Meteor over Moscow

Well, the boom would have been hard to sleep through. But, wake up call for what, exactly?

Asteroid defense I reckon. But after Wall Street had to close due to being underwater we still have ****-all but lip service being paid to global warming, so until an actual city gets obliterated...probably not.
 
Originally Posted by macdoc
The youtube one shows a serious big meteor
I see nothing in any of the video that allows you to make any pronouncement of its size or distance.

Remember I can block out the entire sun by holding my hand up, but my hand and the sun are nowhere near the same size. One is simply much nearer than the other.

You may not understand but I do. I've seen other sizeable meteors including a huge ( as meteors go ) earth grazer and I understand the mechanics of bollides reasonably well. I hit the major meteor showers several times a year and have seen numerous fireballs.

Size is relative to others in it's class of objects and most meteors are much much smalle. That was a big enough to do significant damage as was the actual case and big enough to land and punch a hole in a frozen lake AFTER it busted up.
I''ll stand by the statement.

Your statement about your relative distance from an object is just nonsense.
The relative size against a spectrum of meteors is determined by the nature of it's passage including the shock wave. How do you think the tonnage is being assessed?
 
Last edited:
The body is estimated to have 15 meters, weighing roughly 8 tons. The resulting airburst would have the equivalent yield of a 1-10 megaton explosion. Note that these are very rough and extremely preliminary estimates.

Early reports suggest that substantial fragments made it to the ground after the airburst, suggesting that this was an iron-nickel asteroid, rather than a stony asteroid or comet (no fragments were ever found from Tunguska). A much more quantitative estimate will come from analysis of the videos, the damage distribution, and the seismic reports. The timing of the shock wave, and the verbal and video reports, are consistent with verbal reports of the Tunguska event in 1908.

What We Know About the Russian Meteor Event
 
Last edited:
I would like to see the face of the guy who owns a glass shop in that area.
 
This one, "The shock wave sound somewhere near Chelyabinsk", from the first link gives a more clear sound of all the after-booms. They go on for really a long time.

This is what leads me to believe that doubts about it having broken up are misplaced. There are many smaller booms, which is what you would expect from a number of fragments traveling super-or-hyper sonically. If these sounds were simply echoes from the surrounding countryside, I would expect them to smear out and not be the distinct "cracks" that we hear, instead sounding more like rolling thunder.
 
Now it is 500 kilotons. It still makes no sense.

First, 1 kiloton is 4.2 * 1012 Joules. 500 kilotons is 2.1 * 1015 J. So to have kinetic energy of 500 kilotons, an 8 ton object would have to move at sqrt[2 * 2.1 * 1015 J / 8000 kg] = 725,000 m/sec. Which is not possible.

Second, a 15 meter nickel-iron body should mass much more than 8 tons. 8 tons is one cubic meter of iron; 15 meter body should be about 3000 tons. Plugging 3000 tons into above formula instead of 8 tons gives 37,000 m/sec - much more reasonable velocity for a meteorite.

So I think "8 tons" is the incorrect part.
 
Well we only had one sharp boom from our meteor which did break up.
 
Now it is 500 kilotons. It still makes no sense.

First, 1 kiloton is 4.2 * 1012 Joules. 500 kilotons is 2.1 * 1015 J. So to have kinetic energy of 500 kilotons, an 8 ton object would have to move at sqrt[2 * 2.1 * 1015 J / 8000 kg] = 725,000 m/sec. Which is not possible.

The figure I've seen is around 3.5 kT.
 
This is what leads me to believe that doubts about it having broken up are misplaced. There are many smaller booms, which is what you would expect from a number of fragments traveling super-or-hyper sonically. If these sounds were simply echoes from the surrounding countryside, I would expect them to smear out and not be the distinct "cracks" that we hear, instead sounding more like rolling thunder.
It behaved exactly as one would predict a meteorite would, exploding above the ground.
 
Now it is 500 kilotons. It still makes no sense.

First, 1 kiloton is 4.2 * 1012 Joules. 500 kilotons is 2.1 * 1015 J. So to have kinetic energy of 500 kilotons, an 8 ton object would have to move at sqrt[2 * 2.1 * 1015 J / 8000 kg] = 725,000 m/sec. Which is not possible.

Second, a 15 meter nickel-iron body should mass much more than 8 tons. 8 tons is one cubic meter of iron; 15 meter body should be about 3000 tons. Plugging 3000 tons into above formula instead of 8 tons gives 37,000 m/sec - much more reasonable velocity for a meteorite.

So I think "8 tons" is the incorrect part.
Nickel Irons tend to reach the ground with parts ablated (like dripping off) off but they don't explode as easily as other meteorite types. Not saying they never explode, but I think they are a lot more sturdy. Meteor Crater AZ was caused by a nickel-iron that disintegrated on impact but it wasn't an air burst.
 
So I think "8 tons" is the incorrect part.

I agree. 15m and 8 tons is completely inconsistent
perhaps they meant 8,000 ton? this would give a density of about 5 g/cm^3, and for a velocity of 15-20km/s, an energy equivalent to 130-250kT of TNT, or around an order of magnitude greater than a Hiroshima Bomb!
 
Nickel Irons tend to reach the ground with parts ablated (like dripping off) off but they don't explode as easily as other meteorite types. Not saying they never explode, but I think they are a lot more sturdy. Meteor Crater AZ was caused by a nickel-iron that disintegrated on impact but it wasn't an air burst.

Are we sure it was a nickel-iron?

ETA: The Russian one, I mean.
 
Last edited:
I agree, but there seems to now be a fair amount of public doubt about an explosion. I don't think the doubt is consistent with the aural evidence.

I disagree. I would say the sound is consistent with multiple objects creating multiple shockwaves; but the meteor breaking up and the meteor "exploding" are two different things. Photos of the smoke/vapor trail show a very consistent and smooth flight path, not punctuated by any large "explosion" traces.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom