Marine Corps General would house gay and straight soldiers seperately

So... it's ok for straight men to be stuck with potentially sexually aggressive gay men, but not ok for women to be stuck with potentially sexually aggressive straight men?

A coed shower room would be anything but private, this isn't a dark alley we're talking about here.

You're right, it's not a dark alley. So why would anyone be in danger of being raped? Do you think that gays are suddenly overcome with lust because they see naked guys, and start raping? Does this happen when straight men see naked women in similar circumstances, especially when surrounded by dozens of others? Have you ever been in a communal shower like you're describing? It's not private. It certainly isn't conducive to criminal acts of violence. And that is what you're describing. Yeah, I can see it now. George sees Alan naked, and goes for it, even though Bill, Tom, Jason and Ben are in there, too.
Get real.
 
Y...Does this happen when straight men see naked women in similar circumstances, especially when surrounded by dozens of others? Have you ever been in a communal shower like you're describing? ....
I hate to bring up anecdotes but in my lifetime as a woman, I have been harassed at various times by men. Once a guy bought me a beer and thought that meant I owed him sex. He ran off when I screamed as he tried to tear my clothes off. I've been touched in private areas on more than one crowed bus or street. I was almost date raped twice by men I didn't know that well but made the mistake of going to their houses with them. (Though I have to add, I was not harassed by dozens of other men in similar circumstances and I would still go places with new acquaintances, though maybe with a tad more caution now that I'm older and wiser.)

These were all minor events, but I do believe if you let strange men in locker rooms with women, it would lead to the wrong men seeking those circumstances out to take advantage of them. I can't see gays in military barracks doing anything similar.
 
I hate to bring up anecdotes but in my lifetime as a woman, I have been harassed at various times by men. Once a guy bought me a beer and thought that meant I owed him sex. He ran off when I screamed as he tried to tear my clothes off. I've been touched in private areas on more than one crowed bus or street. I was almost date raped twice by men I didn't know that well but made the mistake of going to their houses with them. (Though I have to add, I was not harassed by dozens of other men in similar circumstances and I would still go places with new acquaintances, though maybe with a tad more caution now that I'm older and wiser.)

These were all minor events, but I do believe if you let strange men in locker rooms with women, it would lead to the wrong men seeking those circumstances out to take advantage of them. I can't see gays in military barracks doing anything similar.
I know things like that happen, but the way people talk about this stuff is like it's going to happen every time. Yet it's extremely rare. I'm certain that gays showered with me in the military. Yet somehow I emerged totally unscathed! Guess I'm just too ugly...
 
I know things like that happen, but the way people talk about this stuff is like it's going to happen every time. Yet it's extremely rare. I'm certain that gays showered with me in the military. Yet somehow I emerged totally unscathed! Guess I'm just too ugly...
I'm supportive of gays in the military. You do know that, right?
 
I was in the Marine Corp for 6 years...and IMO this would be a terrible idea. IMO segregation would create a far worse atmosphere than the current DADT. The Marine Corp already has very strict harassment regulations in place. If harassment takes place...in either direction....it should be dealt with in the normal fashion...swiftly.

As a serving member of coming up to 20 years service, I also agree it would be wrong. In the Australian Defence Forces, gays have long been openly allowed. Segregation only creates a divide where there is none. I've worked with openly gay members and have no problems with them.

Sexual orientation has no effect on loyalty, courage, competence, etc. Oh - and I am heterosexual.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom