Karen - Stop!

(Despite the word originally referring to a caste of Indians who were more murderers than thugs, and like Thor, has had the "th" sound changed from the original hard "t")
Actually the first letter of Thor in Old Norse was thorn - Þorr - which is pronounced as a soft th. It never had a hard T.

You are, however, correct about "thug", as far as I know.
It was the same sound as English "Th" in Medieval times. It has become a "T" in most Nordic languages in modern times.

The Hindi word from which we get "thug" begins with the letter "ठ", which represents a sound close to our T but with two twists:
  • The extra puff of air you probably sometimes push out with a T without thinking about it, especially if it's before the word's most emphasized vowel (and not after an S), which can sound like an unwritten separate H after the T but doesn't make it count as a separate sound in English, is mandatory; if you fail to aspirate it you're making a different sound in Hindi. (Although we Englishers normally only aspirate unvoiced plosives {p,t,ʈ,k}, in Indic languages it's more common in the voiced ones {b,d,ɖ,g}, which is why romanized words in those languages are so full of "bh", "dh", and "gh". Because it's part of the same phoneme with the p/t/ʈ/k/b/d/ɖ/g, not really a separate sound, linguists represent it with a superscript when they're trying to stick to a 1:1 ratio of sounds to (full-sized) letters: pʰ/tʰ/ʈʰ/kʰ/bʰ/dʰ/ɖʰ/gʰ.
  • It's also retroflex, which means the tip of your tongue needs to be curled back. The closest we Englishers get is if we're about to say an R after the T, but the Hindi sound usually involves a bit more curling than even that. It's pretty much impossible to do without having it spill into adjacent vowels, from where it can even spread to other consonants, so they can sometimes end up going through a whole word without uncurling their tongues. Different romanization schemes either ignore this distinction or try to represent it with a dot below the letter, a tail on the letter as I used above, or doubling the letter.
If ठ weren't aspirated, it would be ट. If it weren't retroflex, it would be थ. If it were neither (just a plain un-fooled-around-with T), it would be त.

Indic languages have no sound like the English/Norse "th".

It wasn't really coopted by rappers, but rather embraced, much like another word they also began to use (and there's another, albeit shakier, example for gay men specifically)... So he, and others, spun it, much like "******" into something positive when said amongst one another
It happens with a lot of words. "Nerd" has swung so far that it's not just positive among those who are stuck with it but even something people seem to look for even the flimsiest excuses to apply to themselves. And the earliest example I know is somewhere around three thousand years old. "Habiru" originally meant something like "outlaws", "raiders", "intruders", or "vagabonds". It was used by people in cities to describe bands of attackers from outside the cities; the earliest examples of Hebrews using it to refer to themselves are in contexts where they're addressing somebody else, using a word that they expect those others to consider applicable; essentially "this is what we know you think of us". But then it became just another name for themselves.
 
It was the same sound as English "Th" in Medieval times. It has become a "T" in most Nordic languages in modern times.

That's how I've always heard it from Scandinavians. I didn't know the history, though.
 
In Faroese and Icelandic they still have the letter ð. We no longer have the letter, but we still have the sound ð in Danish, which is probably the reason why we tend to be better than Germans at pronouncing English th. :)
But our ð is usually spelled with a d. The Norse god is always pronounced with a t but spelled as both Thor and Tor. Thursday: torsdag, however, is never spelled with a th- in Danish.
 
Last edited:
If they can't be arsed to track down their own source for their own claim, why should it fall on me to put any more effort into it than they have?

Any particular reason why you can not, or will not, support your own claim yourself?

Stop being a Karen.
 
I wonder if it's a conspiracy. Do hairdressers deliberately convince particularly obnoxious clients to get one? Or does the Karen personality make them crave it? :)

It's a hair style that happens to suit several face shapes, and is relatively low maintenance for the wearer, so it's not surprising it should be common, particularly among ladies of a particular age group. It was actually considered a good style until it became too common and then it became associated with the Karen meme.

The hair style itself is not to blame for the actions of a few individuals that happen to wear it, but unfortunately cultures have a habit of associating hair styles with behaviors. For examples consider shaved heads on young white men, side ponytails on teenaged girls, long hair on teenaged boys, and dreadlocks on anybody who isn't from the Caribbean. It's tragic in cases where a given style would really suit the appearance of a person but they can't have it because it'll raise undesirable associations in the assumptions of others.

In a perfect world everybody could have whatever hair style suits them best, without cultural baggage.
 
Two bits to throw in the mix this morning:

"It's usually used as a pejorative for middle-aged white women," said Matt Schimkowitz, a senior editor at Know Your Meme, the online meme encyclopedia. "It's almost like they have an entitlement, where they're kind of lording their privilege over another."

https://www.msn.com/en-us/lifestyle...e-women-and-a-hugely-popular-meme/ar-BB14FWPX

I certainly haven't ever seen "Karen" used when anything other than a white woman is involved.

Obnoxious white chick? Must be a Karen.
 
The View (July 1, 2020): Americans' Obsession With "Karens"
 
apye8wwvms851.jpg
 
It happens with a lot of words. "Nerd" has swung so far that it's not just positive among those who are stuck with it but even something people seem to look for even the flimsiest excuses to apply to themselves. And the earliest example I know is somewhere around three thousand years old. "Habiru" originally meant something like "outlaws", "raiders", "intruders", or "vagabonds". It was used by people in cities to describe bands of attackers from outside the cities; the earliest examples of Hebrews using it to refer to themselves are in contexts where they're addressing somebody else, using a word that they expect those others to consider applicable; essentially "this is what we know you think of us". But then it became just another name for themselves.


That's fascinating, this account of how 'Hebrew' derives from 'Habiru'. Thanks for posting!

This is the first I heard the term Habiru, but, curious, I googled around a bit, and here's what came up. (This is entirely off-topic, I realize, more suited for that other thread than this one, but this is too interesting to not make at least one post about.)

For one thing, the connection between Habiru and Hebrew is, apparently, far from commonly accepted. The mainstream view is not in favor of this theory, this connection, at all,apparently. (For obvious reasons, as we'll see.)

That apart, how Habiru became Hebrew, is apparently -- what I found by, like I said, random Googling, not deep study, so sure, I could be wrong (that is, it could be the sites Google pointed me to, are, in fact, crank sites, although I didn't myself get a crank-vibe there) -- is very different than your account.

Apparently Habiru or Apiru were this geographically diverse CLASS of outlaws, fringe elements, laborers, mercenaries, runaway slaves, as you say; but where this narrative differs from yours is that apparently this CLASS is what the Hebrews actually arose out of. (They did not simply end up appropriating the term, as you suggest, apparently this is who they actually WERE.) If this is true, then the implications are far reaching. This means there is no Hebrew nation at all. Not only are Moses's hallucinations and his sea parting, etc, a collection of tall tales, but, in fact, the whole Hebrew nation itself, all of Israel of the Old Testament, is made up drivel. All of that, per this Apiru narrative, was just a collection of runaway slaves that, diffused across geographies, came to acquire a (diffuse, shaky, informal, yet real) clout of sorts, and eventually came to make up these stories about themselves, and eventually came to end up thinking of themselves as the Hebrew "nation".

Like I said, entirely off-topic -- apologies for derailing the thread somewhat -- but, if true, really interesting, and realy really far reaching in its implications.
 
I have been previously more comfortable with the dreaded "K-slur", but I am beginning to worry that the definition is blurring and it is generalizing into a generic gendered insult that has little meaning beyond the "shrill woman" trope.

For example, an incident where a woman pulled a gun on an unarmed person over a minor parking lot squabble has been labeled a "Karen". I fail to see how brandishing a gun in a confrontation is "Karen" behavior. In fact, pulling a gun seems very dissimilar to the "I want to see a manager" trope and seems like a more direct, self-help (in a bad way) attitude.

I fear the Karen insult is just becoming a generic anti-woman term devoid of any useful definition. While I thought it was useful to shorthand "white woman demanding to see a a manager/cop over a petty complaint" has transformed into "shrill bitch", which is regrettable.

https://www.complex.com/life/2020/07/video-shows-michigan-woman-pulling-gun-on-black-woman-and-daughter
 
Last edited:
Pure journalistic laziness, just as any story involving one or more government party/department/member is labelled “xxxxx-gate”
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom