Karen - Stop!

I've been following some subreddits like r/talesfromretail and r/talesfromthefrontdesk. These are stories from people who are in a customer service role.

For a couple years at least, "Karen" has been used in these subs consistently to refer to anyone who acts entitled or abusive towards staff, typically including obnoxious escalations ("I want to speak to your manager").

Race was never an identifying factor, and men who behaved this way are often referred to in the subs as a "male Karen".

It's not surprising that the term has recently been expanded to include white women who act entitled or obnoxious about racial issues. But that is not its original or exclusive usage.

I'm just waiting for the story about the woman with the I-Want-To-Speak-To-Your-Manager haircut who acts entitled and obnoxious and then claims she's being treated badly because of her haircut.
 
It's almost as if --brace yourselves!-- ideas change over time!!

Ask someone to define what "an Ugly American" is, for example.
 
(Despite the word originally referring to a caste of Indians who were more murderers than thugs, and like Thor, has had the "th" sound changed from the original hard "t")

Actually the first letter of Thor in Old Norse was thorn - Þorr - which is pronounced as a soft th. It never had a hard T.

You are, however, correct about "thug", as far as I know.

/offtopic
 
"As mysteriously as she arrived --in full screech, at the customer service desk-- Karen vanished, leaving behind nothing but an enigma wrapped in a mystery wrapped in a vociferous complaint about something utterly trivial." --The History of Karen, MacMillan Books, 2021. First edition comes with a preprinted complaint form you can mail in to the manager.
 
I don't know whether that's a specifically American problem, or just the result of co-opting by rappers, but the word thug is used elsewhere to identify thugs, regardless of skin colour.

It wasn't really coopted by rappers, but rather embraced, much like another word they also began to use (and there's another, albeit shakier, example for gay men specifically). As you may have guessed, it's a US-specific stereotype, a modern-day version of "the Brute", the super-strong black man, powered by drugs or sometimes Voodoo, who beats white men to death, violently rapes white women, and can only be stopped by a hail of gunfire. To paraphrase Tupac:

"You can call yourself a lawyer, a man, an African-American...to them, all you are is thugs and *******."

So he, and others, spun it, much like "******" into something positive when said amongst one another, to mean strength, mentally and spiritually, who struggles for himself, his family, and his community.

But from the outside...

We get Trayvon Martin, a "thug" because some white guy decided any black person in his little community was "suspicious";

Terence Crutcher, who despite putting his hands on top of his car and holding still, was to quote a cop in the helicopter that flew over him shortly before one of several on the grouns shot and killed him, was "a real bad dude";

Richard Sherman, who once yelled into a mic;

Common, the vegan, anti-violence rapper, for...I still don't know;

And of course, the "Chicago Gangsta" President Obama, when not a "Kenyan anti-colonialist", the guy with the fake Hawaiian birth certificate that was flown to DC from Hawaii, by Hawaiian officials, and on and on and on...

...can you tell that this is a bit of an obnoxious stereotype? But yes, it's an American Problem - I won't speak to other countries one way or the other.
 
It wasn't really coopted by rappers, but rather embraced, much like another word they also began to use (and there's another, albeit shakier, example for gay men specifically). As you may have guessed, it's a US-specific stereotype, a modern-day version of "the Brute", the super-strong black man, powered by drugs or sometimes Voodoo, who beats white men to death, violently rapes white women, and can only be stopped by a hail of gunfire. To paraphrase Tupac:

"You can call yourself a lawyer, a man, an African-American...to them, all you are is thugs and *******."

So he, and others, spun it, much like "******" into something positive when said amongst one another, to mean strength, mentally and spiritually, who struggles for himself, his family, and his community.

But from the outside...

We get Trayvon Martin, a "thug" because some white guy decided any black person in his little community was "suspicious";

Terence Crutcher, who despite putting his hands on top of his car and holding still, was to quote a cop in the helicopter that flew over him shortly before one of several on the grouns shot and killed him, was "a real bad dude";

Richard Sherman, who once yelled into a mic;

Common, the vegan, anti-violence rapper, for...I still don't know;

And of course, the "Chicago Gangsta" President Obama, when not a "Kenyan anti-colonialist", the guy with the fake Hawaiian birth certificate that was flown to DC from Hawaii, by Hawaiian officials, and on and on and on...

...can you tell that this is a bit of an obnoxious stereotype? But yes, it's an American Problem - I won't speak to other countries one way or the other.
Epithets are de-humanizing. And should be avoided, unless de-humanization is the goal.
 
I've been following some subreddits like r/talesfromretail and r/talesfromthefrontdesk. These are stories from people who are in a customer service role.

For a couple years at least, "Karen" has been used in these subs consistently to refer to anyone who acts entitled or abusive towards staff, typically including obnoxious escalations ("I want to speak to your manager").

Race was never an identifying factor, and men who behaved this way are often referred to in the subs as a "male Karen".

It's not surprising that the term has recently been expanded to include white women who act entitled or obnoxious about racial issues. But that is not its original or exclusive usage.

I'm just waiting for the story about the woman with the I-Want-To-Speak-To-Your-Manager haircut who acts entitled and obnoxious and then claims she's being treated badly because of her haircut.
That men who behave that way are referred to as "male Karens" per your observations reminds me of another discussion in these threads that you may have seen RE the expression "the exception proves the rule".


If "Karen" does not,in and of itself, refer specifically to a female- the addition of "male" to the front of it as a qualifier would be unnecessary.

If I searched the "reddits" that you read, would I find references to "Black, Asian, or Teenaged" Karens. ?
 
Last edited:
That men who behave that way are referred to as "make Karens" per your observations reminds me of anothe discussion in these threads that you may have seen RE the expression "the exception proves the rule".

If "Karen" does not, and of itself, refer specifically to a female- the addition of "male" to the front of it as a qualifier would be unnecessary.

How about "male nurse", then? Nurses aren't inherently female. It just means the speaker doesn't trust the audience to know that.
 
How about "male nurse", then? Nurses aren't inherently female. It just means the speaker doesn't trust the audience to know that.
Since it is a epithet supposedly criticizing only a behavior the qualifier is unnecessary.

Do they frequently say things like "I had a customer today who was a real female jerk!"? Not likely, because being a "jerk" actually is an epithet solely deriding behavior- and not identity.
 
Since it is a epithet supposedly criticizing only a behavior the qualifier is unnecessary.

Do they frequently say things like "I had a customer today who was a real female jerk!"? Not likely, because being a "jerk" actually is an epithet solely deriding behavior- and not identity.

I suspect in many (most?) cases people would assume a "jerk" is male because the speaker is likely to refer to a female jerk as a "bitch". I'm not saying that's a good practice, but I think it would be a very common usage. It's extraordinary how gendered language is, and how far gender penetrates into so many aspects of life.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom