Lily the Muppet Loves Free Food

Sounds like LBJ's Great Society War on Poverty of 50 years ago. What he didn't get, and what you and your Amen Chorus of lefties don't get, is when you subsidize something, you only get more of it. Econ 101.

You know there are countries in the world that don't give anything to their poor, don't subsidize schools and don't spend money on food programs. We call them "third world." All first world countries offer these simple subsidies.
 
Which is to say we are biting our nose to spite our face. Humans flourish more in a healthy and vibrant society. It's like the broken window theory of law enforcement (not to be confused with the broken window economic fallacy). A healthy society reinforces social health and reduces anti-social behavior. It works to everyone's benefit. So even if you don't care abut the poor. It's still good for you to help them.

Funny how the "broken window" theory worked so well in cleaning up Times Square and revitalizing the economy but the wingnuts' response to helping the destitute is "redistribution of wealth!"

But seriously: A campaign that tells poor people where they can get money to help 2 to 8 year olds healthy food is evil because...? Who does not want a 2 to 8 year old to be able to eat healthy food?

The same people who view anything that doesn't benefit them directly as "redistribution of wealth!"

Robert Prey said:
Go work at a food bank for a day. They always need volunteers and you'll have first hand experience with Americans who are facing food insecurity.

Ever seen anyone there who isn't overweight?

So Robert, spend much time at food banks? :rolleyes:
 
Funny how the "broken window" theory worked so well in cleaning up Times Square and revitalizing the economy but the wingnuts' response to helping the destitute is "redistribution of wealth!"
A.) I'm not sure what you mean by cleaning up Time Square or what it has to do with redistribution of wealth. B.) Redistribution of wealth is a rhetorical device and I would argue a straw man. By your logic the military is the redistribution of wealth. So what? It's not an argument.
 
You know there are countries in the world that don't give anything to their poor, don't subsidize schools and don't spend money on food programs. We call them "third world." All first world countries offer these simple subsidies.

Yeah, well it sure wasn't that way in the good OLD USA that I grew up in. Peanut butter and jelly or baloney sandwiches made by mother, paid for by father, and no government handouts. That's how it used to be, before one sixth of the country became "poor" due to the LBJ and the subsequent Lefties, War on Poverty.
 
Yeah, well it sure wasn't that way in the good OLD USA that I grew up in. Peanut butter and jelly or baloney sandwiches made by mother, paid for by father, and no government handouts. That's how it used to be, before one sixth of the country became "poor" due to the LBJ and the subsequent Lefties, War on Poverty.

are you actually starting to believe your rhetoric?
 
Interesting! So if you subsidize education, you'll get more education and a smarter populace? And if you subsidize universal health care, you'll get more doctors and more people getting access to them? And if you subsidize green energy, you'll get a better environment? And if you subsidize mass transit, you'll get more ways to travel for less money? What a wonderful defense of liberalism you've just offered. Thank you!

Whoooahh what a lot of Lefty Shakin' goin on. When you subsidize education, you get government approved education -- lowest common denominator education, dumbed down education and how to put a condom on a cucumber education from grade 5, and two mommies or two daddies education from the first grade, but alas few engineers. And when you subsidize health care you get all kinds of people demanding every possible freebie, because it's "free." And when you subsidize "Green Energy" you get yellow as in Lemon energy, which cannot work economically unless subsidized with funds stolen from taxpayers, and when you subsidized mass transit, you get empty trains, over paid unions, and lots of crime. And that's what liberalism is really all about.
 
Yeah, well it sure wasn't that way in the good OLD USA that I grew up in. Peanut butter and jelly or baloney sandwiches made by mother, paid for by father, and no government handouts. That's how it used to be, before one sixth of the country became "poor" due to the LBJ and the subsequent Lefties, War on Poverty.
And of course, there were no starving children. At least, you never saw any in your sanitized, segregated little world where mommy and daddy always took care of you and never let you see any bad stuff.
 
Whoooahh what a lot of Lefty Shakin' goin on. When you subsidize education, you get government approved education -- lowest common denominator education, dumbed down education and how to put a condom on a cucumber education from grade 5, and two mommies or two daddies education from the first grade, but alas few engineers. And when you subsidize health care you get all kinds of people demanding every possible freebie, because it's "free." And when you subsidize "Green Energy" you get yellow as in Lemon energy, which cannot work economically unless subsidized with funds stolen from taxpayers, and when you subsidized mass transit, you get empty trains, over paid unions, and lots of crime. And that's what liberalism is really all about.

But wait, now I'm confused. You said when you subsidize something you get more of it. And you said this was Econ 101. So if this is true, then if you subsidize something awesome, you'll get more of that too. Which is great!

But then you go and say it's not true, after all. If you subsidize education, you end up with less education? Isn't that the opposite of having more?

I don't get all this fancy conservatism. It's way over my head.
 
Yeah, well it sure wasn't that way in the good OLD USA that I grew up in. Peanut butter and jelly or baloney sandwiches made by mother, paid for by father, and no government handouts. That's how it used to be, before one sixth of the country became "poor" due to the LBJ and the subsequent Lefties, War on Poverty.

Where in the USA did you grow up? And when? I grew up in the USA, and there were subsidized school lunches back then - in the 50s. Fifteen cents got you a hot meal with milk and a dessert. The kids who brought bologna sandwiches were the ones who were well off.

In my years, the principal's office had a little bucket of coins on the secretary's desk so that anyone could come in and without losing face, say, "I lost my lunch money" and the they'd give us the money. There were a couple of weeks when I "lost" my lunch money four days out of five. Sometimes even fifteen cents was too much to come up with when things were really bad.

Moved to Memphis from New Orleans in '62 - lunch was a quarter. From Memphis to Tulsa - lunch was still a quarter in '63 and '64. Every state in the country had internal devices to get subsidized state and federal produce, canned goods, and particularly dairy and bread. It didn't seem so wrong back then. What's changed, Robert?

And how's that search for hungry people going? Have you made it down to any of the foodbanks, shelters, Sally Ann? I think you've been looking for quite some time, now. Call me a cynic, but I'm beginning to wonder if you're really sincere in wanting to find those people at all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom