Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

I guess this is what confuses me.

I get the concern over a bombing hoax. When I was in grad school, it was common for the police to get bomb threats on nights of big exams.

But this kid wasn't actually claiming it to be a bomb, or doing a bombing hoax! He never left it sitting in a discrete place, or pretended it was a bomb.

Nor was he sneaking around; as I understand he had it plugged into a wall in the English class. Maybe I'm wrong, journalism ain't what it use to be.
 
No you interpreted it that way. I based it on the information given in the details of the report. Not other peoples outrage posts on line.

He carried it around with him. The engineering teacher told him not to show it to the other teachers. Anyone with half a brain can see how if then those same other teachers confronted him on it he would pull back and not be forthcoming as his own comments show.

His Engineering teacher is the one at fault here. Why in the world would you tell him that he should be sneaky about it instead of treating it like a science project....

whatever..... go on in your rage frenzies. Explanations and reasons and logic never seem to make a dent around here anyway.
:rolleyes:

He didn't voluntarily show it to another teacher without being asked according to the article: it was in a briefcase in English class when he plugged it in and it made a noise. That is what attracted the English teacher's attention.

So who, he or the teachers and police, have half a brain? If you see wires around a circuit board, you might ask what it is, but to assume it is a bomb? No wonder Radio Shack declared bankruptcy!

What was he supposed to say once he told them (correctly) that it was a clock project? And how happy would you be if a whole bunch of adults suddenly demanded even more answers of you because they thought it could be a (fake) bomb, most likely because of your skin color and religion, and put you in handcuffs? Clearly the engineering teacher was right because of what actually happened.

Anyway are you suggesting that a 14 year old may lack somewhat in mature, deep, and calm thinking skills when detained and suspended because a bunch of authorities think you are a terrorist because you built a clock?

This post is based entirely on the news article you claim to have read.
 
Last edited:
GyFFS, truethat.
It wasn't the STEM teacher, it was the English teacher that told him not to show it (and then confiscated it) after the alarm part rang during class.
 
Does this remind anyone of the TV show Mayberry where Barney the deputy was so incompetent that he was allowed to have a gun only if he kept the single bullet in his shirt pocket? Sounds more true to life than I ever suspected.
 
The passive aggressive accusation seems to come from the kid simply disagreeing with the cops. The accuse him of making a hoax* bomb, and he replies that he only intended for it to be a clock.

That is not passive aggressive in my book, but I know people who would think that it is. As far as they are concerned, the kid needs to agree with Law Enforcement every time. It does not matter if the kid is right and the police are wrong.

The cops perhaps don't understand what a hoax actually is. They seem to think that if it looks like a bomb to some, it must be a hoax, regardless of the kid's intentions.

*just for fun, I like to image the police here talking in a very strong redneck accent, and saying "hoax" with two syllables: "Wut we got here is a hoe-axe! Deys tryin to pull one over un us, but wees to smart fur dat!""
 
Last edited:
I stand corrected then. But this article states that the English teacher is the one that confiscated it


http://www.dallasnews.com/news/comm...ted-after-taking-homemade-clock-to-school.ece

The point is, THAT is the person who caused this whole mess. Not Ahmed and not the other teachers.

He came to school eagerly showing off the clock and the first teacher told him not to show it to anyone else. THAT is the person that caused the misunderstanding.

It's understandable that if the teacher says to him (Don't show this to any of your other teachers!) They have now shifted it from a clock to something ominous and this would most likely be reflected in the child's demeanor if then later those same "other teachers" asked him about it.

A. If there was a problem with it, the first teacher should have taken care of it right then, not tell the student to be secretive about it.

B. If there wasn't a problem with it, the teacher should have encouraged the student to show the other teachers and the issue would have been avoided.

All this ranting and raging is unreasonable. It was a series of misunderstandings. I can't fault the school for their original confusion.

I do think that the police reaction was absolutely over the top. (I've already stated this but of course no one is bothering to read it)


And again the passive aggressive comment is referring to his original demeanor with he first teachers who asked him about it. I'm sure the schools first reaction wasn't to throw up the bat signal and call the cops.
 
Last edited:
Nor was he sneaking around; as I understand he had it plugged into a wall in the English class. Maybe I'm wrong, journalism ain't what it use to be.

That doesn't make sense. It looked like it was run off a 9v battery from the pictures I saw. No 110 VAC plug
 
The passive aggressive accusation seems to come from the kid simply disagreeing with the cops. The accuse him of making a hoax* bomb, and he replies that he only intended for it to be a clock.

Disagreeing with a cop with that skintone? People get hurt bad for that.
 
The passive aggressive accusation seems to come from the kid simply disagreeing with the cops. The accuse him of making a hoax* bomb, and he replies that he only intended for it to be a clock.

That is not passive aggressive in my book, but I know people who would think that it is. As far as they are concerned, the kid needs to agree with Law Enforcement every time. It does not matter if the kid is right and the police are wrong.

The cops perhaps don't understand what a hoax actually is. They seem to think that if it looks like a bomb to some, it must be a hoax, regardless of the kid's intentions.

*just for fun, I like to image the police here talking in a very strong redneck accent, and saying "hoax" with two syllables: "Wut we got here is a hoe-axe! Deys tryin to pull one over un us, but wees to smart fur dat!""
Of course he was being passive aggressive: he denied it was a fake bomb despite the cops telling him otherwise.

On thinking more about it, I am surrounded by fake bombs. My flashlight alone has wires, an enclosure, and batteries that look a lot like the dynamite sticks depicted on TV. And my car is actually a real bomb, I guess, because it actually is wired to make explosions (a few hundred or thousand a minute at idle).
 
I kind of agree with this. Seems the most rational approach than all the screaming meemees flipping out like there wasn't a reason to be concerned.

I think the kid was probably passive aggressive and I kind of wonder if he didn't bring it to school on purpose just to cause a scene.

Regardless the handcuffs are ridiculous and over kill.


As the mom of a Muslim Arab son who is also interested in Engineering I can tell the kid was interested, my kid had a room filled with things like that.

But several questions.

A. Why bring it to school in a little suitcase like that?

That was the box he could use to mount the LED numbers. And to protect the electronics during transport.


B. Why bring it to school at all?

Story specifies this. He was proud of what he did, and wanted to show his engineering teacher.

C. Why did the engineering teacher tell him not to show it to the other teachers. The teacher should have stepped in right then, not told him to be sneaky about it. It probably contributed to him keeping his mouth shut instead of coming forward about it if his favorite teacher said that to him.

The teacher likely saw it might cause a problem. Kid wasn't being sneaky. He had it in his backpack. Which kids use to transport items to and from school.

D. What part of Zero tolerance don't parents understand. It's zero tolerance for a reason. While I agree the arrest and hand cuffs were over the top, the suspension isn't. It's not the worst thing in the world to get suspended from school. Parents need to get over it.

I wasn't aware there was a zero tolerance towards clocks.
 
Of course he was being passive aggressive: he denied it was a fake bomb despite the cops telling him otherwise.

On thinking more about it, I am surrounded by fake bombs. My flashlight alone has wires, an enclosure, and batteries that look a lot like the dynamite sticks depicted on TV. And my car is actually a real bomb, I guess, because it actually is wired to make explosions (a few hundred or thousand a minute at idle).

Have to be careful! My wifes R2D2 has wires in it! A BIIIG battery to power it! And it's remote controlled! Might be a bomb!
 
I would suggest the Science teacher told the kid not to show the clock to anyone else because he was concerned that one of the boy's class mates would think it was funny to wreck his hard work.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom