Michelle Duggar of "19 Kids and Counting" Doesn't Believe in Overpopulation

As a former foster parent I feel the need to make a plug here. If someone really wants to have lots of children or just enjoys raising children, there are lots of great kids out there in need of good homes and loving parents. There's no need to keep making your own.

My mom fosters, my wife and I have our own child.

I dislike the meme that people should avoid having their own children as it is selfish, and should instead take in, what are essentially, the cast-offs of other people.

People that foster are GREAT people, and those poor kids need homes, I guess it's just the insinuation that people who want kids should pick up the slack of terrible parents.

It reminds me of the good hearted folks who kill themselves taking in unwanted pets, while backyard breeders crank out new dogs at insane rates. The problem is at source.

To try and be clear, good parents having their own kids is only seen as a problem because so many bad parents crank them out.
 
Her mouth joins her vagina as another orifice which should not be a clown car.
 
I once saw an interview with Michelle Duggar in which she was asked why they decided to have so many kids. She said that god keeps blessing them with children. I got the feeling that those two haven't figured out where babies come from.

Steve S
 
You have seriously oversimplified the problem of overpopulation. Actually you have simplified the relationship between the size of the population and the use of resources.

First of all overpopulation is overpopulation. It does not matter if it is caused by an increase in birth rates or a decrease in death rates. Yes, the aging of the population will require a different allocation of resources than an increase in birth rate will. In the end the situation is the same: we exceed the resources available.

You are also making a fundamental error in assuming that each person consumes the same amount of resources. This is incorrect. For example, a child born in a developed country will use significantly more resources than a child born in a developing country.

In other words, if the birth rate in developed countries increased it would lead to a dramatic increase in the use of resources.

You are also neglecting to account for environmental factors. Specifically, as temperatures rise there is en expectation that crop yields will decline.

And as far as I am aware the latest projections do not show a leveling out of the population by 2030. Here is a link to a UN report from May 2011. The world population is expected to reach 10 billion by 2100. Read the report for the particulars.

As a former foster parent I feel the need to make a plug here. If someone really wants to have lots of children or just enjoys raising children, there are lots of great kids out there in need of good homes and loving parents. There's no need to keep making your own.

:clap:

I once saw an interview with Michelle Duggar in which she was asked why they decided to have so many kids. She said that god keeps blessing them with children. I got the feeling that those two haven't figured out where babies come from.

Of course they do... God. And this "shot" at a quivver full was God telling them they weren't pius or sanctimonious enough, ergo her comments about overpopulation. Surely it couldn't have been her nearly prolapsed uterus screaming "No Mas!".
 
I once saw an interview with Michelle Duggar in which she was asked why they decided to have so many kids. She said that god keeps blessing them with children. I got the feeling that those two haven't figured out where babies come from.

Steve S
Yeah, medical science sort of knows what causes babies.
 
My mom fosters, my wife and I have our own child.

I dislike the meme that people should avoid having their own children as it is selfish, and should instead take in, what are essentially, the cast-offs of other people.

People that foster are GREAT people, and those poor kids need homes, I guess it's just the insinuation that people who want kids should pick up the slack of terrible parents.

It reminds me of the good hearted folks who kill themselves taking in unwanted pets, while backyard breeders crank out new dogs at insane rates. The problem is at source.

To try and be clear, good parents having their own kids is only seen as a problem because so many bad parents crank them out.

Sure, and foster parenting is really not for everyone. I can't count the number of times I've been kicked in the fork by angry kids. I would also never suggest (nor would many agencies allow) taking in 19 children.
 
18 inches per person gives me about 2 million miles for 7 billion people shoulder to shoulder.


There are good reasons for increasing population in a context of an economically free people, but being thrifty isn't it.

Your math is right, but she's talking about area, not linear distance.

Area of person = 18in x 18in = 324 sq.in = 8.07e-8 sq. miles
Total area = 7,000,000,000 x 8.07e-8 = 564 sq. miles.

It's kind of a silly metric, but true. That many people could fit into Jacksonville. I'm pretty sure it would displease the fire marshal, however.
 
<snip>
By the way, I am doing my part: no kids and keeping it that way. :D

Lowering the average intelligence of the population is smart? :D

Just kidding, I don't have children either. I figure the more productive they are the more likely they are to wind up slaves to the parasites.
 
So we have more kids to take care of aging parents who are living longer, and they'll have to have even more kids to take care of them, who will have... Ever heard of a Ponzi scheme?

A realistic solution is more automation: it would enable most old people to take care of themselves.

If you were a smart robot would you want to spend your time wiping drool off the chins of old people? :D

A better solution would be to clone young bodies for the elderly so they could work and pay for their own care. :)
 
Ms Duggar may be motivated to counteract various and sundry abortions, thinking that she needs to "balance the scales."

Or, she may like screwing now and again, but enjoy child raising a lot.

I expect her husband has strong wrists.
 
I like the choice of Jacksonville, which people think of as a small city. It is small by population, but the area is huge, 880 or so square miles. It is the largest city in the US by area. The city limits start way out from downtown, where there's nothing but farms.

Yeah, I live near Jacksonville. On the interstate, you hit the city limit sign and know that you only have an hour to go before you reach the city.
 
I like the choice of Jacksonville, which people think of as a small city. It is small by population, but the area is huge, 880 or so square miles. It is the largest city in the US by area. The city limits start way out from downtown, where there's nothing but farms.

I guess I'm being pedantic. Sitka, AK is 2,870 sq miles with a population of 10,323. Its in the US, just not in the lower 48.
 
I think it's peculiar that it's news worthy for a woman who is famous precisely for her radical actions and views around the concept of overpopulation to be saying something about overpopulation.

I guess if she was a hypocrite it would be worth reporting, but it seems like we've just learned water is still wet here.

Maybe it's just fun to see her pretending it's an issue that even concerns her.
 
In the end she will have lots of her genes carrying on. In nature isn't that what it's all about?
 
I guess I'm being pedantic. Sitka, AK is 2,870 sq miles with a population of 10,323. Its in the US, just not in the lower 48.

Even better then: "The entire population of the world could fit within Sitka, AK, population 10,323, even if everyone had a pony."
 
"if they were stretched shoulder to shoulder, could fit within the city limits of Jacksonville"

This claim with some variation, has been around since at least the 80s... when the world population was around 4 billion.

Clearly she's also too stupid to understand that God only provided us with so much arable land, so much land we could live on, so much potable water, etc. etc.

What an idiot. I feel sorry for those kids when they get out in the real world.

I feel sorry for the rest of us who have to live in the same world as them after being raised by this weirdo. Every time I hear of this woman I feel like vomiting. Nineteen babies? One woman? <Shudders>

Are humans de-evolving? Something I wonder about. It seems these days that intelligent people, on average, have far fewer kids than the dummies. Are we the only species violating Darwin by helping the weak? Dangerous thought maybe, but hey, it's a skeptic site.

Gonna take a shower now.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom