Left-Right politics as a predictor of AGW stance

http://www.nature.com/neuro/journal/v10/n10/abs/nn1979.html

Because liberals are more likely to perceive the world in shades of grey?



Political scientists and psychologists have noted that, on average, conservatives show more structured and persistent cognitive styles, whereas liberals are more responsive to informational complexity, ambiguity and novelty. We tested the hypothesis that these profiles relate to differences in general neurocognitive functioning using event-related potentials, and found that greater liberalism was associated with stronger conflict-related anterior cingulate activity, suggesting greater neurocognitive sensitivity to cues for altering a habitual response pattern.
 
I'm skeptical. How about an example or two?
http://www.canadafreepress.com/index.php/article/4153

In 1998, the Calgary Herald quoted then Minister of the Environment for Canada, Christine Stewart, as saying:
“No matter if the science is all phony, there are collateral environmental benefits… Climate change provides the greatest chance to bring about justice and equality in the world.

Tim_WirthWP:
http://article.nationalreview.com/424508/climate-gtterdmmerung/the-editors
We’ve got to ride the global-warming issue. Even if the theory of global warming is wrong, we will be doing the right thing — in terms of economic policy and environmental policy.

Richard Bendick, State department official and environmental official under Clinton:
"A global climate treaty must be implemented even if there is no scientific evidence to back the greenhouse effect


I've seen several other statements like that over the years. Certainly they haven't been common, but I would imagine that most people who are of the same mindset as Madam Stewert above are smart enough to not say as much using their outside voice.
 
Why is there such polarisation / correlation between political leaning and opinion on climate change? To the extent that knowing somebody's political stance is a remarkably good predictor of their stance on global warming? The only half-decent explanation I have seen is the affect heuristic (people believe what suits them).

Any other reasons?

(My suggestion is that this thread should not be about science)

I see others have said this, it is not about right vs. left, twenty years ago I was a sceptic of AGW, now I am not. I am still a leftist.

Now if I got my science from Glenn Beck and Rush Limbaugh, that would change things.
 
The left leaning scientists where I work are more likely to believe in AGW where as those of us that are middle or more conservative dont.
That has changed since Climategate however.;)
I also think that the conservative scientists have a more rigorous approach to science.

I totally believe in helping people and saving the environment. Reducing emissions(electric or aether power) etc. Get rid of oil.
Flowers and rainbow ponies for everyone.

But at the same time I am a gun owning motorcycle riding music playing college educated fool.... And I think AGW is BS. As is the IRS and the FED.

As educated person, and applying the scientific method, I do not think that every parameter has been taken into account in modeling the earths climate system. Complex models are notorious for that.

Data has already been shown to be "wanting" as well as their method!!
 
I see others have said this, it is not about right vs. left, twenty years ago I was a sceptic of AGW, now I am not. I am still a leftist.
Your own case notwithstanding, are you in disagreement that there is a pretty high correlation between political leaning and AGW views?

If you agree about the correlation, do you think it is a total fluke?

Ideas about why it is not a total fluke are the subject of the thread
 
Planks of party platforms are chosen for political reasons. Many are reactive to what the opposing part does. One party is pro something, the other party HAS to be anti.

My own distinction between the parties is : Democrats = emotional, Republicans = logical.

From the Dems, we get "think of the CHILDREN!" and "Poor people are going to drown !!!". From the Repubs we get "What is it going to cost?"

I've always thought that the two parties were on the wrong sides of gun control and abortion. Poor people SHOULD have the right to protect themselves, and the "think of the children" clause of the Dems ought to make them anti-abortion. But you know the old saw: "Politics makes strange plank fellows".
 
Lefties generally see AGW as a way to spread the wealth around.

However, those who i have meet who are extremely opposed to pollution, industrialism, modernity and etc, are actually far-right semi fascist.
Strange but true.
 
My own distinction between the parties is : Democrats = emotional, Republicans = logical.

Well, that's probably because you're easily manipulated. Both parties play on people's emotions, especially fear. In the case of Republicans, there's been virtually no cost-benefit analysis in the area of "defense." Those who do apply cost-benefit scrutiny to global warming are relatively middle-of-the-road because conservatives are in denial on the science. Then there's the added problem of taking people seriously in the economic policy/reaction phase after they have conducted themselves so dishonestly (or ignorantly) in the science phase.
 
Your own case notwithstanding, are you in disagreement that there is a pretty high correlation between political leaning and AGW views?

If you agree about the correlation, do you think it is a total fluke?

Ideas about why it is not a total fluke are the subject of the thread

I understand but then I live in the US where the politics of belief in evolution are mind boggling. I think that people who rely on infotainment lack the knowledge to make an informed decision. But compared to the politics of homophobia this seems to be minor.
 
Planks of party platforms are chosen for political reasons. Many are reactive to what the opposing part does. One party is pro something, the other party HAS to be anti.

My own distinction between the parties is : Democrats = emotional, Republicans = logical.
Except for Ben Stein and Expelled and the whole anti-evolution movement, the homophobia platform and the 'the US is a Christian country where religion is under seige' mentality.
That is totaly emotional.
 
Planks of party platforms are chosen for political reasons. Many are reactive to what the opposing part does. One party is pro something, the other party HAS to be anti.

My own distinction between the parties is : Democrats = emotional, Republicans = logical.

From the Dems, we get "think of the CHILDREN!" and "Poor people are going to drown !!!". From the Repubs we get "What is it going to cost?"

I've always thought that the two parties were on the wrong sides of gun control and abortion. Poor people SHOULD have the right to protect themselves, and the "think of the children" clause of the Dems ought to make them anti-abortion. But you know the old saw: "Politics makes strange plank fellows".

What world do you live in?

Republicans logical?

Remind me again, which party hyped the "death panel" lie about Obama´s health care reform?

Which party is way more receptive to creationism and general religious idiocy?

Which party seems absolutely convinced that homosexuality is a bad thing?

Which party did the administration belong to that was described by one of its members as "not a fact-based administration"?

And so on...

You´d have an easier job convincing me that Jerry Falwell is an atheist than that the Republicans act based on logic.
 
My own distinction between the parties is : Democrats = emotional, Republicans = logical.

People who deal in facts and logic tend to be democrats.

for example only 12% of scientists identify with Republicans
http://people-press.org/report/?pageid=1549
When the leanings of independents are considered, fully 81% identify as Democrats or lean to the Democratic Party, compared with 12% who either identify as Republicans or lean toward the GOP.
 
If you look just beneath the surface you can see why there is a political divide on the global warming issues. Inconvenient truth is pretty close representation of the reason.

The left (at least in this country) has a tendency to believe environmental protection is an important value. On the right, environmental protection is more likely to be seen as unnecessary, costs jobs, interferes with individual freedom and property rights and so on.

There is a philosophical divide that results in a political divide along those philosophical lines. From there it's just a matter of filtering the facts to fit your philosophical view.
 
Some suggest, with good reason, that this [increased CO2] may be a boon to humanity, increasing the amounts of farmland and the rate at which plants grow thanks to increased CO2. And now, a theory: Said benefits must be denied because that interferes with the use of environmentalism as memetic argument to control big business. That's a theory right there. Pay attention to observations to see if it plays out, or has been for years.

Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

What if scientists actually experiment on plants with increased CO2 and find out they don't do so well?

http://researchnews.osu.edu/archive/co2plant.htm
http://www.logicalscience.com/skeptic_arguments/CO2-fertilization.html
http://www.claremontclimatereport.com/2010/01/co2-increase-benefits-invasive-plant.html
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1200/is_n2_v146/ai_15624446/
 
Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

What if scientists actually experiment on plants with increased CO2 and find out they don't do so well?

Get out of here with this "experiment" nonsense and let's talk about real science.
 

Beerina is channeling Jerome Da Gnome:
Thank you Chaos, I have been saying that the questions should be

1) Is the climate changing? (Yes the evidence is very strong that it is warming)
2) Is this going to have an adverse effect? (Yes, crops and population infrastructures can't move as quickly as the climates, especially if it with national borders)
3) Do we know what humanity can do to reduce this, even if it is "natural"? (We have some ideas, and the most obvious one is to reduce emissions of greenhouse gasses).

I think the evidence is also strong that this warming period isn't just due to natural variataion, but even if it were, so what?



You do know that plants grow better with more CO2 and heat, yes?

Your point #2 is stupid bordering on retarded.



:irule:13:

What happened to the Australian wheat harvest last time it was very hot? (clue: there was also a drought).

Plants need water too.

If the deserts moved further away from the equator, to be replaced by rainforest, how will that help people whose cities and farmland starts degrading? The consequent mass migration across national boundries is likely to cause unrest and war.

There are many studies on the effects of CO2 on plants, but it is not as simple as you make out.

The point was that if nothing else happened, the fertile regions would move, and people would try to follow them, causing new land conflict.

And water conflict.

As I said: adverse consequences.
 
Get out of here with this "experiment" nonsense and let's talk about real science.

The real effect of increasing CO2 on plants is like any other change - it upsets the ecology. You increase the number of red ants in a field, the number of other insects goes down; plants don't get pollenized; mice can't find their favorite fodder, and ferrets go extinct. Same for CO2 - A little extra might be beneficial for any plant, but too much invites disease to dig in like never before and suddenly you are plaged with snakes. And the plants, in the end, suffer from the upset.

Ecologies are as tuned as species are on the planet. No disturbance is good, and something this basic can be as bad in the short (hundreds of years) term as hunting wolves to extinction.
 
It's basically because of the Republican platform:

1. The Christian right: (anti-science. For instance: Here in Kansas, we actually have to teach evolution as a "contraversial" subject (whatever that means)). This is where they get their popular support.

2. Large corporations: (anti-environmentalist. -- because they would like to use previously made factories without greening them up, which costs money -- also anti-tax, but nevermind that here). This is where they get money for advertising.

I don't think it's so much a personal view for the people in question, as the view they must maintain in order to get elected.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom