Mitzna

I notice, too, that Ben is slow to provide evidence for that sweeping claim.

C'mon Ben! Surely there's a right-wing conspiracy theory page out there that supports you?
 
Starshark said:
I notice, too, that Ben is slow to provide evidence for that sweeping claim.

C'mon Ben! Surely there's a right-wing conspiracy theory page out there that supports you?

That's because I have no evidence. Just propaganda, see.

The difference is that "evidence" is the stuff you agree with, and propaganda is the stuff you reject.


http://www.idf.il/arafat/terrorism2/english/main_index.stm

http://www.idf.il/Fatah/english/main_index.stm

more in the "archive" link here:

http://www.idf.il/newsite/english/main.stm


-Ben
 
Hmm. Well, you've certainly proven that there are Palestinians who perpetuate terrorist attacks. But where's the bit about it being 'right and holy'? And why apply it to all Palestinians?

Isn't that just like me saying "Israelis think it's right and holy to bomb Lebanon"?
 
Ben Shniper said:


Here's a hypothetical for you:

If a peace partner stole billions from his own people, gets elected with 99% of the vote each time while preaching democracy, never lifts a finger to stop the most atrocious terrorism imaginable,


It doesn't matter. If it is a peace partner, you don't have anything to do with the internal affairs of that particular country. Every country as the government they deserve. If the palestinians want a better one, they have to fight for themselves.

And as it as been widely showned, never lifting a finger to stop terrorism as not been an impediment for Saudi Arabia and Pakistan to be considered allies...

BTW, "the most atrocious terrorism imaginable" is state terrorism against civilians, that was supported by the US in the East Timor situation, and is still done in Israel.


Ben Shniper said:

rejects all peace deals, and secretly funds these terrorist groups with millions of dollars from hostile nations like Iraq, Iran, and Saudi Arabia, would you have peace?

-Ben

Of course, if it rejects all peace deals, it is not a peace partner, so this is not appliable...
 
And not just Fiat . . . is not anyone concerned about the bases Nissan has been building?!!!

--J. "Back and to the Left!!" D.
 
Met Mitzna

On a trip several years ago, my wife, my best friend and I happened to meet Mitzna--as Mayor of Haifa. Got a picture of it as well.

This has nothing "real" to do with this thread, but I thought I'd say that my feelings were that he was a very nice guy (I don't dabble in Israeli politics, however, so it could make no difference whether or not he wins). But it would be kinda neat to have met the PM of a country (even if it was before his rise to greatness).

Just my thoughts,

Brad
 
Re: Met Mitzna

Math Maniac said:
On a trip several years ago, my wife, my best friend and I happened to meet Mitzna--as Mayor of Haifa. Got a picture of it as well.

A humane point to make. Yes, I have heard over and over that Mitzna is a relatively honest and upstanding guy. I don't doubt it. But I don't like his politics for the current era. After peace can be made then maybe, but not in the middle of a war Arafat started because he thought he could trade blood for concessions.

I'm unconvinced that Mitzna is skeptical enoughh of Arafat's promised versus demonstrated intentions.

-Ben
 
Here is a link to a report showing a third party actually backing up some of the sources I have put from the IDF.
http://www.hrw.org/reports/2002/isrl-pa/

This third party regularly speaks about Israeli actions against Palestinians, it is a relatively unbiased source.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Apologetic statements by public officials have also been accompanied by the broadcast of incendiary statements on publicly funded television. There were several recorded instances of such broadcasts on the official PA television channel in 2001, particularly in the broadcasts of weekly Friday prayer sermons. Among these were the live broadcasts of Shaikh Ibrahim Ma`adi delivering sermons from a Gaza mosque on June 8, 2001, and again on August 3, 2001. "Blessed are the people who strap bombs onto their bodies or those of their sons," Ma'adi said on the first of these occasions. On the second, he explicitly called for bombings in Tel Aviv, Hadera, Ashkelon, and other Israeli cities, adding:

The Jews have bared their teeth. They have said what they have said and done what they have done. And they will not be deterred except by the color of the blood of their filthy people. They will not be deterred unless we willingly and voluntarily blow ourselves up among them.93

In the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, such statements constitute incitement to crimes against humanity. Under international criminal law, the PA has a responsibility to ensure they are neither broadcast nor published, and should bring to justice those who make them.
....

There have been several reports of segments on PA television that explicitly encourage children to take part in clashes with Israeli forces and extol the virtues of martyrdom.

...

On August 26, 2002, the Palestinian Journalists Syndicate called on Palestinian armed factions to stop using children, and declared that it was "absolutely forbidden" for photojournalists to take pictures of children carrying weapons or taking part in militant activities. The statement said that footage of armed children served "the interests of Israel and its propaganda against the Palestinian people." Tawfiq Abu Khousa, deputy chair of the syndicate, said, "We have decided to forbid taking any footage of armed children, because we consider that as a clear violation of the rights of children and for negative effects these pictures have on the Palestinian people."3

It is the encouragement of children to carry weapons and take part in armed activity that is wrong, not media coverage of these activities.
...
Human Rights Watch found that there were steps that the PA could have taken to prevent or deter such attacks, but that it remained unwilling to risk the political cost of acting decisively. The PA routinely failed to investigate, arrest and prosecute persons believed to be responsible for these attacks, and did not take credible steps to reprimand, discipline, or bring to justice those members of its own security services who, in violation of declared PA policy, participated in such attacks. In addition, although President Arafat repeatedly condemned suicide attacks against civilians, he consistently failed to insist that terms of honor and respect such as "martyr"-which Palestinians use to designate persons who have died or suffered grave loss in clashes with Israeli forces or settlers-should not apply to people who die in the course of carrying out indiscriminate attacks against civilians.

....
The PA's failure to act in an effective and consistent manner against Palestinian attacks on civilians contributed to an atmosphere of impunity, allowing the armed groups to conclude that there would be no serious consequence for those who planned or carried out attacks that amounted to war crimes, and in the cases of suicide bombings, crimes against humanity. This failure reflects a high degree of political responsibility on the part of President Arafat and the PA leadership for the many civilian deaths that have resulted.

...

As the spiral of violence wound tighter, the Palestinian Authority continued to condemn publicly armed attacks that deliberately targeted civilians but, except for a brief period from mid-December 2001 to mid-January 2002, took no clear or credible actions to prevent such attacks or to punish those responsible.

...

Although the PA's legal governing authority derives from the Oslo Accords signed with Israel, the duty to prevent systematic indiscriminate attacks against civilians is not contingent on Israeli compliance with those accords or rendered null by what the PA regards as Israeli violations of the accords. That duty should not be a bargaining chip whose implementation is subject to political negotiations. As the political authority in place, the PA has a responsibility to bring to justice individuals who order, plan, or carry out attacks against civilians. The PA has failed to meet this obligation.

When the PA made arrests, they were often indiscriminate, picking up supporters of one or another militant group without regard to any alleged responsibility for the serious crimes being committed in the name of that group. Instead of being investigated, detained suspects were typically held without charge and later released. The PA has explained these releases as a response to the danger posed by Israeli bombings of places of detention, but it has not tried to explain why suspects were not investigated, charged, or brought to trial.
...

In the first weeks of the clashes, the PA released numerous detainees, most of them members of Hamas and Islamic Jihad, some of whom had been in PA detention without charge or trial for several years.78 According to press reports, the first releases took place on October 4, 2000, when twelve Hamas detainees were released from Gaza Central Prison. Subsequent releases occurred over the following week. A PA security official in Gaza claimed that by mid-October the PA had "begun to re-arrest them."79 In Nablus, fourteen of the thirty-five who had been released reportedly responded to a summons to turn themselves back in.80 Hamas political leader `Abd al-`Aziz al-Rantisi was rearrested on October 18 and released again on December 26, 2000, at the end of Ramadan.81

The Islamic Jihad organization has cited these releases as a factor contributing to the group's ability to carry out attacks against Israeli targets.
...

Some of the detainees released at the beginning of the uprising, as well as other armed militants and political critics of the PA, were re-detained and re-released periodically during 2001. Some were formally arrested and, beginning in late October 2001, the PA started using administrative detention orders to detain suspects. Individuals known to be leaders of groups responsible for attacks against civilians nevertheless continued to operate openly in the West Bank and Gaza Strip-in the case of Bethlehem-area al-Aqsa Brigades leader Atef Abayat, even when technically under "house arrest."

...

In mid-April 2001, the PA confirmed that it had released Muhammad Deyf, imprisoned since 1996 for his role in the Hamas suicide bomb attacks in February of that year, although officials insisted he remained under their control in "a safe place where he cannot be reached by the Israeli authorities."86 No such pretenses were made when Deyf narrowly escaped death in an Israeli rocket attack targeting him as he traveled by car in Gaza city on September 26, 2002.87
..

In another captured document, al-Karmi approached Arafat via Marwan Barghouti, requesting payments to twelve "fighter brethren," not including himself.123 Despite al-Karmi's own self-proclaimed responsibility for attacks on civilians, Arafat granted a payment of $350 to each individual on al-Karmi's list, again without making any apparent effort to ensure that these fighters were not responsible for attacks on civilians. The payments were made on January 7, 2002, a week before al-Karmi was assassinated. At the time of his assassination, according to media reports, the PA had assured European Union officials that al-Karmi was under arrest.124 According to one report, he was assassinated "while visiting his wife and daughter during a furlough from the `protective custody' of a PA jail."125

....

Based on its own investigation as well as media accounts and publicly available, captured PA documents, Human Rights Watch identified instances in which individuals employed in one or another Palestinian security force were involved in shooting or suicide bomb attacks targeting civilians. Human Rights Watch also found that individual members of the PA security forces have had ongoing associations with armed groups that have carried out suicide bombing attacks on civilians. On at least two occasions, individual members of PA intelligence services assisted perpetrators in carrying out such attacks.139
...

The PA should have made credible efforts to reprimand, discipline, or, where appropriate, bring to justice members of its own security services who, in apparent disregard for declared PA policies, participated in or lent support to those responsible for attacks against civilians. Insofar as Human Rights Watch could determine, it did not do so.
...


High-ranking PA officials, including President Arafat, failed in their duty to administer justice and enforce the rule of law in compliance with international standards. Through their repeated failure to arrest or prosecute individuals alleged to have planned or carried out suicide attacks against civilians, they contributed a climate of impunity-and failed to prevent the bloody consequences. Their payments to, and recruitment of, individuals responsible for attacks against civilians likewise demonstrate, at least, a serious failure to meet their political responsibilities as the governing authorities, if not a willingness to support them. However, there is no publicly available evidence that Arafat or other senior PA officials ordered, planned, or carried out such attacks.

{thanks renata for this link}

-Ben
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom