svero said:So let's just suppose for a second that Mitzna was voted into office and he did all these sorts of things. And I realize you don't believe this will happen, but If the violence in Israel did cease and led to a 10 yr period of stability would you consider it the right decision? (Hypothetically speaking..)
Ben Shniper said:So, my answer is a definate no. If Mitzna did these kind of unilateral concessions, I would not considder that to be an honorable peace, regardless of how long it lasted.
-Ben
Megalodon said:
There is no honor on the Israeli position right now, so were does that leaves us?
What does a financially troubled Italian car manufacturer have to do with the conflict in the West Bank (loan and savings)?Doctor X said:by fiat
Ben Shniper said:
Israel must fight for its existance.
I get the feeling you don't like my argument about honor because you don't believe in honor.
That's fine. But in that case I'd say that making peace with lifelong terrorists was immoral (if you believe in morality), or at least self destructive (if you believe in the right of humans to fight for survival), or at the very least illogical (if you believe in the use of logic as a tool for survival).
Originally posted by svero
...but If the violence in Israel did cease and led to a 10 yr period of stability would you consider it the right decision? (Hypothetically speaking..)
svero said:So let's just suppose for a second that Mitzna was voted into office and he did all these sorts of things. And I realize you don't believe this will happen, but If the violence in Israel did cease and led to a 10 yr period of stability would you consider it the right decision? (Hypothetically speaking..)
corplinx said:
There is a flaw here. The palestine terror groups _believe_ that it is right and holy to kill the jewish infidels. If Israel stopped retaliating that would just give them more leeway.
corplinx said:
There is a flaw here. The palestine terror groups _believe_ that it is right and holy to kill the jewish infidels. If Israel stopped retaliating that would just give them more leeway.
Megalodon said:
No flaw. It's an hipothetical question, asked (I assume, I apologize to svero if it isn't so) to see how deep is Ben's prejudice against any peace possibility that exclude the biblical "it's your land, so kill them all"
Doctor X said:...fiat...
Aardvark_DK said:
What does a financially troubled Italian car manufacturer have to do with the conflict in the West Bank (loan and savings)?
corplinx said:
There is a flaw here. The palestine terror groups _believe_ that it is right and holy to kill the jewish infidels. If Israel stopped retaliating that would just give them more leeway.