Karen - Stop!

I'm objecting on principle, not on the number of choices on the state-approved array.


Until we can get people to adopt unique names such as “1276894569012TG” I think it is sensible to try and protect future adults from the insanity of some parents.

Mind you given kids have survived through childhood with surnames such as “Alcock” and “Dipcock” it’s probably not too much of a burden for them.
 
I genuinely believe that certain names such as Mavis and Doris aren't actually given to people until they reach a certain age and begin blue-rinsing their hair.
 
It's easy to see how it can be annoying to all the nice women out there called Karen, but they'll probably be able to turn it into a joke. The Karen Karens probably won't.

I know, right? Entitled white bitches got no sense of humor.
 
Until you've used the same name a few times and then it's hard to keep track, unless you refer to them with names like Hurricane Malcolm the third, or Hurricane Jane part deux.

This thread prompted me to look into the history and practice of hurricane naming.

It turns out that the main problem is having an easily recognizable name for the storm while it is active. After it dissipates, the need to keep track of it goes away. So the naming authority maintains regional lists that include enough names to get through the year, and they just roll over to the beginning of the list whenever they get to the end.

They do make an exception for storms that are so destructive or deadly that they persist in public consciousness long after they pass through. Then they retire the name out of respect for the painful memories of the storm.

In the usual course of events, though, re-using the names every year isn't a problem for storm tracking.
 
Rent free.


:)

Okay, I do see the difficulty with using contemporary, or contentious, names. Because one man's villain, one man's monstrosity, is, or can be, another's not villain, not monstrosity. No matter how difficult that might be, in some cases, for the former to understand just how and why! :)


Also, the World Meteorological Association chooses names by committee for lists that are strictly followed in rotation.

Names are retired when the death toll is very high, for reasons of sensitivity. So Hitler would be an obvious bad choice.

Also, hurricanes are not named after specific individuals.

https://public.wmo.int/en/our-manda...aster-risk-reduction/tropical-cyclones/Naming

https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/storm-names.html


I was kidding, as far as Hitler and Trump. But you have to admit, it is very much conceivable, even likely, that having a raging hurricane that causes death and destruction, named with your name, might be ... not very nice. One can see that might, a bit, just spoil the name for you. Much like this Karen thing. (At least the latter is kind of an organic thing, while here the name's coldly, deliberately picked.)

Sure, makes it easier to remember, like TM says. No doubt that is the whole point. Well, fictional names, weird names that people are unlikely to have -- unless their parents had a very weird taste as far as baby names -- might seem reasonable. Darth Vader, or Shrek -- Shrek sounds great! -- you can mine Tolkien, or JK Rowling, or regular fairy tales for familiar names that people won't have. That seems more reasonable than using real people's names, even if specific individuals aren't being targeted..
 
It's easy to see how it can be annoying to all the nice women out there called Karen, but they'll probably be able to turn it into a joke. The Karen Karens probably won't.


Scottish Karens?

Those are two extremes. The Karen that considers everything a slight, and the Karen with a sunny smile that takes things like this in her stride. I'm sure there are all kinds of Karens in between, including those that are mildly discomfited, and those that are embarrassed but don't make a thing of it, as well as those that are deeply mortified by it while still not necessarily being a bitch, why not? Doesn't seem very ... fair, to subject random people to this kind of thing, for no fault of theirs.
 
This thread prompted me to look into the history and practice of hurricane naming.

It turns out that the main problem is having an easily recognizable name for the storm while it is active. After it dissipates, the need to keep track of it goes away. So the naming authority maintains regional lists that include enough names to get through the year, and they just roll over to the beginning of the list whenever they get to the end.

They do make an exception for storms that are so destructive or deadly that they persist in public consciousness long after they pass through. Then they retire the name out of respect for the painful memories of the storm.

In the usual course of events, though, re-using the names every year isn't a problem for storm tracking.

They don't use the same names every year, but they do reuse names eventually, except for the ones they've retired. I think they have multiple sets of names and rotate them, but I don't know the details.

ETA: There are six lists that rotate. https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/aboutnames.shtml
 
Last edited:
:)

Okay, I do see the difficulty with using contemporary, or contentious, names. Because one man's villain, one man's monstrosity, is, or can be, another's not villain, not monstrosity. No matter how difficult that might be, in some cases, for the former to understand just how and why! :)





I was kidding, as far as Hitler and Trump. But you have to admit, it is very much conceivable, even likely, that having a raging hurricane that causes death and destruction, named with your name, might be ... not very nice. One can see that might, a bit, just spoil the name for you. Much like this Karen thing. (At least the latter is kind of an organic thing, while here the name's coldly, deliberately picked.)

Sure, makes it easier to remember, like TM says. No doubt that is the whole point. Well, fictional names, weird names that people are unlikely to have -- unless their parents had a very weird taste as far as baby names -- might seem reasonable. Darth Vader, or Shrek -- Shrek sounds great! -- you can mine Tolkien, or JK Rowling, or regular fairy tales for familiar names that people won't have. That seems more reasonable than using real people's names, even if specific individuals aren't being targeted..

Association with a bad storm or unpleasant character is dark, but none of these other examples carry the sheer contempt of the Karen meme. Being named "Katrina" might be rough, but it's surely rough in a different way.




People love the "Karen" term because people collectively dislike that type of person, understandably - and now they have a name for it that sort of fits and is humorous. I get all that. I just hate seeing it used in newspapers, and associated with haircuts, and deployed in contexts like this:

https://imgur.com/gallery/n3NYF2v

Those women in the photo aren't doing anything to earn the "Karen" designation. People are just making "Karen" jokes because they're older and have short hair. That's what I hate about ******* "Karen." I analyzed my feelings, and that's the real problem. If the meme hadn't become so ubiquitous, people wouldn't be attaching it to any middle-aged women who are just existing, being mildly annoying, etc. They'd stick to associating it with the entitled/racist/helicopter-mum behaviors. Then normal Karens wouldn't be inundated with "SHUT UP, KAREN" if they try to discuss movies on Facebook or something.

But, oh well. It is what it is now. And like I said before, there are bigger social problems out there. And most people use the term in the "valid" way, so why should it upset me.


EDIT: It strikes me that naming a child must be agonizing. How is anyone to know what will happen with that name in the coming decades? Storms, supervillains, dictators, memes - anything could happen!
 
Last edited:
This thread prompted me to look into the history and practice of hurricane naming.

It turns out that the main problem is having an easily recognizable name for the storm while it is active. After it dissipates, the need to keep track of it goes away. So the naming authority maintains regional lists that include enough names to get through the year, and they just roll over to the beginning of the list whenever they get to the end.

They do make an exception for storms that are so destructive or deadly that they persist in public consciousness long after they pass through. Then they retire the name out of respect for the painful memories of the storm.

In the usual course of events, though, re-using the names every year isn't a problem for storm tracking.


You should also have found that they were at one time always woman's names, not men's?

https://www.history.com/news/why-hurricanes-and-tropical-storms-were-only-named-after-women
 
Wait, we're doing this wrong. We're a skeptics forum, at least nominally. So instead of getting all touchy feely about this, we should be looking at how actual Karens are actually reacting to this.

Until a real poll/survey's published, we could go around asking all the Karens we know what they think of this meme.

Of course, the long-suffering Karens, who first had their name stuck on to a hurricane, next on to this meme, so now when they find their name drawing them into a q&a session on their name, you can hardly blame them if they react violently. A risk us skeptics should be willing to take on, in the interest of science and objectivity.
 
You should also have found that they were at one time always woman's names, not men's?
I should have? I doubt it. I could have if I'd carried my inquiry further. Don't see how it matters to anything I was saying, though. If you think it's an interesting point to raise, there's probably better ways to do it, than to try to make it about what I should or should not have done.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom