Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Do you think Ahmed stands a good chance of one day becoming an electrician or someone working in a related field? :)

Yes, or especially an engineer. I think this is the kind of life changing moment that will really guide him towards that field. Especially if he has the funding to attend schools like MIT (if he can get in, why not!) That's why I've said GO AHMED!!!:thumbsup:
 
nope


(I happened to see it when you first posted it. Just the random luck of timing.)

Well NOPE but then I was going to spin out again and I don't understand why you can't simply read the actual reason for his suspension. (Although to be fair I don't really know why since his parents won't release the information. I bet the reason they aren't is because it's far more dramatic to keep spinning the hoax bomb angle. People like that story! ;) )


Just like people keep referring to the POP TART GUN story and pretending the kid was suspended because of the shape he ate the poptart.

Even though really he was suspended for ......hmmmm..... what's that policy again...........

"As much as the parents want this case to be about a 'gun,' it is, rather, a case about classroom disruption from a student who has had a long history of disruptive behavior," Nussbaum wrote in his opinion, which was dated June 26, the Washington Post reported. He asserted that the suspension came as a result of disciplinary problems the boy had, and not just because of what he did with the breakfast pastry.

"Had the student chewed his cereal bar into the shape of a cat and ran around the room, disrupting the classroom and making 'meow' cat sounds, the result would have been exactly the same," Nussbaum wrote, according to the Post.


Booooooring. No room for moral outrage in that story!!!!! Let's not talk about the truth and the policies. Nope.



http://www.cbsnews.com/news/examiner-recommends-school-board-uphold-pop-tart-suspension/
 
Last edited:
Well NOPE but then I was going to spin out again and I don't understand why you can't simply read the actual reason for his suspension.


That is indeed a mystery. However, I have read all the revealed school rules and the only one that relates to Ahmed's clock is the "principled rules" (the principle makes the rules) clause I quoted above.

(Although to be fair I don't really know why since his parents won't release the information.


Oh, so you DO understand why I can't simply read the actual reason for his suspension! Because it's not published anywhere! So why did you just write that you don't understand this? Did you mean, above, that you don't understand why I don't simply agree with your wild guesses?

I bet the reason they aren't is because it's far more dramatic to keep spinning the hoax bomb angle. People like that story! ;) )


So the police were called for some other reason? Did Ahmed steal the clock from someone else? The letter to parents the school issued referred to "bringing items to school that were prohibited." No rule prohibited the clock, so what was it? Drugs? "Our Principle is a Racist" signs? Qurans?

*snip irrelevant Pop Tarts comparison
 
The pop tart comparison is NOT irrelevant. It's the same exact thing. People freaking out over a headline and deciding that what they read in the headline (which is all most people read these days) is the gospel truth and there couldn't possibly be any more to his story.

It's clear to me that the reason he was suspended was because of the disruption in the classroom.

That is a totally separate reason from why they called the police.
 
The problem with the "disrupting the classroom" excuse is that it makes anything a teacher overreacts to a "disrupting" offense.

Example: "I don't like that political ribbon you're wearing, Joan. Take it off please."

"No, I have the right to wear it."

"It upsets me to see you supporting a cause I disagree with. Take it off."

"You're not allowed to make me do that."

"All right, I gave you a chance to cooperate, now I'm going to confiscate it."

"That's not allowed either!"

"Yes it is, because we have now spent forty-five seconds arguing about it during my lesson time. That means you're disrupting my classroom and you'll be suspended for it."

Abuse of authority can never be redressed if we always give the authority every benefit of the doubt. That's why we don't. "Disrupting the classroom" is an accusation that can always be made no matter what the actual events were. It therefore is entirely unconvincing.

The classroom disruption ended as soon as Ahmed was able to silence the beeping and return to his seat. That shouldn't have been much different from a cell phone ring tone going off, or any number of other electronic devices present.
 
The problem with the "disrupting the classroom" excuse is that it makes anything a teacher overreacts to a "disrupting" offense.
(much good stuff snipped for brevity)

I find your post disruptively clear and convincing. Please report to the Principal's office and prepare to be arrested.
 
The problem with the "disrupting the classroom" excuse is that it makes anything a teacher overreacts to a "disrupting" offense.

Example: "I don't like that political ribbon you're wearing, Joan. Take it off please."

"No, I have the right to wear it."

"It upsets me to see you supporting a cause I disagree with. Take it off."

"You're not allowed to make me do that."

"All right, I gave you a chance to cooperate, now I'm going to confiscate it."

"That's not allowed either!"

"Yes it is, because we have now spent forty-five seconds arguing about it during my lesson time. That means you're disrupting my classroom and you'll be suspended for it."

Abuse of authority can never be redressed if we always give the authority every benefit of the doubt. That's why we don't. "Disrupting the classroom" is an accusation that can always be made no matter what the actual events were. It therefore is entirely unconvincing.

The classroom disruption ended as soon as Ahmed was able to silence the beeping and return to his seat. That shouldn't have been much different from a cell phone ring tone going off, or any number of other electronic devices present.


Nope. Again you don't understand. If you don't believe me, go pick up a copy of the KAPLAN NYSTCE test prep book for the ATSW and you will find the EXACT question that you have just posted.

Instead of it being a ribbon it would be "black arm bands" protesting Frederick's suspension.

Are you allowed to intervene?

Nope.

But if the same situation kids are walking up the hallways during classes and banging on the lockers

Are you allowed to intervene?

Yes because it disrupts the learning environment.


Your example has nothing to do with what the rule applies to. It means to ACTUALLY disrupt the learning environment. You know like with an alarm clock going off and having the teacher have to STOP TEACHING and try to figure out what is going on. It's got nothing to do with annoying the teacher.

Teachers will often meet students in their experience who express opinions and ideas that offend the teacher.

That's not what it is about. Thanks for proving very clearly that you have no understanding of the rule whatsoever. So it is no wonder that you are completely confused about the protocol.
 
Last edited:
Your example has nothing to do with what the rule applies to. It means to ACTUALLY disrupt the learning environment. You know like with an alarm clock going off and having the teacher have to STOP TEACHING and try to figure out what is going on. It's got nothing to do with annoying the teacher.

I would like to suggest creating a more robust learning environment, one that is less delicately balanced on the razor's edge between strictly predictive and utter chaos.

Imagine if someone farted.
 
I love this thread, mainly because I can ignore it for a couple of days, tune back in on the latest page only, and still read the exact same arguments that I read over a week ago.

Keep it up people, you need to play catch up to the Amanda Knox thread, and there are 10,000's of posts still needed to get there.

Norm
 
Nope. Again you don't understand. If you don't believe me, go pick up a copy of the KAPLAN NYSTCE test prep book for the ATSW and you will find the EXACT question that you have just posted.

Instead of it being a ribbon it would be "black arm bands" protesting Frederick's suspension.

Are you allowed to intervene?

Nope.

But if the same situation kids are walking up the hallways during classes and banging on the lockers

Are you allowed to intervene?

Yes because it disrupts the learning environment.


Somehow, I doubt that when a teacher breaks those rules and lies about it, the KAPLAN NYSTCE test prep book for the ATSW leaps off the shelf and sets things right.

You're arguing based on what the rules are supposed to be. The rest of us are concerned about what actually happened.

Even if your unlikely claim about disrupting the class being the real reason for the suspension is true, the letter that was sent to parents is at the very least disingenuous. If class disruption was the issue, why is the reminder in the letter about non-permitted items rather than about disrupting classes?

Sorry, it just doesn't wash. You know what seems a lot more likely to just about everyone, including the President? That the racist school officials and police officers of a town with known issues of racism profiled the kid and rained **** on him because they're racists, and then made up excuses later.
 
<snip>

Keep in mind we ONLY know what happened on Ahmed's side here and his sisters side. If there was nothing to hide here, and they've already gone full court press to the media, why don't the parents just sign the release forms to allow both the school and the police department to discuss what actually happened?

What's the big deal at this point? Certainly it's not about protecting his privacy?

<snip>


I don't think the cops need a release to make their reports public. In many states they would need a release not to. About the only thing I can think of that would make them balk is if their attorneys thought that something in those reports might provide ammunition should they find themselves the target of a lawsuit.

And if that were the case they would only be delaying the inevitable, since they would almost certainly have to surrender those records during discovery.

Nothing seems to be stopping them from discussing the case, either. At least when they feel inclined to. It isn't like they've gone total blackout.

As far as the kid's parents are concerned, they might be able to provide their okay relating to the kid, but they could not grant permission for the school to release anything about any of the other players involved, which would make the parents release somewhat moot.

Do you think the father's okay is going to be enough to permit the school to open all of their relevant records?

Do you think the school would?
 
Last edited:
I don't think the cops need a release to make their reports public.

From what I understand, the report itself actually is public, but it doesn't say much of anything, just gives the name of the suspect (Ahmed), the complainants (three teachers, from what I read), and the charge (making a hoax bomb).

Records, if any, of the interrogation, are apparently sealed because the suspect is a juvenile. I don't know what is and is not public record for a non-juvenile case. If the police interrogate you, and it's on tape, can reporters get their hands on it? I've seen a lot of footage of such interviews, but they were all associated with a trial, in which they were entered as evidence.

From what I understand, they really are restricted from releasing material.

My guess, though, is that it is very convenient for them if they are, because my guess is that it would show a sullen uncommunicative teenager, and most Americans would note that that isn't illegal, and might even bring up that whole "right to remain silent" issue.

As for why the parents wouldn't sign the release, why should they? There's no real incentive for them to do that and, following up on what you said, it's not likely they would provide all relevant data. They would provide whatever makes them look good.
 
Somehow, I doubt that when a teacher breaks those rules and lies about it, the KAPLAN NYSTCE test prep book for the ATSW leaps off the shelf and sets things right.

You're arguing based on what the rules are supposed to be. The rest of us are concerned about what actually happened.

Even if your unlikely claim about disrupting the class being the real reason for the suspension is true, the letter that was sent to parents is at the very least disingenuous. If class disruption was the issue, why is the reminder in the letter about non-permitted items rather than about disrupting classes?

Sorry, it just doesn't wash. You know what seems a lot more likely to just about everyone, including the President? That the racist school officials and police officers of a town with known issues of racism profiled the kid and rained **** on him because they're racists, and then made up excuses later.


It doesn't wash to you because you don't know what you are talking about. Like I said.

The point about the Kaplan book is that distinction is CLEARLY made, it's made to teachers all the time. It's drilled into their heads.

Not just with regard to situations like this but also other types of situations.

You guys had never even HEARD of the policy and even though I showed you the sources and finally had to go quote the EXACT line over and over and over gain, you still didn't "get it."


You don't understand the policy and the way it is implemented. You con't care that I've explained it several times know. That Ahmed's suspension hasn't been lifted.

You don't care that Ahmed's parents won't allow the school to discuss what happened even though they are spinning their version all over the news.


You don't care that the teacher was acting in the best interests of the safety of the other students until they knew what was going on.


You don't care about AAAAAAAANNNNNNY of that. You've got your outrage and you are "Stickin' to it." Makes a much better "story" to just pretend the facts "ain't true" "don't wash"

Your ignorance on the topic???? Does it concern you???? Does it give you pause to think........well maybe I'm not really understanding the position the teachers or school were in......

NOPE!!!!


Just like racist parents on the OTHER side of the coin aren't going to be willing to listen to what "Really happened." "That is wasn't a bomb or a hoax bomb" That they are jumping to conclusions. "Well maybe I'm not really understanding the situation here....."


NOPE!!!!!!



And that my friends is WHY schools are forced to use zero tolerance policies. And that is why the letter was sent home.


Tah dah!:D
 
Last edited:
"Look-alike weapon" covers the item in that list. I suspected the school had such a condition; I remember very clearly that mine did, but that was some time ago.

That's the closest thing in the list, and the only one that could possibly be applied.

So the question is whether that thing really looks like a bomb.

Actually, it looks like a clock in a pencil box. The only sense in which it looks like a bomb is that Victor-Victoria style "clock that looks like a bomb that looks like a clock."

Nevertheless, an awful lot of people look at it and think "bomb", so it could certainly be said to fit under that list item. My objection to that goes back to the reason for my irritation with this case. It relates to the "anti-geek" thread of conversation. What it looks like to me is some circuit boards in a pencil box. To far too many people, that's weird. That's odd. Why would anyone ever do that? He must be up to no good! And now he won't even answer our questions? Slap the cuffs on him!

The kid got arrested because he made a scary item that people didn't understand, and didn't act normal. And would the same thing happen to a white kid who did the same thing? No one could prove the answer to that question, so I won't go there.

What I will say is that I want young people in America to tinker with electronics, even if lots of people think that's weird.
 
<snip>

Records, if any, of the interrogation, are apparently sealed because the suspect is a juvenile. I don't know what is and is not public record for a non-juvenile case. If the police interrogate you, and it's on tape, can reporters get their hands on it? I've seen a lot of footage of such interviews, but they were all associated with a trial, in which they were entered as evidence.

<snip>


It varies from state to state. A lot.

From California, where a judge can seal everything at a whim until the trial is over, to Florida, whose "Sunshine Laws" verge on draconian, and a judge had better be able to articulate a detailed explicit reason for any record he allows to be kept from the public once it is no longer "part of an active investigation" (virtually the only tool cops have to withhold any information they have collected.)

This includes any interrogation records and even (as seen in the Casey Anthony case) tapes from surveillance cameras in the jails.

Juvenile records get a little more restraint perhaps, but the cut-off is when anything is released to defense attorneys as part of discovery, at which point it becomes unquestionably part of the public record, and therefore mandatory to release.

This is one of the reasons media outlets love Florida cases. They can get their hands on every tidbit. Their zeal resulted in one of the rare exceptions carved out by legislative statute, the [Dale] Earnhardt Law, which allowed autopsy pictures to be withheld from the press.

I'm not sure where Texas in particular stands on the public records spectrum.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom