MirageMemories: Care to discuss?

Cough cough.

Ahh ya like the Secret Service hustled the Vice President off to safety but allowed THE PRESIDENT in a well publicized event, to keep reading to a classroom of school children.

MM

I don't understand this response. In criticizing your opponent's position that George W. Bush would personally have to strangle people who did not immediately agree with the plan, you have chosen to make an irrelevant comparison to an event whose details you ignored. Is that your concept of debate?
 
I see a lot of trivia in the supposed critical thinking coming out of this Forum.

Take this thread alone, look at how many compulsive posts were made with virtually nothing to say before I made my first response.

Critical thinkers among other attributes, are patient and have self discipline.

What I've seen here is mostly a lot of ego tripping and posturing to the JREF fan club.

I've seen little indication of a capacity for sensitivity, concern or empathy here, so claims to 'professions of feeling', I have to take with a "grain of salt".

MM

No true Scotsman is a term coined by Antony Flew in his 1975 book Thinking About Thinking. It refers to an argument which takes this form:
Argument: "No Scotsman puts sugar on his porridge." Reply: "But my uncle Angus likes sugar with his porridge." Rebuttal: "Ah yes, but no true Scotsman puts sugar on his porridge." This form of argument is a fallacy if the predicate ("putting sugar on porridge") is not actually contradictory for the accepted definition of the subject ("Scotsman"), or if the definition of the subject is silently adjusted after the fact to make the rebuttal work.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_scotsman
 
Cough cough.

Ahh ya like the Secret Service hustled the Vice President off to safety but allowed THE PRESIDENT in a well publicized event, to keep reading to a classroom of school children.

MM

Oh when did you know we were under an attack? First Plane? Second Plane?

This is one of the CTers key dumb ideas the book and reading etc. Now you will connect the dots to a CT that includes your fake stuff at the WTC. When you find the silent explosives you used on the WTC tell me; we can make some money!

This has to be in the Top Ten CTers list of dumb smoking guns.

Is there a list of dumb smoking guns; this is one of them. (good job)
 
What key piece of evidence?

WTC7 and yes I've already ready the Gravy report and waded through the million page thread on the subject here. I also noted how anyone not in the Official Story camp is treated.

MM

Well, thanks for the answer. It's not what I meant by a key piece of evidence though - your conclusion seems to be that WTC7 was deliberately demolished. It's the evidence for your conclusion that I was asking for. What was it about WTC 7 collapsing that led you to your conclusion?
 
WTC7 and yes I've already ready the Gravy report and waded through the million page thread on the subject here. I also noted how anyone not in the Official Story camp is treated.
MM, it appears you've never been to a conspiracy forum and observed how they treat anybody who considers the official story the one that best fits the evidence. It certainly is a two-way street, is it not?

Government shill, blind sheep, Bush lover, Nazi, disinfo agent, you name it.
 
MM, 9/11 was an important event, it drastically changed the course of history and it still affects alot of people. Unless you were five years old when it happened, you should know that speculating about it based on nothing and promoting lies is disrespectful an immature.
 
MM claims to be an impartial "truth-seeker", but reveals his hypocrisy by crying foul at the way he has been treated by some of our forum members. Where is his indignation for personal attacks on the LC forum where fellow CTers like Roxdog, tower, and water_bender engage in exactly that type of behavior on a regular basis?

Myself and several other skeptics were constantly insulted and ridiculed by those mentioned above and others, while we simply addressed the arguments and stayed on topic. Often times in threads that MM was participating in. Funny, I don't recall MM ever taking issue with that.

Yet, MM comes here and does nothing more than attempt to bait and then criticize those who take the bait, all the while flat out ignoring those that attempt to actually engage in discussion.

MM clearly has no interest in honest debate.
 
MirageMemories@LC said:
When I say; "I was a skeptic", I was NEVER a bigoted skeptic.

Like most people who watched 9/11 unfold live on CNN, I was so overwhelmed by that shock and awe event that I was a pushover when the Official Story came down.

I mean who in their right mind could believe that our own people would do something like that in order to further a political agenda?

Even so I was plagued by the nagging feeling that WTC 1 & 2 should not have collapsed in spite of the spectacular plane crashes and fireballs.

When PBS released their documentary WHY THE TOWERS COLLAPSED, I was finally provided with what seemed like a believable, professional explanation for what seemed impossible. I stopped having doubts and was completely unaware that there was a 9/11 Truth Movement.

Last spring I saw Dave von Kleist's IN PLANE SITE and Dyland and Korey's LOOSE CHANGE PT2.

The skeptic in me balked but when the video of WTC7 was presented, I was pushed over the edge and an icy cold chill swept up my spine as I realized it was clearly brought down and was not the kind of collapse that would be expected just due to the influence of gravity. It's hard, if not IMPOSSIBLE to get a symmetrical collapse of that nature without planned intervention.

I've been involved ever since and please don't think that my joining JREF means I am another bigoted JREFer.

Far from it. I want to hear what the best they have to offer is, and I want to be able to post there, but on my own terms.

It's certainly not a place to reveal yourself, if you have a thin skin.

They are masters of abuse but I find it's difficult to be personally rattled when their postings provide so little to respect.

They like to take the poorest examples of those in the 9/11 Truth Movement and assume everyone in the movement is like that.

They also assume anyone who is a member here gets up and salutes the LC documentary every morning.

I see this meeting place as the Loose Change 9/11 Truth Movement Forums. I don't see it as the 9/11 Loose Change Video Forums.

Regardless of how many undotted "i's" skeptics catalogue in the Loose Change documentary, it still carries a message that is true and needs to be heard.

http://z10.invisionfree.com/Loose_Change_Forum/index.php?showtopic=2900
Sigh.
 
Originally Posted by MirageMemories@LC
The skeptic in me balked but when the video of WTC7 was presented, I was pushed over the edge and an icy cold chill swept up my spine as I realized it was clearly brought down and was not the kind of collapse that would be expected just due to the influence of gravity. It's hard, if not IMPOSSIBLE to get a symmetrical collapse of that nature without planned intervention.
Have you informed NIST to call off their investigation? Please could you state why you know it is Impossible for this building to have collapsed without intervention?

Please state the exact intervention that you speak about, please back it with facts and evidence.

Please also state your expertise this relevant area that qualifies you to make this assertion. Are you a highly trained, highly skilled structural engineer? A Civil engineer maybe? Or how about an Architect? Or maybe your specialist subject is controlled demolitions. Please state.

I've been involved ever since and please don't think that my joining JREF means I am another bigoted JREFer.
But wait you said before you don't categorise people and all of a sudden you are a not a nasty bigoted JREFER but everybody else is ?. Oh dear me I smell hypocrisy.

So what are you exactly? Are you just regular guys that get off on accusing your fellow country men of mass murder?

Wow what a guy.
It's certainly not a place to reveal yourself, if you have a thin skin.
No its not. It’s a place to leave childish, immature fantasies at the door when you enter. It is a place to present facts,evidence and well reasoned arguments. To date you have not done so.

You have posted cliché after cliché, please stop avoiding the questions that are directed at you, present your case and start debating.

Or leave, go back to LC, you clearly belong there.
They are masters of abuse but I find it's difficult to be personally rattled when their postings provide so little to respect.

Really? Maybe that is because we are all “bigoted JREFFERS".

Respect is something you earn; it is something you have to work for. It comes with rational and reasonable debate. It comes will well presented ideas and thoughts. It comes with facts and evidence to back up your claims. It does got given by default, it is earned, my friend, to date you have earned none.
They like to take the poorest examples of those in the 9/11 Truth Movement and assume everyone in the movement is like that.
And you are the best LC has to offer? Then it is small wonder you are not taken seriously.
They also assume anyone who is a member here gets up and salutes the LC documentary every morning.
Evidence? Or another childish remark aimed at forum members who you call bigots?

(Why do you use bigot in all your posts? can you not change it now and again? how about big nose of biggusdickus, it just breaks down your repetitivenessnow and again. just hint).
Regardless of how many undotted "i's" skeptics catalogue in the Loose Change documentary, it still carries a message that is true and needs to be heard.
Yes the message is gullible naive idiots buy into it. They spend cash, time and effort on propping up the BS it promotes. They line the pockets of the makers of this movie, who are laughing all the way to the bank and will abandon those guilible enough to do so when there pockets are fully lined.

Now please

present your facts.

What do you think happened on 911?
 
Last edited:
Well if I'm such a disappointent to y'all I such you just ignore me.

I call 'em the way I see 'em.

You folks certainly do the same.

MM
 
Well if I'm such a disappointent to y'all I such you just ignore me.

I call 'em the way I see 'em.

You folks certainly do the same.

MM


MM, Why don't you grow up and just discuss the topics presented. You're the only one calling names and acting like a child. Did you come here to troll or did you come here to debate using logic and critical thinking skills? You've presented no evidence, no hard facts and no content that actually supports your claims. Everyone at this forum wishes only to have rational discussions with each other and with those who do not believe in the official story. Are you here to do the same or are you just here to cause problems and be, yet another, poser of truth?

Those are my questions. Will you answer them...any of them?
 
Well if I'm such a disappointent to y'all I such you just ignore me.

I call 'em the way I see 'em.

You folks certainly do the same.

MM

Now you are just trolling.

You've been asked multiple times to present evidence.
You've been asked multiple times to present your case.
You've ignored the requests.

You may call them the way you see them, but in the real, grown up world, facts are uncovered by research and analysis. Both include all data, not, like you, just the tin hat material. Little children stop at "what they see", grown ups dig deeper.

Why exactly are you here?
Not for debate because you refuse to engage?
Not to learn because you refuse to listen.
Not to educate because you refuse to provide education material.

What is left besides trolling to amuse your immature personality?
 
MM, Why don't you grow up and just discuss the topics presented. You're the only one calling names and acting like a child. Did you come here to troll or did you come here to debate using logic and critical thinking skills? You've presented no evidence, no hard facts and no content that actually supports your claims. Everyone at this forum wishes only to have rational discussions with each other and with those who do not believe in the official story. Are you here to do the same or are you just here to cause problems and be, yet another, poser of truth?

Those are my questions. Will you answer them...any of them?

I dont want to add to the chorous for MM to have to reply (dont bother, just address the main poster/s) but it must be noted that all these guys say they want an honest debate, to learn the truth.

When its supported by science, physics, peer reviewed papers and reaffirmed by thousands and thousands of engineers, enough to change building codes and standards into the future etc, for someone to still say its wrong without any idea why its so and with a failure to acknowledge the level of understanding behind the science involved and claim on their part that they indeed have nothing but speculation is completely against their claims of an honest debate and a desire to learn.

If they did wish to understand they would be humble and admit they are not experts and place trust where its due - the scientific papers on the event. Not some backyard science shown time and again to be nothing but an errored hypothesis.

Unfortunately for MM from his LCF comfort zone - where speculation and innuendo, suspicion and accusation is as good as whats needed to be considered fact or truth - to come here where those same conversations dont survive without a sound mathematical model or verifyable eye witness account to back them up...well it just would plainly suck and be very discouraging.

carry on.

Edit: The belief system is similar to the woo style. People believe in psychics, no matter how much you can show its just crap the people still want to believe it. Religion is the same.
 
Last edited:
Well if I'm such a disappointent to y'all I such you just ignore me.

I call 'em the way I see 'em.

You folks certainly do the same.

MM
They like to take the poorest examples of those in the 9/11 Truth Movement and assume everyone in the movement is like that.
Please give an example or two of who you consider the finest of those in the 9/11 Truth Movement.
 
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/6197454770f47cdff.gif[/qimg]

I thought any suspicious illogical behaviour regarding the events of 9/11 was on topic?

Why were the nation's law enforcement officers (Secret Service) following standard procedure and hustling the VICE PRESIDENT to safety but content to let the PRESIDENT sit exposed in a grade school classroom reading to a bunch of children?

Of course you amazing debunkers, to the man/woman, choose to ignore this in favour of your usual smoke blowing.

MM
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom