MirageMemories: Care to discuss?

It might look like it, T.A.M. , but if you care to view MM's posts on LC too you'll see s/he is just incapable of logical discourse and is totally dependent on self-sustaining and mindless assertion.

( that's my quota of fairly long words for the rest of the evening :D )

At least I'm not afraid to use the same name on both sites like you obviously are GlennB. And if it's because you've been banned there, just pm me. I won't report you. Unless you cross the line and do something that would also get you banned on JREF.

MM
 
Since you are speculating, MM, what percentage of people in the CIA do you think would not hesitate to go along with a plan that involves murdering 3000+ Americans plus inflict billions of dollars in damage?

Surely you realize that the CIA is populated with Americans themselves? And many of these CIA employees have families that they go home to? Surely you do not think that all of these CIA employees are evil and would have no qualms about engaging in this plan?

Why do you seem to think the CIA would be involved and act as if it would be no problem for them to be involved? CIA employees have feelings and are patriotic too. Right?

Lurker
 
...Meanwhile you folks with the big debunker brains pile on the crap because regardless of the truth, you can't stand the humilation you'd feel if your obsessive convictions were undermined by an ounce of doubt.

There are so many reasons why a proper investigation is needed that it staggers the mind that all you supposedly brilliant folk can do is keep crapping on the truth.

You can play lawyer all you want. I know it's a fun pastime, but the requirements for a proper investigation are reasonable doubt and not 100% proof which seems to be the only persuader here.
Yawn.

Y'know, no matter how much you want this issue to be true, it isn't. Read that again and contemplate it, if you can.
 
Last edited:
I'll let heyLeroy address most of the above, as it was him to which you were replying. However, the quotes below are in reference to JREF etc, so I feel compelled to discuss.

If you wish to interrogate me, I intend to ask the occasional question myself. If that's not kewl with you don't confiscate my posts from LC and demand replies in JREF! You could have asked me these questions where you originally read them instead of seeking the sanctuary of JREF and your guaranteed gang of supporters.

Ahh if only the LCers could follow such wise advice...but since they can't, I guess both groups will use such tactics.

I'm fully convinced that it wasn't done by 19 radical Islamists because I don't find the NIST Report provides a credible explanation for why the towers collapsed.

So you are saying that your belief, or lack there of, concerning the OS (19 saudi hijackers) hangs on the lack of convincing that NIST has done with regards to the WTC1/2 Collapse. Well if that is true, than I am sure you must have a tonne of points that display where NIST has been "inadequate" in their explanation for you...please ellaborate.

In the interest of open-mindedness, it's conceivable that there were additional Islamic terrorists 'on the ground', that were responsible for assuring the total collapse of the towers. While I don't find that scenario very credible, it is within the realm of possibility.

It has a lack of credibility because, just like 99% of the truth movements theories, there is NO EVIDENCE to back it up.

Like I said, the number of people involved, outside of the actual organizers, would be totally dependent on which plan was chosen. The more powerfull the explosives, the fewer people likely to be involved in the preparation. The more lead time, the fewer people required.

kind of vague, and nonspecific.

You finish your reply with typical JREF 'play-to-the-crowd-of-admirers' abusive crap about space launching golf balls with elastic bands while in effect, criticizing me for bothering to answer you.

ok, I'll give you that one, but when in Rome...

You asked me to talk about a speculation post from another site and then you make your dismissal summation about how pointless it all supposedly is.

Well if speculation was pointless it wouldn't get used by scientists, detectives, investigators of all stripes, and courtroom attorneys. It's a part of the reasoning process that we all use so if your going to mock me then your mocking yourself in the process.

Speculation used as one of many reasoning and logical tools is totally appropriate. Disguising it as evidence and facts to prove a lie, however, is totally INAPPROPRIATE.

Evidence is required to prove and convict.

It is not required to speculate, research, investigate and compare observations.

Correct. However, it is required to APPROPRIATELY charge/accuse as well. If evidence and facts are not the basis of accusation, than such is slander and libel.

TAM
 
At least I'm not afraid to use the same name on both sites like you obviously are GlennB. And if it's because you've been banned there, just pm me. I won't report you. Unless you cross the line and do something that would also get you banned on JREF.

MM

MM - "cross the line" ? Are you kidding?

Take a look around at the regular LC posters and the blatant *expletive deleted* abuse they dish out.

Take a look at the sceptic posters that have been banned at LC just for respectfully debating from a counter-CT position.

It would take a concerted effort, or blind ignorant abuse, to get banned here.

The same cannot be said of LC.

I can't help but conclude they're afraid of something. I suspect that "something" is people presenting evidence, and demanding it in return.
 
Evidence is required to prove and convict.

You've provided none yet accuse just the same.

ie. the USSS did not follow SOP

It is not required to speculate, research, investigate and compare observations.

You've provided nothing but this and what you do provide is often easily disputed. Certainly so in this thread.

ie. the USSS should have bundled GW Bush off immediatly.
 
...I'm fully convinced that it wasn't done by 19 radical Islamists because I don't find the NIST Report provides a credible explanation for why the towers collapsed.
And yet untold thousands of experts in related fields the world over have no problem whatsoever with the explanation for why the towers collapsed. But because you can't comprehend, you're "fully convinced" there's some other reason.

My goodness gracious.
 
Evidence is required to prove and convict.

It is not required to speculate, research, investigate and compare observations.
MM

MM has no facts he is a fictional fellow. A simple teller of lies in the correct movement of other liars.

So all your comments are speculation no facts. You need to post up front you are just passing on lies.
 
Oh but because no bunker..a grade school classroom would suffice.

No precautionary measures like hustle him out of there.

Yes that makes so much sense.

MM

You admit yourself that the appearance at the school was public knowledge 4 days before

Knowing that would you expect him to run out of the protective confines of a school building and pound on his chest and scream 'I'm Here!! Shoot me!!'

or would it have been better to wait the ten mins while secret service makes sure no suspicious activity is happening locally immediately after the attacks?

Or maybe #11) George Bush just didn't want to miss an opportunity to learn about Goats!
 
MM - "cross the line" ? Are you kidding?

Take a look around at the regular LC posters and the blatant *expletive deleted* abuse they dish out.

Take a look at the sceptic posters that have been banned at LC just for respectfully debating from a counter-CT position.

It would take a concerted effort, or blind ignorant abuse, to get banned here.

The same cannot be said of LC.

I can't help but conclude they're afraid of something. I suspect that "something" is people presenting evidence, and demanding it in return.

Glenn I do sympathize with your frustration regarding the tolerance levels at LC but I have no hand in policy there.

I hang out at LC because of the 9/11 subject matter and not because of the LC film as I've said previously.

I belong to other forums but LC and JREF are the most active ones that I've encountered hence that's where I hangout when time permits.

For the record, just because my name shows up as having logged in here, it doesn't mean my JREF window is open and I'm stalling on a reply.

Also, as one person being barraged by many, I can't reply to the huge volume of attacks err I mean replies that I face here.

MM
 
And yet untold thousands of experts in related fields the world over have no problem whatsoever with the explanation for why the towers collapsed. But because you can't comprehend, you're "fully convinced" there's some other reason.

My goodness gracious.

Please provide a list of those thousands of experts in related fields and provide evidence that they have "no problem whatsoever" with the explanation for the towers collapse.

Since this issue has been raised so often, I'm sure you have this information readily available.

MM
 
Please provide a list of those thousands of experts in related fields and provide evidence that they have "no problem whatsoever" with the explanation for the towers collapse.

Since this issue has been raised so often, I'm sure you have this information readily available.

MM
http://mceer.buffalo.edu/publications/wtc/02-SP02Screen.pdf
http://www.implosionworld.com/wtc.htm
http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/defense/1227842.html?page=1&c=y
http://www.public-action.com/911/jmcm/sciam/
http://news.uns.purdue.edu/UNS/html4ever/2006/060911.Sozen.WTC.html
http://wtc.nist.gov/oct05NCSTAR1-1index.htm
 
Please provide a list of those thousands of experts in related fields and provide evidence that they have "no problem whatsoever" with the explanation for the towers collapse.

Since this issue has been raised so often, I'm sure you have this information readily available.

MM

I see, so we are to expect professionals to not only come out and publicly criticise an official account/statement/theory, but now we have to expect them to come out and publicly endorse an official account/statement/theory.

Well, perhaps you can link to some public statements by professionals who agree with the theory of gravity, that the earth orbits the sun and that scarlett johansen has a fantastic pair..... of eyes?

Or maybe experts don't comment unless they are in DISAGREEMENT?
 
I see, so we are to expect professionals to not only come out and publicly criticise an official account/statement/theory, but now we have to expect them to come out and publicly endorse an official account/statement/theory.

Well, perhaps you can link to some public statements by professionals who agree with the theory of gravity, that the earth orbits the sun and that scarlett johansen has a fantastic pair..... of eyes?

Or maybe experts don't comment unless they are in DISAGREEMENT?
Oooh, I know. Myabe it's because their little cult has them so used to blocking out anything that does agree with their fantastical worldview that they can't even hear people that disagree with them. Such behavior was certainly demonstrated by 28th Kingdom.
 
You admit yourself that the appearance at the school was public knowledge 4 days before

Knowing that would you expect him to run out of the protective confines of a school building and pound on his chest and scream 'I'm Here!! Shoot me!!'

or would it have been better to wait the ten mins while secret service makes sure no suspicious activity is happening locally immediately after the attacks?

Or maybe #11) George Bush just didn't want to miss an opportunity to learn about Goats!

Yes I clearly stated "the appearance at the school was public knowledge 4 days before".

Well we saw at the Pentagon how much protection a building affords to a missile attack err I mean a 757 crash. Somehow I doubt a Sarasota public school was build more solidly than the newly reconstructed section of the home of the U.S. military establishment, but of course I could be wrong.

I keep hearing this 10 minutes claim. I guess it's a nice round number and most importantly a small number. It's my understanding and I hope this isn't interpreted as another lie, that GW didn't actually leave the scholl until around 9:35 am. This would place him in the school for over half an hour from the time of the attacks.

Maybe I'm a victim of propaganda but my impression was that the SS placed their primary existence on protecting the PRESIDENT.

On 9/11 they hussled the VICE PRESIDENT to the command bunker. That's fine, makes sense to me. It was being precautionary when conditions were still supposedly unknown and developing.

But when it comes to the office of the PRESIDENT OF THE UNITES STATES of AMERICA, the most powerful country in the whole wide world, I don't expect the Secret Service to give the reading of a goat story to school children more import than the immediate movement of the PRESIDENT to any location that has not been publicized. If that sounds illogical, I'm sorry, but when I went to school, 2 + 2 still equaled 4.

MM
 

And let's not forget:
Me (Structural Engineering)
R.Mackey
Architect
Chippy
Maccy
Anti-Sophist
Lurker
And so much more.

I'd also like to mention that the supervisors at my firm were so impressed with the technical depth and accuracy of the NIST NCSTAR1 report that they made it required reading for all engineers at the design level in the firm. That's probably at least 100 structural, mechanical, and geotechnical engineers that have all read the report.
 
Please provide a list of those thousands of experts in related fields and provide evidence that they have "no problem whatsoever" with the explanation for the towers collapse.

Since this issue has been raised so often, I'm sure you have this information readily available.

MM

Wow. MM the I got no fact just lies guy asks for thousands of experts.

Wow. From the truth movement with only .00067 percent of all engineers in their truth movement he asked for only a thousand.

MM you are off by an order of magnitude. Find just one fact or expert with a fact.

Gee there are more engineers at JREF than there are truther engineers who have facts on 9/11.
 
But when it comes to the office of the PRESIDENT OF THE UNITES STATES of AMERICA, the most powerful country in the whole wide world, I don't expect the Secret Service to give the reading of a goat story to school children more import than the immediate movement of the PRESIDENT to any location that has not been publicized. If that sounds illogical, I'm sorry, but when I went to school, 2 + 2 still equaled 4.

MM

You appear to still be operating under the faulty assumption that the president was in any real, immediate danger while in a room filled with small children. Were one of the kids going to jump up and stab him?
 
I see, so we are to expect professionals to not only come out and publicly criticise an official account/statement/theory, but now we have to expect them to come out and publicly endorse an official account/statement/theory.

Well, perhaps you can link to some public statements by professionals who agree with the theory of gravity, that the earth orbits the sun and that scarlett johansen has a fantastic pair..... of eyes?

Or maybe experts don't comment unless they are in DISAGREEMENT?

Or maybe, just maybe Davie lad, experts don't comment unless they were part of the process from the very beginning.

I'm forever amused by how often skeptics make the claim that if the story is wrong the professionals will come running, screaming "no way!"

The world I live in says people no matter what their stripe, do not contradict the establishment if they know it entails risk with no foreseeable benefit. Let the next guy be the hero.

I took engineering in college. Structural engineering was my best grade. I wouldn't for a moment expect people in the profession to challenge the NIST findings without some assurance that it wouldn't bite them in the ass.

Delude yourselves all you want but the fact remains few people are willing to stick their necks out against the establishment when it means risk to themselves, their families, their jobs and their friendships.

MM
 
Well we saw at the Pentagon how much protection a building affords to a missile attack err I mean a 757 crash. Somehow I doubt a Sarasota public school was build more solidly than the newly reconstructed section of the home of the U.S. military establishment, but of course I could be wrong.

I keep hearing this 10 minutes claim. I guess it's a nice round number and most importantly a small number. It's my understanding and I hope this isn't interpreted as another lie, that GW didn't actually leave the scholl until around 9:35 am. This would place him in the school for over half an hour from the time of the attacks.

Maybe I'm a victim of propaganda but my impression was that the SS placed their primary existence on protecting the PRESIDENT.

On 9/11 they hussled the VICE PRESIDENT to the command bunker. That's fine, makes sense to me. It was being precautionary when conditions were still supposedly unknown and developing.


Were specific people being targeted?

NO, symbols of American power were being targeted.

_______________________________

Was GWB in immediate danger?

NO, the attacks were occuring hundreds of miles to the north in a manner which would be somewhat untenable to use against a school. The targets being hit were huge and easily identifiable structures. Schools are not nearly as large and are very difficult to distinquish, in the air, from a myriad of suburban houses and light industrial buildings.
____________________________

Was Cheney in danger.

Quite possibly. Although the Whitehouse is indeed harder to spot from the air than the other buildings it is an obvious target, and is in the vicinity of the other targets.
______________________________

Was there a danger of a ground attack on GWB?

There was no indication of one but if there were to be one then hustling him out of the school right away would be the absolute worst thing to do. It would mean he would be exposed while exiting the school. While inside at least no terrorist could be sure of his exact location inside.

_________________________________

Had the USSS taken him out immediatly, where would they take him?

AF1 - Here we have a large , easily identifiable target for any ground attack. We also have a target in a place that other aircraft frequent and thus it may not be unusual for one to be within a few miles. A plane travelling 400 MPH will cover 6 miles in one minute.
__________________________________________________

So they have no immediate reason to remove GWB, they must ensure the security of the immediate perimeter before moving him and they must make sure that AF-1 is secure and ONLY then can they move the President.

Cheney was in a building that, at least in some ways, fit the profile of the targets that day.

MM's assumptions are all shown to be incorrect!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom