Metatheory and the NIST report

There's a lot of unrelated noise here about moon landings, unnecessary personal attacks and the like. Examples are often useful to illustrate a point, but this is not the thread for moon conspiracies.

This thread was started to deliberate the theoretical adequacy of the NIST report, the structure of their argument and its ability to deal with evidence.

Most have been consistent to keep their posts on topic, but it's starting to take a turn towards irrelevancy.

Unless your purpose is to derail the conversation, i ask that you try to keep the thread as focused as possible so that we can have some useful disagreements (instead of the irrelevant bridge-club chatter about who's qualified and who's crazy.)

With appreciation,

jh
lol, i will die of old age before you reveal your Jones junk, just do it and get out the thermite and thermate Jones made up in 2005 out of the blue.
 
I was interested in this thread at one point but I was under the impression that all the meta-theory issues had already been put to bed. For instance, the falsifiability notion from early on. It was fairly trivial to demonstrate that the NIST theory was falsifiable.
 
I was interested in this thread at one point but I was under the impression that all the meta-theory issues had already been put to bed. For instance, the falsifiability notion from early on. It was fairly trivial to demonstrate that the NIST theory was falsifiable.

Rather than "put to bed," it seems these issues have been glossed over.

The falsifiability criteria was never demonstrated to exist. Having shown that the NIST floor truss failure models were based on conditions that NIST admits were not representative of the conditions in the towers, we just skipped right over to another subject.

My argument that the floor truss lab tests satisfied a test of the NIST theory were again, rebutted not with a counterargument, but a simple bare assertion.

When presented with evidence that NIST ignored its own estimations in order to produce a simulated collapse, no counterargument came forward--just a quick move onto the next subject, and some conjecture about when I'm going to say the word "thermite".

The latest failure of the report is in its inability to deal with evidence: namely the WPI steel and the ferrous microspheres found by the USGS. It's clear that the NIST theory is unable to deal with the existence of this evidence. It's clear that this evidence cannot be ignored. But the answer the "skeptics" here employ is that these phenomena are easily explained by some passing reference to human blood or that diesel or wallboard is the likely source of sulfur without a shred of argumentation to back up such a claim. At best, some say "look it up on your own, then come back to me." As if that constituted an argument.

If a twoofer were to put forth such a claim, he would be (justifiably) laughed off this site. However, if you hold the right set of beliefs, no one will say anything about your ridiculous articles of faith.

So, to say the falsifiability criteria, or any of the others in the OP have been "put to bed" in regard to the NIST report is to do some wishful reading.
 
Rather than "put to bed," it seems these issues have been glossed over.

The falsifiability criteria was never demonstrated to exist. Having shown that the NIST floor truss failure models were based on conditions that NIST admits were not representative of the conditions in the towers, we just skipped right over to another subject.

My argument that the floor truss lab tests satisfied a test of the NIST theory were again, rebutted not with a counterargument, but a simple bare assertion.

When presented with evidence that NIST ignored its own estimations in order to produce a simulated collapse, no counterargument came forward--just a quick move onto the next subject, and some conjecture about when I'm going to say the word "thermite".

The latest failure of the report is in its inability to deal with evidence: namely the WPI steel and the ferrous microspheres found by the USGS. It's clear that the NIST theory is unable to deal with the existence of this evidence. It's clear that this evidence cannot be ignored. But the answer the "skeptics" here employ is that these phenomena are easily explained by some passing reference to human blood or that diesel or wallboard is the likely source of sulfur without a shred of argumentation to back up such a claim. At best, some say "look it up on your own, then come back to me." As if that constituted an argument.

If a twoofer were to put forth such a claim, he would be (justifiably) laughed off this site. However, if you hold the right set of beliefs, no one will say anything about your ridiculous articles of faith.

So, to say the falsifiability criteria, or any of the others in the OP have been "put to bed" in regard to the NIST report is to do some wishful reading.
You do not even understand your own criteria you set up. You are so far totally unprepared to do what the OP said. You are clearly a Jones thermite person, you are just too obtuse to get to the point.

Plus you quibble over the falsifiability, which is so easy to prove for NIST. (easy to prove, and since you are not able to make that connection you are unable to live up to your own OP, which is kind of like fraud) That makes you unable to do what you promised in the OP. If you are going to quibble about the easy stuff you are not really living up to the OP.

Either you do not understand the concepts you stated in the OP, or you lifted the OP and posted it, not knowing what you were doing. Or you worked hard on the OP trying to be all scholarly, and you fail to understand how to apply the concepts anyway.
 
Last edited:
Rather than "put to bed," it seems these issues have been glossed over.

The falsifiability criteria was never demonstrated to exist. Having shown that the NIST floor truss failure models were based on conditions that NIST admits were not representative of the conditions in the towers, we just skipped right over to another subject.

My argument that the floor truss lab tests satisfied a test of the NIST theory were again, rebutted not with a counterargument, but a simple bare assertion.

When presented with evidence that NIST ignored its own estimations in order to produce a simulated collapse, no counterargument came forward--just a quick move onto the next subject, and some conjecture about when I'm going to say the word "thermite".

The latest failure of the report is in its inability to deal with evidence: namely the WPI steel and the ferrous microspheres found by the USGS. It's clear that the NIST theory is unable to deal with the existence of this evidence. It's clear that this evidence cannot be ignored. But the answer the "skeptics" here employ is that these phenomena are easily explained by some passing reference to human blood or that diesel or wallboard is the likely source of sulfur without a shred of argumentation to back up such a claim. At best, some say "look it up on your own, then come back to me." As if that constituted an argument.

If a twoofer were to put forth such a claim, he would be (justifiably) laughed off this site. However, if you hold the right set of beliefs, no one will say anything about your ridiculous articles of faith.

So, to say the falsifiability criteria, or any of the others in the OP have been "put to bed" in regard to the NIST report is to do some wishful reading.

The Underwriters Laboratories tests did not satisfy a test of the NIST theory. The NIST theory requires the stripping of fireproofing as a critical condition, without which, collapse would not occur, the UL tests were done on assemblies with fireproofing. From this alone, and without pointing out other differences between the assemblies in the test and the assemblies in the WTC, I hope we can agree that the UL tests did not constitute a test of the NIST theory.

As for the WPI steel and the microsperules, I agree the explanations coming from anywhere are extremely weak, and further study is needed to fully explain these phenomena.
 
You do not even understand your own criteria you set up. You are so far totally unprepared to do what the OP said. You are clearly a Jones thermite person, you are just too obtuse to get to the point.

Plus you quibble over the falsifiability, which is so easy to prove for NIST. (easy to prove, and since you are not able to make that connection you are unable to live up to your own OP, which is kind of like fraud) That makes you unable to do what you promised in the OP. If you are going to quibble about the easy stuff you are not really living up to the OP.

Either you do not understand the concepts you stated in the OP, or you lifted the OP and posted it, not knowing what you were doing. Or you worked hard on the OP trying to be all scholarly, and you fail to understand how to apply the concepts anyway.

Beachnut, I seem to notice a pattern in your posts, I really hope all 4400 of them aren't this pointless.
 
Beachnut, I seem to notice a pattern in your posts, I really hope all 4400 of them aren't this pointless.
I was just saying, we have a person who throws up the smoke screen of the OP, so he can eventually present Jones theory of thermite. I am only a lowly engineer, a former USAF pilot, and after my masters program I worked in a lab at WPAFB. At the lab it was easy to spot BS like the OP as a smoke screen. If you can not see Jay is not really living up to the OP then check out his inability to agree the NIST theory meets the criteria of falsifiability. I may not be getting though, I am not the best writer, but it is clear to me he already believes in Jones's work, so why the smoke screen. He thinks he can be cute and prove with the criteria of the OP that NIST is not making it, and will show Jones's work does. He has failed already as he quibbles over NIST meeting criteria he pushed, and a kid in the 5th grade can show. Where do you think the little spheres junk comes from, if not Jones? I will leave you to waste time with someone who will not change his conclusion which he is not able to defend in the light of day.

I my lab he would be producing, or gone. None of this tap dancing stuff. Fraud comes in many guises, and this is the most despicable, hiding behind the screen of intelligent debate. Jones's work is fraud. You can waste time debating it and be fooled as it is packaged as in the OP. But when someone who sets up the OP quibbles over the easiest criteria to prove, then you have fraud in presentation. 12 pages of posts and he is still unable to agree on the simple stuff. Just ask him to roll out the real agenda. I guess being in charge an having to produce makes you want to cut to end in a timely fashion and stop the BS.

I know, another worthless post, 4400 worthless posts. I have a perfect record then.
 
You do not even understand your own criteria you set up. You are so far totally unprepared to do what the OP said. You are clearly a Jones thermite person, you are just too obtuse to get to the point.

Plus you quibble over the falsifiability, which is so easy to prove for NIST. (easy to prove, and since you are not able to make that connection you are unable to live up to your own OP, which is kind of like fraud) That makes you unable to do what you promised in the OP. If you are going to quibble about the easy stuff you are not really living up to the OP.

Either you do not understand the concepts you stated in the OP, or you lifted the OP and posted it, not knowing what you were doing. Or you worked hard on the OP trying to be all scholarly, and you fail to understand how to apply the concepts anyway.


Your post contains no argument--just assertions. Can you make an argument?

An argument is a string of sentences, of which one is the conclusion. The others are premises which follow some structure of logic and should support the conclusion.

I'd like to have a discussion with you, but if all you do is throw around bare assertions, the conversation will never get past "i know you are but what am i".

If it's "so easy to prove" the falsifiability of the NIST theory, then show me by what standards the NIST theory can be false.
 
I was just saying, we have a person who throws up the smoke screen of the OP, so he can eventually present Jones theory of thermite. I am only a lowly engineer, a former USAF pilot, and after my masters program I worked in a lab at WPAFB. At the lab it was easy to spot BS like the OP as a smoke screen. If you can not see Jay is not really living up to the OP then check out his inability to agree the NIST theory meets the criteria of falsifiability. I may not be getting though, I am not the best writer, but it is clear to me he already believes in Jones's work, so why the smoke screen. He thinks he can be cute and prove with the criteria of the OP that NIST is not making it, and will show Jones's work does. He has failed already as he quibbles over NIST meeting criteria he pushed, and a kid in the 5th grade can show. Where do you think the little spheres junk comes from, if not Jones? I will leave you to waste time with someone who will not change his conclusion which he is not able to defend in the light of day.

I my lab he would be producing, or gone. None of this tap dancing stuff. Fraud comes in many guises, and this is the most despicable, hiding behind the screen of intelligent debate. Jones's work is fraud. You can waste time debating it and be fooled as it is packaged as in the OP. But when someone who sets up the OP quibbles over the easiest criteria to prove, then you have fraud in presentation. 12 pages of posts and he is still unable to agree on the simple stuff. Just ask him to roll out the real agenda. I guess being in charge an having to produce makes you want to cut to end in a timely fashion and stop the BS.

I know, another worthless post, 4400 worthless posts. I have a perfect record then.

jay howard is clearly not throwing up a smoke screen, he has made valid points. He hasn't stated his personal theory because that is not what this thread is about, it is about the NIST theory. a few posts ago I said that I though the Usmani hypothesis has the potential to best theory, with further testing of it, Dr. Greening believes the best theory is of the chemical attack that he has described. None of these involve Jones, or conspiracies, but to explore both requires scrutiny of the NIST. So why not address jh's points rather than trying to accuse him of some sort of agenda? you don't know what his theory is, and it doesn't matter.
 
jh:

can we agree that the UL tests can not be considered a test of the NIST theory solely based on the fact that the absence of fireproofing was a critical factor to the NIST collapse theory whereas the UL tests were done on assemblies with fireproofing?
 
I appreciate the clarification.

The Underwriters Laboratories tests did not satisfy a test of the NIST theory. The NIST theory requires the stripping of fireproofing as a critical condition, without which, collapse would not occur, the UL tests were done on assemblies with fireproofing. From this alone, and without pointing out other differences between the assemblies in the test and the assemblies in the WTC, I hope we can agree that the UL tests did not constitute a test of the NIST theory.

If I'm not mistaken, NIST performed tests separate from the UL assembly certifications. Either way, you are claiming that the tests bore no relevance to NIST's collapse theory, right? So then, by what standards does the NIST theory appeal to in order to make sense? The simulations alone?

As for the WPI steel and the microsperules, I agree the explanations coming from anywhere are extremely weak, and further study is needed to fully explain these phenomena.

It seems you are in agreement that the NIST theory is unable to explain these phenomena, correct?
 
Your post contains no argument--just assertions. Can you make an argument?

An argument is a string of sentences, of which one is the conclusion. The others are premises which follow some structure of logic and should support the conclusion.

I'd like to have a discussion with you, but if all you do is throw around bare assertions, the conversation will never get past "i know you are but what am i".

If it's "so easy to prove" the falsifiability of the NIST theory, then show me by what standards the NIST theory can be false.
Jay, give me a break, everyone has shown you the falsifiability of the NIST theory. Any engineer, or lay person can do it in their head. You are the only one who quibbles about it. Have you not paid attention. Cut to the chase and post your Jones stuff we can save a thread and save you further embarrassment because you can not be honest and show the falsifiability of the NIST theory.

Why are you still quibbling, get on with the rest of your OP stuff. It has been many pages and you just whine about other stuff like this. I can not help it if you can not show the falsifiability of the NIST theory and agree it is met. Why are you still quibbling?

My conclusion base on your OP and your posts is, you support Jones's theories on 9/11. Sorry, but it is clear to me. Prove me wrong, tell me Jones's theories on 9/11 are junk, just crap and false, things he made up in 2005. Go ahead, and then you can get back to your OP.
 
Jay, give me a break, everyone has shown you the falsifiability of the NIST theory. Any engineer, or lay person can do it in their head.

Then, please tell me what would make the NIST theory false.

...I can not help it if you can not show the falsifiability of the NIST theory and agree it is met.

If you claim the "it's easy to prove the falsifiability of the NIST theory," then you should be able to back that claim up by showing what criteria would make the NIST theory false.

My conclusion base on your OP and your posts is, you support Jones's theories on 9/11. Sorry, but it is clear to me. Prove me wrong, tell me Jones's theories on 9/11 are junk, just crap and false, things he made up in 2005. Go ahead, and then you can get back to your OP.

Show me where I appeal to Jones' arguments.

Make an argument or sit on the sidelines.
 
jay howard is clearly not throwing up a smoke screen, he has made valid points. He hasn't stated his personal theory because that is not what this thread is about, it is about the NIST theory. a few posts ago I said that I though the Usmani hypothesis has the potential to best theory, with further testing of it, Dr. Greening believes the best theory is of the chemical attack that he has described. None of these involve Jones, or conspiracies, but to explore both requires scrutiny of the NIST. So why not address jh's points rather than trying to accuse him of some sort of agenda? you don't know what his theory is, and it doesn't matter.
Jay only quibbles and has not made valid points to advance his OP, he has thrown in veiled packets from Jones's work.

The fire alone theory is interesting, it does meet or exceed the critera put forth in the OP. Fire alone would need all, or some of the things that the impacts brought to the event. You have to have fires out of control with no fire fighting. You have to start big fires all over. Or do you? Do you need the holes of the impact to keep a steady source of air for the fire? Did you need 60,000 pounds of fuel to start the fires? Did you need the damage to the shell and the core from the impact? Do you need big gapping holes spanning a few floors? Would the insulated steel make two hours before failure? Do you need the test NIST did to be wrong about the fireproofing meeting standards? The WTC design was unique. You have to have a core, a shell, and the floors. The strength of the entire building is in these three parts together, no part can be missing, or the WTC is in trouble.

That theory easily can be shown to meet the falsifiability criteria, just like the NIST theory. I would love it if Jay acted more scientific and would just continue and stop quibbling about his own criteria, or even stopping to comment to me.

The http://www.era.lib.ed.ac.uk/bitstream/1842/1216/1/WTCpaper.pdf theory is fine, and does not even come close to being a 9/11 truth instrument of woo. But you are still playing with a closet Jones supporter, who will continue to sneak in the Jones junk as he continue to blow smoke...
 
Last edited:
is Jones's work junk or not?

Then, please tell me what would make the NIST theory false.

If you claim the "it's easy to prove the falsifiability of the NIST theory," then you should be able to back that claim up by showing what criteria would make the NIST theory false.

Show me where I appeal to Jones' arguments.

Make an argument or sit on the sidelines.
Jay, just tell the world Jones's work is crap, not only crap but made up junk. Tell them and I will sit on the side lines and contemplate my failure to see you as a true scientist prepared to solely argue your OP not matter what distractions come.

Jay, you bring up stuff from his work. You are not good at hiding it. Just tell me Jones's work is crap, and get on with the good stuff, you know the fire only idea may have some merit, what do you think?

The chief conclusions are:
1. The analysis presented points to a compelling fire induced collapse mechanism rather unique to the type of structure that the WTC Twin-Towers represented
2. This analysis also shows that the collapse is initiated principally by a stability mechanism as a result of geometry changes in the structure caused by thermal expansion effects
3. Furthermore it is quite possible that the geometric changes required to precipitate collapse could result from very low temperatures not high enough to induce significant reduction in the material properties
4. It can therefore be provisionally concluded that these buildings could have collapsed as a result of a major fire event. This is of course assuming that any of the active fire suppression systems would either fail or be unable to control the development of the fire. This is a normal assumption
when designing fire protection for buildings (http://www.era.lib.ed.ac.uk/bitstream/1842/1216/1/WTCpaper.pdf)​

Denounce Jones's work as tripe so I can sit by the sidelines. It would help then to know you know Jones's work is garbage, so when you bring up stuff from Jones I know it is just for academic reasons and not that you actually think Jones's work is good for anything like warning the whole world about the inside job his work he made up points to. Is Jones's work tripe or the stuff you believe?
 
Last edited:
Well, I'm back, and this thread sure went to the dogs...

jay howard is clearly not throwing up a smoke screen, he has made valid points. He hasn't stated his personal theory because that is not what this thread is about, it is about the NIST theory. a few posts ago I said that I though the Usmani hypothesis has the potential to best theory, with further testing of it, Dr. Greening believes the best theory is of the chemical attack that he has described. None of these involve Jones, or conspiracies, but to explore both requires scrutiny of the NIST. So why not address jh's points rather than trying to accuse him of some sort of agenda? you don't know what his theory is, and it doesn't matter.

jay howard has no valid points. My last post on Page 7 remains completely unaddressed by him. In summary:

  1. The NIST report is falsifiable, as described here over several pages
  2. The UL intact-truss testing has no direct bearing on the collapse model
  3. He has conflated observations on the recovered steel to represent NIST's estimate of the entire volume of structural steel
  4. He did not, but may finally, understand that the WPI paper -- concerning only a single piece of steel from the Towers -- shows that the steel never even approached melting temperature
Basically all he's doing now is saying "nuh-uh." That's not useful. You'll also note that he declined to respond to my question of where he's copying his information from. Once in a while he still sticks in a tell-tale footnote, and those notes aren't from NIST. I'm guessing he's got an old copy of a Griffin paper, but they don't match anything I have. Until we get past these basic errors of fact, there is little point trying to draw inference from them, and I have nothing further to say until jay corrects his mistakes.

Anyway, regarding the Ove Arup paper, this is one of the few legitimate criticisms of the NIST report in existence. I wholeheartedly agree that it has the potential to be the "best" theory, and would falsify the NIST report if found to be true. However, I question its accuracy.

If we put any stock in the NIST fire and structural heat transfer models, they predict burnout on the impact floors after about two hours. Had there been no fireproofing damage, given what we saw in the truss tests, the maximum temperature in the floor elements would be expected to peak at under 500 oC and lead to deflections within the normal range of elasticity, thus the thermal expansion and subsequent contraction would not materially increase the strain energy in the support columns. The NIST models may be wrong, but this would not be a simple mistake, and we need much more evidence to draw such a conclusion.

If we assume no impact damage at all, i.e. no broken windows and the fire ventilated mainly by stack effect, then we can expect an even cooler if longer-duration fire. This is not, of course, what the Arup paper proposes, but we need to be clear what we mean when we say "no impact damage."

It's definitely worth comparing the two side-by-side. I still put more stock in the NIST result, but if you want to criticize NIST, this is the way to do it. Dr. Usmani has done his homework, as few others have.
 
That theory easily can be shown to meet the falsifiability criteria, just like the NIST theory. I would love it if Jay acted more scientific and would just continue and stop quibbling about his own criteria, or even stopping to comment to me.



You can say "NIST is falsifiable" over and over again, but without saying what exactly would falsify the theory, it is just a bare assertion. It is an empty statement. Show me, or say, "I can't show you what criteria would falsify the NIST theory."
 
Well, I'm back, and this thread sure went to the dogs...



jay howard has no valid points. My last post on Page 7 remains completely unaddressed by him. In summary:

  1. The NIST report is falsifiable, as described here over several pages
  2. The UL intact-truss testing has no direct bearing on the collapse model
  3. He has conflated observations on the recovered steel to represent NIST's estimate of the entire volume of structural steel
  4. He did not, but may finally, understand that the WPI paper -- concerning only a single piece of steel from the Towers -- shows that the steel never even approached melting temperature
Basically all he's doing now is saying "nuh-uh." That's not useful. You'll also note that he declined to respond to my question of where he's copying his information from. Once in a while he still sticks in a tell-tale footnote, and those notes aren't from NIST. I'm guessing he's got an old copy of a Griffin paper, but they don't match anything I have. Until we get past these basic errors of fact, there is little point trying to draw inference from them, and I have nothing further to say until jay corrects his mistakes.

Anyway, regarding the Ove Arup paper, this is one of the few legitimate criticisms of the NIST report in existence. I wholeheartedly agree that it has the potential to be the "best" theory, and would falsify the NIST report if found to be true. However, I question its accuracy.

If we put any stock in the NIST fire and structural heat transfer models, they predict burnout on the impact floors after about two hours. Had there been no fireproofing damage, given what we saw in the truss tests, the maximum temperature in the floor elements would be expected to peak at under 500 oC and lead to deflections within the normal range of elasticity, thus the thermal expansion and subsequent contraction would not materially increase the strain energy in the support columns. The NIST models may be wrong, but this would not be a simple mistake, and we need much more evidence to draw such a conclusion.

If we assume no impact damage at all, i.e. no broken windows and the fire ventilated mainly by stack effect, then we can expect an even cooler if longer-duration fire. This is not, of course, what the Arup paper proposes, but we need to be clear what we mean when we say "no impact damage."

It's definitely worth comparing the two side-by-side. I still put more stock in the NIST result, but if you want to criticize NIST, this is the way to do it. Dr. Usmani has done his homework, as few others have.


take a look around the forum R.Mackey. Our young friends REV and Fates have stirred things up at another Moon Hoax thread, and most indearingly called all the astronauts LIARS.

TAM:)
 
"NIST is falsifiable"

You can say "NIST is falsifiable" over and over again, but without saying what exactly would falsify the theory, it is just a bare assertion. It is an empty statement. Show me, or say, "I can't show you what criteria would falsify the NIST theory."
Jay, the very fact you can not agree means you have no clue. You can not even do the simple stuff because your champion is Jones. I am sorry you can not do the simple stuff you set forth in the OP. If you can not show "NIST is falsifiable" you are the one who needs to sit on the side lines. (I knew this on your opening post) (if you can not work with distraction or show "NIST is falsifiable", you are not very good)
 
You can say "NIST is falsifiable" over and over again, but without saying what exactly would falsify the theory, it is just a bare assertion. It is an empty statement. Show me, or say, "I can't show you what criteria would falsify the NIST theory."

I and others gave you numerous pieces of conceivable evidence that would falsify the NIST theory. I will repeat a simple one.

Let's presume tomorrow evidence came to light that the WTC towers were still, in fact, standing. Under this new piece of evidence, do you think we could safely conclude that the NIST report was false?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom