I don't think you have been in a thread where I had (once again) to clarify a minor point about rules of warfare (the actual ones, not what some people think they are). The rules as to civilians essentially say that you should try hard/make the best effort you can given information and capabilities not to harm civilians if it is possible not to. BUT it is also noted that this does not apply if those civilians are close to/in areas where they are not fully seperate from enemy troops, if they are in facilities/areas where troops are quartered, in locations hiding troops, making materials for troops, producing electricity or other items being used for the functions of the troops (water supply, food production/preperation - etc. The VC had people doing all of those things. **** happened. Nobody likes it (I hope), but the Rules are designed to make sure the military participants only strike at each other. The VC, NK, Al quaeda, etc were/are cowards refusing to follow those civilized rules and simply die.