Jonathan h. Cole has uploaded a new videoclip!

Foolish. That wasn't even close to what would have occured in the debris pile. A small scrap of aluminum, a tiny scrap of plastic, and a ton of wood, doesn't even come close to what would have occured in a debris pile from a collapsed building.

You can discuss the decision of the FBI testing for explosives in another thread. I will e more than happy to educate you on that subject.
 
Why look for something if there's no reason to?

No reason to? Not even firefighters talking about "devices" in the building, witnesses and firefighters describing hearing explosions, witnesses describing seeing flashes in the building in sequence prior to collapse, and accounts of molten steel up to even weeks after?

So you believe it is better to work backwards from a conclusion? Planes crashed, jet fuel fires ensued, buildings collapsed therefore planes and jet fuel caused the collapses... No matter what...even though people experienced and heard explosions, even though news commentators and others described it as looking just like a CD, even though Van Romero first thought it was an engineered collapse, even though "the steel melted", "pancake theory" was tossed aside, NIST was wrong about and later conceded to free fall speed, Jon Cole showed thermite can do everything it's proponents claimed effectively debunking the very refutations you all supported, even though NIST and everyone else are still only offering THEORIES, you don't feel it is prudent then or now to consider, entertain, or even investigate incendiaries and explosives?

When you saw the planes hit, were you sure the buildings were going to collapse?
 
No reason to? Not even firefighters talking about "devices" in the building, witnesses and firefighters describing hearing explosions, witnesses describing seeing flashes in the building in sequence prior to collapse, and accounts of molten steel up to even weeks after?

So you believe it is better to work backwards from a conclusion? Planes crashed, jet fuel fires ensued, buildings collapsed therefore planes and jet fuel caused the collapses... No matter what...even though people experienced and heard explosions, even though news commentators and others described it as looking just like a CD, even though Van Romero first thought it was an engineered collapse, even though "the steel melted", "pancake theory" was tossed aside, NIST was wrong about and later conceded to free fall speed, Jon Cole showed thermite can do everything it's proponents claimed effectively debunking the very refutations you all supported, even though NIST and everyone else are still only offering THEORIES, you don't feel it is prudent then or now to consider, entertain, or even investigate incendiaries and explosives?

When you saw the planes hit, were you sure the buildings were going to collapse?
How about the people that claimed it sounded like a train? Should they look for lost trains too?

Why would I be sure they would collapse? I was surprised they took the initial hit as well as they did.
 
Last edited:
No reason to? Not even firefighters talking about "devices" in the building,

One or two firefighters. However, none that were there that day, believe in a CD.

witnesses and firefighters describing hearing explosions,

Explosions are common in large fires. Also, explosions =/= explosives.
Do you know that there are about 8 things that go boom in a fire, that are in fact, not explosives?

witnesses describing seeing flashes in the building in sequence prior to collapse,

One firefighter, and was never documented. Not one video of such flashes. Flashes are not omni-directional.

and accounts of molten steel up to even weeks after?

Show me an explosive that produces molten steel?

Show me proof that someone can identify correctly, a molten substance, by sight alone. *hint: very few can, without relevant training, and even then, the incorrect to correct ratio is high.

So you believe it is better to work backwards from a conclusion?

Not at all. Most scientists go where the evidence points them to.

Planes crashed, jet fuel fires ensued, buildings collapsed therefore planes and jet fuel caused the collapses... No matter what...

Incorrect. Jet fuel did not cause the collapse by itself. Do try to real the NIST report.

even though people experienced and heard explosions,

Again, explosions =/= explosives.


even though news commentators and others described it as looking just like a CD,

You mean to tell me that two buildings that fall down, look simmilar? No way..... tell me more!! :rolleyes:

even though Van Romero first thought it was an engineered collapse,

And do you know what he thinks now, after further research and studying?

even though "the steel melted", "pancake theory" was tossed aside,

Steel melted was never part of any of the investigations' theories.

The pancake theory was presented as a possibility by FEMA, and disproven by NIST. And, that was collapse iniation. Do try to do some more homework.


NIST was wrong about and later conceded to free fall speed,

Incorrect.

Jon Cole showed thermite can do everything it's proponents claimed effectively debunking the very refutations you all supported,

Incorrect.

even though NIST and everyone else are still only offering THEORIES,

Says the one presenting only rediculous theories.

you don't feel it is prudent then or now to consider, entertain, or even investigate incendiaries and explosives?

No. Considering there is no evidence of such devices.

When you saw the planes hit, were you sure the buildings were going to collapse?

Some people considered it. Most didn't think so. Does this have anything to do with reality?
 
BTW, if you would like to discuss the claim by Erik Lawyer and FF911T about explosive investigations, please go here and read the opening post.

I look forward to your discussion.
 
No reason to? Not even firefighters talking about "devices" in the building, witnesses and firefighters describing hearing explosions, witnesses describing seeing flashes in the building in sequence prior to collapse, and accounts of molten steel up to even weeks after?

So you believe it is better to work backwards from a conclusion? Planes crashed, jet fuel fires ensued, buildings collapsed therefore planes and jet fuel caused the collapses... No matter what...even though people experienced and heard explosions, even though news commentators and others described it as looking just like a CD, even though Van Romero first thought it was an engineered collapse, even though "the steel melted", "pancake theory" was tossed aside, NIST was wrong about and later conceded to free fall speed, Jon Cole showed thermite can do everything it's proponents claimed effectively debunking the very refutations you all supported, even though NIST and everyone else are still only offering THEORIES, you don't feel it is prudent then or now to consider, entertain, or even investigate incendiaries and explosives?

I would say you set some kind of record, for the most wrong in one post. Then, I remembered Merry Melodies, and his longer winded diatribes of fail!
 
One or two firefighters.

Theres more than that and you know it. Louie Cacchioli, Albert Turi, Richard Banaciski, and Stephen Gregory just to name FOUR. So were you lying or mistaken?

However, none that were there that day, believe in a CD.

John Shroeder is one I can think of. So were you just mistaken or lying?

Louie Cacchioli seems to have a problem with the official story...


"My story was never mentioned in the final report and I felt like I was being put on trial in a court room. They were trying to twist my words and make the story fit only what they wanted to hear" [PDF download]
-Firefighter Louie Cacchioli



Explosions are common in large fires. Also, explosions =/= explosives.
Do you know that there are about 8 things that go boom in a fire, that are in fact, not explosives?

But you would also have to agree that explosions could = explosives...logically right? Explosions come from explosive materials being ignited or activated correct? Why wouldn't NIST or FEMA want to investigate the possibilities of explosives if people heard, saw and experienced pops like gunshots, flashes, explosions? Does it make sense to you that after a terrorist attack on a building that already had a terrorist attack using a bomb that explosives should not have been considered or investigated, especially considering all the supporting evidence for such?


One firefighter, and was never documented. Not one video of such flashes. Flashes are not omni-directional.

Wrong again... Or lying...

"I saw a flash flash flash [at] the lower level of the building. You know like when they demolish a building?"
--Assistant Fire Commissioner Stephen Gregory


Show me an explosive that produces molten steel?

How about an incendiary called thermite? Are you claiming that thermite doesn't leave molten steel?

Show me proof that someone can identify correctly, a molten substance, by sight alone. *hint: very few can, without relevant training, and even then, the incorrect to correct ratio is high.

Show YOU proof? How about you show me proof they misidentified it? The burden of proof is on you, since you, who was not there, are claiming that all of these individuals who were there, building professionals, demolition and removal professionals, firefighters etc are all mistaken.

What made all these people misidentify it as molten steel? Why were these people seeing the molten steel come from steel components.

What makes your post 9/11 denial so much more credible than their experience on 9/11 and the days and weeks after?

Do you know for a fact that it wasn't molten steel? No, not even close. Therefore accounts of pools, channels, dripping molten ends of steel beams should be considered and investigated. That's what demonstrates your bias and lack of falsifiability in your position is because you refuse to even consider it and let an investigation sort it out. You and your comrades here don't want it investigated because it could prove you wrong.


Not at all. Most scientists go where the evidence points them to.

Really? So the evidence is that airliners hit the towers and their impact and jetfuel caused a fired that caused both towers to collapse without stopping and that's that? And everything else is irrelevant? Sounds like starting at a conclusion and working backwards to me. Clearly, that is the ONLY path they have and will take. Planes hit the towers, jet fuel fires ensued, total collapses ensued and no matter theory they come up with, it must fit that model of evidence only.


Incorrect. Jet fuel did not cause the collapse by itself. Do try to real the NIST report.

Yes, it was allegedly jet fuel fire. And again, NIST only offers a theory that starts at a conclusion. Are you not seeing this?



Again, explosions =/= explosives.

And again explosions could also = explosives right? You agree with that right? Explosives should have been explored and instead they weren't.




You mean to tell me that two buildings that fall down, look simmilar? No way..... tell me more!! :rolleyes:

Again, we are talking about reasons why explosives should have been considered and investigated. I gave a reason. Many people the day of thought it looked like a CD. Your sarcasm and lack of comprehension is noted though.


And do you know what he thinks now, after further research and studying?

Yes I do. However, you do realize you are actually saying he did this "further research and studying" within 10 days of making that statement...10 DAYS AFTER 9/11... right?

Are you saying 10 days later he KNEW FOR A FACT the collapse was due jet impacts and jet fuel fires? Something NIST would have to wrestle with for 10 years, he figured out in 10 days?

Do you consider that pressure may have been applied to him from someone in govt since he is funded by govt grants?


Steel melted was never part of any of the investigations' theories.

I never said it was. It was part of the establishments.

The pancake theory was presented as a possibility by FEMA, and disproven by NIST. And, that was collapse iniation. Do try to do some more homework.

Yes I acknowledged that. Perhaps you have reading comprehension issues.




Incorrect
.

Actually correct: google it.





Incorrect
.

Ok I guess you havent seen the presentation yet and instead can only offer pseudo-authoritative one word answers.
Google the presentation. I can't post URLS




Says the one presenting only rediculous theories.

It's "ridiculous" and I don't see anywhere that I've promoted any theories about the collapse. Nor do I see how the notion of incendiaries and explosives at the towers are ridiculous.



No. Considering there is no evidence of such devices.

Of course considering there was no steel to forensically and thoroughly examine and investigate, and also considering there was not a concerted effort to search for explosives since we all know a conclusion(s) was reached before the investigation itself.



Some people considered it. Most didn't think so. Does this have anything to do with reality?

What did you think? And after they collapsed were you sure the planes and fires caused it? If so, how do you know you are right?
 
How about an incendiary called thermite? Are you claiming that thermite doesn't leave molten steel?



Show YOU proof? How about you show me proof they misidentified it? The burden of proof is on you, since you, who was not there, are claiming that all of these individuals who were there, building professionals, demolition and removal professionals, firefighters etc are all mistaken.

What made all these people misidentify it as molten steel? Why were these people seeing the molten steel come from steel components.
The physical evidence doesn't exist.
  • The truth movement literally had to photoshop photos of search and rescue operations, plus cleanup to try and make people believe there was physically melted (liquefied) steel. Steven Jones thought he could pass it without anyone noticing like an idiot, and he quietly redacted the pictures from his own editorials when the obvious farce was brought out.
  • The truth movement thinks melted metals can be identified without any other analysis than seeing it by both metallurgists and laymen. And they can't analyze context or circumstance. Proof of this is in their repetitive use of Astanah's own statements; all they care about are scare words, not the actual results of the analyses done or the conclusions of those who had the opportunity to analyse the materials themselves.
  • They can't even produce quote-mined witness testimony of bright fireworks displays inside or outside of the buildings pre-collapse.
  • They can't provide a single photo of structural members melted by thermite unless they cherry-pick through photos of the columns cut during clean up
Which is why the burden of proof is in fact yours. Most competent people are already skeptical of the thermite theory on the basis that claimants have already tried fabricating so called evidence to convince people. If the evidence is as compelling as you want to suggest this should have never been necessary for any part of the movement to try.

But you would also have to agree that explosions could = explosives...logically right? Explosions come from explosive materials being ignited or activated correct? Why wouldn't NIST or FEMA want to investigate the possibilities of explosives if people heard, saw and experienced pops like gunshots, flashes, explosions? Does it make sense to you that after a terrorist attack on a building that already had a terrorist attack using a bomb that explosives should not have been considered or investigated, especially considering all the supporting evidence for such?
Explosions come from highly combustible materials and reactive chemicals. Gas leaks are notoriously dangerous in residential fires for this reason. No truth movement claim has addressed why non-explosive sources, or simile/metaphorical references by witness shouldn't be rightfully considered. And likewise when no physical or documentary evidence provides credence to associating witness statements with the use of real bombs.

For example common types of explosions include:

Propane
Industrial
Refinery
Residential Gas
Boiler
Natural Gas
Petroleum
Fuel Tanks
Coal Dust

Not including inaccuracies in witness statements.
 
Last edited:
...

But you would also have to agree that explosions could = explosives...logically right? Explosions come from explosive materials being ignited or activated correct? Why wouldn't NIST or FEMA want to investigate the possibilities of explosives if people heard, saw and experienced pops like gunshots, flashes, explosions? Does it make sense to you that after a terrorist attack on a building that already had a terrorist attack using a bomb that explosives should not have been considered or investigated, especially considering all the supporting evidence for such?

... ?
Wow, where have you been. I have been fooled by the shills spreading the lie of the "official story". You have opened my eyes, and mind! I just found proof of the big inside job as it dovetails with your impressive insight. I was blind and now I can think for myself. Thank you!!!

I found 16 WTC first responder descriptions of explosive noises...

"Sounded like bombs" –Keith Murphy
"A huge explosion" –Gerard Gorman
"Sound of popping and exploding" –Alwish Monchery
"Explosions" –William Burns
"Kept hearing these large boom, boom" –Rosario Terranova
"Sounded like explosions." –Anthony Fitzgerald
"Like a shotgun going off" –Mark Meier
"Sounded like explosions" –Wilfred Barriere
"Sounded like bombs, like blockbusters" –John Murray
"You could hear explosions" –Richard Smiouskas
"Sounded like an M-80, that's how loud they were" –Tim Pearson
"Sounds like a shotgun" –Eric Ronningen
"Sounded like an explosion" –John Morabito
"There were lots of explosions" –Jeff Birnbaum
"Under the assumption that the sounds were secondary bombs." –Andrew Rodriguez
"Sounded like bombs. Like a bomb going off. I mean, it was huge." –FDNY Deputy Chief Peter Hayden
I am going to get a Pulitzer! 10 years and I will be the first! Thank you, thank you very much.

Jonathan h. Cole, why has he failed to earn a Pulitzer for his fantastic work? I wish I was an engineer, I am just a pilot trying not to buy the farm too soon. What a super engineer.
I have to go work on my Pulitzer Package; it will be like breaking Watergate, albeit taking 9 extra years to gather up JHC's super conclusions and forming a proof positive case for the inside job.
 
Last edited:
Theres more than that and you know it. Louie Cacchioli, Albert Turi, Richard Banaciski, and Stephen Gregory just to name FOUR. So were you lying or mistaken?

Citation needed. Don't take their comments out of context either.

Asst. Commissioner Gregory doesn't know what it came from. He states "I don't know if it means anything. I mean, I equate it to the building coming down. "

I could do this for almost each and every firefighter from FDNY.

Their Oral Histories that you've quotemined, are public information.

John Shroeder is one I can think of. So were you just mistaken or lying?

I don't know, considering you haven't posted anything to know where he stands.

Louie Cacchioli seems to have a problem with the official story...

"My story was never mentioned in the final report and I felt like I was being put on trial in a court room. They were trying to twist my words and make the story fit only what they wanted to hear" [PDF download]
-Firefighter Louie Cacchioli

You do realize that he is talking about the 911 C.R. here, and to my knowledge and research, it has never been verified. Do you know where this comes from originally?

But you would also have to agree that explosions could = explosives...logically right?

Explosions capable of cutting any column in the WTC buildings, would have been heard all over lower Manhattan, and recorded on dozens of recording devices.


Explosions come from explosive materials being ignited or activated correct?

Sure. In the most simple of terms....

Why wouldn't NIST or FEMA want to investigate the possibilities of explosives if people heard, saw and experienced pops like gunshots, flashes, explosions?

Because NIST found no evidence on any of the steel in the WTC that showed evidence of being harmed by any explosion. Neither did the FBI, ATF, FDNY, NYPD, ASCE, or any of the other agencies that inspected the evidence. Not one shred of physical evidence was found that would be consistant with an explosive.

Does it make sense to you that after a terrorist attack on a building that already had a terrorist attack using a bomb that explosives should not have been considered or investigated, especially considering all the supporting evidence for such?

Not when there wasn't evidence of any of them.

Wrong again... Or lying...

"I saw a flash flash flash [at] the lower level of the building. You know like when they demolish a building?"
--Assistant Fire Commissioner Stephen Gregory

Don't quotemine.

How about an incendiary called thermite? Are you claiming that thermite doesn't leave molten steel?

No steel was shown to have been affected by therm*te of any kind. Not that therm*te was found, but I digress.....

Show YOU proof? How about you show me proof they misidentified it? The burden of proof is on you, since you, who was not there,

I can't prove a negative. However, it is YOUR claim that there was molten steel, so you'll be needing to back that up.

But, just to show you how easy it is to identify, please tell me the molten substance.
whatisthis.jpg


BTW, I was there.

are claiming that all of these individuals who were there, building professionals, demolition and removal professionals, firefighters etc are all mistaken.

Firefighters and building professionals, and demolition and removal professionals, are not an authority on molten metal identification. So, yes, they could be mistaken quite easily.


What made all these people misidentify it as molten steel? Why were these people seeing the molten steel come from steel components.

whatisthis.jpg


What is it?

What makes your post 9/11 denial so much more credible than their experience on 9/11 and the days and weeks after?

Because I have an education in a relevant field, and experienced it. Your turn champ.

Do you know for a fact that it wasn't molten steel? No, not even close.

Yes. The steel recovered showed no signs of ever being molten.

Your turn champ.

Therefore accounts of pools, channels, dripping molten ends of steel beams should be considered and investigated.

Sure. However, hearsay is not evidence. Photos of hot metal being pulled out of the pile, with square edges, is not molten.

That's what demonstrates your bias and lack of falsifiability in your position is because you refuse to even consider it and let an investigation sort it out.

Not it at all. Please, I encourage you and the rest of the truthers to pool your money and do your own investigation. You're free to do exactly that.

You and your comrades here don't want it investigated because it could prove you wrong.

Nope, not it at all. We support your desire to have a new investigation. We just don't want to have to pay for another one, when the ones that were already done, are good enough.

But hey, pool your money. Ask Gage where the $80,000 went that was recently raised.....

Really? So the evidence is that airliners hit the towers and their impact and jetfuel caused a fired that caused both towers to collapse without stopping and that's that?

Yep. Since, well, it matches reality the most accurately....

And everything else is irrelevant? Sounds like starting at a conclusion and working backwards to me.

Incorrect. Sorry about your delusion.

Clearly, that is the ONLY path they have and will take. Planes hit the towers, jet fuel fires ensued, total collapses ensued and no matter theory they come up with, it must fit that model of evidence only.

I'm not sure what your point is.....

Yes, it was allegedly jet fuel fire. And again, NIST only offers a theory that starts at a conclusion. Are you not seeing this?

No, it was an office contents fire. The jet fuel fire was the ignition.

NIST only offers that one conclusion because it matches the evidence the best.


And again explosions could also = explosives right? You agree with that right? Explosives should have been explored and instead they weren't.

Except that no explosive evidence was found, and no sound capable of coming from an explosive was ever recorded. Especially immediately before collapse.

Again, we are talking about reasons why explosives should have been considered and investigated. I gave a reason.

Not even close. Not a reason at all. Explosions are COMMON in fires. COMMON. Should I investigate every fire that has any sound of explosion as a terrorist event? No, because we'd investigate damn near every fire.

Many people the day of thought it looked like a CD. Your sarcasm and lack of comprehension is noted though.

I understood you just fine, and I am glad you picked up my sarcasm. I was laying it on pretty thick.

You do realize that every other known CD that uses explosives, has audible, extremely loud explosions IMMEDIATELY prior to collapse, right? And you also realize this didn't occur on 911, right?


Yes I do. However, you do realize you are actually saying he did this "further research and studying" within 10 days of making that statement...10 DAYS AFTER 9/11... right?

Yes. There is someone who posts here, that is coworkers with Van. And it doesn't take much. Bazzant did it.

Are you saying 10 days later he KNEW FOR A FACT the collapse was due jet impacts and jet fuel fires? Something NIST would have to wrestle with for 10 years, he figured out in 10 days?

Yes. NIST didn't take 10 year to figure it out. It took 8 years to do a proper engineering analysis. Do try to follow along.

Do you consider that pressure may have been applied to him from someone in govt since he is funded by govt grants?

No. Because we've heard his own words.

I never said it was. It was part of the establishments.

Do explain.

Yes I acknowledged that. Perhaps you have reading comprehension issues.

Perhaps it's your lack of being able to express yourself correctly.

Actually correct: google it.

We've all seen this before. Go do some research champ. Stay off the CT websites.


Ok I guess you havent seen the presentation yet and instead can only offer pseudo-authoritative one word answers.
Google the presentation. I can't post URLS

I've seen it. It's garbage.

It's "ridiculous" and I don't see anywhere that I've promoted any theories about the collapse. Nor do I see how the notion of incendiaries and explosives at the towers are ridiculous.

You're promoting the controlled demolition and thermite bull ****. Do try to put your head from your rectum.

Of course considering there was no steel to forensically and thoroughly examine and investigate,

Incorrect, as already been explained to you.


and also considering there was not a concerted effort to search for explosives since we all know a conclusion(s) was reached before the investigation itself.

Incorrect again. In fact, every ounce of debris removed from GZ was searched for any kind of evidence.

Do google "Fresh Kills Landfill" and "911".

Or, read here.
http://www.nysm.nysed.gov/exhibits/longterm/documents/recovery.pdf

And here

http://911depository.info/PDFs/Othe...nc - World Trade Center Forensic Recovery.pdf


What did you think? And after they collapsed were you sure the planes and fires caused it? If so, how do you know you are right?

I thought that we'd get lucky and the fire would be extinguished.

Yes, I was. No explosives.
Personal experience and education.
 
Theres more than that and you know it. Louie Cacchioli, Albert Turi, Richard Banaciski, and Stephen Gregory just to name FOUR. So were you lying or mistaken?

And how many of them have joined that idiotic Fire Fighters for 9/11 Truth cult?

(Last i heard, none of them.)



John Shroeder is one I can think of. So were you just mistaken or lying?

Schroeder has PTSD and, from the way he talks, is probably not terribly bright. For some reason, he thinks it odd to find a crispy critter in a closet. Dude must have slept through some rescue training.

Louie Cacchioli seems to have a problem with the official story...

He has no useable evidence to offer that anything was amiss. He was inside the north tower when the south was hit and when it collapsed, the same as Schroeder. It sounded like "bombs" going off, but that is meaningless, since he was inside another building that was being hit repeatedly by chunks of another as that other started to collapse.

"My story was never mentioned in the final report and I felt like I was being put on trial in a court room. They were trying to twist my words and make the story fit only what they wanted to hear" [PDF download]
-Firefighter Louie Cacchioli.

English is not his primary language. He may not have fully understood what was being asked.

He still had nothing in particular to offer the panel.

Why wouldn't NIST or FEMA want to investigate the possibilities of explosives if people heard, saw and experienced pops like gunshots, flashes, explosions? Does it make sense to you that after a terrorist attack on a building that already had a terrorist attack using a bomb that explosives should not have been considered or investigated, especially considering all the supporting evidence for such?

Makes perfect sense to anyone with fire investigations training. They had hundreds of sets of eyes searcbhng the rubble for anythng that looked out of place. They found sod-all for demolitions evidence. The investigation was done. Live with it.

"I saw a flash flash flash [at] the lower level of the building. You know like when they demolish a building?"
--Assistant Fire Commissioner Stephen Gregory

At that range, he would also have heard any demolitions charges useful for the destruction of a building. This also ignores the fact that nothing was being done to the bottom of the building as the top discombobulated, as evidenced by the fact that the building did not topple over.

How about an incendiary called thermite? Are you claiming that thermite doesn't leave molten steel?

And bears leave lumps of indigestible plant fiber in the woods. Your point?

What made all these people misidentify it as molten steel?

Hyperbole. Happens a lot in big fires. Some metals melt, such as pot metal, aluminum, lead, copper and brass. We know that there was molten lead and brass in WTC 6. There would have to have been molten aluminum.

Now, unless you can show me a big cast iron pig, you have no proof that there was any significant amount of steel melted in the fires.

Why were these people seeing the molten steel come from steel components.

They didn't. If you mean that piece of sheet metal in the grabber, that looks more like red-hot sand or burning wood falling loose as the object is removed from the pile. You see a lot of such items in a ground fire.

What makes your post 9/11 denial so much more credible than their experience on 9/11 and the days and weeks after?

The twoofer interpretation of what they experienced is not credible, since it is based on gross ignorance. My interpretation, based on my training and experience in fire fighting, is the more credible.

Do you know for a fact that it wasn't molten steel? No, not even close. Therefore accounts of pools, channels, dripping molten ends of steel beams should be considered and investigated. That's what demonstrates your bias and lack of falsifiability in your position is because you refuse to even consider it and let an investigation sort it out. You and your comrades here don't want it investigated because it could prove you wrong.

Your making this statement without any training or experience to back it up destroys your credibility.

Planes hit the towers, jet fuel fires ensued, total collapses ensued and no matter theory they come up with, it must fit that model of evidence only.

Wrong. Evidence to the contrary must be credible, that is, must show that some other process was at work. There is none.

Yes, it was allegedly jet fuel fire. And again, NIST only offers a theory that starts at a conclusion. Are you not seeing this?

You are not reading what others have posted here. The jet fuel was just an accelerant. The fatal damage was done by ordinary Class A fuels such as paper and office furnishings.

And again explosions could also = explosives right? You agree with that right? Explosives should have been explored and instead they weren't.
They were investigated as far as was needed to establish what caused them or to show that they were not really explosions. A simple time line shows that most of them were not anything unusual.

Again, we are talking about reasons why explosives should have been considered and investigated. I gave a reason.

And none of them are valid.

Many people the day of thought it looked like a CD. Your sarcasm and lack of comprehension is noted though.

Many science professors once thought that there was a substance which they call "phlogiston."

Got a point?

However, you do realize you are actually saying he did this "further research and studyiWhat did you think? And after they collapsed were you sure the planes and fires caused it? If so, how do you know you are right?
For my part, it is consistant with everything I learned and saw as a fire fighter.
 
He has no useable evidence to offer that anything was amiss. He was inside the north tower when the south was hit and when it collapsed, the same as Schroeder. It sounded like "bombs" going off, but that is meaningless, since he was inside another building that was being hit repeatedly by chunks of another as that other started to collapse.

Louie Cacchioli sauid he was taken out of context and said it was "like" bombs" going off, so unlike Shroeder this is just a quote mine.
 
Theres more than that and you know it. Louie Cacchioli, Albert Turi, Richard Banaciski, and Stephen Gregory just to name FOUR. So were you lying or mistaken?

Just to name 4? lol, as if you have more. Quote mines don't count so that rules out Louie Cacchioli, Albert Turi and Stephen Gregory. So you have left one guy who actually thinks (at least did anyway) there were bombs, but was so out of it thinks the North Tower fell first and no one who was with him supports what he thinks because they all realise that what he experienced was the collapse of the first tower. Great witness you have there.

But you would also have to agree that explosions could = explosives...logically right?

No video evidence of explosives, no one with blast injuries, no evidence of any any in the rubble.

No, it is not logical at all to say they could have been explosives. Rational logical people know that people reporting explosions are expected in fires and in fact in many other circumstances.



Explosions come from explosive materials being ignited or activated correct? Why wouldn't NIST or FEMA want to investigate the possibilities of explosives if people heard, saw and experienced pops like gunshots, flashes, explosions?

No, because all that is expected in a normal fire. All of it. Considering how we have absolutely no evidence other than truthers sceaming "THERE WOZ LOUD NOISES" sometimes, there was no reason to spend tens or hundreds of thosuands of dollars looking at something just for conspiracy theorusts and just so they could ignore it all anyway.



Wrong again... Or lying...

"I saw a flash flash flash [at] the lower level of the building. You know like when they demolish a building?"
--Assistant Fire Commissioner Stephen Gregory


Oh a Fire Commissioner, eh? Thats quite high up you know. How about you tell me if he is one of those covering up the demolition of WTC7. You do realise that dozens and dozens and dozens have spoken about WTC7 and none of them support a single thing truthers say about it and most of them specifically contradict what truthers say about it? In over 10 years none of the 911 firefighters have even expressed a dissenting view over it either. So since the FDNY are clearly covering things up, why would they say that about WTC1 and 2? Cant have it both ways.



How about an incendiary called thermite? Are you claiming that thermite doesn't leave molten steel?


Molten steel reports are COMMON AND EXPECTED IN FIRES:

https://www.google.com/search?pz=1&...=799&cad=b&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.,cf.osb

And feel free to try different search terms, you can find lot plenty of variations of fire melting steel. If you just want to find fire creating molten metal, theres even more.

As usual there is nothing special about what happened on 911 in this regard.

Show YOU proof? How about you show me proof they misidentified it? The burden of proof is on you, since you, who was not there, are claiming that all of these individuals who were there, building professionals, demolition and removal professionals, firefighters etc are all mistaken.

Sorry I think thats our line. 99% of the experts "who were there", don't agree with you. All you have is a small amount of quotemines and then you have the even tiny pathetic number left after that that dont really support you anyway.

What made all these people misidentify it as molten steel? Why were these people seeing the molten steel come from steel components.

The same reason people misindentified it all these other times:

https://www.google.com/search?pz=1&...=799&cad=b&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.,cf.osb

Cant you guys get it through your heads? Reports of molten steel in fires are not remarkable. Neither are reports of explosions.





Are you saying 10 days later he KNEW FOR A FACT the collapse was due jet impacts and jet fuel fires? Something NIST would have to wrestle with for 10 years, he figured out in 10 days?

Good lord.... NIST did not spend the best part of 10 years trying to find out IF impact and jet fuel and fire caused the buildings to collapse.

Everyone already knew that.

The question was exactly how the failiure occured in order to improve building safety. That is what the professional world was so interested in and why you can find plenty of professonal commentary on the WTC collapses (none supporting truthgers of course) and around a hundred papers about various aspects of the collapses published in numerous respected journals. If you claim NIST is in on a conspiracy then you just implicated a helleva lot more people than just NIST.
 
Last edited:
No reason to? Not even firefighters talking about "devices" in the building, witnesses and firefighters describing hearing explosions, witnesses describing seeing flashes in the building in sequence prior to collapse, and accounts of molten steel up to even weeks after?

So you believe it is better to work backwards from a conclusion? Planes crashed, jet fuel fires ensued, buildings collapsed therefore planes and jet fuel caused the collapses... No matter what...even though people experienced and heard explosions, even though news commentators and others described it as looking just like a CD, even though Van Romero first thought it was an engineered collapse, even though "the steel melted", "pancake theory" was tossed aside, NIST was wrong about and later conceded to free fall speed, Jon Cole showed thermite can do everything it's proponents claimed effectively debunking the very refutations you all supported, even though NIST and everyone else are still only offering THEORIES, you don't feel it is prudent then or now to consider, entertain, or even investigate incendiaries and explosives?

When you saw the planes hit, were you sure the buildings were going to collapse?

Ever hear of the Gish Gallop?

Have you seen this video of Van Romero and me discussing his statements that the collapses looked like a controlled demolition?



May we expect you to retract this particular claim?

May we expect you to research your other claims, and retract them when you find they're wrong?

Me, I'm not holding my breath. Proponents of "Truth" can't handle real truth.

Dave
 
Louie Cacchioli sauid he was taken out of context and said it was "like" bombs" going off, so unlike Shroeder this is just a quote mine.
Schroeder did actually witness one explosion, and the twoofers are not bright enough to interpret what he saw and reported. The elevator in the lobby blew just as he entered the building. This was pretty clearly Willie R's second explosion, and it was jet fuel deflagrating in the elevator shaft.

So Schroeder actually blows Willie out of the water.
 
Curious as could be

Why don't you use the search function? All your claims have been made before and utterly debunked. If you can't be bothered to do any research why should we bother with you?:confused:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom