John Edward vs Sylvia Browne (Question for Robert S. Lancaster)

[psychicuk]

I would like to know the reason why Robert S. Lancaster put up a site to stop Sylvia Browne yet why would you not do the same for John Edward or any other well known psychics.

 

[Starthinker]

Cause some are the real deal and cannot be criticized.

 

[psychicuk]

Cause some are the real deal and cannot be criticized.

So John is real?

 

[Starthinker]

I am almost certain he is real.

 

[GeeMack]

So John is real?

Just as real as thieves like Sylvia and her kid, don't you agree?

 

[Lisa Simpson]

John Edward is real. As in, he's not a puppet.

 

[psychicuk]

Just as real as thieves like Sylvia and her kid, don't you agree?

You have a job so do I, only fair to make a living.

 

[Starthinker]

You have a job so do I, only fair to make a living.

Yep, and some make their living from the non-living.

 

[Lisa Simpson]

I would like to know the reason why Robert S. Lancaster put up a site to stop Sylvia Browne yet why would you not do the same for John Edward or any other well known psychics.

Not to speak for Robert but:

A. a site like Stop Sylvia takes time so doing more than one at a time would be difficult

B. At the time Stop Sylvia started, Sylvia Browne had a weekly platform to spew her lies, and John Edward did not. Therefore, Sylvia was, at least nominally, a better target to "stop".

 

[psychicuk]

Not to speak for Robert but:

A. a site like Stop Sylvia takes time so doing more than one at a time would be difficult

B. At the time Stop Sylvia started, Sylvia Browne had a weekly platform to spew her lies, and John Edward did not. Therefore, Sylvia was, at least nominally, a better target to "stop".

Then he should do a stopjohn site and give up his futile attacks on us.

 

[mist]

I would like to know the reason why Robert S. Lancaster put up a site to stop Sylvia Browne yet why would you not do the same for John Edward or any other well known psychics.

I'm guessing you read http://www.stopsylvia.com/faq/ and you created this thread for fun, am I right?

 

[The Central Scrutinizer]

I would like to know the reason why Robert S. Lancaster put up a site to stop Sylvia Browne yet why would you not do the same for John Edward or any other well known psychics.

Cause Sylvia is the only fake psychic.

 

[Lisa Simpson]

Then he should do a stopjohn site and give up his futile attacks on us.

Us? Since when do you speak for Sylvia? Plus, don't you think there will be supporters of John Edward who would say "leave us alone and pick on Sylvia"? Not to mention, his attacks are hardly "futile". They are necessary to expose a fraud.

 

[ExMinister]

Then he should do a stopjohn site and give up his futile attacks on us.

Why would he do that? His site has helped reach a great number of people who might have otherwise been deceived, and continues to do so.

At one time he had plans to do other Stop sites. Who knows, only he can tell you whether those sites are still in the works, but I don't think you need to worry about Stop Sylvia going anywhere.

 

[psychicuk]

Us? Since when do you speak for Sylvia? Plus, don't you think there will be supporters of John Edward who would say "leave us alone and pick on Sylvia"? Not to mention, his attacks are hardly "futile". They are necessary to expose a fraud.

It's a job not fraud...we all have to make money to make a living.

 

[Lisa Simpson]

It's a job not fraud...we all have to make money to make a living.

So telling people lies is a good way to make a living? Is what Bernie Madoff did acceptable in your eyes?

 

[psychicuk]

So telling people lies is a good way to make a living? Is what Bernie Madoff did acceptable in your eyes?

The man made a mistake is all I will say on that matter.

 

[ExMinister]

Us? Since when do you speak for Sylvia? Plus, don't you think there will be supporters of John Edward who would say "leave us alone and pick on Sylvia"? Not to mention, his attacks are hardly "futile". They are necessary to expose a fraud.

Psychicuk has been known to refer to Sylvia Browne as his mother and to Chris as his good friend. I don't have time to link or quote them at the moment, but I think the reference to Chris is in the middle of his Psychic and Medium Readings Challenge thread.

 

[Starthinker]

It's a job not fraud...we all have to make money to make a living.

The really odd thing about this is when I compare my "job" to Sylvias I wonder why people support her and we are just scraping by.

 

[The Central Scrutinizer]

It's a job not fraud...we all have to make money to make a living.

You're right. From what I understand, Robert scrapped his plans for www.stoppsychicukfromworkingatmcdonalds.com.