MirageMemories: Care to discuss?

Don't worry, I'm sure he'll be along once he gets over his paranoid fantasies about being IP blocked by JREF.
He may be back, but I doubt he will choose to engage in any meaningful debate. At least based on this quote from that thread:
MM@LC said:
I was pushed over the edge and an icy cold chill swept up my spine as I realized it was clearly brought down and was not the kind of collapse that would be expected just due to the influence of gravity. It's hard, if not IMPOSSIBLE to get a symmetrical collapse of that nature without planned intervention.
Note, he offers up (in bold all caps no less), the impossibility of the collapse. No data, no analysis, nothing. Just based on watching it.

Why after all this time am I still surprised when a 9/11 CTists makes such definitive claims without a shred of analysis?
 
Last edited:
Why after all this time am I still surprised when a 9/11 CTists makes such definitive claims without a shred of analysis?

Probably for the same reason I am; I am constantly dumbfounded that anybody can seriously make such broad, sweeping statements about something they know absolutely nothing about.
 
Now, I'd like to discuss this with you, as the logistics of such a plan is the biggest thing that I just can't wrap my mind around. I can't post your work in its entirety, but under fair use, I can post these snippets.

Would you mind starting a new thread with your analysis of the logistics over here? I'd love to hear more of your ideas, and discuss them, but as I've been banned at the LC forum, that's a bit difficult.

Thanks.


How exactly the logistics of the plan to demolish the building were done, we don't know. It is unfair to demand a ready answer. The only way to find out is to have a criminal investigation. We don't have the resources needed for that.

Your point is that such an operation can be excluded a priori?

Hardly, when our suspects include the owner Larry S and Securacom responsible for security for the whole WTC complex, headed by brother and cousin Bush. Including CIA and various intelligence bodies of course.

Access to the buildnings would be no problem whatsoever. They had total control.
 
I use to think..."sure go ahead, give them their new investigation", but now, no way...you know why? Because if we gave you ten investigations, the only way you would accept them is if they confirmed your preheld beliefs. If a new investigation was carried out, lets say by the NYPD, etc...you'd say they were bought off...it doesnt matter.

TAM
 
How exactly the logistics of the plan to demolish the building were done, we don't know. It is unfair to demand a ready answer. The only way to find out is to have a criminal investigation. We don't have the resources needed for that.

Your point is that such an operation can be excluded a priori?

Hardly, when our suspects include the owner Larry S and Securacom responsible for security for the whole WTC complex, headed by brother and cousin Bush. Including CIA and various intelligence bodies of course.

Access to the buildnings would be no problem whatsoever. They had total control.

Who, exactly, should conduct this investigation? What group(s) would be acceptable to the truth movement?
 
How exactly the logistics of the plan to demolish the building were done, we don't know. It is unfair to demand a ready answer. The only way to find out is to have a criminal investigation. We don't have the resources needed for that.


Your point is that such an operation can be excluded a priori?

Yes.
Hardly, when our suspects include the owner Larry S and Securacom responsible for security for the whole WTC complex, headed by brother and cousin Bush. Including CIA and various intelligence bodies of course.

Access to the buildnings would be no problem whatsoever. They had total control.

Evidence?
 
:words:
Hardly, when our suspects include the owner Larry S
:words:
Can you give us the EVIDENCE that makes Larry Silverstein a suspect?

I know he lost billions in the attack, but in the rational world this hardly makes you a suspect. :rolleyes:

So, please provide your EVIDENCE or retract your insinuation.

(It's so tiresome, they always post the same nonsense ...)
 
How exactly the logistics of the plan to demolish the building were done, we don't know. It is unfair to demand a ready answer.
False. The logistics of the 9/11 terrorist attacks are extremely well known including the whereabouts and training of the various hijackers, the routes of the airplanes, times of impact, passenger lists and two flight data recorders. If you intend to produce a viable counter theory, the logistics are required to show how your theory encompasses more of the data than the official government story.
The only way to find out is to have a criminal investigation.
False. The way you intend to determine guilty parties is by questioning people you've declared as suspects without any evidence. You name the CIA and Larry Silverstein along with other federal agencies, and yet you have done nothing to ensure their right to due process has been preserved. You and your cronies would much prefer to go on a witch hunt with the power to subpoena anyone you "suspect" of being involved.
We don't have the resources needed for that.
False. The constitution would not allow you to conduct the type of investigation you would require to prove your point.
Your point is that such an operation can be excluded a priori?
Straw man. His point was that your theory is lacking the evidence to be called a theory.
Hardly, when our suspects include the owner Larry S and Securacom responsible for security for the whole WTC complex, headed by brother and cousin Bush. Including CIA and various intelligence bodies of course.
See my statement above. You intend to call these people into your office and question them on their involvement?
Access to the buildnings would be no problem whatsoever. They had total control.
This statement has no basis in reality. Access to the WTC towers is not an issue. Access to the supporting structure of some of the largest free-standing buildings in the US would require the total removal of office equipment, dividing (non-structural) walls, and electrical equipment. This could not be accomplished in secret by a small group of government agents, no matter how much "access" they had.
 
Well it's nice to see someone finally plugged the JREF Server back in.

It's flattering to see how many posts you folk can generate without requiring any input from moi, especially consider the topic heading is a question directed at me.

I'm not sure what you wish to discuss, and I use that term discuss quite 'loosely' here. Everyone is no doubt standing by to flood response with the usual 'cut & paste' replies.

The posting of mine you were referring to was qualified by myself as speculative from the start.

I made it quite clear I had no evidence, and that I was simply providing what I though was a plausible means of achieving a goal.

Anyway, I can't (unfortunately) hang around much today waiting to respond to the usual high volume of abusive replies. I'm at work, but I will try and check in and reply to anything that is respectful enough to be worthy of a reply.

MM
 
Well it's nice to see someone finally plugged the JREF Server back in.

It's flattering to see how many posts you folk can generate without requiring any input from moi, especially consider the topic heading is a question directed at me.

I'm not sure what you wish to discuss, and I use that term discuss quite 'loosely' here. Everyone is no doubt standing by to flood response with the usual 'cut & paste' replies.

The posting of mine you were referring to was qualified by myself as speculative from the start.

I made it quite clear I had no evidence, and that I was simply providing what I though was a plausible means of achieving a goal.

Anyway, I can't (unfortunately) hang around much today waiting to respond to the usual high volume of abusive replies. I'm at work, but I will try and check in and reply to anything that is respectful enough to be worthy of a reply.

MM

You are not here to tell us anything! You have no facts as does your LCF.

With no facts only a fool would be a CTer pushing lies as you do. Are you still pushing lies?

You are the poorest example of the truth movement! Someone who tells lies.

You are just like the whole truth movement; no facts.

Pick your top Truther and show us who is the top example of the truth movement. Please let us know your top ten truthers of truth! (as you know the LC videos are in total error)
 
Last edited:
Well it's nice to see someone finally plugged the JREF Server back in.

It's flattering to see how many posts you folk can generate without requiring any input from moi, especially consider the topic heading is a question directed at me.

I'm not sure what you wish to discuss, and I use that term discuss quite 'loosely' here. Everyone is no doubt standing by to flood response with the usual 'cut & paste' replies.

The posting of mine you were referring to was qualified by myself as speculative from the start.

I made it quite clear I had no evidence, and that I was simply providing what I though was a plausible means of achieving a goal.

Anyway, I can't (unfortunately) hang around much today waiting to respond to the usual high volume of abusive replies. I'm at work, but I will try and check in and reply to anything that is respectful enough to be worthy of a reply.

MM
Just speaking for myself.

Since you admit you don't have evidence, I have no interest in hearing your wet dreams. Why you choose to "speculate" by accusing innocent people of murder instead of spending time actually trying to find the real truth brings more abuse to yourself then anything anyone here can say.
 
The posting of mine you were referring to was qualified by myself as speculative from the start.

I made it quite clear I had no evidence, and that I was simply providing what I though was a plausible means of achieving a goal.

How do you form opinions without evidence? And why bother discussing speculation anyway?
 
Well it's nice to see someone finally plugged the JREF Server back in.

It's flattering to see how many posts you folk can generate without requiring any input from moi, especially consider the topic heading is a question directed at me.

I'm not sure what you wish to discuss, and I use that term discuss quite 'loosely' here. Everyone is no doubt standing by to flood response with the usual 'cut & paste' replies.

The posting of mine you were referring to was qualified by myself as speculative from the start.

I made it quite clear I had no evidence, and that I was simply providing what I though was a plausible means of achieving a goal.

Anyway, I can't (unfortunately) hang around much today waiting to respond to the usual high volume of abusive replies. I'm at work, but I will try and check in and reply to anything that is respectful enough to be worthy of a reply.

MM

Hi MM,

I'm intrigued to know what convinced you about (your view of) the truth of 9/11. You've said that you were initially happy with government reports of what happened, but then saw 'In Plane Sight' and 'Loose Change'.

Now I'm assuming there was at least one key piece of evidence that caused you to believe the theories in those productions. Because so far, I don't know what that is.

The quote at the top of this thread from you, you've said you don't want to discuss as it's just speculation. Well that's fine, but it can't have just been speculation that made you change your mind in the first place, can it?

I'm hoping you can identify one key, objective point that turned things for you. If it stays in the realm of speculation, 'if you believe', 'you have to conclude somehow', then there's not really anything concrete (no pun intended) to discuss.
 
You are not here to tell us anything! You have no facts as does your LCF.

With no facts only a fool would be a CTer pushing lies as you do. Are you still pushing lies?

You are the poorest example of the truth movement! Someone who tells lies.

You are just like the whole truth movement; no facts.

Pick your top Truther and show us who is the top example of the truth movement. Please let us know your top ten truthers of truth! (as you know the LC videos are in total error)

Yawn!

Do you use a random word generator for your posts?

Absolutely no content to reply to.

I guess the content is reflective of it's source.

MM
 
Just speaking for myself.

Since you admit you don't have evidence, I have no interest in hearing your wet dreams. Why you choose to "speculate" by accusing innocent people of murder instead of spending time actually trying to find the real truth brings more abuse to yourself then anything anyone here can say.

For yourself or about yourself?

Thank you for your wet dream.

You must really value running up your post count.

MM
 
Hi MM,

I'm intrigued to know what convinced you about (your view of) the truth of 9/11. You've said that you were initially happy with government reports of what happened, but then saw 'In Plane Sight' and 'Loose Change'.

Now I'm assuming there was at least one key piece of evidence that caused you to believe the theories in those productions. Because so far, I don't know what that is.

The quote at the top of this thread from you, you've said you don't want to discuss as it's just speculation. Well that's fine, but it can't have just been speculation that made you change your mind in the first place, can it?

I'm hoping you can identify one key, objective point that turned things for you. If it stays in the realm of speculation, 'if you believe', 'you have to conclude somehow', then there's not really anything concrete (no pun intended) to discuss.

What key piece of evidence?

WTC7 and yes I've already ready the Gravy report and waded through the million page thread on the subject here. I also noted how anyone not in the Official Story camp is treated.

MM
 
Yawn!

Do you use a random word generator for your posts?

Absolutely no content to reply to.

I guess the content is reflective of it's source.

MM

Which fake business planted the bombs we never heard at the WTC?

Come on and lets us hear the facts; You are just talk. What is your new theory?

I must ask if use the same to generate your stories?
 
MM - you recently said at LC :

Miragememories said:
They are masters of abuse but I find it's difficult to be personally rattled when their postings provide so little to respect.

They like to take the poorest examples of those in the 9/11 Truth Movement and assume everyone in the movement is like that.

They also assume anyone who is a member here gets up and salutes the LC documentary every morning.

I see this meeting place as the Loose Change 9/11 Truth Movement Forums. I don't see it as the 9/11 Loose Change Video Forums.

Regardless of how many undotted "i's" skeptics catalogue in the Loose Change documentary, it still carries a message that is true and needs to be heard.

Would you put our feelings about LC's theory on the fate of Flight 93 into the class of "dotting an i" ?

"Dotting i's and crossing t's" is trivial tidying up. Is that how you see critiques of LC?
 
The Almond said:
If you intend to produce a viable counter theory, the logistics are required to show how your theory encompasses more of the data than the official government story.

This is one of the points I was trying to bring up over at the LC boards when I got banned abruptly. The scientific way to go about an investigation means that you discard theories that don't fit the evidence as well as another that does. Someone responded that I meant "discard the peices of evidence which do not fit their desired result?" As you can see, that is the opposite of what I am saying, but I think it might be a good insight into the mind of your averagee CT enthusiast, and how they differ from a true skeptic:

Skeptics change or discard theories that don't fit the evidence.
Conspiracy Theorists change or discard the evidence that doesn't fit the theory.
 
I motion to re-institute the IP ban on miragememories.

http://z10.invisionfree.com/Loose_Change_Forum/index.php?showtopic=2900


miragememories said:
Hope I'm not just getting paranoid?

You mean when you make a thread titled that you've been IP-blocked from the forum?

I think it's fairly a concise example of what happens when paranoid people are faced with a situation they cannot adequately explain. They jump to conclusions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom