Mitzna

He's Israel's option to surrender in the war on terrorism. With 20 more people dead today, he has a slightly better shot.

Once Israel surrenders to Arafat's demands of a state without peace, you can count on a bigger war starting soon after. Just like this "intifadah" was launched with Hizbollah's support after Israel withdrew from there with a paper peace.

-Ben
 
I've read a little but exactly what does he advocate in terms of a "surrender" as you put it? I've read that he's not a religious man. Is that true? Will that affect his chances seriously?
 
Imagine a US President who said that in response to the September 11th attacks, he would immediately work out a deal with the Taliban where Osama would be put on trial by Taliban law in Afghanistan without any chance for extradition. Imagine a president who would withdraw immediately all troops from Saudi Arabia and Kuwait in accordance with Osama's wishes. Imagine that President not doing anything about Saddam's subsequent takeover of most of the oil of the world.

That's Mitzna.

-Ben
 
So let's just suppose for a second that Mitzna was voted into office and he did all these sorts of things. And I realize you don't believe this will happen, but If the violence in Israel did cease and led to a 10 yr period of stability would you consider it the right decision? (Hypothetically speaking..)
 
svero said:
So let's just suppose for a second that Mitzna was voted into office and he did all these sorts of things. And I realize you don't believe this will happen, but If the violence in Israel did cease and led to a 10 yr period of stability would you consider it the right decision? (Hypothetically speaking..)

Are you saying that appeasement might work?

Jews, like any other group, have to rely on themselves first and foremost for defense. Noone else can reduce that burden by much. If Jews won't defend themselves, then why should anyone else?

So, my answer is a definate no. If Mitzna did these kind of unilateral concessions, I would not considder that to be an honorable peace, regardless of how long it lasted.

-Ben
 
Ben Shniper said:
So, my answer is a definate no. If Mitzna did these kind of unilateral concessions, I would not considder that to be an honorable peace, regardless of how long it lasted.

-Ben

There is no honor on the Israeli position right now, so were does that leaves us?
 
Megalodon said:


There is no honor on the Israeli position right now, so were does that leaves us?

Israel must fight for its existance. Palestinians are at best fighting for a 24th Arab nation to be carved out of one of the smallest countries in the world, or more accurately Israel's destruction if you read their internal press releases.

If there is no honor in fighting for one's existance, then perhaps there is no honor period. I get the feeling you don't like my argument about honor because you don't believe in honor.

That's fine. But in that case I'd say that making peace with lifelong terrorists was immoral (if you believe in morality), or at least self destructive (if you believe in the right of humans to fight for survival), or at the very least illogical (if you believe in the use of logic as a tool for survival).

-Ben
 
One is reminded of Black Adder:

"There are three things you can do:

1. Kill yourself.

2. Kill your manservant.

3. Kill everybody in the whole world."


Me? I'm a #3 kinda guy!
 
Aadvark:

Indeed! I have been tempted to suggest a new solution. Since the US is a warmongering sociopath of a nation that is either a vassal of Israel or just waiting for the excuse to betray Israel, I propose the US military invade all of Palestine and transport all of the Israelis and Palestinians to Des Moines.

In their place we will give the land to the Chechens. They have had 3,000+ years to make the region peaceful; it is someone else's turn.

If either of the Palestinians or Isrealis complain, we move them to Compton. After that, Branson, Missouri, but I may have to check some internation legal statutes about that level of punishment.

Of course, they could just stop killing one another. The Israelis could, just perchance, cease trying to take over Palestinian lands by fiat by building more settlements whilst, Heavens to Betsy, the Palestinians could cease blowing up a bunch of children.

Probably too much to ask. . . .

--J.D.
 
Well . . . if you do not know . . . there is just no hope educating you to the Truth [Tm.--Ed.]

--J. "A Conspiracy, my Brutha! A C-O-N . . . spriacy!" D.
 
Ben Shniper said:


Israel must fight for its existance.

No, they're not. They are by far the most powerful nation in the area. No country in there would try to destroy Israel. Most, probably all of Israel problems are a consequence of the settlements in a foreign land.
So the fight is not one of survival. It's one of occupation against the will of the residing citizens. If you think there is honor in that, than you have a very twisted sense of honor..


I get the feeling you don't like my argument about honor because you don't believe in honor.

I believe in honor. And I know a lot of different honor codes. My personal honor code says that a huge, powerful army killing children in a foreign land and using rockets against civilian targets is wrong.

That's fine. But in that case I'd say that making peace with lifelong terrorists was immoral (if you believe in morality), or at least self destructive (if you believe in the right of humans to fight for survival), or at the very least illogical (if you believe in the use of logic as a tool for survival).

Nice words, but pure nonsense. If you make peace with "lifelong terrorists", than they are no longer terrorists, and you have peace.
You were asked:

Originally posted by svero

...but If the violence in Israel did cease and led to a 10 yr period of stability would you consider it the right decision? (Hypothetically speaking..)

And replied that it would not be an honorable peace, so it would not be a right decision.

So your position must be something of the sort: let's kill them all, fill palestine with israelis and then we will have peace.

Is that correct?
 
svero said:
So let's just suppose for a second that Mitzna was voted into office and he did all these sorts of things. And I realize you don't believe this will happen, but If the violence in Israel did cease and led to a 10 yr period of stability would you consider it the right decision? (Hypothetically speaking..)

There is a flaw here. The palestine terror groups _believe_ that it is right and holy to kill the jewish infidels. If Israel stopped retaliating that would just give them more leeway.
 
corplinx said:


There is a flaw here. The palestine terror groups _believe_ that it is right and holy to kill the jewish infidels. If Israel stopped retaliating that would just give them more leeway.

No flaw. It's an hipothetical question, asked (I assume, I apologize to svero if it isn't so) to see how deep is Ben's prejudice against any peace possibility that exclude the biblical "it's your land, so kill them all"
 
corplinx said:


There is a flaw here. The palestine terror groups _believe_ that it is right and holy to kill the jewish infidels. If Israel stopped retaliating that would just give them more leeway.

Do you happen to have a reference for this comment?
 
Megalodon said:


No flaw. It's an hipothetical question, asked (I assume, I apologize to svero if it isn't so) to see how deep is Ben's prejudice against any peace possibility that exclude the biblical "it's your land, so kill them all"

Here's a hypothetical for you:

If a peace partner stole billions from his own people, gets elected with 99% of the vote each time while preaching democracy, never lifts a finger to stop the most atrocious terrorism imaginable, rejects all peace deals, and secretly funds these terrorist groups with millions of dollars from hostile nations like Iraq, Iran, and Saudi Arabia, would you have peace?

-Ben
 
Doctor X said:
...fiat...

Aardvark_DK said:

What does a financially troubled Italian car manufacturer have to do with the conflict in the West Bank (loan and savings)?

"fiat" (Latin) = ~"Let it be done" => a decree, an arbitrary/authoritative order
(e.g. "Fiat lux" = Let there be light)
 
corplinx said:


There is a flaw here. The palestine terror groups _believe_ that it is right and holy to kill the jewish infidels. If Israel stopped retaliating that would just give them more leeway.

Yes, I'm well aware of how the Israeli right thinks in this regard. Personally I don't believe it. Killing Jewish Infidels, as you or they put it, is a direct response to the behaviour of the Israeli govt. People are far more motivated by dead relatives or curfews, or their houses being bulldozed than by some abstract religiously motivated ideology. They flock to the religion when they have nothing left, and corrupt leaders like Arafat know that. Religion is and always has been a tool of the elite to control the masses.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom