Well, I'm back, and this thread sure went to the dogs...
jay howard has no valid points. My last post on Page 7 remains completely unaddressed by him. In summary:
- The NIST report is falsifiable, as described here over several pages
- The UL intact-truss testing has no direct bearing on the collapse model
- He has conflated observations on the recovered steel to represent NIST's estimate of the entire volume of structural steel
- He did not, but may finally, understand that the WPI paper -- concerning only a single piece of steel from the Towers -- shows that the steel never even approached melting temperature
Basically all he's doing now is saying
"nuh-uh." That's not useful. You'll also note that he declined to respond to my question of where he's copying his information from. Once in a while he still sticks in a tell-tale footnote, and those notes aren't from NIST. I'm guessing he's got an old copy of a Griffin paper, but they don't match anything I have. Until we get past these basic errors of
fact, there is little point trying to draw inference from them, and I have nothing further to say until
jay corrects his mistakes.
Anyway, regarding the Ove Arup paper, this is one of the few legitimate criticisms of the NIST report in existence. I wholeheartedly agree that it has the potential to be the "best" theory, and would falsify the NIST report if found to be true. However, I question its accuracy.
If we put any stock in the NIST fire and structural heat transfer models, they predict burnout on the impact floors after about two hours. Had there been no fireproofing damage, given what we saw in the truss tests, the maximum temperature in the floor elements would be expected to peak at under 500
oC and lead to deflections within the normal range of elasticity, thus the thermal expansion
and subsequent contraction would not materially increase the strain energy in the support columns. The NIST models may be wrong, but this would not be a simple mistake, and we need much more evidence to draw such a conclusion.
If we assume no impact damage at all, i.e. no broken windows and the fire ventilated mainly by stack effect, then we can expect an even cooler if longer-duration fire. This is not, of course, what the Arup paper proposes, but we need to be clear what we mean when we say "no impact damage."
It's definitely worth comparing the two side-by-side. I still put more stock in the NIST result, but if you want to criticize NIST, this is the way to do it. Dr. Usmani has done his homework, as few others have.