Jonathan h. Cole has uploaded a new videoclip!

Having just watched the part of the video after the above I critiqued, I'm not sure I could reply to all the points in it. Some seem quite pertinent in fact. Would be great if someone else here could.
The video has no merit; the video exposes the ignorance of the author. Feel free to run with the pertinent facts. There are none save the fact the author missed the fact the media takes nonsense and publishes it. The sad part is 911 truth builds the delusions based on the media mistakes, like melted steel. The dumbest part might be the eutectic nonsense, since the author claims to be an engineer, he failed to take chemical engineering, a big mistake, or did he forget his chem engr classes. Here we have a failed engineer trying to back in the evil doers behind 911, the big inside job delusion.

Where are the pertinent parts? Why has Cole failed to publish his claptrap in a journal? exactly

Do you mean Cole has some substance beyond exposing the news sources make BIG mistakes, publish nonsense? Or what?
 
Let me put it this way. If you keep asking him to support his view, he will put you on ignore (for not wanting to "debate").

Once again you need to apply for the 1m, you picked that a mile away ;)
 
Having just watched the part of the video after the above I critiqued, I'm not sure I could reply to all the points in it. Some seem quite pertinent in fact. Would be great if someone else here could.

You'll need to point out any pertinent points since those of us who could reply to them probably don't actually find them pertinent.
 
Next pic is of Bazants paper, I did'nt know that Bazant published his paper "Why Did the World Trade Center Collapse?" only two days after the event (seems awfully quick for a representative evaluation)

Bazant and Zhou's paper was submitted two days after the event, but not published until it had been through the peer-review process and publication schedule, so it was actually published in January 2002. It was published as a "Rapid Communication", which is a well-understood type of paper whose function is to present preliminary findings as quickly as possible; it's expected that a rapid communication will involve a more basic level of analysis than a full paper, and will be followed later by a more thorough analysis - as, indeed, Bazant went on to do. I've seen rapid communications in physics written and submitted within a couple of days of getting the experimental results; that is in fact their whole purpose. So there's actually nothing in the slightest unusual about the timing of the Bazant and Zhou paper, given that Bazant is a world-leading expert on the subject and therefore had only to apply principles with which he was already thoroughly familiar.

Video then states that the paper ignores newtons third law. But to apply newtons third law to a collapse as structurally complex as this would be foolish.

Not really, no. It's actually a barefaced lie to say that Bazant's papers ignore Newton's Third Law, as Bazant himself has pointed out in published discussions of his work (though he was a little more circumspect in his language); Newton's Third Law is implicitly included in every calculation. What truthers do is make up a completely different, and imaginary, law of physics, along the lines of "A falling block of a building must be crushed up at the same rate as the stationary lower block is crushed down", pretend it's a statement of Newton's Third Law, then say that Bazant is ignoring it. Of course he's ignoring it; it's a law of physics that doesn't exist.

Then it points out the fact that the original NIST report does not model the conditions after collapse initiation were reached. As far as I can tell, that is a good point.

Not really, no. Any competent engineer, and just about any competent scientist of any discipline, will agree that it's intuitively obvious that a moving weight of building-sized proportions will, at best, do very serious damage to any structure below it, and that the crucial engineering challenge is to stop it moving in the first place. Once the top block has started moving, disaster is inevitable.

For comparison, look at the work done by NIST to model the collapse of WTC7. They ended up with a simulation that only really reproduced the gross features of the collapse, and failed to reproduce the fine detail, as anyone could have predicted from the complexity of the task, and this part of their work led to no recommendations for future construction codes. All it's done is give truthers another target for irrelevant sniping. As far as I can see, modelling WTC7 after collapse initiation was more or less a complete waste of time and money.

Dave
 
All I will say is that video that Marokkaan linked to was specifically crafted for people like Marokkaan and other "useful idiots".
 
Bazant and Zhou's paper was submitted two days after the event, but not published until it had been through the peer-review process and publication schedule, so it was actually published in January 2002. It was published as a "Rapid Communication", which is a well-understood type of paper whose function is to present preliminary findings as quickly as possible; it's expected that a rapid communication will involve a more basic level of analysis than a full paper, and will be followed later by a more thorough analysis - as, indeed, Bazant went on to do. I've seen rapid communications in physics written and submitted within a couple of days of getting the experimental results; that is in fact their whole purpose. So there's actually nothing in the slightest unusual about the timing of the Bazant and Zhou paper, given that Bazant is a world-leading expert on the subject and therefore had only to apply principles with which he was already thoroughly familiar.

...

Not really, no. Any competent engineer, and just about any competent scientist of any discipline, will agree that it's intuitively obvious that a moving weight of building-sized proportions will, at best, do very serious damage to any structure below it, and that the crucial engineering challenge is to stop it moving in the first place. Once the top block has started moving, disaster is inevitable.
...
Zeuzzz,

Adding to what Dave said,

1. Bazant and Zhou writing up a first paper within 2 days is actually a good measure for how easy it is to predict the basic overall behaviour of highrise buildings such as the WTC towers once they are allowed to fall through the height of one floor. I am not a structural engineer or a physicist, but even I once drafted a simple model which predicted total collapse roughly 40-70% of free fall acceleration. I didn't look at energy budgets and was ignorant of structural engineering formulas, but did apply Newtonian physics directly. Took me, with high school physics more than 20 years in my past, an afternoon to work it out numerically.

2. Bazant's first paper, 2 days after, has not really been refuted since - in fact they followed up with more detailed analysis; the paper passed the test of time

3. NIST, being aware of Bazant an Zhou, understanding its implications thoroughly, and of course being a body full of highly qualified engineers with hundreds of man years experience investigating building failures between them, knew full well that analysing collapse progress beyond the critical initiation phase was a useless endeavour, for many reasons:
3.1 It was clear from basic considerations such as Bazant and Zhou that no conditions in addition to those that led to collapse initiation were to be looked for to explain total and rapid collapse
3.2 It was clear from the beginning that the forces and energies at play in an ongoing collapse beyond a point in time very soon after initiation were so vastly overwhelming, exceeding maximum designed for load by an order of magnitude (factor 10) or more, that no recommendations to improve building strength such that collapse could be arrested would ever be feasible. It would involve increasing the strength of all structural components by a factor of 10 or more, which would quickly translate into construction costs rising by a prohibitive factor. It is much much easier to improve buildings such that collapse doesn't initiate quite as soon, so that's what responsible engineers turned their resources to.
3.3 It was clear that the dynamics of total collapse are so vastly complex, and the initial conditions known with some margin of error only, as to totally prohibit any chance of explaining every observed detail: It's classic chaos theory
In short, truthers criticizing NIST for not modelling collapse progression are asking for the government to waste money.
 
Then it points out the fact that the original NIST report does not model the conditions after collapse initiation were reached. As far as I can tell, that is a good point.

Unfortunately, this is a canard that's been latched onto by members of the truth movement as some sort of critique that the analysis was woefully incomplete. That sidesteps the fact that it was done on purpose:
31. Why didn’t NIST fully model the collapse initiation and propagation of the WTC towers?
The first objective of the NIST WTC investigation included determining why and how WTC 1 and WTC 2 collapsed following the initial impacts of the aircraft (see NIST NCSTAR 1). Determining the sequence of events leading up to collapse initiation was critical to fulfilling this objective. Once the collapse had begun, the propagation of the collapse was readily explained without the same complexity of modeling.
Source: http://www.nist.gov/el/disasterstudies/wtc/faqs_wtctowers.cfm
​
My bolding. Dave and Oystein here have touched on why:
For comparison, look at the work done by NIST to model the collapse of WTC7. They ended up with a simulation that only really reproduced the gross features of the collapse, and failed to reproduce the fine detail, as anyone could have predicted from the complexity of the task, and this part of their work led to no recommendations for future construction codes. All it's done is give truthers another target for irrelevant sniping. As far as I can see, modelling WTC7 after collapse initiation was more or less a complete waste of time and money.

Dave

3.2 It was clear from the beginning that the forces and energies at play in an ongoing collapse beyond a point in time very soon after initiation were so vastly overwhelming, exceeding maximum designed for load by an order of magnitude (factor 10) or more, that no recommendations to improve building strength such that collapse could be arrested would ever be feasible. It would involve increasing the strength of all structural components by a factor of 10 or more, which would quickly translate into construction costs rising by a prohibitive factor. It is much much easier to improve buildings such that collapse doesn't initiate quite as soon, so that's what responsible engineers turned their resources to.
3.3 It was clear that the dynamics of total collapse are so vastly complex, and the initial conditions known with some margin of error only, as to totally prohibit any chance of explaining every observed detail: It's classic chaos theory
In short, truthers criticizing NIST for not modelling collapse progression are asking for the government to waste money.
To summarize all that lays behind what Dave and Oystein said, it comes down to this:
  1. As Bazant et. al. demonstrated, once the collapse started, it was going to go all the way. As has been pointed out before: Bazant and Zhou presumed an impossibly ideal scenario as their starting point (that the collapse only impacted the vertical supports in a way that allowed them to exert maximum vertical resistence to the collapse), and their calculations showed that there was still so much energy available that the collapse would proceed anyway. Therefore there is no need to model the towers collapse beyond initiation. Once it starts, it's finishing, because it's demonstrated that there's far too little resistence to it in the maximum ideal condition. And because both towers (his work only covers the main towers, IIRC) were compromised by both the jetliners impacts and the subsequent fires, there was no way the bottom segments could even come close to meeting its own end of the ideal situation*.
  2. The collapse becomes increasingly "chaotic" i.e. highly sensitive to initial conditions. Oystein directly came out and said it, and I'm certain Dave's discussed this too in prior threads. When you take any gross element of the towers - a floor truss, for example - and model its behavior, you're stuck with a situation that's rapidly changing as the collapse progresses, and where that truss goes completely depends on specifics of that situation as time progresses. When a truss impacts a lower floor, does it get deflected north? South? Some other direction? Is it deflected by inches, or feet? And so on. Multiply that by however many elements of the structure you wanted to model, and then add the complexity of those elements themselves distorting, coming apart, absorbing energy or imparting it to another element... that is a classicly chaotic system. The second reason that NIST wouldn't go beyond collapse initiation is that the situation grows so complex that it becomes practically impossible to model. You're modeling so many interactions of so many pieces that you end up with an expanding series of increasingly complex calculations as the collapse progresses, and each of those interactions are again sensitive to the initial conditions that a tiny difference in one place has an extreme effect down the line.
In the end, what use is there to model the collapse beyond initiation? The gross features are known, and NIST's brief was to gain understanding in order to determine what needs to be done to increase future safety. They fulfilled that brief by modeling as far as they did. Furthermore, modeling the system beyond that point is doing little more than tracing where the rubble bounces. Given that the core reason for the towers collapses were determined, and given that modeling beyond that point would've been painfully difficult to do, it's reasonable to conclude that NIST did as much as they needed to do.

I know this specific objection by truthers sounds reasonable. That's the "danger" in them: Some do indeed sound reasonable. But you'll find that those objections are pushed anyway even though the truther knows what the answer is. You'll see that quite often. The goal in presenting that critique is not to cite reasonable objection; it's to give the impression that they're raising legitimate questions. The issue of the collapse not being modeled beyond initiation was legitimate the first time. But since then, it's been answered. And now, it's no longer being presented as critique, but rather for the purposes of proselytization. It's a well-evolved tactic on the truthers part.

Hope that helps.



* I'm also ignoring the fact that the Bazant/Zhou scenario required perfect alignment of column-to-column impacts, which would be extremely difficult if one was lowering the upper segment onto the lower via crane. It's obviously an impossible situation in the chaos of an uncontrolled collapse, but that's the entire point of the analysis: Bazant and Zhou's collapse scenario was the best case for resistence - direct, perfectly vertical column-to-column impacts - and we all know that the real-world collapse was rubble on floors/floor truss to column failure. We all know that the truss to column connections are far weaker, and we also know that the floors present a far, far larger area to impact than the tops of the columns did. So we know that no matter what, there was far more than enough energy to complete the collapse.
 
I just watched the whole video and boy am I mad. Why are all those scientists lying to us? Do you think they work for the Illuminati? They're the same guys who laugh at us when we talk about chemtrails and weather control. So there you go. More proof that they really control the world. If only we could find out who was really pulling their strings. Larry Silverstein maybe.

And what's with that Dave Thomas guy? What makes him so important that he gets special mention in a Truther video? He's not the only guy who's written bad things about Truthers in those debunker magazines. Could Dave be an agent of the Illuminati? I think this is worth investigating.

Thanks for the info, Scott! That prompted me to actually watch the whole video. :mad:

At least some truthers have finally responded to my July/August 2011 Skeptical Inquirer article. Even though Richard Gage and AE911truthiness responded vigorously to Ted Goertzel's article in the Jan/Feb. 2011 Skeptical Inquirer, they completely ignored mine, leading me to think that they would rather not have any truthers reading that article, period. That's why I made it available for all in this Gage-Bane post.

It's funny that Cole mentioned the 1934 World's Fair radio tower demolition with ThermiteTM (12:06 in). You see, that was never mentioned by any truther, anywhere. I only learned about it from an attentive reader who wrote told Skeptical Inquirer about it. Then, we discussed it here on JREF, and I presume that's where Cole learned about it.

Cheers, Dave
 
At least some truthers have finally responded to my July/August 2011 Skeptical Inquirer article. Even though Richard Gage and AE911truthiness responded vigorously to Ted Goertzel's article in the Jan/Feb. 2011 Skeptical Inquirer, they completely ignored mine, leading me to think that they would rather not have any truthers reading that article, period. That's why I made it available for all in this Gage-Bane post.


Thanks for the link!

You say that truthers have since replied to that article, do you have a link to this too?
 
Thanks for the link!

You say that truthers have since replied to that article, do you have a link to this too?

Look up ^^^^^^. "Jonathan h. Cole has uploaded a new videoclip!".

Perhaps you missed the Opening Post? The topic of this very thread?
 


You seem to be adamant that 9/11 is a conspiracy, and you try to make your point by posting videos. But you never comment on whats on the clips, instead you use an entire thread to quarrel with people that wants to know your take on the clips you post. That is not the way to get thru to people; in fact you are a much better "asset" for the non-ct´s than you are for the "truth movement", cause you are actually proving their point - ct`ers dont know their science, they dont know how to argue for their opinions on the "cause" and they get offensive cause they are wrong or called out on their arguements (or lack of them rather). However; if thats the way you wanna play this, you need to understand that the non-ct`ers will come down on you like a ton of bricks. And putting folks on your ignore list every time you get called on your lack of answers/replies is sandbox behaviour; more fitting for a five year old than a grown person. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
And putting folks on your ignore list every time you get called on your lack of answers/replies is sandbox behaviour; more fitting for a five year old than a grown person. :rolleyes:

Hey, stop that! He's prepared to defend the claims he links to, or back down if they prove to be false. We know this because he squeeked so.

Whenever I post a video, I am prepared to defend it or even back down from a claim that I may be making with it. Can I expect the same from you?

Man or mouse, it is up to you.
 
Can somebody point me to anywhere Marokkaan has ever backed down from a claim he is making when shown to be wrong?
 
Hey, stop that! He's prepared to defend the claims he links to, or back down if they prove to be false. We know this because he squeeked so.


Yeah riiiiiiiiiiite! And my 78 year old mum is a paratrooper..... :jaw-dropp ;)
 
Can somebody point me to anywhere Marokkaan has ever backed down from a claim he is making when shown to be wrong?

I asked for evidence for that claim in post #43. None has been given so far.

Note that he could have easily snookered me there by answering "OK, so maybe I've never backed down," but that requires one thing CT nutters (and fanatics in general) never seem to have: the ability to laugh at yourself.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom