Michelle Duggar of "19 Kids and Counting" Doesn't Believe in Overpopulation

Mark R

Thinker
Joined
Jun 26, 2010
Messages
127
”Well, first off, the idea of overpopulation is not accurate because really the entire population of the world, if they were stretched shoulder to shoulder, could fit within the city limits of Jacksonville,” Duggar said.

Link

You really would have to be this stupid to have so many kids. As the article clarifies, and as anyone who every paid attention to a high school economics class should know, the real issue of overpopulation is the availability of resources to sustain a population.

Obviously she has never heard of scarcity either.

Still, Duggar believes she and her family are resourceful when it comes to buying and discarding. “What our family does is that our motto is we buy used and we save the difference. We go to the thrift store. We buy used cars.”

Evidently being cheap will solve overpopulation. Dam all these science people for complicating such a simple issue.

If you really want to bang your head, watch the video of the interview (if your dare). She really seems to think she is so smart it is comical.

By the way, I am doing my part: no kids and keeping it that way. :D
 
The biggest population time bomb is the aging of most of Europe and even much of Asia (including China) due to low birth rates. Why is China easing it's one child policy? Hmmm...
 
I forgot to mention another favorite part:

"To say that there are too many children is like saying there are too many flowers,” Duggar said, quoting the late Mother Teresa. “Our world needs more joy.”


She might rethink this quote where she to understand Mother Teresa's emphasis on the importance of suffering to achieve salvation.

Though, maybe not.
 
Dear Michelle,

You are an ignorant bitch. All the best.

RandFan.
 
"if they were stretched shoulder to shoulder, could fit within the city limits of Jacksonville"

This claim with some variation, has been around since at least the 80s... when the world population was around 4 billion.

Clearly she's also too stupid to understand that God only provided us with so much arable land, so much land we could live on, so much potable water, etc. etc.

What an idiot. I feel sorry for those kids when they get out in the real world.
 
Sorry to rain on the parade, but projections have the world population peaking as early as 2030, with most of the growth happening in Africa. When that continent starts to drag itself out of the mire, stops tribalism and starts benefitting from its massive amount of minerals, peak population could come earlier. What then? Do we want the whole world to end up full of geriatrics as Japan will shortly be?
 
Last edited:
18 inches per person gives me about 2 million miles for 7 billion people shoulder to shoulder.


There are good reasons for increasing population in a context of an economically free people, but being thrifty isn't it.

I think she also meant heel to toe. Which would kill billions of people if any of them leaned inward at all. Lethal human dominoes.

Slightly related, and a bit gross, my high school math teacher determined that the entire human population of the world could fit in one tenth of a cubic mile if everyone was ground into a paste.
 
Sorry to rain on the parade, but projections have the world population peaking as early as 2030, with most of the growth happening in Africa. When that continent starts to drag itself out of the mire, stops tribalism and starts benefitting from its massive amount of minerals, peak population could come earlier. What then? Do we want the whole world to end up full of geriatrics as Japan will shortly be?

I think we are all aware that the population in a number of countries is aging. I am not exactly sure what point you are making in context of the topic.

Also, what is a solution to the unprecedented aging of the population? Ensure equilibrium though some Logan's Run inspired methodology?

I do not think having more kids is the solution.
 
My point is that overpopulation is not a long term problem, and having more children is exactly what's required to ease the problems of an ageing population. All this "have a look at me, I've got no kids, aren't I great"? Crap.
 
How could over population not be a long term problem?
If the population continues to grow, it will, long term, reach a level which cannot be sustained.
Resources are finite.
 
Not if it peaks soon.

I don't understand what this means.
Over population is not a peak, it is overpopulation, that is more than the available resources can support.
If the population peaks before it reaches that point, it is by definition not over population
 
My point is that overpopulation is not a long term problem, and having more children is exactly what's required to ease the problems of an ageing population. All this "have a look at me, I've got no kids, aren't I great"? Crap.

So we have more kids to take care of aging parents who are living longer, and they'll have to have even more kids to take care of them, who will have... Ever heard of a Ponzi scheme?

A realistic solution is more automation: it would enable most old people to take care of themselves.
 
Kerikiwi,

Well that's the point I'm trying to make. I believe that the world is a better place now than any "golden age" anyone wants to point to, and have no reason to believe that this will change before the peak is reached. Personally I'm more worried about a falling world population, which is on the cards.
 
So we have more kids to take care of aging parents who are living longer, and they'll have to have even more kids to take care of them, who will have... Ever heard of a Ponzi scheme?

A realistic solution is more automation: it would enable most old people to take care of themselves.

Oh for goodness sake, if I could magically make the world population stay as it is now, I would. But I would also organise things so that birth rates were at replacement rates. What I see is population peaking, and then falling.

Not a Ponzi scheme at all.
 
I like the choice of Jacksonville, which people think of as a small city. It is small by population, but the area is huge, 880 or so square miles. It is the largest city in the US by area. The city limits start way out from downtown, where there's nothing but farms.
 
My point is that overpopulation is not a long term problem, and having more children is exactly what's required to ease the problems of an ageing population. All this "have a look at me, I've got no kids, aren't I great"? Crap.

You have seriously oversimplified the problem of overpopulation. Actually you have simplified the relationship between the size of the population and the use of resources.

First of all overpopulation is overpopulation. It does not matter if it is caused by an increase in birth rates or a decrease in death rates. Yes, the aging of the population will require a different allocation of resources than an increase in birth rate will. In the end the situation is the same: we exceed the resources available.

You are also making a fundamental error in assuming that each person consumes the same amount of resources. This is incorrect. For example, a child born in a developed country will use significantly more resources than a child born in a developing country.

In other words, if the birth rate in developed countries increased it would lead to a dramatic increase in the use of resources.

You are also neglecting to account for environmental factors. Specifically, as temperatures rise there is en expectation that crop yields will decline.

And as far as I am aware the latest projections do not show a leveling out of the population by 2030. Here is a link to a UN report from May 2011. The world population is expected to reach 10 billion by 2100. Read the report for the particulars.
 
As a former foster parent I feel the need to make a plug here. If someone really wants to have lots of children or just enjoys raising children, there are lots of great kids out there in need of good homes and loving parents. There's no need to keep making your own.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom