Mass shooting in small town Texas

So law abiding gun owner before yesterday.
What part of the article you linked to supports your claim.

This part says he was buying the rifle illegally; he lied on the form 4473 if what I read about his domestic violence history is true.
When Kelley filled out the background check paperwork at the store, he checked the box to indicate he didn't have disqualifying criminal history, the official said. He listed an address in Colorado Springs, Colorado when he bought the rifle, the official said.

ETA; It seems the news reports can't really agree on the perp's criminal history.
 
Last edited:
You tell me how the types of firearms I make in my garage are related to mass shootings. Can you do it without a weasel word like "maybe"?

Is it a fair question to ask someone to make a direct, non-hypothetical connection without actually knowing you personally and your individual circumstances?

It feels a little like a "gotcha" in that you exclude the only way it would be possible to answer the question if there is a legitimate answer.

I am open to the idea that I a missing something or have misunderstood something. If that is the case, please inform me and I will alter my view. At the moment, it sounds like this to me:

You: What does the one in my hand have to do with letter writing.
Other: Well you could use it to write a letter.
You: BZZZZ! no hypotheticals!! If you didn't personally witness me write it, you got nothing! This pen can't possible be connected to letters!


What have I missunderstood?
 
Two arguments come up every time gun control becomes an issue,and they are both painful to listen to, because they are so incredibly stupid.


One is that if guns were outlawed, criminal people with murderous streaks would just use other weapons.

The other is that if guns were outlawed, it wouldn't keep any guns out of criminals' hands.

Each, individually, is moronic, but they are usually used together, which also adds a degree of self-contradiction, making the stupidity of the whole greater than the sum of the stupidity of the parts.

Well they are rarely stated exactly like this. Gun control will have some effect for sure. But it's clear that even now there is black market with guns, and it won't vanish overnight. Also similar attacks by using different means are common in countries with tight gun control.
Maybe next time try to actually bring up some counter arguments.
 
Last edited:
Also similar attack by using different means are common in countries with tight gun control.

In which country are attacks like this, by different means, as common as in the USA? It's been stated several times that this was the 307th mass killing in the USA this year. Which country, adjusted for population, has anything close to that?

These are serious questions. Since you say it's common, it shouldn't be difficult to substantiate.
 
Is it a fair question to ask someone to make a direct, non-hypothetical connection without actually knowing you personally and your individual circumstances?
Arcade22 implied that mass shootings are related to the legal non-violent activities in my garage.

It feels a little like a "gotcha" in that you exclude the only way it would be possible to answer the question if there is a legitimate answer.
What am I excluding?

I am open to the idea that I a missing something or have misunderstood something. If that is the case, please inform me and I will alter my view.
I posted in this thread about making and registering firearms IAW federal law; firearms of the type which are very rarely associated with any violent crime at all. But somehow he has decided to connect me to mass shootings.
 
What part of the article you linked to supports your claim.

This part says he was buying the rifle illegally; he lied on the form 4473 if what I read about his domestic violence history is true.


ETA; It seems the news reports can't really agree on the perp's criminal history.

If he wasn't charged with domestic violence then why would the actual crimes he was convicted of remove his right to own firearms? Everyone is saying now he shouldn't have been able to, but no one is really demonstrating that what he was actually convicted of would carry that.

It does not say he lied on the form, just that he put down that he had not been convicted of a felony which seems to be true.
 
There is also the domestic violence. News reports are conflicting at the moment. I made that argument prematurely.
 
Arcade22 implied that mass shootings are related to the legal non-violent activities in my garage.


What am I excluding?
Any answer that is theoretical or not specific to you. The problem with that is that he can't know enough about you personally and can only answer theoretically.


I posted in this thread about making and registering firearms IAW federal law; firearms of the type which are very rarely associated with any violent crime at all. But somehow he has decided to connect me to mass shootings.

That's fair enough, and I am not attempting to prove his claim. But my first instinct that that asking how a gun you create could be connected to mass shooting without allowing hypotheticals is that same as saying "I have never committed a mass shooting, so it is impossible that I ever could, or that someone else could with my weapons" which clearly does not track logically.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Any answer that is theoretical or not specific to you. The problem with that is that he can't know enough about you personally and can only answer theoretically.
The actual problem is that he assumed too much and should have learned more prior to that post.
 
Times have changed. I grew up in a rural community in TN. We didn't lock our doors for years. I could hunt or merely roam all over neighboring properties without a problem. Everyone knew who I was and trusted that I wouldn't cause a problem or was not up to mischief. It is very different now...

I spent 5 years in San Antonio during the early 70's. Outside of the city it was virtually the same way. Farmers and Ranchers could leave their 30-30 (a varmint rifle) hanging in the window of their unlocked pick-up truck without a problem. That has all changed now.

It is nothing new that has only happened in the past few years. It's been developing over time and is becoming worse and worse.

I wish I had the answer, but I don't. It's not a gun culture problem as most idgits imply. It is something other than that. Something is happening that I only have partial answers for it.

The Easy Rider Rifle Rack.
 
http://www.businessinsider.com/texas-church-gunman-devin-patrick-gun-law-felon-domestic-violence-2017-11

It also seems that his criminal charges was not for domestic violence so he did not lose his right to own guns for that reason.

"Kelley apparently was not convicted of domestic violence in the incidents that led him to be disciplined; such a conviction could have also legally disqualified him from gun ownership.

But even if the assault charges didn't technically go down as domestic violence, assault alone can be treated as a felony, which should preclude gun ownership."

Seems likely that he was legally able to own guns as he was just below the threshold that such things kick in.

At this point it seems likely that the background check system was a false negative. Kelley was convicted of assault and sentenced to a year in jail. Any person "convicted of a crime punishable by a sentence exceeding one year" is prohibited from owning a firearm. Unless Kelley got the maximum sentence for his crime that conviction would have met the threshold. (If we knew the section of UCMJ he was charged under we could look this up). The threshold for domestic violence is even lower. As the targets of his assault were a spouse and child the assault should have been counted as domestic violence.
 
There is also the domestic violence. News reports are conflicting at the moment. I made that argument prematurely.

But it seems that it wasn't charged as domestic assault just assault so no legal bar to owning guns.
 
At this point it seems likely that the background check system was a false negative. Kelley was convicted of assault and sentenced to a year in jail. Any person "convicted of a crime punishable by a sentence exceeding one year" is prohibited from owning a firearm. Unless Kelley got the maximum sentence for his crime that conviction would have met the threshold. (If we knew the section of UCMJ he was charged under we could look this up). The threshold for domestic violence is even lower. As the targets of his assault were a spouse and child the assault should have been counted as domestic violence.

So show what it was.
 
Well, Texas apparently denied him a license to carry, so it seems like there is something in his record that shows up on a background check.

So what? I think denying a carry license for anyone with violent crimes like assault even if they do not preclude gun ownership is a bad thing.
 
For a start, I would be happy with forcing the NRA to quote the entire 2nd Amendment in all their communications and on all their plaques etc.

As long as anti Second Amendment proponents are required to quote paragraph six of the decision in US v Cruikshank in it's entirety you have a deal.

For the unenlightened, this is the often cited quote:

"The right to bear arms is not granted by the Constitution."

This is paragraph 6:

"6. The right to bear arms is not granted by the Constitution; neither is it in any manner dependent upon that instrument for its existence. The Second Amendments means no more than that it shall not be infringed by Congress, and has no other effect than to restrict the powers of the National Government."

ETA - link to the decision:

https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/92/542/case.html
 
Last edited:
In which country are attacks like this, by different means, as common as in the USA? It's been stated several times that this was the 307th mass killing in the USA this year. Which country, adjusted for population, has anything close to that?

These are serious questions. Since you say it's common, it shouldn't be difficult to substantiate.

I'm not saying 'as common as in US'. By common I mean nobody really is surprised anymore, when it happens.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom