MirageMemories: Care to discuss?

In a developing situation where even NORAD was unable to cope, how can you qualify the president's position in a well announced public location as threat free?

How could the UNITED STATES SECRET SERVICE be so sure that quickly unless they had inside knowledge or were ordered by superiors to maintain their current status?

MM

Where was the threat?

There was no IMMIADIATE threat, he was in a secure building, surrounded by Secret Service personnel, so where the hell was the threat?

Are you now accusing the UNITED STATES SECRET SERVICE as well as the President of the USA of being involved in mass murder of 3000 US citizens, Is there nobody you will not accuse to fore fill your paranoid delusions.

Now stopping talking crap and start listing facts.

WHAT PROTOCALS DID THE US SECRET SERVICE BREAK ON 911?
 
...I have no idea how much inside knowledge GW had but I believe Cheney knew the whole story!
So, Bush knew nothing about it, according to you. And of course he couldn't have, because he would not have been caught looking stupid in that classroom if he'd have been "in on it". Right in the script, it would have said something like: "Put down the Goat book decisively, affix a look of concern and brave determination on your face, wave over your staff, whisper for 15 seconds or so, make a terse statement to the class, and then stride purposefully out the door. FADE TO BLACK."

Now then, Rumsfeld and Wolfowitz were also not in on it, obviously. Need I even explain why? All right, you dragged it out of me. Because neither Rumsfeld nor Wolfowitz would EVER have agreed to any "inside job" plan by which their lives were directly threatened by it. Right? Here we've got this big explosive projectile (whatever it was) heading directly at the Pentagon, and who are inside while that's happening? Correct! Rummy and Wolfie Witless! So: The Secretary of Defense and his Deputy knew NOTHING about a 9/11 inside job, and neither did the President.

So Cheney - what - pulled his shotgun in the White House and made people do it his way, threatened to invite them on a hunting trip if they objected? Made it all up as he went along? Spur of the moment deal?
 
MM,
9/11 came and went. POTUS is still alive. The SS did their job.
All of your Dr. Seuss logic (wasn't that an early title, "If I Ran the SS") is meaningless. Period. The SS, like everyone else, was trying to analyze(se) the situation. They, like you and me, didn't know what was really going on. Were there trucks with bombs heading for other areas; ten more planes already in the air, bombs already placed at other facilities, etc.... Those first hours were mass confusion. The extract from Clarke pretty well sums up what was going on - they were reacting to an ongoing and volatile situaiton.(Damn that Mike W coming in here with FACTS!)

You write rather well, and you're a clever bit of work, but ultimately, you're Russell with an attitude. If everything comes down to "Well, I read the evidence, but it just doesn't seem to me that that's how the SS should behave", then there's no convincing you, is there?
This is the Russell Pickering (whom I've affectionately dubbed Politeness Man) approach, and it's why Russell's act wore thin, as will yours. If those are your debating rules, and no amount of evidence or documentation is going to convince you that your particular world-view is not the best filter for judging physics, biology, mathematics, engineering, construction or demolition, then all you leave us is the pleasure of smacking you around a little bit.

We have loads of threads here where opinion counts. I have a long-running and good-natured tiff going on whether MacArthur Park is the worst song since cavemen first bonked two rocks together or merely the worst of the twentieth century. If you want to discuss the Dickens v Chaucer or Fellini v Kubrick, no one's going to demand you give evidence to support matters of "taste" or "opinion". But if you choose to opine that things we saw and which have been documented and studied by experts and professionas DID NOT HAPPEN, then those opinions are worthless speculation and you will be metaphorically shot down in flames for them.

As long as your response to "Is that your final answer?", is "Well, it's how it looks to me....", then you're not here for a debate, you're here to troll.

It's true. My spiders say so. :spjimlad: :spjimlad: :spjimlad:
 
...the towers stood about an hour or so after the aircraft impact, then they exploded...the towers handled the impact, and jet fuel and office supplies will not melt steel (start a fire in your burn pit in the back yard and see how long you have to heat a piece of heavier angle iron to get it to even bend) or pulverize concrete to fine dust...for those towers to come down as they did, completely demolished, something had to occur at the base, otherwise a large portion of the towers (below the impacts) would have remained somewhat intact, messed up but not made into a pile of rubble...
 
MM:

I think all the time...my career requires it. I make life and death decisions every day. My use of the word moron, tonight is twofold. First, for you, it was to get your attention, as you had been ignoring all comments and questions I had been posting. Secondly, I am in a grumpy mood wrt the truthers the last day or two, call it "Debate/Discussion" fatigue if you will.
You are exhibiting classical truther debating/discussion tactics, so it rubbed me the wrong way, on the wrong night.

As for speculation, I am not saying it is complete nonsense, but when you use it to accuse someone of something it is juvenile, slanderous, and just ignorant. It is part of the toolbox one uses to deduct and reason, yes, but it is one of many tools, that help us to sift through evidence. It is not to be used as the foundation for a lynching of innocents til proven guilty.

I agree, that Cheney is likely the "real" mind behind the presidency, but regardless, it does not change the fact that the SS made a decision, and in my mind, the mind of most here at JREF, and likely in the minds of most americans, it was the proper move. The president was in a previously secured area, surrounded by children. This 9/11 attack was not planned a day or two before 9/11, so your assumption that the knowledge of his placement in Florida would have made any difference in jet attacks a thousand miles north east of his location is not practical or logical.

TAM
 
...the towers stood about an hour or so after the aircraft impact, then they exploded...the towers handled the impact, and jet fuel and office supplies will not melt steel (start a fire in your burn pit in the back yard and see how long you have to heat a piece of heavier angle iron to get it to even bend) or pulverize concrete to fine dust...for those towers to come down as they did, completely demolished, something had to occur at the base, otherwise a large portion of the towers (below the impacts) would have remained somewhat intact, messed up but not made into a pile of rubble...
You really have a lot of work ahead of you, Dan. I suggest lurking quite a bit longer here at JREF, before you post such a "Kick Me" statement as that above.

If you're ready now, however, you can start by listing out your credentials as they relate to the profession of controlled demolition.

As Gravy says: Proceed.
 
...the towers stood about an hour or so after the aircraft impact, then they exploded...the towers handled the impact, and jet fuel and office supplies will not melt steel (start a fire in your burn pit in the back yard and see how long you have to heat a piece of heavier angle iron to get it to even bend) or pulverize concrete to fine dust...for those towers to come down as they did, completely demolished, something had to occur at the base, otherwise a large portion of the towers (below the impacts) would have remained somewhat intact, messed up but not made into a pile of rubble...

Welcome to the forum dan. While I doubt your stay will be long lived, welcome while you are here.

(1) good point, the towers did stand well after impact, so they did survive, as the designers had stated they should, an impact of a jet airliner, even one at high speed.

(2) The office furniture, carpeting, curtains, office equipment, chemicals, and jet fuel all contributed to create a fire that reached temps of near 1200-1400 F, more than enough to SIGNIFICANTLY reduce the strength of the un fire protected (impacts removed fireproofing) steel, which then bend/twisted/sagged, what have you, pulling the exterior inward, ultimately causing the collapse.

(3) A very large portion of the dust that came from the collapses, as proven through chemical analysis of the dust, was in fact Gypsum wallboard, which turns, readily, into a fine dust. Concrete was less than 50% (much less if I recall) of the dust make up. The wallboard was also the source of Dr. jones Sulfur...the key to his Thermite hypothesis.

(4) prove your last assertion with scientific calculations, or such information from a peer reviewed scientific article published in a reputable journal, or I will assume it is pure bunk speculation.

TAM
 
...{
9902458414ad2ebc7.gif
snipped} for those towers to come down as they did, completely demolished, something had to occur at the base, otherwise a large portion of the towers (below the impacts) would have remained somewhat intact, messed up but not made into a pile of rubble...

Have you actually watched the collapses? 500,000 tons(the weight of 5 Nimitz class aircraft carriers) of steel and concrete were barreling downward at 80 mph by the time the bases were reached. Are you seriously trying to say that the bases had to be pre-weakened? Really??

They dont build a safety factor of 10,000 into skyscrapers.....sheesh.
 
...the towers stood about an hour or so after the aircraft impact, then they exploded...the towers handled the impact, and jet fuel and office supplies will not melt steel (start a fire in your burn pit in the back yard and see how long you have to heat a piece of heavier angle iron to get it to even bend) or pulverize concrete to fine dust...for those towers to come down as they did, completely demolished, something had to occur at the base, otherwise a large portion of the towers (below the impacts) would have remained somewhat intact, messed up but not made into a pile of rubble...

Oh boy, backyard science proving 9/11 was an inside job.

Someone alert Steven Jones, he may want to cite this in his next paper.
 
Dan you cant scale fire. Think of how you are comparing a backyard barbecue pit fire to a fire an acre in size elevated almost 1000 feet in the air. You have an updraft condition via the holes in the building and elevator/utility shafts. I'm no fire expert but wouldn't a small backyard fire be able to shed heat via the surrounding difference in air temperature better than a huge fire in a convective current similar to that of a forest fire?
 
Last edited:
...the towers stood about an hour or so after the aircraft impact, then they exploded...the towers handled the impact, and jet fuel and office supplies will not melt steel (start a fire in your burn pit in the back yard and see how long you have to heat a piece of heavier angle iron to get it to even bend) or pulverize concrete to fine dust...for those towers to come down as they did, completely demolished, something had to occur at the base, otherwise a large portion of the towers (below the impacts) would have remained somewhat intact, messed up but not made into a pile of rubble...

Oh, I never looked at it that way! I'm totally convinced...















that you need serious counseling if you believe that nonsense!:Banane09:
 
...thanks for the welcome...I like to read alot on here (and other places)...
...as far as what I believe, I believe what I seen, the towers were completely destroyed from top to bottom...and it wasn't from the impacts...
...and you really don't need to be a scientist or have 'credentials' to know how steel (heavy steel beams and plates) react to heat (I did work the rolling mills a few years in the late '70's tho) and 1200 degrees F ain't gonna do it, bend them that is, if those temps were even reached in that hour before the collapse
...as far as counseling goes, I am sure alot of people need counseling, maybe I could get counseling to help me be part of the gang, one of the 'big boys' HA...
 
...thanks for the welcome...I like to read alot on here (and other places)...
...as far as what I believe, I believe what I seen, the towers were completely destroyed from top to bottom...

Nothing indicates this statement is true, unless you poorly worded a phrase that the entire building was destroyed.

and it wasn't from the impacts...

No, it was the impacts and subsequent fire.

...and you really don't need to be a scientist or have 'credentials' to know how steel (heavy steel beams and plates) react to heat (I did work the rolling mills a few years in the late '70's tho) and 1200 degrees F ain't gonna do it, bend them that is, if those temps were even reached in that hour before the collapse

You experience in a rolling mill is just plain sad for you to make statements like that. You are using it to extend knowledge of steel's structural strength in handling loads. Your knowledge it tiny, and you try applying it to things out of your grasp.

Which am I to believe? Everty structural text on steel ever written, as well as all the Structural engineers in the world, or some guy who shaped cold metal for a few years?

Hmmm.
 
...thanks for the welcome...I like to read alot on here (and other places)...
...as far as what I believe, I believe what I seen, the towers were completely destroyed from top to bottom...and it wasn't from the impacts...
...and you really don't need to be a scientist or have 'credentials' to know how steel (heavy steel beams and plates) react to heat (I did work the rolling mills a few years in the late '70's tho) and 1200 degrees F ain't gonna do it, bend them that is, if those temps were even reached in that hour before the collapse
...as far as counseling goes, I am sure alot of people need counseling, maybe I could get counseling to help me be part of the gang, one of the 'big boys' HA...
Uh-oh. Dan, I think you've painted yourself into the Beam Weapon camp or the Nuke Shaped Charge In The Basement camp.

There were pics of twisted steel after the collapses of the WTCs, I'm sure you've seen 'em. Explain. You just stated that the temps were not hot enough to bend steel. Yet, we've got bent steel. Feeling the heat yet, Dan?
 
Dan, please do yourself, and us, a favor by reading at least the basics of the NIST report on the towers. The structural engineering, fire safety engineering, physics, and demolitions communities all say you are very, very wrong, both about your assumptions and your conclusions.

I recommend starting here:

NIST Answers to Frequently Asked Questions http://tinyurl.com/pqrxt

And for more detail, delving into these reports:

NIST final report on WTC 1&2 http://wtc.nist.gov/reports_october05.htm

NIST WTC 7 Interim Report http://wtc.nist.gov/progress_report_june04/appendixl.pdf

Structural engineer Zdenek Bazant on the WTC and the progressive collapse of tall buildings www.civil.northwestern.edu/people/bazant/PDFs/Papers/ProgressiveCollapseWTC-6-23-2006.pdf

Physicist Manuel Garcia's Counterpunch articles on the physics of the WTC collapses
http://www.counterpunch.org/physic11282006.html
http://www.counterpunch.org/thermo11282006.html
http://www.counterpunch.org/darkfire11282006.html

Frank Greening's papers on the WTC, Momentum transfer, "tipping,", concrete pulverization, etc
http://www.911myths.com/WTCREPORT.pdf
http://www.911myths.com/Energy_Transfer_Addendum.pdf
http://www.911myths.com/WTC2TIP.pdf
http://www.911myths.com/WTCONC1.pdf

An excellent book:
Debunking 9/11 Myths: Why Conspiracy Theories Can't Stand Up to the Facts
http://www.amazon.com/Debunking-11-Myths-Conspiracy-Theories/dp/158816635X
 
Uh-oh. Dan, I think you've painted yourself into the Beam Weapon camp or the Nuke Shaped Charge In The Basement camp.

There were pics of twisted steel after the collapses of the WTCs, I'm sure you've seen 'em. Explain. You just stated that the temps were not hot enough to bend steel. Yet, we've got bent steel. Feeling the heat yet, Dan?

WTC building 5, not hit by plane, fire fueled by office contents. Photo shows floor 8 of 9.

879044aa72598802f.jpg
 
Dan, what do you have to say about the fact that basically the world's structural engineers and demolitions experts disagree with you?

Seriously. If you want to believe in an alternative theory, and you are an honest investigator, you have to deal with that fact.

What is you theory on why so many professionals in the relevant fields disagree with your theory?
 
Dan you worked in a rolling mill? OK did they make bar joists there? are you aware the web of the bar joists In the towers were only about 11 tenths of an inch thick? That those same bar joists were in pairs spaced 80 inches apart? and 60 feet long? they were not "thick beams" or "massive plates." All it took was a segment of any bar joist to get hot enough at its lower angle stock or bar web to soften and fail to support a live load of 39999 pounds (100 psf x 60' x 6'8") and the dead load of the concrete floor, steel pan and reinforcing and trusses themselves? A chain is no stronger than its weakest link.
 
...thanks for the welcome...I like to read alot on here (and other places)...
...as far as what I believe, I believe what I seen, the towers were completely destroyed from top to bottom...and it wasn't from the impacts...
...and you really don't need to be a scientist or have 'credentials' to know how steel (heavy steel beams and plates) react to heat (I did work the rolling mills a few years in the late '70's tho) and 1200 degrees F ain't gonna do it, bend them that is, if those temps were even reached in that hour before the collapse
...as far as counseling goes, I am sure alot of people need counseling, maybe I could get counseling to help me be part of the gang, one of the 'big boys' HA...
Yet another ADD tin hatter who posts whatever dibbles onto the keyboard without regard to the subject of the thread.

Let me guess Dan (and please correct me where I'm wrong).

You don't work in any field related to construction of high rise buildings.
You don't have a college degree in a related engineering field of study.
You don't work in any field related to demolitions.
You never read the NIST report.
In fact, you haven't read any of the official reports about 9/11
You haven't read the rebuttal documents/videos to LC.
You haven't talked personally with any of the first responders to any of the 9/11 events.

How am I doing Dan?
 
How could the UNITED STATES SECRET SERVICE be so sure that quickly unless they had inside knowledge or were ordered by superiors to maintain their current status
?

I have not said that anyone could absolutly know that GWB was in no danger in the school. What I did was illustrate that before rushing the President out of there it would be prudent to ensure that there was no danger in exposing him outside.

There was no intel at all to suggest that an air attack was coming for the school, the occuring attacks were hundreds of miles from Bush's location. Attacks that use domestic flights as these did required some planning, mostly what to do as soon as the plane is commandeered. One needs to know where to go. To this end first you have to get to the town where the school is. The school then would have to be scouted, what does it look like from the air, what are the easily recognized landmarks along the way, what flights would put you within striking distance at the right time. 4 days would be cutting it rather close. Hell it would be a lot less complicated just to set up on the ground in the vicinity and wait for GWB to come outside then send half a dozen RPG rounds at him and the motorcade or, another senario, position a sniper to take him out as he exits.

You say you'd have immediatly moved the president out of harms' way but you simply could not be sure that moving him would not actually be moving him INTO harm's way. You say use AF-1. But a 747 sitting on a runway is a hell of an easier target to find and hit than a suburban school. A motorcade is a very noticible target as well for some types of attack.

Yes, if the school had had a bunker it would be better to move him there for the time being. It did not.
Cheney was much closer to the confirmed attacks and he was in a building that would be an obvious target whether or not either Cheney or Bush happened to even be there at the time and it does have a bunker.

However, you seem to be claiming that GWB was not moved because they/he knew he was safe. You have also stated that Cheney was the one that knew the whole story. But the USSS insisted that Cheney move to the bunker. This means that the USSS knew that Bush was safe but those assigned to Cheney did not know that he was safe.

Why bother telling the USSS anything at all? Why inform Bush's contingent but not Cheney's? Especially given that you believe that Cheney was pulling all the strings that day?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom