Killtown's new "smoking gun" for flight 93, debunked

It boggles the mind..........


So if it shows the area prior to any destruction and this is photographed after the 11th then is the entire town of Shankesville in on the cover-up? Those who heard or saw anything and reported that it occured on the 11th would have to have been coerced somehow to declare that it occured on the 11th rather than afterward while knowing that the world press would be desending on their town shortly.

Kt gets deeper into the mud with every convoluted procalamtion.
 
Good point.
It was made nation wide for all civilian aircraft at 9:25 on Sept 11.

I found two different dates for the lifting order, Sept 13 and Sept 14 BUT I seem to recall that it was lifted first for helicopters which could mean that they were in the air on Sept 12.

I have not caught up all the way on this tread; but;

I flew on 9/12 and 9/13 but I was military.

The police flew! I do not see why law enforcement could not use any asset and fly on 9/12.

The police followed up on my flight at an FBO when I got gas. I was flying a light aircraft.

The CAP flew blood products all over the US, since commercial flights were grounded and could not do the vital service. (Civil Air Patrol)

You would have to check up the other flights; but as I said a small police plane flew in after I gased up to make sure I was good to go and it helps I had my military flight plan etc.
 
Thanks Cl1mh4224rd and welcome to the forum. Here is your post with the links fixed.

(edit: D'oh. I can't post links yet, but I believe citing my sources is important, so I had to mangle them slightly. Sorry. :( )

How far away from Shankesville is the home town for WTAE?
WTAE is a local news channel in my area. They're based in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.

According to Google Maps it's about an 80 mile drive from Pittsburgh to Shanksville. Probably about 70 miles as the crow flies.

Beyond that, though, the man seen in that image is not a reporter; it's then-Governor of Pennsylvania, Tom Ridge1. The first time he visited the site, according to an article dated September 19th2, seems to be September 20, 2001:

Attorney General John Ashcroft is scheduled to visit the crash site with FBI Director Robert Mueller and Gov. Tom Ridge on Thursday.
...although I may be wrong about that. Finding past articles on their site is a real pain.

--
1 According to the alternate text attached to the exact same image in a slideshow on WTAE's website: http://html.thepittsburghchannel.com/sh/slideshow/_auto/sh1364s13.html (Note: There's also some pictures of debris that I haven't seen before.)

2 http://thepittsburghchannel.com/news/966339/detail.html
 
Last edited:
Thanks Cl1mh4224rd for the heads-up about that being Tom Ridge.
Here's what I have just found:

http://www.post-gazette.com/headlines/20010912crashnat2p2.asp
Day of Terror: Outside tiny Shanksville, a fourth deadly stroke

Wednesday, September 12, 2001

[...]
Yesterday, the priority of the FBI and state troopers was to protect the scene.
[...]
Gov. Tom Ridge arrived about 6:15 p.m., flying over the crash scene in a National Guard helicopter before being briefed on the ground by state police.
 
Last edited:
Is there any point in continuing with this thread? Or starting any thread where Killtown has raised any issues. I think his credibility has just gone out the window. That is, if he had any to start with.
 
Is there any point in continuing with this thread? Or starting any thread where Killtown has raised any issues. I think his credibility has just gone out the window. That is, if he had any to start with.
i dont think KTs credibility is capable of goign out the window, as far as im concerned it was never in the building to begin with
 
I am now dumber for having considered Killtown's "theory" for the brief moment required to dismiss it as ridiculous.
 
Thanks Cl1mh4224rd for the heads-up about that being Tom Ridge.
Here's what I have just found:

post-gazette.com/headlines/20010912crashnat2p2.asp
Ahh, there we go. Thanks.

It's a little unclear to me, though, on which day he actually flew over the crash site; the 11th or the 12th. Either way, though, Killtown's claim makes even less sense. It implies now that it had been either 8 or 32 hours after the crash before "They" set the trees on fire. Slackers.
 
Last edited:
It sounds to me like it might have been at around 6pm on the 11th, when Gov. Ridge visited, based on the newspaper story. All of the other events the writer cited happened on the 11th, and stories are usually published early in the morning on the day they are dated. But, that doesn't mean that he didn't visit by helicopter on the 12th as well, so the photograph could have been taken then. Either way, it doesn't seem to matter.
 
Ahh, there we go. Thanks.

It's a little unclear to me, though, on which day he actually flew over the crash site; the 11th or the 12th. Either way, though, Killtown's claim makes even less sense. It implies now that it had been either 8 or 32 hours after the crash before "They" set the trees on fire. Slackers.

Even Killtown isn't sure:

Now look at this WTAE photo taken from a National Guard helicotper with PA's Gov. Tom Ridge on board that was taken after 6 p.m. on what looks like 9/11. See if you can see the extent of forest damage as in the above aerial or the proceeding aerials


And in an article dated Sept. 12th, we have this:

There were 20 FBI agents on hand yesterday, and another 30 were expected last night. The contingent of 100 state troopers was expected to swell to 150. They planned to spend last night spaced out along the crash perimeter within each other's eyesight to ward off curiosity seekers and prevent anyone from tampering with evidence.

Two curiosity seekers were arrested for trying to get through the perimeter, one of them aboard an all-terrain vehicle.

Also on hand were officials from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, the Federal Emergency Management Agency, the Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency, the Federal Aviation Administration and United Airlines. A team from the National Transportation Safety Board was en route.

Gov. Tom Ridge arrived about 6:15 p.m., flying over the crash scene in a National Guard helicopter before being briefed on the ground by state police.

So I'd say it was taken on the 11th, barring a more definitive statement from those involved.
 
Even Killtown isn't sure:




And in an article dated Sept. 12th, we have this:



So I'd say it was taken on the 11th, barring a more definitive statement from those involved.

Er, Horatius, that was the article I posted. :p ;) I found it on the net, but it is actually in Killtown's blog, I see.

But, yes, I thought it was pretty clear that it states Ridge visited after 6.15pm on the 11th, and the article went to press later that night. It was written to be read on the 12th.

I've posted at Killtown's blog, but he makes so many bad judgements that I just haven't the time or inclination to address them all. I agree with Gravy - he is freakishly stupid.
 
I'm sorry, can you show me what it is you debunked and how you debunked it exactly?

The only thing I seem to conclude is that it is inconclusive to determine whether or not the trees are burnt and if they aren't you proved this pic was taken before the aerial showing them burnt and after the crash.

I think a bunch of adults came together just to concur they all believe Killtown to be "freakishly stupid" while slapping each others high-5's.


I happen to believe that the forest was burnt earlier, but I haven't seen anyone prove KT wrong so for now, I keep the option in my mind that this could be an entirely staged scene created later that night.
 
It is up to KT to post evidence that the offical story is not 100% correct. He has attempted to do that by posting certain photos. However he cannot make up his mind when those photos were taken. Nor do the photos show what KT says they should show.

In short KT has provided no credible evidence.

I am sure others will say more.
 
I have witnessed the results of brush fires in forests immediately after they were extinguished and days afterward. In some fires that extinguish quickly for example an air fuel burst, the brush beneath the canopy will burn but the leaves in the canopy (if the trees are tall enough to escape the brush fire,)will remain for a day or two. Until the canopy dies off from the effects of fire on the lower tree trunks.
 
TC329 - This photo must be taken in context with all the other evidence from that time. Trying to interpret details of one photo out of context is nothing but hot air.
I suspect that KT has gone down this road deliberately. By removing the context and concentrating on a single frame he makes his arguments seem more persuasive
 
I'm sorry, can you show me what it is you debunked and how you debunked it exactly?

The only thing I seem to conclude is that it is inconclusive to determine whether or not the trees are burnt and if they aren't you proved this pic was taken before the aerial showing them burnt and after the crash.

I think a bunch of adults came together just to concur they all believe Killtown to be "freakishly stupid" while slapping each others high-5's.


I happen to believe that the forest was burnt earlier, but I haven't seen anyone prove KT wrong so for now, I keep the option in my mind that this could be an entirely staged scene created later that night.
Have you read the KT thread from the archive?
 
I think a bunch of adults came together just to concur they all believe Killtown to be "freakishly stupid" while slapping each others high-5's.

What you have to remember is, there's a lot of history with KT. Even if he's right about when this particular phot was taken, there's still a lot of other reasons to think he's "freakishly stupid".
 
I'm sorry, can you show me what it is you debunked and how you debunked it exactly?

The only thing I seem to conclude is that it is inconclusive to determine whether or not the trees are burnt and if they aren't you proved this pic was taken before the aerial showing them burnt and after the crash.

I think a bunch of adults came together just to concur they all believe Killtown to be "freakishly stupid" while slapping each others high-5's.


I happen to believe that the forest was burnt earlier, but I haven't seen anyone prove KT wrong so for now, I keep the option in my mind that this could be an entirely staged scene created later that night.

It is thoroughly debunked in that KT reached the conclusion that this photo shows the forest unburned but with the crater already there. From there he determines that the forested area was burned sometime after the supposed crash.
The photo DOES NOT demonstrate that the forest is unburned and thus any conclusions that he arrives at that require the forest to be unburned at the time of this photo are simply not backed up by any evidence whatsoever.

He might as well have stated that this photo demonstrates that monkeys flew out of his butt. Perhaps they did but this photo bears not on such a claim.
 
Killtown's latest analysis is classic, right up there with adding mph and ft:

http://z10.invisionfree.com/Loose_Change_Forum/index.php?showtopic=1924

killtown @ LCF said:
Looks like it's coming down "nearly 90 degs" to me:

flight93altitude.gif

:jaw-dropp
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom