My diagrams above is based on Patricio's transcript, and it resembles Franz's transcript pretty well (notice the timestamps on the first object). The aircrew - at least - believed that this object was the same all along, but they we're at the same time in doubt about the radars capability.Originally posted by wipeout
I was referring to my original speculation that any strange radar readings could be explained if the radar was simply going wrong in some way.
That was before I knew there were no radar readings for main group of objects.
What is new to me is that this is wrong -- there were radar readings after all in the direction of the oil-platforms, just very ambiguous ones, so Captain Franz's translation shows there were more early radar objects than just the first object:
That is what is illustrated in my diagram.
I think a few things is worth noticing here:
a) They don't seem to trust the radar very much.
b) There is confusion concerning who-is-who (radar operator / camera operator / pilot / ground control) in all the transcripts I have seen. I guess it's hard to make out the voices 100%?
c) Who has access to what? They seem to have access to eachothers screens. Or do the pilot use his own radar?
Under all circumstances, we're but left with speculations, and this is why I don't really find the radar signals stated in the transcripts usefull for measures.
I'm not gonna contact Telephonics, because I'm quite frankly bored with this case by now. I'm on standby untill thorough experiments has been conducted - enough speculations and calculations already.
I guess you're right. Hazy statements can often lead to hazy interpretations
I assumed Alex meant UFO skeptics and scientists who got involved after seeing the oil-flare theory being attacked by Maussan on TV in the last couple of weeks and might be able to help counter the attack through their TV and other media contacts.
...