Marine Corps General would house gay and straight soldiers seperately

Okay, well I think this tangent needs to be brought back to order.

Anyway, to relate with the OP don't house them seperately, since segregation is never a good idea, it only leads to further complications, since you'll never end the ways to seperate. Women trapped in men's bodies? Lesbians trapped in men's bodies? Bisexuals? One-time experimenters?

Let them stay sticking men with men and women with women and leave it at that.

Having had to share a bathroom with one woman for a few years now, I will say, that I wouldn't put up with it if not for being married to her.
 
No ad hom implied. I was merely using your "formerly skeptigirl" avatar tag as an indication that you are female, there was no intended implication of a loss of skepticism. Now that that's cleared up, do you have a problem with men hanging out in your locker room oggling? This is the same feeling that men have about gay men being in their locker room.
Well how about using a legitimate analogy? It wouldn't bother me if a lesbian was in the locker room. So what, even if they hit on me? I'm not interested, end of story.

The reason it would bother me if a man were in there is men have a long history of aggression toward women sexually. Date rape, for example, is an issue with guys.

Without getting into another long drawn out argument that women can be aggressive, it just isn't very likely. You cannot say that about men in a locker room with naked women. Some men will be aggressive in those circumstances. Some men will go into locker rooms with the express reason of enjoying live porn.

With gay people in same sex locker rooms you cannot show the same thing happens or is likely to happen.

I have no problem with the airport scanners that reveal one's body. I work in health care. Not many people have sex in mind because they see naked patients.
 
No I have no issue with it, but I won't dismiss it as completely irrational - I can see their point. The presence of somebody openly sexually attracted to them in the locker room is not accepted by society when it's the opposite gender
I don't think that's true. More than a few men would be happy to have women in a coed locker room. Probably a few men wouldn't like it. Mostly because they value some macho exclusion of women in their male bonding social situations. Of course, a few women wouldn't care about the guys in the locker room either, but most probably would.

You really are ignoring all the other differences between men and women in your version of reality here. Guys rape, women very rarely do.
 
This idea could backfire spectacularly. I suggest you just mash 'em all in together. Marines are kind of really awesome at self control.
 
What about a Marine who is a lesbian trapped in the body of a man? Would he get to shower with the female officers? Or, failing this....at least have webcam access to the shower block?

Old joke...

You are going to like this unit son, every wedensday night we play poker...
sorry sir I don't Gamble.
OK, well..thursday nights are a hoot, we have a few drinks and..
Sorry sir, I don't drink...
Good god? Are you a poof?
No sir.
well, you won't like friday nights either.
 
Well how about using a legitimate analogy? It wouldn't bother me if a lesbian was in the locker room. So what, even if they hit on me? I'm not interested, end of story.

The reason it would bother me if a man were in there is men have a long history of aggression toward women sexually. Date rape, for example, is an issue with guys.

Without getting into another long drawn out argument that women can be aggressive, it just isn't very likely. You cannot say that about men in a locker room with naked women. Some men will be aggressive in those circumstances. Some men will go into locker rooms with the express reason of enjoying live porn.

With gay people in same sex locker rooms you cannot show the same thing happens or is likely to happen.

I have no problem with the airport scanners that reveal one's body. I work in health care. Not many people have sex in mind because they see naked patients.

There is a perfectly sexless reason the two genders are kept separate in the locker/shower room. Female menstruation, and for (usually the very young teenage) male, short salute are but two.

Other bodily happenings that are gender specific can cause slight comedic for some and very :blush: moments for the emotionally unprepared. (Woman opens her locker and improperly secured pads-Tampax avalanche atop some male sitting on the bench below.) Immature I know, but there are many immature Americans...:D
 
I don't think you need separate quarters for gay soldiers. I don't know why there's this attitude that all gay men cannot control themselves and will just mount any guy that comes their way.

While I'm not gay, I do know a few gay men (as well as a few gay-women/lesbians too), and they are attracted certain types of men (and in the lesbian's case, women), much in the same way that I'm attracted to certain types of women, not blindly attracted to every single female between the ages of 18 and 40 that happens to cross my path.
 
There is a perfectly sexless reason the two genders are kept separate in the locker/shower room. Female menstruation, and for (usually the very young teenage) male, short salute are but two.
What? It's OK for men to take showers with naked women except they might see a few drops of blood???????????

The pointy little head problem, OTOH, fits with what I already posted.

Other bodily happenings that are gender specific can cause slight comedic for some and very :blush: moments for the emotionally unprepared. (Woman opens her locker and improperly secured pads-Tampax avalanche atop some male sitting on the bench below.) Immature I know, but there are many immature Americans...:D
This is an odd belief you have here. But whatever...
 
The reason it would bother me if a man were in there is men have a long history of aggression toward women sexually. Date rape, for example, is an issue with guys.

So... it's ok for straight men to be stuck with potentially sexually aggressive gay men, but not ok for women to be stuck with potentially sexually aggressive straight men?

A coed shower room would be anything but private, this isn't a dark alley we're talking about here.
 
Well how about using a legitimate analogy? It wouldn't bother me if a lesbian was in the locker room. So what, even if they hit on me? I'm not interested, end of story.

The reason it would bother me if a man were in there is men have a long history of aggression toward women sexually. Date rape, for example, is an issue with guys.

Without getting into another long drawn out argument that women can be aggressive, it just isn't very likely. You cannot say that about men in a locker room with naked women. Some men will be aggressive in those circumstances. Some men will go into locker rooms with the express reason of enjoying live porn.

With gay people in same sex locker rooms you cannot show the same thing happens or is likely to happen.

I have no problem with the airport scanners that reveal one's body. I work in health care. Not many people have sex in mind because they see naked patients.

You are trying to rationalize a cultural artifact. I think this would be a bit strange to someone from a culture that wore very little or no clothing for example.
 
So... it's ok for straight men to be stuck with potentially sexually aggressive gay men, but not ok for women to be stuck with potentially sexually aggressive straight men?

A coed shower room would be anything but private, this isn't a dark alley we're talking about here.
Provide some evidence your claim is valid. I'm not aware gay men are out there raping other men in any quantities that register on anyone's radar.
 
You are trying to rationalize a cultural artifact. I think this would be a bit strange to someone from a culture that wore very little or no clothing for example.
You can claim gay men in a men's locker is analogous to men in a women's locker. I say it isn't. Lesbians in a women's locker is analogous, but once you go to examples of men in a women's locker or women in a men's locker, you have additional factors besides just the sexual attraction factor. The differences make the analogy a fail.
 
You can claim gay men in a men's locker is analogous to men in a women's locker. I say it isn't. Lesbians in a women's locker is analogous, but once you go to examples of men in a women's locker or women in a men's locker, you have additional factors besides just the sexual attraction factor. The differences make the analogy a fail.

No I am not claiming that, I am claiming that the idea of when you need privacy and when you do not is heavily dependent on society. I have been places were men and women showered together and it was not a big deal. It is the idea that nudity and sex are related that causes a lot of this.
 
What? It's OK for men to take showers with naked women except they might see a few drops of blood???????????

The pointy little head problem, OTOH, fits with what I already posted.

This is an odd belief you have here. But whatever...

Ummm, a few drops? Yea, right. Different women different situations.

For me, that wouldn't be description at all. See Psycho.
 
Ummm, a few drops? Yea, right. Different women different situations.

For me, that wouldn't be description at all. See Psycho.
[sidetrack]You might be surprised to learn the actual volume which is typically estimated by women to be much more than it really is.[/sidetrack]

It wouldn't matter how much blood. It's just a body process. Why would men be unable to handle seeing it?
 
As Eddie Izzard said about the "first airborne transvestite brigade" he suggested to create, that'll certainly have the element of surprise:

"--those guys look funny!"
"-aaah! They've got guns!!!"
 
Skeptic Ginger: 1) I'm pretty sure your average male is not that aggressive. Something about aggregates here. Leading into
I hate the thought of bringing this issue up again since it led to a repetitive pages long debate in the past that women were rapists and aggressors as if it was politically incorrect to point out the obvious fact men account for the vast majority of crimes of violence against women. Very few women are aggressors against men, and while they certainly murder men, it is extremely rare for a woman to rape a man. It is not that rare (relative to women perps) for a man to rape a women.

I never said anything about "average male" being aggressive and violent. Of course they aren't.

2) He said "but 2" meaning they're examples. (Also, because some men simply do not want to know at all.)[/QUOTE]And they were but two I replied about.

The only point I was making was that you cannot compare men and women together in a locker room (or similar setting involving removed clothing) with homosexuals being in the same setting with other heterosexuals of the same sex. There are many more differences between the two examples besides sexual attraction to the other people in the room.

This issue about menstrual blood being some big deal to men is a side track.
 
Raped men are significantly less likely to report the incident than women.
You have no evidence gay men pose a risk of rape the same way allowing men to shower with women would.

Rape is a crime of violence and includes a power difference factor. If anything, there is a long history of men committing violence against gays, not the other way around. In prisons, where there is a risk of male rape, it isn't thought to be an issue of homosexuality, it is one of power.

Date rape is probably on the continuum of more sexual and less violent than stranger rape. I don't know enough about the psychology of date rapers. But if you want to argue gays date rape other men, I'd like to see some evidence, not just a claim it happens and gay men don't report it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom