Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

I wonder if the kid will rethink his ethnicity now. It's not too late to choose differently.

If he went with African Armenian instead, he wouldn't be accused of having a fake bomb, but they might investigate him for stolen property. Australian might work. Then he'd just get harassed for damaging a perfectly good clock. But if he's gonna be a techie, I'd pick Japanese. Chinese might get a charge of trying to steal technology.

It's tough to be a kid.
 
I wonder if the kid will rethink his ethnicity now. It's not too late to choose differently.

If he went with African Armenian instead, he wouldn't be accused of having a fake bomb, but they might investigate him for stolen property. Australian might work. Then he'd just get harassed for damaging a perfectly good clock. But if he's gonna be a techie, I'd pick Japanese. Chinese might get a charge of trying to steal technology.

It's tough to be a kid.

It seems like his ethnicity has served him very well so far, so I wouldn't recommend a change. African Armenian is an interesting choice though. He might be the only one in the world.
 
True

But understanding is clearly seen. If you see people blathering all over the place, bringing things up like

JUST SHOW ME THE ONE LINE

You show them the one line and then they spin off to argue something else, then you can tell they are not really trying to understand something AT ALL.

:)

Indeed. Understanding, or lack of it, is clearly seen.


When discussing a prohibited items policy, if someone quotes something from a policy about disrupting class, it is very clear whether or not someone has understood.





You seem to be taking the position, now, that Ahmed was suspended because he disrupted class. That may very well be true, and if that is your current position, I don't know how you would know that, but I certainly wouldn't dispute it. I'm not particularly interested in the particular subject. He certainly wasn't arrested for disrupting class. No teachers are required to call police if someone disrupts class. Using an item to disrupt class is irrelevant when determining whether that item should ever be in school, Period the end. Perhaps you are no longer interested in any of those other topics, preferring instead to focus on Ahmed's disruption of class when his clock alarm went off during English class.

However, his alarm going off in English class is a different issue from the contents of Texas Education Code Chapter 37, which is itself not relevant in the context in which it was raised, which is also not related to anything that would require a teacher or principal to call the police.

Someone, indeed, is "spinning off to argue something else", but I don't know who you had in mind. It certainly isn't me.

Just in case all this spinning off is confusing, I'll reiterate the position I've taken before, and will take again. It consists of several statements, all related.

Ahmed should not have been arrested.
Ahmed's clock did not violate any school policy. (To your more recent statement, Ahmed was responsible for disrupting class when the alarm went off. That's a separate issue. I don't find it very interesting, although others might.)
No policy required them to call the police. They were required to call the police if they suspected a crime had happened or student safety was in jeopardy. However, they were not required to be suspicious. Furthermore, any suspicion that they did have was based on a mistake on their part. Calling the police was not a terrible, unforgivable mistake. Indeed it was a common, perfectly understandable mistake, but it was a mistake. Or more accurately, believing that the conditions existed that required them to call the police was a mistake.
After the police investigation, the school should have admitted their error, and encouraged Ahmed to continue to build gadgets and indeed, bring them to school. Instead, they implied that him bringing the gadget was a violation of the rules.
 
Last edited:
You've shared your opinion several times. I just don't see what it has to do with ANYTHING being discussed in the case.

I have an opinion that it's wrong that people can serve in the military at age 18 but can't legally drink until they are 21 years old.

If we are discussing a story about a bar tender who refused to serve a 20 year old Army guy, and called the cops on him for making a scene, my OPINION on the LAW is irrelevant.

The bar tender followed the law. Maybe calling the cops was a bit much. But the bar tendered followed policy.

If the cops took the Army guy outside and roughed him up, it's GOT NOTHING TO DO WITH THE BARTENDER

The bar tender followed policy and the law.


You want to put forth your OPINION of the entire situation, well go ahead. I just think it's completely stupid and irrelevant to do so.

You want to start a thread debating whether or not the law is right, or the policy is right, well knock yourself out and go for it. That's a different discussion.

As it stands now, regardless of your "opinion" on the policy, the school followed policy (except for the first teacher)

The teacher followed policy
The principal followed policy

The kid was suspended and the suspension was upheld.

I'm not sure what you think your OPINION on this has to do with anything?:boggled::boggled::boggled:


It is quite clear you don't understand how the policy of "disturbing the learning environment" is used. So your confusion and debating a law you obviously just glanced at for a few minutes, is quite amusing. Carry on. I'm sure someone will be interested in discussing your misconceptions with you. :)
 
Last edited:
Quite possibly.

He demonstrated initiative, expressed an interest in electronics, and was bullied because of that.
My guess is that Zuck has some experience with that.

None of the people sticking up for the kid are doing it based on the quality of his work.


The highlighted portion is what I have a problem with. I don't know for certain that he didn't deserve the attention he got. It sounds like he was warned by another teacher, ignored that teachers advice and actually set the alarm and plugged it in during class, and he was somewhat uncooperative with police.

I think it's 50/50 whether or not he built a hoax bomb. Maybe it was just as a goof and he didn't mean to cause such a stir, but we're talking about a 14 year old teenage boy - they do these types of things sometimes.

I don't think it's a given that he was bullied or that the reaction was inappropriate, or that he is entirely innocent in this. Schools do overreact a lot (in the news anyways) so it's certainly possible that they did so here.
 
You've shared your opinion several times. I just don't see what it has to do with ANYTHING being discussed in the case.

I have an opinion that it's wrong that people can serve in the military at age 18 but can't legally drink until they are 21 years old.

If we are discussing a story about a bar tender who refused to serve a 20 year old Army guy, and called the cops on him for making a scene, my OPINION on the LAW is irrelevant.

The bar tender followed the law. Maybe calling the cops was a bit much. But the bar tendered followed policy.

If the cops took the Army guy outside and roughed him up, it's GOT NOTHING TO DO WITH THE BARTENDER

The bar tender followed policy and the law.


You want to put forth your OPINION of the entire situation, well go ahead. I just think it's completely stupid and irrelevant to do so.

You want to start a thread debating whether or not the law is right, or the policy is right, well knock yourself out and go for it. That's a different discussion.

As it stands now, regardless of your "opinion" on the policy, the school followed policy (except for the first teacher)

The teacher followed policy The principal followed policy
The kid was suspended and the suspension was upheld.

I'm not sure what you think your OPINION on this has to do with anything?:boggled::boggled::boggled:


It is quite clear you don't understand how the policy of "disturbing the learning environment" is used. So your confusion and debating a law you obviously just glanced at for a few minutes, is quite amusing. Carry on. I'm sure someone will be interested in discussing your misconceptions with you. :)



Removed the most irrelevant bit.

The highlighted bit - where in the policy did it say that the school needed to call the police? Given that the school did call the police, why did the police arrest Ahmed? Anyone competent could see that it was missing the fake explosives that a fake bomb would need. It looked like a clock - Ahmed said it was a clock. The simplest explanation is that the rest was just prejudice.

One might have a discussion about whether he deserved praise or a disciplinary sanction for showing a teacher something he made, but he didn't deserve to be arrested.

Still, I can begin to see part of the problem, having seen the attitude people involved in training US teachers.
 
I found a wonderful illustration of the concept of "bombiness" that some people think this kid was trying to evoke/invoke in some way. Greek artist Petros Efstathiadis.

"The bombs I create (and then photograph) are harmless and absurd. They are made out of soap, flowers, light bulbs or sponges. In fact, my bombs are made only to undermine the concept of bombs."

https://www.lensculture.com/articles/petros-efstathiadis-bombs
 
Last edited:
Apparently the application of the policy in this case rests entirely on the "Any articles not generally considered to be weapons, including school supplies, when the principal or designee determines that a danger exists" clause.

Contrary to claims that zero-tolerance policies eliminates bias and racism, the principal "or designee" appears to have free rein to apply as biased or racist judgments as he or she feels like, without contravening the written policy.
 
Apparently the application of the policy in this case rests entirely on the "Any articles not generally considered to be weapons, including school supplies, when the principal or designee determines that a danger exists" clause.

Contrary to claims that zero-tolerance policies eliminates bias and racism, the principal "or designee" appears to have free rein to apply as biased or racist judgments as he or she feels like, without contravening the written policy.


Yes. But it's protocol.

That's the important thing.

:rolleyes:
 
Removed the most irrelevant bit.

The highlighted bit - where in the policy did it say that the school needed to call the police? Given that the school did call the police, why did the police arrest Ahmed? Anyone competent could see that it was missing the fake explosives that a fake bomb would need. It looked like a clock - Ahmed said it was a clock. The simplest explanation is that the rest was just prejudice.

One might have a discussion about whether he deserved praise or a disciplinary sanction for showing a teacher something he made, but he didn't deserve to be arrested.

Still, I can begin to see part of the problem, having seen the attitude people involved in training US teachers.


The school had to call the police over the suspicious nature of the device. In other words. (as I have said ad nauseum in this thread) they did not KNOW what it was.

Period. Protocol.

Second I love how you just disregard the example I gave above when it clearly demonstrates that the behavior of the POLICE is not the responsibility of the school.

Why it is so hard for people to grasp this EASY distinction is beyond me. Part of it is because I guess most of you just are cynical towards any type of protocol or rules. Fine. Be that way. Hate the rules. Hate the laws.

But when they are not followed teachers and administrators can be penalized, suspended or even lose their jobs. That's because PARENTS and people are who are not educators, treat teachers with zero respect and jump all over the place freaking out without knowing what actually happened.

Keep in mind we ONLY know what happened on Ahmed's side here and his sisters side. If there was nothing to hide here, and they've already gone full court press to the media, why don't the parents just sign the release forms to allow both the school and the police department to discuss what actually happened?

What's the big deal at this point? Certainly it's not about protecting his privacy?



ETA At this point I'm just spinning in wheels repeating information over and over again and new people are chiming in quoting me directly and asking me to reply.

I'm not going to reply to any direct question that I've already answered several times over by now. I'm drained. Go read if you have an issue.

I've posted the rules, protocols, Education Code of Texas, simplified charts that explain things and it seems like no one is even reading them. Or perhaps because I've actually studied these protocols for years they just seem super obvious to me already.

But I'm only going to reply if I find the post new and interesting. Have a great discussion. :)
 
Last edited:
I think it's 50/50 whether or not he built a hoax bomb. Maybe it was just as a goof and he didn't mean to cause such a stir, but we're talking about a 14 year old teenage boy - they do these types of things sometimes.

I think it's possible, except.....

If there's no arrest, there's no real story here. The reason this case grew to where it did is the photo of Ahmed in handcuffs.

That's important because of the meaning of "hoax bomb". We don't throw people in jail because they make devices that look like bombs. Such a device, by itself, is not a hoax bomb. It becomes a hoax bomb when someone employs it in such a way it is intended to make people think it is a bomb.

When Ahmed pulled it out of his backpack and said, "Look at my clock." it became something that was not a hoax bomb.


What it still could have been was some sort of bomb themed prank, or perhaps a deliberate political statement, in which he made a clock, but just scary enough that he knew someone would freak out about it, so he could say, "Look, look, I'm being oppressed!" I don't have any real evidence that that happened, but I wouldn't dismiss the possibility. Nevertheless, that is not a crime. He went out of his way to make sure that he told his teacher that it was a clock. The idea that it was a hoax bomb might be more credible if anyone at all actually believed it was a bomb.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom