Japanese mayor: Wartime sex slaves were necessary

I read an article on the Asahi Shinbun where there is written that Hashimoto-san did not say anything like that.
I start to wonder where is the truth.
Maybe it is just a fake news made up from Yahoo!?

(is it possible to upload photos directly from the PC? )
 
Oh god, the Japanese are quite ********** up, largely from the fact that the Allies didn't really reconstruct them the way they did the Nazis. I'm sure they would brag about conquest if they felt they could get away with it.

Another idiotic statement.
Let` s wait until Al-Qaeda or China will "reconstruct" the Americans, then :D
 
I read an article on the Asahi Shinbun where there is written that Hashimoto-san did not say anything like that.
I start to wonder where is the truth.
Maybe it is just a fake news made up from Yahoo!?

(is it possible to upload photos directly from the PC? )

That's not what the Japan Times is reporting.

Besides, all politicians the World over claim to have been misquoted, quoted out of context, misunderstood, misinterpreted, and generally being victims of bigoted journalists whenever they are caught with their foot in their mouth.
 
That's not what the Japan Times is reporting.

Besides, all politicians the World over claim to have been misquoted, quoted out of context, misunderstood, misinterpreted, and generally being victims of bigoted journalists whenever they are caught with their foot in their mouth.

Or maybe you should read Japanese newspapers

旧日本軍の慰安婦を「必要だった」などとした発言について16日朝、フジテレビの番組で「誤解で傷ついた方がいらっしゃるなら大変申し訳ない」と発言。16日夕、この発言は元慰安婦に向けた謝罪だとした。市長や共同代表の辞職には「選挙で有権者が判断すればいい」「(党内の)みんなから降ろされない限り、自分から降りません」と否定した。
http://www.asahi.com/politics/update/0516/OSK201305160072.html

橋下氏「傷ついた方がいるなら申し訳ない」 慰安婦発言
http://www.asahi.com/politics/update/0516/OSK201305160004.html

大阪市議会は15日、橋下市長に対し、いわゆる従軍慰安婦問題について誤解を招く発言を慎むよう申し入れた。
http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/politics/news/20130516-OYT1T00667.htm

Answering an idiotic remark with another every bit as stupid isn't going to advance the debate ...

On this you are perfectly right, Flo-san ;)
 
Well, the history book thing is good to know, but I'll still want to find further evidence of this. Not that I'm doubting you. We often have a furor in the skeptics community over some school board teaching whatever bit of woo, only to find out that it's a single school, not tax-supported, and not the standard eighth grade science text, after all.

If we are talking about the same issue, the New History Japan textbooks from 2000-2001, were supposedly used by 0.038% of junior high schools.

As to the latter part? I'd like that they teach their future citizens what actually happened. Tainting that sentence with "feel guilty and ashamed over" is a tad hyperbolic, wouldn't you say? I don't want them losing sleep or losing their lunch over attrocities, but I want them to know what happened. I want them to know that their country was the "aggressor nation" and not a poor picked-upon victim of its historical allies and their new buddies. I'd like them to own up to Nanjing and Changi and the Philippines; and to comfort women and the truth in that respect - that it was "to the victors go the spoils".

As to "which countries".... I actually think the US does a pretty good job of teaching slavery and its carpetbagging/Jim Crow aftermath. I also know a lot of young-ish Germans who probably have detailed knowledge of WWII, the Nazis and the "Final Solution" that they would not likely have if "20th Century History" was an elective course and that history wasn't "crammed down their throats" (to quote a German girlfriend*) at almost every level of their education.

*She was just expressing annoyance at them thinking she had to be taught the same thing every year. "I got it! Don't make me watch those sickening films, again."

Well, indeed. And Germany was one of the places I had in mind where things are overdone just a little bit, are they not?
 
So do you think the number 731 was deliberately chosen to piss people off?

I don't think so.

By no means did I imply that, but it was just bad placement, like wearing a necklace with a swastika on it to a Holocaust memorial site.
 
By no means did I imply that, but it was just bad placement, like wearing a necklace with a swastika on it to a Holocaust memorial site.

I think Abe was visiting a base which was used to rescue people after the tsunami, so it isn't really comparable to a Holocaust memorial site given that the tsunami victims were mostly Japanese. And I think that most people choosing to wear a swastika necklace are going to be rather Nazified people to begin with; it's not as if they would turn up there and think "Oh, whoops! I can't believe I wore my swastika necklace here of all places!"
 
Well, indeed. And Germany was one of the places I had in mind where things are overdone just a little bit, are they not?

Not at all. I find it rather comforting that most of the OTHER people in the world who can be counted on to say, "Never again!" are in Germany, just as I would like that every school kid in America grows up actually understanding the history of slavery and Jim Crow and every citizen of Taiwan knows their history as regards the original population of that island,... and a dozen other societies I can think of. I just don't want any white-washing of history.
 
Not at all. I find it rather comforting that most of the OTHER people in the world who can be counted on to say, "Never again!" are in Germany, just as I would like that every school kid in America grows up actually understanding the history of slavery and Jim Crow and every citizen of Taiwan knows their history as regards the original population of that island,... and a dozen other societies I can think of. I just don't want any white-washing of history.

I agree. Well, then, I will try and research a little more about the history textbooks that are used in Japan by actually buying one and reading what they say.

Specifically, I will look for references to the Rape of Nanking, Unit 731 and the comfort women issue. It is best to have some actual hard evidence.

Hopefully I will be able to come back here and report my findings.
 
Has anyone asked Hashimoto if his logic applies current day Okinawa? I mean those poor American solidiers bearing up under the pressure and responsibility of being the local force for a world power. Surely, it must be okay for them to go through the area raping available local females? Why should they be prosecuted. A man needs to get his rocks off, after all. So they raped some high school kid? Big deal!

It's funny you should ask because in the same interview he said some other stuff:

Toru Hashimoto, the young, brash mayor of Osaka who is co-leader of an emerging conservative political party, also said that U.S. troops currently based in southern Japan should patronize the local sex industry more to help reduce rapes and other assaults.

. . .

Hashimoto said he recently visited Okinawa in southern Japan and told the U.S. commander there "to make better use of the sex industry."

"He froze, and then with a wry smile said that is off-limits for the U.S. military," he said.

"I told him that there are problems because of such formalities," Hashimoto said, explaining that he was not referring to illegal prostitution but to places operating within the law. "If you don't make use of those places you cannot properly control the sexual energy of those tough guys."

A little more background on Hashimoto here. Salacious tabloid-y stuff, but if you are interested.
 
And people in the US who still think that napalming Vietnam was something like "a noble cause"

http://news.google.com/newspapers?n...cstAAAAIBAJ&sjid=GKEFAAAAIBAJ&pg=4029,4022614

I don't think you have been in a thread where I had (once again) to clarify a minor point about rules of warfare (the actual ones, not what some people think they are). The rules as to civilians essentially say that you should try hard/make the best effort you can given information and capabilities not to harm civilians if it is possible not to. BUT it is also noted that this does not apply if those civilians are close to/in areas where they are not fully seperate from enemy troops, if they are in facilities/areas where troops are quartered, in locations hiding troops, making materials for troops, producing electricity or other items being used for the functions of the troops (water supply, food production/preperation - etc. The VC had people doing all of those things. **** happened. Nobody likes it (I hope), but the Rules are designed to make sure the military participants only strike at each other. The VC, NK, Al quaeda, etc were/are cowards refusing to follow those civilized rules and simply die.
 
I don't think you have been in a thread where I had (once again) to clarify a minor point about rules of warfare (the actual ones, not what some people think they are). The rules as to civilians essentially say that you should try hard/make the best effort you can given information and capabilities not to harm civilians if it is possible not to. BUT it is also noted that this does not apply if those civilians are close to/in areas where they are not fully seperate from enemy troops, if they are in facilities/areas where troops are quartered, in locations hiding troops, making materials for troops, producing electricity or other items being used for the functions of the troops (water supply, food production/preperation - etc. The VC had people doing all of those things. **** happened. Nobody likes it (I hope), but the Rules are designed to make sure the military participants only strike at each other. The VC, NK, Al quaeda, etc were/are cowards refusing to follow those civilized rules and simply die.

Again, whitewashing, spinning and so forth..

Just because you happen to support one of the sides.

I think your comments are not so different from Hashimoto-san` s.

In fact, Hashimoto-san was half-disounting rape, you are half-discounting even worse crimes.

Disgusting but unfortunately not unusual, even here in Japan.
 
Wow, with no more offense than you give, I believe you have either a comprehension problem or a disagreement with the entire civilized world. I did not give you my opinion, I gave you the rules for civilians in war in the civilized world. You are free not to like them - but that has no bearing on anything- certainly not on the person trying to explain the results of what you do not like and why it brought about those things thast so trouble you when uncivilized persons feel free to use civilians as shields, slave labor, paid labor in war industries, etc. I refered to them (the military persons allowing much less actively pusuing such illegal actions) as cowards - they are because they hide behind civilians instead of being civilized and dying for their beliefs - or, more often, criminal desires. YMMV, but I seriously could not care less about your beliefs if this is what they are/how they function.
 
Oh, since I may have written above your pay-grade, to be more precise and specific. The use of burning/some chemical/mechanical agents on locations where enemy soldiers are hiding is absolutely legal and ethical by the rules of warfare whether civilians are present or not(Geneva and the like) as the rules very specifically note/state that soldiers hiding among civilians is IS a war crime (they are responsible for any harm/death that occurs due to their doing such cowardly acts) - the attackers (us in your case) are not - they are allowed to destroy the enemy wherever they hide - the only conditional is that they also are to AS MUCH AS TECHNICALLY AND PHYSICALLY POSSIBLE WITHOUT EXPOSING THEM (the good guys) TO DEATH/DAMAGE attempt to not harm the civilians. That is not in any way saying civilian deaths are a war crime (or civilian harm).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom