. Would you feel comfortable as a defendant in a court of law with the prosecution using your standard of evidence?

I dream about getting mass murderers like Silverstein, people who are up to their armpits in blood, in front of an unbiased jury.
I alternate between him and other murderers like Cheney and Rumsfeld.
Here's a good one for you.
I'll donate 1,000 dollars to any charity of your choice, if you can find one occassion before 9/11 when whackjob, as POTUS, spent some time in a kindergarten with the little ones.
Yet where was he on 9/11, in with the little ones - everybosy say Ahhh.
 
You misunderstand, I don't mean through the front wall, I mean through the building.
I mean through the front wall, through any interior walls and out through the back wall. A feat that is impossible, as your photos show.
However, on 9/11 the nose of the attack plane does just that, through the front wall, through any intervening walls and then out through the back wall,
here it is again,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l38oEJwAb1Q&mode=related&search=

Wrong. You are assuming that the plane went through as a whole. This is indeed impossible, and was not what happened. Presumably, the plane more or less disintegrated as it entered the building, however, that just meant that over a hundred tons of high-speed wreckage razed the stricken floors. It is obvious to nearly anybody looking at the footage of the hit that very few large parts of the plane made it through the building.

It is telling that truthers trying to claim that the nose penetrated the building intact carefully crop the footage so you cannot see the cone-like burst dissolve into a cloud, and see that only smaller parts (the largest being part of an engine) fly out trailing fire and smoke.

If that thing in the video had been a nose-cone, we would have seen it continue out into the air and curve to the ground.

Finally, you may wonder how wreckage could go all the way through the building at all, but that has an explanation too:

Remember the argument that the towers were constructed to withstand a plane impact? Do you know how that was done?

It was done by constructing the building so that a plane as much as possible could pass through the building without transferring all its energy to the structure.

As we know, it didn't quite work out that way. Apparantly the calculations are no longer available, but it appears that they were based on a possible plane impact being from a plane heading for landing on a nearby airport. This was, pre-911, the most reasonable scenario. That, however, means a plane going at appr. half the speed of the actual impacts, and being relatively low on fuel. The buildings mat well have been able to survive such a collision (but it would still have devastated the floors actually stricken).

Hans
 
malcom have you provided evidence of explosives found? im still waiting for an answer to this
You must have missed the bit about Prof Steven Jones finding thermite / thermate residues and others finding explanations for the month long hot spots etc. Try a little research of your own, why don't you?
 
I dream about getting mass murderers like Silverstein, people who are up to their armpits in blood, in front of an unbiased jury.
I alternate between him and other murderers like Cheney and Rumsfeld.
Here's a good one for you.
I'll donate 1,000 dollars to any charity of your choice, if you can find one occassion before 9/11 when whackjob, as POTUS, spent some time in a kindergarten with the little ones.
Yet where was he on 9/11, in with the little ones - everybosy say Ahhh.

How intellectually dishonest of you. Your refusal to answer a straightfoward question speaks volumes about you character. Your challenge is also dishonest, as the POTUS had been in office for 7 months & 22 days before the incident, and probably was busy getting accustomed to the job. If you look at his total time in office, you will find that he makes many school visits. Every time I hear one of you conspiracy theorists spout off your drivel, I am reminded of the calm & professional manner that Col. Bidlack has rebutted your spurious & foolish claims. I personally heard the pain in his voice when he shared with us the horrors he witnessed that terrible day & I have no doubt he is telling the truth. You, however have provided nothing but poorly concieved, paranoid delusions. You speak of thermite/thermate residue at GZ.
Did it ever occur to you what other reactions would produce the same chemical residue? I'll give you a hint: The buildings were full of it...Also, thermite/thermate is not an explosive & will not make an explosion (I'm willing to bet you have no idea how it works either-another hint: it involves gravity)
When You actually come up with some real evidence, Someone PM me, till then, I'll be doing something more entertaining, like playing WoW...
 
You must have missed the bit about Prof Steven Jones finding thermite / thermate residues and others finding explanations for the month long hot spots etc. Try a little research of your own, why don't you?
Both aleged thermi/ate residues and hotspots have alternative explanations. All is irrelevant for this discussion, however, because thermi/ate is not an explosive.

Hans
 
Sure let's got to Offut, why not?

BTW: A better analogy would be a full, unopened, beer can hitting a brick wall at 1,000 MPH, and it wouldn't surprise me at all if it did. I know a scuba tank will go through one.
A scuba tank is made of steel. No matter, Offutt, here we come.
Let's start with a golf tournament. A celebrity golf tournament.
A celebrity golf tournament that means the runways are closed to all but celebrities and their executive jets from dawn on 9/11.
Maybe we can start with Warren Buffet's breakfast date watching a 'passenger' jet whack straight through her office window.
An office she would have been sitting in, but for Warren's invite.
An invitation accompanied by a military escort.
Then again, we could start with all flights from Offutt having to leave before dawn on 9/11 to accomodate the celebs.
What took off from Offutt around 4am central time?
The flight records are there, let's have a look at them.
Why didn't the commander of Offutt AFB postpone the Golf tournament when he realised it would disrupt his airfield in the midst of exercise Global Guardian?
http://www.cooperativeresearch.org/entity.jsp?entity=global_guardian
 
My pleasure, the owners of the Port Authority saved $5 billion = they didn't have to spend $5 billion.
Then they drew billions in insurance payments and billions more in grants.
Warren Buffet, for example dropped $2.2 billion on 9/11.
As soon as I found out how much Buffet had dropped, I realised that he was a patsy. He had been very cleverly set up.
His celebrity golf tournament, even one of 'his' executive jets followed the Shanksville plane and watched it crash. By 'his', I mean an executive jet that belonged to a company he owned. The claim was later pulled from the net, but it was about for a while.
His brewakfast date who had her life saved etc.
All there for some future Noam Chomsky to show his students how smart he was. All reported in the MSM, except the bit about the $2.2 billion.
So I know how deep MSM involvement in 9/11 is.
I'm just waiting for others to catch up, then I'll make sure those in the MSM are brought to book as accessories and accessories after the fact.
The longer this 'catch up' goes on, the more thorough the clean up will be.
I believe that there are Islamic 'terrorists' now, of course, why not?
Don't you think the NWO/neocons have manufactured todays 'terrorists'.
Or do you expect people to lie down and take the kind of constant kicking that has been handed out to the Palestinians over the years.
Here's an example of that,
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-6604775898578139565&q=palestine+israel&hl=en
Don't confuse the money the Banksters saved and actually profited by due to 9/11, with the cost to the US taxpayer of the Banksters insatiable appetite for war.


Oh I see, aside from the fact that you have actually failed to answer where the return is for the 600 billion dollar investment I would like to move on and ask you about what I have bolded.

So you are asking me to believe that Islamic terrorist exist because of the constant kicking handed out to the Palestinians, something that they would get very annoyed at. Something so annoying in fact a few of them may actually decide to do something about it, like maybe hijack four planes and slam them into landmark buildings perhaps?

Of course not Malcolm because in the sentence above you totally contradict this statement by saying the NWO manufactures terrorists.

So which is it Malcolm do Islamic terrorists have a genuine beef against US foreign policy , which as you have said they have for years or are they manufactured by the NWO ?

Maybe you feel that Islamic terrorists didn't exist before 911 because these guys are too stupid to realise they were being kicked, after all they are just cavemen and coke heads with box cutters are they not ?
 
It was only when I learned of WTC7 dropping at or around free fall speed, that I realised something was badly wrong.

Let me get this straight: you "realised" that 9/11 was an inside job because you don't understand the physics involved in building collapses ?

For example, WTC7 was brought down in free fall or near free fall time by admitted controlled demolition.

Sorry, but your ability to research seems null. Please verify this before posting.

Demolition charges would have been installed in whatever system was adopted.

That was not the question. How does a controlled demolition differ from a "natural" collapse so you can tell the difference instantly ?

you cannot produce one scintilla of evidence that the plane that hit the south tower was flight 175.

Video evidence and plane wreckage isn't enough ?

WTC7 came down by controlled demolition all right and I would have no difficulty in persuading an unbiased jury of that fact.

Then do so. Automatically, this would result in an investigation of government involvement, and you'd be proven right. Why are you here, then ? GO. Go to a judge and present your case.

Silverstein admitted the building was 'pulled' and only verbal gymnastics that border on the ludicrous can say any different.

He said nothing of the sort. Please READ the conversation and understand the damn context.

Why should a steel framed building be expected to fall when fire had never before brought down a steel framed building.

That is a lie. Fire has brought down steel framed buildings before; and steel is the worst possible structural material against a fire.
 
I'll donate 1,000 dollars to any charity of your choice, if you can find one occassion before 9/11 when whackjob, as POTUS, spent some time in a kindergarten with the little ones.
Yet where was he on 9/11, in with the little ones - everybosy say Ahhh.

So if I have this clear, you'll donate 1,000 dollars to charity of my choice, if I can prove a president, like Bush did a staged photo op with children, for around an hour? Before 911?
 
I dream about getting mass murderers like Silverstein, people who are up to their armpits in blood, in front of an unbiased jury.
I alternate between him and other murderers like Cheney and Rumsfeld.
Here's a good one for you.
I'll donate 1,000 dollars to any charity of your choice, if you can find one occassion before 9/11 when whackjob, as POTUS, spent some time in a kindergarten with the little ones.
Yet where was he on 9/11, in with the little ones - everybosy say Ahhh.



20010125-1.jpg

January 25, 2001 Merritt Elementary School, Washington, D.C. (probably kindergarten)

Remarks by the President to Students and Faculty at Merritt Elementary School

Confirmed by the International Herald Tribune.


nalle-2001-02-09.jpg

February 9, 2001 J. C. Nalle Elementary School, Washington, D. C. (third grade)

Remarks by President Bush at Nalle Elementary School.

Confirmed by CNN.


edu3-p1228-03-398h.jpg

February 20, 2001 Moline Elementary School, St. Louis, Missouri (third grade)

President Bush and Laura Bush listen to student Janea Bufford read at Moline Elementary School in St.Louis, Mo., Feb. 20, 2001

Confirmed by CNN


20010221-5-a.jpg

February 26, 2001 Townsend Elementary School, Townsend, Tennessee (probably fourth or fifth grade)

President Bush speaks at Townsend Elementary School in Tennessee

Confirmed by CNN


p826-05-lakewood.jpg

March 1,2001 Lakewood Elementary School, North Little Rock, Arkansas (probably kindergarten)

President Bush visited Lakewood Elementary School . . .

Confirmed by CNN


20010815-2.jpg

August 15, 2001 Griegos Elementary School, Albuquerque, New Mexico (second grade)

President Bush visits with a second-grade class at Griegos Elementary School in Albuquerque, N. M, Aug. 15.

Confirmed by CNN


20010823-6.jpg

August 23, 2001 Crawford Elementary School, Crawford, Texas (all grades)

During an impromptu visit to Crawford Elementary School, August 23 . . .

Confirmed by The Washington Post

For the record, Bush was in a second-grade class, and not a kindergarten class, on September 11. Also note that American public schools are not in session (except for some summer remediation programs) from the beginning of June through the end of August, though this varies slightly in many locations.

Higher education for all Americans has always been a major priority of mine, so you can send your check to:

The United Negro College Fund
8260 Willow Oaks Corporate Drive
P.O. Box 10444
Fairfax, VA 22031-8044
United States of America

Be sure to tell them you're donating $1000 in my name, and ask them to send me a letter so stating. Let me know when you're ready to send the check, and I'll PM you my address. I'll post a scan of the letter here as soon as I receive it. I'm sure this won't be a financial hardship for you, as you're a retired businessman with "loadsa dosh" (or was that "lora dosh" :confused:).
 
I dream about getting mass murderers like Silverstein, people who are up to their armpits in blood, in front of an unbiased jury.
I alternate between him and other murderers like Cheney and Rumsfeld.
Here's a good one for you.
I'll donate 1,000 dollars to any charity of your choice, if you can find one occassion before 9/11 when whackjob, as POTUS, spent some time in a kindergarten with the little ones.
Yet where was he on 9/11, in with the little ones - everybosy say Ahhh.

I've been doing a bit of research on this. Not being American, I don't know if kindergarten equates to Elementary school. However, since Bush was at the Booker Elementary school, I assume that is what you mean.

Here're 2 such pics as you request:

President George W. Bush reads to students at J.C. Nalle Elementary School in Washington, D.C. on February 9, 2001
http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/images/nalle-2001-02-09.html


President George W. Bush speaks with the First Lady Laura Bush at Moline Elementary School in St.Louis, Missouri on February 20 2001.
http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2001/02/images/20010220-4a.html

I'll get back to you by PM about where to send the cash, once I see you acknowledge these as accurate.

ETA: Damn, Spitfire beat me to it. I support his charity.
Spitfire, you are lucky I am an honest mod ;)
 
Last edited:
Oh Malcolm, how embarrassing for you. It shouldn't be though as you've been proven wrong over and over again.

I wonder how you will react to this? I'm guessing either ignoring it or spinning your way out. Being an honest person and making good on your donation comment is not an option I would bet on.
 
All explosions caused by CD charges?
Surely one is more than enough evidence of an inside job.

No. Even if there WAS a bomb, it wouldn't mean it was an inside job.

But the fact that there was EXPLOSION sounds does not mean there were EXPLOSIONS.

The fact that there were EXPLOSIONS does not mean there were EXPLOSIVES.

Do you understand that ?
 
You must have missed the bit about Prof Steven Jones finding thermite / thermate residues

As in the case of Raytheon, you're distorting the facts again. Jones found a chemical signature which might have been indicative of thermate. He didn't find thermate residues.

You need to find a way of presenting your 'evidence' in a less ambiguous way because otherwise nobody will take your claims seriously.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom