Killtown's new "smoking gun" for flight 93, debunked

oops too late

Killtown's latest analysis is classic, right up there with adding mph and ft:

http://z10.invisionfree.com/Loose_Change_Forum/index.php?showtopic=1924

:jaw-dropp

Killtown, consider yourself lucky that JREF members didn't see this and that I'm going to be nice enough not to point this out to them. This is, to be generous, definitely not one of the smartest things you've said.

This is a graph of elevation. It says absolutely nothing of the horizontal distance that the airplane travels, thus it's really dumb to think that you can figure out the angle of travel based on this.

THINK about this, Killtown. Would you agree that an object traveling at 1 million miles an hour aimed 1 degree downward would hit the ground faster than an object released at the same elevation and is allowed to fall freely? Because it would. The vertical component of distance can't tell you anything about the angle at which the object is traveling.
 
Just done a few calculations. Something is seriously wrong. I assume the graph is altitude measured in feet (0 - 40,000 feet). The horizontal line is seconds. The time period is 30 seconds.

The graph suggests the plane went from 40,000 feet to 20,000 feet in 5 seconds. My calculations suggest this is impossible. It would be descending at 2,727 miles per hour. This does not include the horizontal velocity.

Can somebody take another look and tell me what the right answer is please?
 
Just done a few calculations. Something is seriously wrong. I assume the graph is altitude measured in feet (0 - 40,000 feet). The horizontal line is seconds. The time period is 30 seconds.

The graph suggests the plane went from 40,000 feet to 20,000 feet in 5 seconds. My calculations suggest this is impossible. It would be descending at 2,727 miles per hour. This does not include the horizontal velocity.

Can somebody take another look and tell me what the right answer is please?
im pretty sure the horizontal is minutes not seconds
 
Thanks. Now I understand my error.

Just as an aside, in LC a long time they were saying the plane was too high up for cell phones to work. The graph shows that the plane was only about 3km (1.5 miles up) for nearly 10 minutes before the crash. This would be easily low enough for ordinary cell phones to work.
 
Thanks. Now I understand my error.

Just as an aside, in LC a long time they were saying the plane was too high up for cell phones to work. The graph shows that the plane was only about 3km (1.5 miles up) for nearly 10 minutes before the crash. This would be easily low enough for ordinary cell phones to work.
As far as I'm aware only one call was made from a cell phone on Flight 93 and that was by Edward Felt who was in the rear lavatory at the time. All the other calls were made from AirFone. Edward Felt called 911 on his cell phone at 9:58am and the plane crashed at 10:06am which is consistent with what you just said about the altitude of the plane at the time.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom