Karen - Stop!

LOL

I post two links clearly defining Karen as a term applying exclusively to Middle aged white women. You ignore the first, then repost an edited version of the second.
Then you accuse me of dishonesty. Priceless.

Yes, your own sources made clear that the term is not used the way you describe. To continue to make that claim while your own sources contradict you is dishonest.
 
Another part of the type, missing from those quotes, was about joining pyramid schemes to sell things like essential oils or allegedly slimming plastic body wraps... but I haven't seen it used for that one lately.

* * *

I must dispute the quoted sentence that claims that it has been increasingly used for disapproval of middle-aged white women without any reference to behavior. I've seen no examples that weren't legitimately brought on by bad behavior. The problem is not that the word is detaching from its behavioral meaning; it's simply that it remains attached to the demographic meaning. The fact that we have a word to criticize such behavior in one demographic group and not other demographic groups is bad enough by itself, even with the behavior still being a prerequisite.
 
Wasn't the Central Park Karen with the dog a Clinton supporter?
 
It seems like the concept of Karen means different things to different people. Perhaps we should reflect upon Karenity, contemplate, and seek guidance from the manager within.
 
Another part of the type, missing from those quotes, was about joining pyramid schemes to sell things like essential oils or allegedly slimming plastic body wraps... but I haven't seen it used for that one lately.

* * *

I must dispute the quoted sentence that claims that it has been increasingly used for disapproval of middle-aged white women without any reference to behavior. I've seen no examples that weren't legitimately brought on by bad behavior. The problem is not that the word is detaching from its behavioral meaning; it's simply that it remains attached to the demographic meaning. The fact that we have a word to criticize such behavior in one demographic group and not other demographic groups is bad enough by itself, even with the behavior still being a prerequisite.
Perhaps it is an entirely innocent word detached from its beginnings describing behavior.
Like "thug", it is not a racist or sexist term at all- and simply a descriptor of someone acting a certain way. In fact, "thug" has more legitimate cover than Karen does.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps it is an entirely innocent word detached from its beginnings describing behavior.
Like "thug", it is not a racist or sexist term at all- and simply a descriptor of someone acting a certain way.

And like "thug", it can be used in a racist and sexist way. Lots of words--if not most of them!-- can.
 
I see.
An example perhaps of "Karen" being used innocently?

(Excluding, of course, referring to someone actually named Karen)

I'd say using "Karen" in the original context, that of people making frivolous complaints and overreacting to the response in a customer-service situation, is innocent:

"What do you MEAN I have to pay extra for more honey mustard packets?! GET ME THE MANAGER, YOU'RE ALL GOING TO BE FIRED!"
"Okay, Karen!"

Non-innocent usage would be trying to dismiss a woman on something because she happens to be white with a bad haircut:

"Excuse me, that's my dog you're kicking."
"Shut up, Karen!"
 
I'd say using "Karen" in the original context, that of people making frivolous complaints and overreacting to the response in a customer-service situation, is innocent:

"What do you MEAN I have to pay extra for more honey mustard packets?! GET ME THE MANAGER, YOU'RE ALL GOING TO BE FIRED!"
"Okay, Karen!"

Non-innocent usage would be trying to dismiss a woman on something because she happens to be white with a bad haircut:

"Excuse me, that's my dog you're kicking."
"Shut up, Karen!"
In this example, is the person being called "Karen" a middle aged white woman (apparently)?
 
In this example, is the person being called "Karen" a middle aged white woman (apparently)?

In the latter one, yes. In the former one, maybe. Those who confine "Karen" remarks to behavior are perfectly willing to apply it to men, people of different ethnicities, and a variety of ages. Because everyone can be a Karen if you define Karen by behavior rather than physical characteristics.
 
In the latter one, yes. In the former one, maybe. Those who confine "Karen" remarks to behavior are perfectly willing to apply it to men, people of different ethnicities, and a variety of ages. Because everyone can be a Karen if you define Karen by behavior rather than physical characteristics.
I see.
Following that line of reasoning, there is nothing racist about referring to a black man as a "thug", provided he has engaged in some brutal behavior.

You be sure to post it for us when you come across someone using "Karen" to describe someone who is not a white woman.
 
I see.
Following that line of reasoning, there is nothing racist about referring to a black man as a "thug", provided he has engaged in some brutal behavior.

I don't see why there would be. Racism would be assuming or suggesting all black men are thugs. That a given individual thug happens to be a black man doesn't mean it's racist to call him such. Provided nobody implies the claim that he's a thug because he's a black man.

You be sure to post it for us when you come across someone using "Karen" to describe someone who is not a white woman.

There's a whole Reddit devoted to Karens. I can't post the name of it because it's got a swear in it. A good many entries are of men and non-white women. The name can be composed by combining "r/" plus a popular short phrase ending in "you" and the word "Karen".
 
I don't see why there would be. Racism would be assuming or suggesting all black men are thugs. That a given individual thug happens to be a black man doesn't mean it's racist to call him such. Provided nobody implies the claim that he's a thug because he's a black man.

And if "people" began using thug to refer to young black men of a certain type, I assume that would be fine as well. Because I wasn't using that label for all black men in their teens and twenties with cornrows. Just a certain obnoxious subset, right?
 
I agree. I don't like the term "Karen" which just seems like a jibe at - as has been pointed out - women of a certain age and maybe complexion. In fact, at best it is a childish taunt and at worst it's a misogynist demand that certain types of women pipe down, get in their lane, know their place, stop getting above themselves, etc... etc...

And, no, the word "bitch" is definitely not better. For me it is an explicitly misogynistic term. I think it is wrong that in some people's eagerness to prove their credentials in one sense, they allow themselves a bit of latitude elsewhere.

"I'm sick of all these Karen bitches phoning up the cops to complain about black people swimming in a swimming pool. I love black people - one of my friends is a black guy. I always chat to him when he serves me at the checkout. I know his first name is John, but if I knew his second name I would call him Mister whatever his surname is. Let me tell you how mad I would be if some ******* Karen - some bitch - came in and was all like 'I wanna speak to your manager!' I would chew out that racist bitch so badly that John would be like, 'Wow! White guys can be cool too!' I really hope it happens one day. Unless it really was John's fault, in which case I would be like, 'Okay, Karen, you were right this time, but don't let it go to your head.'"

The difference between a bitch and a Karen is that a bitch is a word for a mean girl. A Karen isn't usually being mean, she is just doing what she thinks she is entitled to do. In the same way, a customer might feel entitled to snap their fingers at the waiter and not realise the resentment they have caused.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom