jay howard has no valid points. My last post on Page 7 remains completely unaddressed by him. In summary:
1. The NIST report is falsifiable, as described here over several pages
All that would be required to back this up is to add into the reply to this, WHAT criteria would falsify the NIST report.
Please keep in mind that falsifiability, as it has been explained since the OP, is not a relative quality: a theory either has it or it doesn't. To be a "good" theory, it must be falsifiable but not false. That is, there must exist some real criteria by which it COULD be false, but tests to demonstrate that criteria have failed, and thus, we have a "good" explanation for some phenomenon.
I'm sure you can see that no one, through these 12 pages or so, has been either able or willing to lay out what these criteria might be. It is my contention that they either do not exist (in which case the theory is non-falsifiable, and hence useless) or they are completely contingent on simulated data.
If they depend entirely on simulated data, and I find data in the simulations that is unrepresentative (by NIST's own admission) of the conditions in the towers
that is used to corroborate their own theory, then why is that not a "valid point"?
2. The UL intact-truss testing has no direct bearing on the collapse model
Then has NIST ever tested its theory in the real world? No.
But this doesn't seem to bother you. If I made up a theory for how the towers could not have fallen from the planes and subsequent fires, and
all I have to make my case are computer simulations, have I made a "good" case?
Likely you would say 'no.' Yet, when the official case is made from the same structure, you apparently have no trouble standing behind its conclusions. Why? Appealing to a theory based on simulations alone is not a good idea--regardless of the conclusions reached. We should be able to test the theory and confirm it or eliminate it. Why is that an unacceptable process in this case but not for competing theories?
3. He has conflated observations on the recovered steel to represent NIST's estimate of the entire volume of structural steel
My criticism is that they didn't use the recovered steel as a baseline for their estimates. Instead, they made up more severe cases based on no recovered evidence and categorized the recovered steel as uncharacteristic of the fires they theorize brought the towers down.
Structurally, there is a problem with giving the simulated data priority over the physical data.
Again, if you think I'm applying some kind of unfair standard here, imagine that I was making the opposite case with an argument that labeled the forensic evidence "uncharacteristic of the fires" in order to make the case, then I appealed entirely to a simulation. You would likely have a problem with that, right?
4. He did not, but may finally, understand that the WPI paper -- concerning only a single piece of steel from the Towers -- shows that the steel never even approached melting temperature
There were at least 2 pieces of steel in question: one from building 7 and one from either building 1 or 2.
The temperature is a concern, but not the primary concern for the steel in question. How did a eutectic reaction take place? One way or another, we must explain "high temperature corrosion and sulfidation" of the steel.
That is an issue that no official theory is willing or capable of explaining with any testability. (I haven't gone over Dr. Greening's work on this yet--mostly because I can't seem to find it. If anyone has a link, please post it.)
Any way you slice it, my original claim, that the NIST theory is inadequate to deal with this evidence, stands without challenge.
Basically all he's doing now is saying "nuh-uh." That's not useful. You'll also note that he declined to respond to my question of where he's copying his information from. Once in a while he still sticks in a tell-tale footnote, and those notes aren't from NIST.
I'm not sure why you're saying this. If anyone doubts that I'm in fact drawing from the NIST report, take a bit of a quote and use your document search feature to find it. If it doesn't turn up after that, then let me know.