Lily the Muppet Loves Free Food

For the most part, in the libertarian 19th century, it was reality.

Once again, in no way a response to what was said.

I'm sorry, but you're really going to have to get the hang of this dialogue thing if there's to be any meaningful communication.

what we have at the moment is many people asking questions and raising points that you can't deal with (and not just because you're not being spoon fed them one at a time) and you picking up your keyboard and effectively answering 'Wibble' to all of them.

Can you please try to respond to the text you've quoted rather than random, slilghtly cryptic sounding but ultimately meaningless sentences.
 
"All" is a three letter word and very specific.
All of whom. We do not know even what a special interest is in the labyrinth of your neural processes. The only group that we know we can list among those you irrationally hate are teachers.

And yes, your hatred is irrational.
 
Robert Prey said:
I only answer questions or respond to comments one point at a time.

Since you can't focus on more than one thing at a time when providing a response, but were able to provide 9 points on your own I wish to call BS and state that you make a poor choice wrt actually creating a dialouge. That being said, lets look at your idea of repealing the minimum wage laws and my earlier response.

So you feel that, in areas were there is low employment and the options available to persons for employment are limited that employers should be able to pay people less than a living wage because something is better than nothing? Minimum wage laws are a reflection that people need to be able to feed and clothe themselves from their labour.

Lets work with a not to unreasonable scenario:

Town A is on the shores of a large inland lake. It is a small town and the industry is set up around the inland fishery.

The fishery collapses suddenly (could be for enviromental reasons, overfishing, etc.) and the town is now running around 50% unemployment. Company x comes in to set up a lumber mill to take advantage of the nearby rail line and large stands of white pine. Seeing the large potential workforce and having no pesky government regulations like minimum wage laws, working hours etc and very little opportunity for this workforce to move to better paying jobs elsewhere, the company offers a wage of $5/hour. Since there is no unemployment insurance, the fishermen look at their families, the growing pile of outstanding bills and take the jobs. Unfortunately for them, living costs in this area will run them at least $10/hour. The company won't budge as they know that there are still a lot of people in the labour pool available willing to take any work at nearly any price and there is only minimal mobility options available to the workforce (it's just too expensive to move a family). Misery in Town A is still high, just not as high as before.

Profits for Company X will allow a higher wage, but the company won't move on that, as it would reduce potential dividends.

Why should there not be a means to ensure that workers are paid a living wage?
 
General welfare is where everyone generally benefits. Roads, bridges, military. courts, etc. Obviously.


What about public education? Public libraries? Public transportation? Public health departments? Is there no value to the general welfare if the citizens all have a certain basic level of income and health?
 
What about public education? Public libraries? Public transportation? Public health departments? Is there no value to the general welfare if the citizens all have a certain basic level of income and health?

It seems that Mr. Prey thinks that only certain people should have these things.

He's on record saying he feels that public education is brainwashing children with liberal ideals. So no Public Education. So, if one can afford it, you go to private school (A proper conservative christian one, I imagine), and all other children go to work.

He does not agree with minimum wage, wanting the USA to return to a 19th century economy.

It would stand to reason he is also against public transportation and health.
 
Solandra.

Uh-huh?

So that is all you are going to explain how facism is an economic system?

Yeah. Colour me unimpressed. What does a genus of nightshade flowers have to do with explaining the concept that Mussolini created an economic system as opposed to a political ideal with a financial policy?
 
And government needs to get rid of its biggest source of income?


What's the source for saying it's the biggest source of income (federally)? According to this PDF file by the GAO, in the fiscal year 2010 this was the breakdown of federal government revenues:

Individual income tax and withholdings: $1,732.9 billion
Corporation income taxes: $179.6 billion
Unemployment taxes: $45.2 billion
Excise taxes: $71.6 billion
Estate and gift taxes: $18.8 billion
Customs duties: $25.1 billion
Other taxes and receipts: $127.5 billion
Miscellaneous earned revenues: $15.8 billion
Intragovernmental interest: $195.0 billion
 
Uh-huh?

So that is all you are going to explain how facism is an economic system?

Yeah. Colour me unimpressed. What does a genus of nightshade flowers have to do with explaining the concept that Mussolini created an economic system as opposed to a political ideal with a financial policy?

Bobby won't anwer because you've asked two questions!

I think I know whay he doesn't like teachers. Given his track record for answering multiple questions, Mom and Dad were probably called for parent-teacher consults more than most parents.
 
With the absence of all income taxes up the food chain, food might very well cost less, not more even with a hefty 23% Fed. Sales Tax.

So it "Might" cost less (after being increased by almost 1/4). Do you think ALL goods and services will lower their costs when "income" tax is removed, even though the independant layers of the foodchain are subject to "corperate" tax not individual "income" tax? Even the ones produced outside of the US? For real?

Let's assume you are right: You have massively devalued the dollar, and dsent prices into free fall. You have now crashed your stockmarket. Oh yes, AND applied a 25% tax on the items, which are not covering your deficits as that 25% of value is much less than anticipated.

Compounded with this your population can have their wages cut to bellow the cost of living as you have removed the minimum wage, and an increasing share of your population is going to be illiterate and unemployable as you expect them to work.

You are now paid less money than you can live on, the prices are about to skyrocket to compensate for the free fall, and you can no longer expect your children to eat because you can't get any help feeding them.

This is meant to make you richer...how?

The reality will be this: Wages will be cut, prices wont be cut to compensate for the lack of tax further down the line, because hey, if you paid a dollar yesterday, you will pay a dollar today, and if it doesn't go to the taxman, it goes as profit. At BEST costs maybe streamlined to "absorb" the VAT added on the shop floor.

And bare in mind I already live in a country with VAT, so have seen it happen, and have seen the costs adjust to rise in VAT.
 
Last edited:
What's the source for saying it's the biggest source of income (federally)? According to this PDF file by the GAO, in the fiscal year 2010 this was the breakdown of federal government revenues:

Individual income tax and withholdings: $1,732.9 billion
Corporation income taxes: $179.6 billion
Unemployment taxes: $45.2 billion
Excise taxes: $71.6 billion
Estate and gift taxes: $18.8 billion
Customs duties: $25.1 billion
Other taxes and receipts: $127.5 billion
Miscellaneous earned revenues: $15.8 billion
Intragovernmental interest: $195.0 billion

My mistake, got carried away. However, taken with the other taxes Mr. Prey wants eliminated (income tax), that would eliminate the two highest sources of government revenue. And I don't think that his idea of a sales tax is gonna cut it to make up the balance.
 
Bobby won't anwer because you've asked two questions!

I think I know whay he doesn't like teachers. Given his track record for answering multiple questions, Mom and Dad were probably called for parent-teacher consults more than most parents.

He didn't answer the one question any way. Or at least not in a way that makes sense to a sane person.

This is not an explanation of why he thinks facism is an economic system:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solandra

I assume an honest response should have been:
Oh arsebiscuits! I don't actually know what Facism! And now I'm supposed to explain it as an economic theory? What the hell? "A highly nationalistic political ethos that emphasises militarism and totalitarianism?" I suppose I could point out that part of the ethos is a massive boost to industry an self sufficient factories, but those are a means to an end rather than a core belief, and are not the defining attributes of the system! Oh bugger it I will just say the first thing that comes into my head as I have no actual answer to give and refuse to admit I was wrong! That will make me sound big and clever and...Solandra!
 
Still waiting for a distinction between Obama Marxism and FDR Socialism.

Or, if he has the stones, an admission that his understanding of these concepts are vague and he mainly is speaking out against excessive government meddling and taxation. Which is a perfectly legitimate point of view and would get him a lot more thoughtful responses than all this nonsense about socialism, Marxism, and taxation-theft.

But, that would require actually making an argument on the issues, instead of just being able to point to the other side and associate them with evil.
 
Last edited:
Government control over Product, Price, Profit Margin, and People.

As you are only describing SOME parts of the Facist Ethos, that are not exclusive to facism, that would be a political ethos with an economic policy then, as opposed to a economic system. Profit Margin, by the way, is not considered part of the facist ideal. Limitations are placed on who can make a profit, not how much. So you couldn't even get it right... Sheesh.
 
I also note a lack of nightshade flowers in Roberts revised answer. I wonder if he will apologise for blatant rudeness?
 
Still waiting for a distinction between Obama Marxism and FDR Socialism.

Or, if he has the stones, an admission that his understanding of these concepts are vague and he mainly is speaking out against excessive government meddling and taxation. Which is a perfectly legitimate point of view and would get him a lot more thoughtful responses than all this nonsense about socialism, Marxism, and taxation-theft.

But, that would require actually making an argument on the issues, instead of just being able to point to the other side and associate them with evil.

Both are socialist, statist, anti-liberty. Beyond that is worthy of a book, not a blog. Obama's policies are both fascistic and socialistic.
 
It seems that Mr. Prey thinks that only certain people should have these things.

He's on record saying he feels that public education is brainwashing children with liberal ideals. So no Public Education. So, if one can afford it, you go to private school (A proper conservative christian one, I imagine), and all other children go to work.

He does not agree with minimum wage, wanting the USA to return to a 19th century economy.

It would stand to reason he is also against public transportation and health.


Details, details.
 
Since you can't focus on more than one thing at a time when providing a response, but were able to provide 9 points on your own I wish to call BS and state that you make a poor choice wrt actually creating a dialouge. That being said, lets look at your idea of repealing the minimum wage laws and my earlier response.



Lets work with a not to unreasonable scenario:

Town A is on the shores of a large inland lake. It is a small town and the industry is set up around the inland fishery.

The fishery collapses suddenly (could be for enviromental reasons, overfishing, etc.) and the town is now running around 50% unemployment. Company x comes in to set up a lumber mill to take advantage of the nearby rail line and large stands of white pine. Seeing the large potential workforce and having no pesky government regulations like minimum wage laws, working hours etc and very little opportunity for this workforce to move to better paying jobs elsewhere, the company offers a wage of $5/hour. Since there is no unemployment insurance, the fishermen look at their families, the growing pile of outstanding bills and take the jobs. Unfortunately for them, living costs in this area will run them at least $10/hour. The company won't budge as they know that there are still a lot of people in the labour pool available willing to take any work at nearly any price and there is only minimal mobility options available to the workforce (it's just too expensive to move a family). Misery in Town A is still high, just not as high as before.

Profits for Company X will allow a higher wage, but the company won't move on that, as it would reduce potential dividends.

Why should there not be a means to ensure that workers are paid a living wage?

Supply and demand. If there is an over supply of labor, then wages must fall. If wages are too low for anyone to work, then no one will work and wages must rise to attract labor.
 
My mistake, got carried away. However, taken with the other taxes Mr. Prey wants eliminated (income tax), that would eliminate the two highest sources of government revenue. And I don't think that his idea of a sales tax is gonna cut it to make up the balance.

Others, who, unlike you, who have thoroughly researched the issue, would disagree.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom