• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

[Merged]Atheism is a really bogus philosophy

:)Look, based on every definition I've ever seen about atheism, which is defined as the doctrine or "belief" that there is no God,
Wrong.

I simply feel one must have some serious psychological problems to label their self this way.
I'm quite certain that you are simply being melodramatic.


In my experience, virtually every person calling himself or herself an atheist is someone who is trying to either thumb their nose at organized religions, which is fine with me, or is trying to pretend that they are far more intelligent than all those stupid people who believe in a higher form of intelligence.
You must not know many atheists.

To deny the existence of a God, or the wisdom and power responsible for our earth and all the life on it, is to "BELIEVE" that LAW & ORDER did not and does not require intelligent direction.
As Joobz pointed out, you are conflating human social constructs with natural processes.

It also means that you must "believe" that something can come from nothing.
No, it does not.

For these reasons, I find anyone who calls their self an atheist to be someone who is just showing off, playing some kind of dorky game.
Due to reasons ranging from your poor use of grammar as well as your use of the word "dorky", combined with your inability to construct a coherent argument, I am left to speculate that you may be in your early teens.

Imagine if this higher power is omnipresent, like the Buddhists believe and call Dharmakaya, like the Hindu believe and call Brahman, like the Taoists believe and call The Tao, like Einstein believed and called The Unified Field, this would mean that YOU are made of this "stuff" we call God, 100%, wouldn't it?
Hokulele has already pointed out the problem with your statement regarding Tao. I would like to add that you are misrepresenting Einstein. He did not attribute any intelligence or intent to the physical workings of the universe.

Wouldn't it then seem somewhat ludicrous for you to deny the existence of yourself?
You ask us to imagine a scenario in which you are correct and then imply that it is ludicrous to deny that you are correct. The problem is that your premise is based on us having to imagine something that you believe to be true. You have presented no evidence to support your premise.
 
Furthermore, bwinwright, the "Law of Attraction" does not mean that people produce more people like themselves.

The Law of Attraction is a vague sort of mystical notion that "like attracts like." It is at the basis of that stupid book The Secret, which says that people who suffer illness, poverty, or abuse bring it on themselves by thinking wrongly - if they would only think all the time about health and wealth, those benefits would be attracted to their positive thoughts and there you are. You know, sort of like "cast your bread upon the waters..."
 
To deny the existence of an intelligence which is both wiser and more powerful than man means you must believe that ORDER DOES NOT REQUIRE INTELLIGENT DIRECTION. The FACT is, this is impossible!

There are numerous examples of incredibly sophisticated and complex orderliness which are beyond the capabilities of man to produce. An eagle, for example, can do things man simply can not replicate, regardless of the nature of man's efforts. Plus, the eagle can reproduce.

The EARTH, itself, is traveling through space at 18.51 miles per second or 66,636 mph, constantly, on its annual orbit around the Sun which it completes once every 365.2422 days, precisely. This mechanical process is far more durable and precise than any watch or clock man has ever been able to make.

Therefore, call it God, TOTO, or whatever you like..but it "is" here. To deny it is simply insanity. Therefore, you atheists need to be more specific or people will just think you're NUTS!!!!!

Funny how you claim it's impossible for there to be order without intelligence, and then give two examples of order without intelligence.
 
In my opinion, atheism is a bogus philosophy, at least for all practical purposes.

Atheism is a philosophy ? I thought it was the default position.

Say, do you have any evidence for God ?

However, to suggest you do not believe in an intelligence and power which dramatically transcends that of mankind is, to me, ludicrous.

Argument from personal incredulity. It's obvious you find it ludicrous because you already have another opinion. I find the belief that some cosmic intelligence designed the universe and everything in it ludicrous.

We can trade opinions all we want. It's the facts that have the last word.

To deny the existence of an intelligence which is both wiser and more powerful than man means you must believe that ORDER DOES NOT REQUIRE INTELLIGENT DIRECTION. The FACT is, this is impossible!

Only someone immensely ignorant of how nature and chaos/randomness works could say such a thing. Please educate yourself. Randomness can and DOES, very often, result in incredible complexity and order.

There are numerous examples of incredibly sophisticated and complex orderliness which are beyond the capabilities of man to produce. An eagle, for example, can do things man simply can not replicate, regardless of the nature of man's efforts. Plus, the eagle can reproduce.

We can't produce stars, either, but they're extremely simple. This point does not help your argument.

The EARTH, itself, is traveling through space at 18.51 miles per second or 66,636 mph, constantly, on its annual orbit around the Sun which it completes once every 365.2422 days, precisely. This mechanical process is far more durable and precise than any watch or clock man has ever been able to make. [/QUOTE]

That's ridiculously false. The Earth does not keep the same speed over time.
 
:)You see, Spindrift, you say ORDER EXISTS without explaining how this can be possible without intelligent direction. Law and order CAN NOT EXIST "without" having first been established by or always existing with the intelligence this orderliness is subject to.

See my previous post. Randomness creates freakishly complex patterns. Some random programs have been created to randomly evolve clocks, and they work wonders.

The Law of Attraction means that life produces life like itself.

What ?

This also appears to be true in the realm of human thought and emotion as well. That is, one's experience is the product of one's habitual thoughts and feelings.

And have nothing to do with special creation.

Atheists seem to believe that this ORDER, this Law of Attraction, exists but was not the product of any form of intelligence? If you will agree that intelligence exists now, then you must also agree that intelligence has "always" existed...or you believe that this something we call intelligence came from nothing?

False dichotomy. You haven't given much thought to this. Intelligence exists now. Chrystlers exist now. Penguins exist now. None of those have existed since the Big Bang, so your reasoning is flawed. What's more, intelligence has evolved, which is a possibility you [purposely ?] left out of your list.

Intelligence can not come from non-intelligence. This is the atheist's primary error.

That's your opinion, but seeing how intelligence exists at many different levels in various species, your opinion is clearly YOUR primary error.

Look, based on every definition I've ever seen about atheism, which is defined as the doctrine or "belief" that there is no God, I simply feel one must have some serious psychological problems to label their self this way.

Without evidence, one cannot claim that something exists.

In my experience, virtually every person calling himself or herself an atheist is someone who is trying to either thumb their nose at organized religions, which is fine with me, or is trying to pretend that they are far more intelligent than all those stupid people who believe in a higher form of intelligence.

In my experience, theists believe in god because it makes them feel important that an omnipotent, flawless cosmic designer made THEM specifically to enjoy a special relationship with them.

We can trade insults all day, if you want.

To deny the existence of a God, or the wisdom and power responsible for our earth and all the life on it, is to "BELIEVE" that LAW & ORDER did not and does not require intelligent direction. It also means that you must "believe" that something can come from nothing.

False. Something came from something else. The exact origin of the universe and how it happened is another story.

For these reasons, I find anyone who calls their self an atheist to be someone who is just showing off, playing some kind of dorky game.

And like most other theists, you don't seek to correct that false view.

Imagine if this higher power is omnipresent, like the Buddhists believe and call Dharmakaya, like the Hindu believe and call Brahman, like the Taoists believe and call The Tao, like Einstein believed and called The Unified Field, this would mean that YOU are made of this "stuff" we call God, 100%, wouldn't it?

Yes, it would. There is, however, no evidence of this.

Wouldn't it then seem somewhat ludicrous for you to deny the existence of yourself?

Circular reasoning, methinks.
 
Bwinright, I have a counterquestion for you. Do you believe, without question or reserve, the bible? Do you believe the Bible is the word of god, direct? Do you believe the translations and mistranslations over the years have had no effect? Do you follow the bible word for word?
 
:)Mister Agenda, I've never heard the incredulity argument before but it sounds extremely sophisticated, even awe inspiring to me, honestly! My question is, "How can something so sophisticated and awe inspiring come from nothing? I honestly do not believe something can come from nothing, do you really? Explain, please. I'm hungry for your wisdom. Seriously! I am.

And now that it has been explained that the argument from incredulity is a fallacy, I see you have no problem resorting to it again immediately. :rolleyes:

I didn't realize you were an atheist, I thought you were one of those guys who believe the universe was created from nothing. I'm glad we're in agreement! :D
 
:) 10 out of 10 for sincere intent

It's important to be earnest. :)

I think one, at least, has been offered already:

True, just not for being offensive. I did not have high hopes though, so the disappointment is bearable. I have a little dream of meeting a believer who acts like he really believes in turning the other cheek and that the meek and the peacemakers are blessed.
 
Atheists seem to believe that this ORDER, this Law of Attraction, exists but was not the product of any form of intelligence? If you will agree that intelligence exists now, then you must also agree that intelligence has "always" existed...or you believe that this something we call intelligence came from nothing? Intelligence can not come from non-intelligence. This is the atheist's primary error.

Intelligence cannot come from non-intelligence? Then where did god come from?

Logically, not only CAN intelligence come from non-intelligence, it MUST come from non-intelligence or else you have infinite recursion of intelligent 'creators'.
 
:)
Give me an example of order without intelligent direction. I just don't think you can. However, if you can, I will convert to atheism, OK?

Damn late to the party, but assuming examples are put forward as I expect they will be, here's my prediction - bwinwright will assert that it didn't happen without intelligent direction, instead his god deisgned it that way

ETA - Close!:
bwinwright said:
You see, Spindrift, you say ORDER EXISTS without explaining how this can be possible without intelligent direction. Law and order CAN NOT EXIST "without" having first been established by or always existing with the intelligence this orderliness is subject to.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3354704#post3354704
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom