Left-Right politics as a predictor of AGW stance

Someone's been reading a little too much Ayn Rand. If you could just drag this straw-man out 1253 more pages you might just have a best seller/ cult classic on your hands!

Daredelvis

You have yet to suggest how it is incorrect.
 
I think there is a definite correlation. And it isn't just AGW. You see in other sciences too, such as evolution. On these matters it has been the conservative establishment that for some reason has made it a plank position, regardless of what the scientific institutions are saying. This is not to say all conservatives are anti-science, just that in the vast pool of uneducated unscientific Americans, a political faction such as the conservative movement, has taken a particular policy position on these matters of science. There are always outliers in individuals, but the official institutional line is clear.

I think you are conflating two different effects. It's no surprise religious fundamentlists are also politically conservative. So those who believe the world is 6000 yo or who reject evolution or the copernican view are likely to vote conservative. These aren't I think mainstream conservatives. The Jerry Falwells may have some votes, but they are not contributing to the platform except in a negative sense of nailing an anti-abortion plank to the candidate's political baggage.. More like a crazy uncle they try to keep out of sight. Also note that both parties give nod to the religious; AFAIK there has never been a US Pres candidate who was openly non-religious, agnostic, atheist. The Dems have their fringe groups too, tho' not as easily characterized. I don't believe that AGW is part of any religious fundamentalist text - so it shouldn't be subject to that effect.

“Conservatives are not necessarily stupid, but most stupid people are conservatives.” - John Stuart Mill

As much as I agree with your dismal view toward political conservatives, the liberal political side seems to have rejected the scientific method at least as vigorously as conservatives. "The debate is over" talk shows a complete disdain for rational skepticism. The idea that a consensus of scientific opinion is a meaningful measure of anything is not only anti-scientific but logically fallacious since it includes an appeal to authority and a argumentum ad numerum. Nowhere in the scientific method do we take a vote; a preponderance of evidence is required, not a preponderance of opinion. When it comes to taking action the liberals seem incapable of a rational plan. There is no cost-benefit analysis to some of the radical-change agendas proposed. Nuclear power is the clearest way to reduce CO2 emissions and yet it is rejected without consideration by the left, based presumably of environmental problems. They pin their hopes on solar panels and wind which are clearly currently unfeasable except as marginal cost-ineffective additions, and ignore the environmental problems, PV cadmium for example.

Well, I don't think many people have seriously considered this issue on either side of the political spectrum. People simply accept the position of "opinion leaders" within each party. Few people I've met actually understand the science beyond newspaper headlines or talking points.

I very much agree. But oddly the same ppl who have never looked into the matter and/or who do not have the credentials, are precisely the ones who are certain the AGW is true without a shred of doubt. It is a type of "faith" to them.

Also, although the science is pretty solid on AGW (certainly the dangers of releasing immense quantities of previously sequestered Co2 is understood)

My only correction to your post - it isn't "understood" in a meaningful sense. Yes higher CO2 levels will create some clear changes in plant growth and Ocean pH etc, at last a marginal increase in temps, but the climatic impact involves numerous systems that are not adequately modeled.

-- there is also a political agenda behind AGW. For example, errors in the IPCC report, such as Himalayan glaciers disappearing by 2035, et al., ALWAYS error on the side of global catastrophic. The reason given by the IPCC is perhaps understandable--they say they wanted to affect political change ... they wanted to force politicians to act before it's too late.

The two things I absolutely hate to hear from any governmental body are fear-mongering and war-mongering. Both use the same basic methods and lead to no good end. Orwell thought the state would create a perpetual state of war, but instead it has created a perpetual state of fear.

Perhaps the scientists should let the science speak for itself. It seems to me scientists hurt their cause whenever they try to mix politics with science: It gives the anti-science crowd fodder to make hay with.

But it's NOT just the anti-science crowd, it's the pro-science crowd too.. Anyone interested in an impartial explication of the case should be very unhappy with the involvement of politics in science. If you are aware of political involvement and this does not cause additional skepticism about the results, then you are not thinking critically. Please read this scathing, understated and short report from the UK Inst of Physics on the East Anglia email debacle.
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200910/cmselect/cmsctech/memo/climatedata/uc3902.htm


IMO the most vocal climate deniers tend to be Libertarians who tend to drag the other conservatives along as they frequently get their information from the same places.

I think this is because global warming represents a problem that needs government action to solve and is caused by failure to regulate. This challenges the fundamental Libertarian world view and as a consequence they need to either change their core beliefs or deny there is a problem.

Because of your frame of reference YOU view the problem as regulatory therefore YOU only see solutions by government enforcement. Unless you answer what force will keep a poor rural 3rd world family from burning twigs and dung to keep warm, what force will cause a poor urban 3rd world resident from working at a coal fired plant to have a better life and what force will prevent increased use of fossil fuels in China for example - then you don't have any solution. Yes you might be able to temporarily create a harsh tyrannical government that forces ppl to act against their immediate self-interests, but it probably won't last and I certainly won't support it. Shall we bomb China's coal mines to enforce your "regulation" ? Heck we can't get the Japanese to stop killing whales nor the Iranians & N.Koreans from building A-bombs and you think we are going to convince several billions to "regulate" themselves to live colder and poorer by not using fossil fuels - that's insane !

Your political view that goverment regulation is the solution doesn't apply to this problem. We require a technical solution. Can we develop clean(er) competitive energy sources scalable for the 3rd world use ? Can we sequester atmospheric CO2 effectively ? Can we reduce the planet's albedo by lofting SO ? ...

The US, EU and Japan can afford to cut their emissions the costly ways, but this doesn't solve the planetary problem, and does create a more intrusive government.

Yes I understand that liberals are technophobes and can't tolerate the idea of a practical solution that involves steps like human controlled albedo, or nuclear power, with fuel reprocessing. They would prefer an all powerful central government that tells me that I can't use more than 6L of water to flush my toilets - despite I live in a region with vast access to fresh water. Or the EPA tells me that I can't burn trees fallen in my woodlot unless I spend gallons of fuel cutting then into small lengths and burning them in a "firepit" or campfire. The unadulterated lunacy of the one-size-fits-all solutions of a central government.

Such as when libertarians, paultards and similar cranks predict the collapse of everything under the sun if government is not immediately abolished?

Such as when militant anti-environmentalists predict total ruin, should even the least bit of environmental protection legislation be enacted?

Such as when Republicans predict "mushroom clouds of American cities", should they not be allowed to use the constitution and the bill of rights for toilet paper?

Your bias is showing when you omit the DemTards anti-nuclear power pro-PV stand. Their elevation of Healthcare to top priority in the middle of a major recession. Their massive stimulus spending bill which is sitting in reserve for an election year to act as spoils for select candidates. Their several attempts to use the returned TARP funds as tho' this was some new source of income instead of an IOU. Also Saint Omaba's signing of the Patriot Act renewal last week (the very bill that turns the Constitution & BoR into TP). Quit being so blind to your own side's stupidity. They are all acting equally foolishly.

Those predictions above aren't proposed as scientific theories, as opposed say to Algore's erroneous scare-claims about climate which were.
 
Last edited:
The idea that a consensus of scientific opinion is a meaningful measure of anything is not only anti-scientific but logically fallacious since it includes an appeal to authority and a argumentum ad numerum. Nowhere in the scientific method do we take a vote; a preponderance of evidence is required, not a preponderance of opinion.

This bespeaks a fundamental misunderstanding on your part about what science is and a fundamental misunderstanding on your part about several specific logical fallacies.

First the fallacy. Appeal to authority is a perfectly legitimate argument form. It does, however require the person actually be expert in the field and be saying something that experts in the field generally do not disagree on. IOW it’s valid if and only if you are referencing a real scientific consensus.

Second, consensus is the ultimate product of science, it’s the strongest thing science ever produces. Yes, it’s possible for consensus to be wrong, but only because it’s possible for science to be wrong. This possibility can never be removed because the scientific process itself doesn’t prove things.

Nuclear power is the clearest way to reduce CO2 emissions and yet it is rejected without consideration by the left, based presumably of environmental problems. They pin their hopes on solar panels and wind which are clearly currently unfeasable except as marginal cost-ineffective additions, and ignore the environmental problems, PV cadmium for example.

Please get your facts straight. Nuclear power is actually quite a popular response to global warming. Among those who regularly challenge denier woo on these forums, I’m possibly the only one who doesn’t favor it and my objections come from the fact I do not see it as being as practical as wind/solar with a backbone DC transmission grid.



Because of your frame of reference YOU view the problem as regulatory therefore YOU only see solutions by government enforcement.

Are you claiming to read minds? Who are you to try and define what my frame of reference is?

To the issue of regulation, there is no known solution to a problem of externalities that does not rely on outside intervention. but modern Rand influenced Libertarianism is heavily based on the principle that externalities can’t occur and consequently they deny them at virtually every turn, Climate science is merely one such example.
 
....modern Rand influenced Libertarianism is heavily based on the principle that externalities can’t occur and consequently they deny them at virtually every turn, Climate science is merely one such example.
Ya think?

Do you think we have lots of "Rand influenced Libertarians" posting in warming threads here? Or even one? I don't think so.
 
This is a huge, huge, huge surprise.

The problem, again, is that right-wingers are fundamentally opposed to government interfering the sacred free-market. How do you argue against a principled faith?

In order to get Republicans behind the issue you have to point to enemy, a bad guy, the villain. If you can figure out a way of making that China, then you have a fighting chance.

Beerina's the equivalent of a lapband informercial claiming electrical pulses will you give a defined stomach. People buy that **** even knowing it "probably won't work." Anything that gives them an excuse to stay away from diet and exercise.

Global warming is a huge problem because there's a lag effect, world-wide free-rider/collective action problem, big business interests, influential intractable ideologues, and the fact that the most burdened victims have not yet been born. Screw everyone else, lets party!
 
.....
Global warming is a huge problem because there's a lag effect, world-wide free-rider/collective action problem, big business interests, influential intractable ideologues, and the fact that the most burdened victims have not yet been born. Screw everyone else, lets party!

Yes, the victims are not yet born to whom the debt of trillions based on AGW scams with no real world import would be carried.

That lag effect is real.

And so yes, with the trillions not wasted, we could proceed to either handle real human problems, or party.
 
Last edited:
Why is there such polarisation / correlation between political leaning and opinion on climate change? To the extent that knowing somebody's political stance is a remarkably good predictor of their stance on global warming? The only half-decent explanation I have seen is the affect heuristic (people believe what suits them).

Any other reasons?

(My suggestion is that this thread should not be about science)

Affect heuristic is probably a very good explanation for the majority of people's beliefs regarding AGW, as well as confirmation bias. Very few people actually go out and do meaningful research on the issue themselves, so their opinions are informed as much by their philosophical outlook as anything else.

Generally, increased government control (intervention | regulation) of the economy is desired by members of the left and opposed by members of the right. The worse AGW turns out to be, the greater the need for government intervention in the economy to restrict CO2 output (in fact, it would be extremely vital for the survival of civilization as we know it, according to some of the outlier predictions). I've read statements from leftist politicians that even if the science is wrong, AGW (or more specifically, the fear of AGW) is our best chance to implement "social justice". I've also read statements (primarily from conservative or libertarian pundits) about how government intervention into the economy is worse than any likely climate outcome.

And then there are people like Bjorn Lomborg, who approach the issue from a pragmatic angle. He believes the mainstream view of global warming but largely disagrees with the remedies, and yet he is referred to as a denier. I would imagine that most "average Joes" fall somewhere between the extremes, with many people being pragmatists.
 
I've read statements from leftist politicians that even if the science is wrong, AGW (or more specifically, the fear of AGW) is our best chance to implement "social justice". I've also read statements (primarily from conservative or libertarian pundits) about how government intervention into the economy is worse than any likely climate outcome.
Such comments are pretty honest, and should be expected as part of rational political debate. However, they tend to be substituted with "AGW is settled truth" or "AGW is a lie" instead of what you've written.


ETA--Or more subtly the arguments can be as follows:

R: AGW is unproven yet the left carry on as though it was proven, so their policy proposals are built on dishonesty as well as being misguided

L: AGW is unproven, yet the right carry on as though it is false, so their policy proposals are built on dishonesty as well as being misguided
 
Last edited:
Just a quick reply to stevea,
If you look at the major conservative vs liberal establishments, you'll see that anti-science planks (as would be perceived the Great Randi) are much more on the fore front of the major conservative institutions. And by major I mean those that come up when you follow the money in DC.
 
Leftists tend to think of society first.
Righties tend to think of their own well being and their family's well being first.

(this is using the most recent study on the topic)
What study is that? I ask because I'd question it.

A Friedman libertarian thinks of society as a whole but in a utilitarian view. They look at AGW as a risk v. reward scenario.
This is a bit of an aside but I can't recall Friedman arguing along utilitarian lines, unless you mean the whole doing good by doing well theme.
 
Personally, I see it (AGW ideology/morality) as the latest progression through a series of failed attempts for (philosophical) materialism to render human life meaningful via material adjustments.

Communism (salvation through socio-political class equality)
Feminism (salvation through sexual equality)
Political Correctness (salvation through individual racial/cultural/physical equality)

Radical Environmentalism (salvation through biological equality)

It stands to reason that the most promising of these schemes will be chosen first. So the further we go down the path, the more ridiculous it gets. We seem to have reached the point where it's legitimate for society to punish its members and morally bully them for not having put the correct item of refuse in the correctly coloured bin.

I know that wasn't really your question Francesca, but these movements have been more on the left than the right, the reason being that the left has always been more philosophically materialist than the right. The right tends to leave more avenues open for derivation of human meaning.
 
I've read statements from leftist politicians that even if the science is wrong, AGW (or more specifically, the fear of AGW) is our best chance to implement "social justice".
I'm skeptical. How about an example or two?
 
You, who brought it up, has to prove it is correct. If you were a skeptic, you´d know that.

Very well, it would predict a similar thing if and when this gets shot down, in another arena, as the left moves on to another memetic rationale to control hated big business. Fair enough?
 
BTW, this demand for proof by the left is in very short supply when asked of their own pet projects. :rolleyes: Still, I await acknowledgement of the above before I proceed.
 
modern Rand influenced Libertarianism is heavily based on the principle that externalities can’t occur and consequently they deny them at virtually every turn, Climate science is merely one such example.

Ya think?

Nope. The above is a fraudulent claim akin to "doctors are in the back pocket of Big Pharma and that's why they don't do herbs and Homeopathy! :mad:"


Oh, wait. Externalities. Another thing the Left has latched onto to memetically support their control of hated big business.

QED.



Back to more fun. Libertarians, and economists, for that matter, realize government can harm productivity, and that that can outstrip the problems that are being "solved" by regulation. You've failed in "first, do no harm".

This is not hot air, but the result of actual measurements of the quality and longevity of life. Hot air is not involved, which is something many "skeptics" around here, on the left, forget when they enter /politics.

No libertarian says regulation of common thing is beyond the purview of government -- after all, what's the libertarian mantra?

Anyone? Anyone? Bueller? Bueller?

It's do what you want with your own body and things as long as it doesn't affect other's property. Affecting the air, or a large, shared body of water, is definitely not something you can do freely.

And having said that (not that anyone's still reading) we should be cautious with regulations. People lived longer, choking and gagging in newly-industrialized London, than they would without industry*.









* "Oh, but we can do better and stop the choking and gagging when we detect it!" Can you? Or can you just crush industry? They managed to effortlessly crush industry in communist countries while still leaving it grotesquely polluting. You need the power they bring (and the attendant improvements to life) before you can dream of cleaning anything up.
 
Last edited:
I've read statements from leftist politicians that even if the science is wrong, AGW (or more specifically, the fear of AGW) is our best chance to implement "social justice".
I'm skeptical. How about an example or two?
Actually I don't think I've seen that argument either. I was thinking of a (completely) different one which is the precautionary principle which I have seen a lot more on the left as a justification.

I wrote an essay on AGW in 1994 (although it was more often called the greenhouse effect then) as part of my chemistry BSc where I invoked that in the conclusion, but since then I've changed my mind about its beneficial force.

IMO to his credit, Anthony "The Third Way" Giddens also rejects the precautionary principle in The Politics of Climate Change
 
Last edited:
Very well, it would predict a similar thing if and when this gets shot down, in another arena, as the left moves on to another memetic rationale to control hated big business. Fair enough?

Fair enough would be if you would provide evidence for your statement - instead of simply repeating your claims.

Fair enough would also be if you finally, after all those years, stopped ignoring the evidence everyone else provides which contradicts your beliefs.
 
BTW, excuse me if I regard comments such as "The [left/right]* hold their position because they understand the truth, whereas the [right/left]* hold theirs because they are gullible/evil/stupid" with a high degree of scepticism. But those statements are--at least--corroborative of the OP proposition.

*either way round.
 
Such comments are pretty honest, and should be expected as part of rational political debate. However, they tend to be substituted with "AGW is settled truth" or "AGW is a lie" instead of what you've written.


ETA--Or more subtly the arguments can be as follows:

R: AGW is unproven yet the left carry on as though it was proven, so their policy proposals are built on dishonesty as well as being misguided

L: AGW is unproven, yet the right carry on as though it is false, so their policy proposals are built on dishonesty as well as being misguided

“settled truth” is an overly broad generalization. That said, there are some things that can reasonably be considered settled.

AGW is a subject where the scientific literature is incredibly one sided. The political debate that is occurring is really a discussion about whether to accept the conclusions being presented in the scientific literature.

Now, looking to the scientific literature in order to make conclusions on science isn’t or at least should not be considered something associate with either left or right. In this case, however there is a strong political effort on the right to reject scientific literature as the basis of “sound science”. This tends to leave the left championing the literature by default.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom