Karen - Stop!

I'm not going to compare Karen to the n-word, of course. It's not even in the same galaxy.

But my problem with it is that it HAS grown pretty far outside the bounds of its intended usage (in US culture and sections of internet culture, at least). It just means "unattractive older woman" in a lot of circles.

But I feel like I'm definitely repeating myself at this point. I don't think this discussion can be had sensibly because of the race angle. Anyone trying to point out that "Karen" is out of control in its applicability can easily be construed as defending racists. This makes the discussion rather pointless.

I'm also kind of biased, because I personally hate the repetitiveness of meme humor. The only meme I ever really liked was "arrow to the knee." So I acknowledge that factor, too. The more I hear "Karen," the more it grates. I thought it was a tiny bit funny at first.
 
Well, if the overall point is people shouldn’t call people disparaging names, I’m on board with that anytime.
 
I'm okay with calling people disparaging names that relate to their behavior (if said behavior is bullying, obnoxious, racist, or something, I mean). I'm obviously less enthusiastic about calling people disparaging names that relate to their appearance or age. I believe "Karen" started out as the former and is morphing into the latter (again, in some contexts). I wish it would go back to simply describing the former.
 
I'm also kind of biased, because I personally hate the repetitiveness of meme humor. The only meme I ever really liked was "arrow to the knee." So I acknowledge that factor, too. The more I hear "Karen," the more it grates. I thought it was a tiny bit funny at first.

Karen would like to speak to the Jarl, she has a complaint about arrow safety in Whiterun and wants him to pay her Restoration mage for her orthopedic knee surgery. Also she's noticed that some of the nearby tombs have undesirable squatters, draugr are quite the wrong sort of people. And can something be done about the noise level in town? People shouldn't dragon shout at night.
 
I'm okay with calling people disparaging names that relate to their behavior (if said behavior is bullying, obnoxious, racist, or something, I mean). I'm obviously less enthusiastic about calling people disparaging names that relate to their appearance or age. I believe "Karen" started out as the former and is morphing into the latter (again, in some contexts). I wish it would go back to simply describing the former.
Disparaging names that refer to a specific behavior typically have the name of that behavior in the word.
"Stop being such a (bully, racist, obnoxious etc..)"
One behaves in those ways.

One is a Karen, Spic, ******, what have you. These pejorative are not behavior related obviously. One would not call an Asian teenager behaving the same way a "Karen"
 
Okay, guys, you who object to the Karen meme -- that kind of includes me too, I guess, kind of -- here's a simple enough solution. Just get someone to sign up here, at ISF, with the user name Karen. And bang! Any subsequent use of the Karen meme -- or at least, most/many such usages, unless very carefully used -- will be an MA violation, and can be reported as such. Problem solved? (Or do we need an FMF thread to confirm this?)

eta: Well, okay, that won't impact the world outside, nor even what forum members do outside of here, but still?
 
Last edited:
Okay, guys, you who object to the Karen meme -- that kind of includes me too, I guess, kind of -- here's a simple enough solution. Just get someone to sign up here, at ISF, with the user name Karen. And bang! Any subsequent use of the Karen meme -- or at least, most/many such usages, unless very carefully used -- will be an MA violation, and can be reported as such. Problem solved? (Or do we need an FMF thread to confirm this?)

eta: Well, okay, that won't impact the world outside, nor even what forum members do outside of here, but still?

Not sure if joke, but I'm going to respond in earnest anyway. :)

I'm not a fan of "gotcha! found a loophole!" solutions. I also don't think your idea would even be technically true, according to the MA? Someone having the handle "Karen" would not, to my knowledge, preclude the use of the Karen meme in general contexts. If that were true, someone could scoop up the handle "Republican" and no one could ever make generalizations about Republicans again. I think? The MA isn't quite that technical, as I understand it. Which is a good thing.

I can't speak for anyone else, but I never want to "silence" anybody. When I argue, I'm trying to get other people to see and consider my point of view. Best case scenario, they incorporate my viewpoint into their own. Worst case scenario, they call me a snowflake and keep doing what they're doing. At the same time, I'm listening to their points of view, and attempting to see where we share common ground.

I want people here to consider the possibility that the application of "Karen" has become a bit too broad to be meaningful, that the meme has sexist/ageist/lookist undertones, and that it may be hurting the feelings of uninvolved people. That's all, really. I enjoy discussing the topic. It's one of the few social topics I've felt like discussing since quarantine began, actually, because the stakes aren't really that high. People here are intelligent, and the mean age is on the older side. This usually makes for a richer discussion, and this topic is no exception.

The last thing I would want to do is say "Neener, neener! You guys can't say it now!" That wouldn't do even a slight bit of good. Ultimately, people are going to do what they want. I don't really care. I just like discussing it.
 
Last edited:
Joke, joke. :) Well, half a joke, actually. The other half was serious, though.

But I agree, this would -- the half-serious portion would -- only be, as you say, a loophole solution, and a half-assed one at that (see my edit, in my earlier comment).

Still, there are folks who object to particular terms, and would like to see them verboten in here, and start threads in FMF to argue their case. In that spirit, why not? If people do want to, that is.

Whether the 'solution' itself holds, that should make for an interesting 50-pager in FMF. Should anyone -- not me! -- care to get one going.


Eta: As for discussing this, sure, absolutely, why not? I don't take this too seriously myself, but to the extent I do -- and I realize I may be unfairly downplaying this, a bit -- my views, as you may've seen upthread, do agree with yours.
 
Last edited:
I'm okay with calling people disparaging names that relate to their behavior (if said behavior is bullying, obnoxious, racist, or something, I mean). I'm obviously less enthusiastic about calling people disparaging names that relate to their appearance or age.
It's the same with compliments for me. For example, a recent co-worker of mine is a woman roughly 5 feet tall and almost certainly under 110 pounds, maybe not even 100, who has been called "feisty". My response to that was that I would never use that word because then I'd be commenting on not just her behavior & personality but also how she looks (as I said at the time, "linebackers never get called feisty"), and the latter is a subject I don't want to comment on, especially while supposedly describing the former.

People are only being labelled Karen because of their behaviour, it isn’t (as far as my limited research) being used for example to tie together all middle aged white looking women.
The problem is that people don't just restrict themselves to only using the behavioral half of the concept; if they did then it wouldn't be a single concept with both behavioral and visual/physical aspects. Mentally tying the description of behavior together with a description of appearance makes one more likely to accuse people who fit that appearance of that behavior whether they're actually doing it or not, and/or makes it easier for people who look different to get away with the same behavior without getting called on it. (I actually behave the same all the time, but when I get rid of my hair I become more likely to get treated as if I were behaving threateningly, so what those people are really responding to is not my behavior, even though they'd claim it was.)
 
I'm okay with calling people disparaging names that relate to their behavior (if said behavior is bullying, obnoxious, racist, or something, I mean). I'm obviously less enthusiastic about calling people disparaging names that relate to their appearance or age. I believe "Karen" started out as the former and is morphing into the latter (again, in some contexts). I wish it would go back to simply describing the former.

I agree. I don't like the term "Karen" which just seems like a jibe at - as has been pointed out - women of a certain age and maybe complexion. In fact, at best it is a childish taunt and at worst it's a misogynist demand that certain types of women pipe down, get in their lane, know their place, stop getting above themselves, etc... etc...

And, no, the word "bitch" is definitely not better. For me it is an explicitly misogynistic term. I think it is wrong that in some people's eagerness to prove their credentials in one sense, they allow themselves a bit of latitude elsewhere.

"I'm sick of all these Karen bitches phoning up the cops to complain about black people swimming in a swimming pool. I love black people - one of my friends is a black guy. I always chat to him when he serves me at the checkout. I know his first name is John, but if I knew his second name I would call him Mister whatever his surname is. Let me tell you how mad I would be if some ******* Karen - some bitch - came in and was all like 'I wanna speak to your manager!' I would chew out that racist bitch so badly that John would be like, 'Wow! White guys can be cool too!' I really hope it happens one day. Unless it really was John's fault, in which case I would be like, 'Okay, Karen, you were right this time, but don't let it go to your head.'"
 
In any interaction with a middle-aged white looking woman, the pejorative "Karen" can be thrown out.


Any pejorative can be throw out about anybody in any situation.

Much like the "n" word pejorative lies in wait in any negative interaction with a person of color- admittedly to a much greater scale.


Since it is racist and means somebody who is inferior to white people, subhumans, if used by white people.

It is either wrong to label groups of people with pejorative tags that obliterate their personhood in favor of a hate-label, or it is not. It cannot be right for some and wrong for others.


There are a lot of pejorative tags that obliterate people's personhood. This one doesn't - if applied correctly. It describes a particular kind of personality. That it can be applied incorrectly, i.e. you can call somebody a Karen even though that somebody isn't one, isn't really an argument against the concept or the word/name for the concept. If that were the case, we could no longer use terms like hypocrite or snob, which are often used incorrectly because people only have a vague idea about their meanings.

I see few problems with the term:
1) Is there a particular kind of personality out there, the one referred to when we talk about 'a Karen'?
I think there is, and people seem to agree on the characteristics of the personality type.

2) Do people confuse the name Karen with the concept a Karen?
To some extent, but mainly because people tend to get concepts wrong. The concept has very little to do with hairstyles or age: A Karen may be young, middle-aged or old, and she may have all kinds of hairstyles. What characterizes her is her behaviour in certain situations: She is self-important, arrogant and uses her (real or imagined) class and/or race privilege whenever she can get away with it to dominate people that she considers to be inferior to her: typically people of African descent, immigrants, people in low-level jobs and probably the homeless, too.

3) Could we come up with another, maybe even better term for this kind of person?
I haven't looked through the literature to find one, but I can't imagine that Karens haven't already been described and given a name in some psychology book about different personalities. (It just occurs to me that names of characters in fiction are often used to describe whole groups of people: an Uncle Tom or a Svengali, for instance, or Oedipus or Medea from the classics.)

4) If we can come up with another term, can people then be persuaded to use it instead of Karen because some people who don't have the Karen personality but just happen to be called Karen (no doubt the majority) are bothered by the new use of their name?
I have no idea.
 
Any pejorative can be throw out about anybody in any situation.




Since it is racist and means somebody who is inferior to white people, subhumans, if used by white people.




There are a lot of pejorative tags that obliterate people's personhood. This one doesn't - if applied correctly. It describes a particular kind of personality. That it can be applied incorrectly, i.e. you can call somebody a Karen even though that somebody isn't one, isn't really an argument against the concept or the word/name for the concept. If that were the case, we could no longer use terms like hypocrite or snob, which are often used incorrectly because people only have a vague idea about their meanings.

I see few problems with the term:
1) Is there a particular kind of personality out there, the one referred to when we talk about 'a Karen'?
I think there is, and people seem to agree on the characteristics of the personality type.

2) Do people confuse the name Karen with the concept a Karen?
To some extent, but mainly because people tend to get concepts wrong. The concept has very little to do with hairstyles or age: A Karen may be young, middle-aged or old, and she may have all kinds of hairstyles. What characterizes her is her behaviour in certain situations: She is self-important, arrogant and uses her (real or imagined) class and/or race privilege whenever she can get away with it to dominate people that she considers to be inferior to her: typically people of African descent, immigrants, people in low-level jobs and probably the homeless, too.

3) Could we come up with another, maybe even better term for this kind of person?
I haven't looked through the literature to find one, but I can't imagine that Karens haven't already been described and given a name in some psychology book about different personalities. (It just occurs to me that names of characters in fiction are often used to describe whole groups of people: an Uncle Tom or a Svengali, for instance, or Oedipus or Medea from the classics.)

4) If we can come up with another term, can people then be persuaded to use it instead of Karen because some people who don't have the Karen personality but just happen to be called Karen (no doubt the majority) are bothered by the new use of their name?
I have no idea.
To you first point.
Particular kind of personality, or particular kind of person?

Is a young black man, teenaged Asian, or elderly Hispanic a "Karen"?

If not, it is a racist/ageist pejorative- not a criticism of a behavior, and shares characteristics with other pejorative of the same nature like Kike, Geezer, ******, Retard, Spic, etc... and it's use should be refrained from inasmuch as one would refrain from those pejoratives.
 
To you first point.
Particular kind of personality, or particular kind of person?


Personality.

Is a young black man, teenaged Asian, or elderly Hispanic a "Karen"?


Very rarely, I think.

If not, it is a racist/ageist pejorative- not a criticism of a behavior, and shares characteristics with other pejorative of the same nature like Kike, Geezer, ******, Retard, Spic, etc... and it's use should be refrained from inasmuch as one would refrain from those pejoratives.


No, it's not. The word describes the Karen personality, which is the kind of personality that you see more often in some segments of the population than in others. The same goes for the name Karen. Extremely few black men are called Karen.
The concept of a Karen is obviously a pejorative since Karens aren't very nice.
I think it's possible to find a young black Karen, but I don't think that there are many of them. I don't think you would find the entitledness required to be a Karen in groups that tend be disenfranchised rather than entitled.
 
And, no, the word "bitch" is definitely not better. For me it is an explicitly misogynistic term. I think it is wrong that in some people's eagerness to prove their credentials in one sense, they allow themselves a bit of latitude elsewhere.[/I]

But it is more honest. I prefer transparency. I want to see it coming
 
Last edited:
Personality.




Very rarely, I think.




No, it's not. The word describes the Karen personality, which is the kind of personality that you see more often in some segments of the population than in others. The same goes for the name Karen. Extremely few black men are called Karen.
The concept of a Karen is obviously a pejorative since Karens aren't very nice.
I think it's possible to find a young black Karen, but I don't think that there are many of them. I don't think you would find the entitledness required to be a Karen in groups that tend be disenfranchised rather than entitled.
It seems you are applying a definition to the term that is not widely accepted:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karen_(slang)

https://www.dictionary.com/e/slang/karen/

Both entries point out that the pejorative applies to "middle aged white women".

less racist/sexist/ageist perhaps than the word "thug"- which we all know refers only to behavior.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
But it is more honest. I prefer transparency. I want to see it coming

This is maybe a tangent but that word, from what I've seen, is used negatively (usually) as well as in an endearing way between people. I don't think that applies to "Karen"
 
It seems you are applying a definition to the term that is not widely accepted:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karen_(slang)

https://www.dictionary.com/e/slang/karen/

Both entries point out that the pejorative applies to "middle aged white women".

less racist/sexist/ageist perhaps than the word "thug"- which we all know refers only to behavior.

1st, your first link is borked. Wikipedia suggests the link which I assume you actually meant.

2nd, both links clearly state upfront that dann is defining the term accurately. Note the first 3 sentences in the Wiki link that somehow must have escaped you: "Karen is a pejorative term used in the Western world for a woman perceived to be entitled or demanding beyond the scope of what is considered appropriate or necessary. A common stereotype is that of a racist white woman who uses her privilege to demand her own way at the expense of others. Depictions also include demanding to "speak to the manager", being an anti-vaxxer, or having a particular bob cut hairstyle."
 
From the link:

WHAT DOES KAREN MEAN?

Karen is a mocking slang term for an entitled, obnoxious, middle-aged white woman. Especially as featured in memes, Karen is generally stereotyped as having a blonde bob haircut, asking to speak to retail and restaurant managers to voice complaints or make demands, and being a nagging, often divorced mother from Generation X.

Want more of the stories behind the hottest slang? Sign up for �� right in your inbox.

And the first one:


Karen is a pejorative term used in the Western world for a woman perceived to be entitled or demanding beyond the scope of what is considered appropriate or necessary. A common stereotype is that of a racist white woman who uses her privilege to demand her own way at the expense of others. Depictions also include demanding to "speak to the manager", being an anti-vaxxer, or having a particular bob cut hairstyle. As of 2020, the term has increasingly been used as a general-purpose term of disapproval for middle-aged white women.

Interesting that your version of the link did not include that last sentence.


Both links point out that it is a term for "middle aged white women"- managing to be ageist, sexist, and racist, all in a single term
 
Last edited:
Interesting that your version of the link did not include that last sentence.

Why would it be interesting? You claimed that the definition dann was using was not widely accepted, and to support that you ignored the majority of the definitions in the links you provided to focus on one sentence. I didn't need to remind you of the bit you were focused on, you needed to be reminded of the totality that you were ignoring that showed you were wrong.


Both links point out that it is a term for "middle aged white women"- managing to be ageist, sexist, and racist, all in a single term

Both links make it clear that there is more to the term than that. Your dishonest rephrasing is not working.
 
Why would it be interesting? You claimed that the definition dann was using was not widely accepted, and to support that you ignored the majority of the definitions in the links you provided to focus on one sentence. I didn't need to remind you of the bit you were focused on, you needed to be reminded of the totality that you were ignoring that showed you were wrong.




Both links make it clear that there is more to the term than that. Your dishonest rephrasing is not working.
LOL

I post two links clearly defining Karen as a term applying exclusively to Middle aged white women. You ignore the first, then repost an edited version of the second.
Then you accuse me of dishonesty. Priceless.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom