Japanese mayor: Wartime sex slaves were necessary

Watanabe

Banned
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
1,447
Yet another example about some people from Japan who have still to come to terms with our past.
The above may not be the typical opinion of the average Japanese, but there are lots of people here that try to whitewash what Japan did in WWII.
Let alone that this all puts even more pressure on Japan in a time where there are lots of border disputes with Korea and China

http://japandailypress.com/pm-abe-says-wwii-war-crime-trials-were-just-victors-justice-1525189

http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/world/2007-03-05-japan-sex-slaves_N.htm?csp=34
 
By chance, is the mayor's name <SNIP> ?
.
.


Edited by Locknar: 
Edited, breach of rule 0, rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Every culture has a guy like that. Remember there are still people in the USA who don't think slavery was that bad.
 
Which mayor are you talking about? The two links are from Abe's two stints as PM.

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...ssary-Japanese-mayor/articleshow/20046166.cms


Here's one copy of the article.

The ridiculous thing is that it's only other countries doing the complaining. Why aren't his fellow Japanese shouting him down at the top of their lungs? This coupled with their rewriting of the history texts just further proves that "the losers get to write the history".
 
I see it's Hashimoto. That doesn't surprise me at all. The guy's an ********.

Toru Hashimoto, the young, brash mayor of Osaka who is also co-leader of an emerging conservative political party, also told reporters that there wasn't clear evidence that the Japanese military coerced women to become what are euphemistically called "comfort women."

He'll probably be Prime Minister in a few years.
 
It seems he partially softened what he said:

Then, he said, “It is a result of the tragedy of the war that they became comfort women against their will. The responsibility for the war also lies with Japan. We have to politely offer kind words to (former) comfort women.”

And:

He also said, “When I checked the history of those years, I found that not only the Japanese army but also those of various countries were utilizing (comfort women).”

http://ajw.asahi.com/article/behind_news/politics/AJ201305130131

I expect Hashimoto is not as bad as Ishihara. Although as he formed a party with him, we can't expect him to be too much better.
 
This will help Japan's image in Korea and China, the two main sources of the "Comfort Girls" in WW2.
 
Hashimoto. What a dumbass. They need to stop putting feet in mouths. Why are they even talking about this stuff at all? Stay out of that minefield.
 
You know I think the cause of Vietnam wasn't bad but the tactics used left a lot to be desired.

Yes, I also remember you were proposing to bomb Congo, Yemen, Saudi Arabia and several other countries (not yours, though..).

But you are right that we are derailing this thread.
 
If you will all park your emotions for a moment:

If you look at this from the PoV of a Japanese foot soldier, circa 1937 to 1945, the sentiment this man presented makes a certain sense. You've been fighting for months, away from home, getting shot at, and the Major from up at Regimental staff gets a few babes for your platoon for a little tension release. Good for morale, but bad for the females in question.

From the PoV of the Geneva Accords, and the treatment of non-combatants, it's a red card then, and a red card now. :mad:

To bring this up in 2013, and try to rationalize the above PoV just makes no sense ... unless this guy is trolling for a particular political reaction.

So who is his audience, politically, in Japan? :confused:
 
Hashimoto. What a dumbass. They need to stop putting feet in mouths. Why are they even talking about this stuff at all? Stay out of that minefield.

Well, this is kind of the worrying thing. It's not going to be a populist winner, so these folks are seemingly willing to be stalking horses for things they believe in. And the problem is that with more years between us and the end of WWII, and the revisionism they've allowed in their textbooks, there are any number of Japanese longing for a return to their glorious past - the one that ruined them, but that you'd never know of based on their re-emergence as a global economic power and cultural hub. The last time I saw any kind of write-up on Japanese opinion polls, that sector seems to be growing. (That was a few years ago and if any of you guys in Japan have any links to good data on that, I'd appreciate seeing it.)

I'm pleased to see, counter to my earlier post in this thread, that a lot of politicos spoke out and figuratively kicked this guy's butt. They've got to forget all this face crap and go after these miscreants every time they open their mouths.

Has anyone asked Hashimoto if his logic applies current day Okinawa? I mean those poor American solidiers bearing up under the pressure and responsibility of being the local force for a world power. Surely, it must be okay for them to go through the area raping available local females? Why should they be prosecuted. A man needs to get his rocks off, after all. So they raped some high school kid? Big deal!
 
So who is his audience, politically, in Japan? :confused:

Hashimoto's support seems to be a bit of a mixed bag. I've seen people deride him as the worst thing that has ever existed, one minute, and the same people praising him for talking good sense the next.

His political ally is Shintaro Ishihara, ex-governor of Tokyo, who has never made any secret of his affection for Imperial Japan's past. He wrote the screenplay for a movie praising the Kamikaze pilots and has made regular nasty comments about Koreans and Chinese. He was publicly announced that the police would have to prepare for rioting Koreans if there was ever a big earthquake, which is a particularly insensitive thing to say given that when there actually was an earthquake in 1923, the police in fact took the opportunity to kill Koreans en masse as well as socialists and anarchists. Yet, Ishihara was very popular with his endless calls for Japan to become more independent of US foreign policy, and he kept getting voted in.

Hashimoto's big thing is cutting costs in local government, encouraging more investment such as wanting to open casinos and getting stricter on "delinquent" children by making them go back to schools on Saturdays.

This seems to be what his main support rests on, less so his nationalist side which has not so much support in Osaka where there is a very large Korean population.

Well, this is kind of the worrying thing. It's not going to be a populist winner, so these folks are seemingly willing to be stalking horses for things they believe in. And the problem is that with more years between us and the end of WWII, and the revisionism they've allowed in their textbooks, there are any number of Japanese longing for a return to their glorious past - the one that ruined them, but that you'd never know of based on their re-emergence as a global economic power and cultural hub. The last time I saw any kind of write-up on Japanese opinion polls, that sector seems to be growing. (That was a few years ago and if any of you guys in Japan have any links to good data on that, I'd appreciate seeing it.)

I'm pleased to see, counter to my earlier post in this thread, that a lot of politicos spoke out and figuratively kicked this guy's butt. They've got to forget all this face crap and go after these miscreants every time they open their mouths.

Has anyone asked Hashimoto if his logic applies current day Okinawa? I mean those poor American solidiers bearing up under the pressure and responsibility of being the local force for a world power. Surely, it must be okay for them to go through the area raping available local females? Why should they be prosecuted. A man needs to get his rocks off, after all. So they raped some high school kid? Big deal!

I think some of the stuff about the textbooks has been overdone. As far as I know, the textbooks that caused all the outrage about fifteen years ago were not used by hardly any schools. Aside from that it isn't quite clear to me what people are expecting Japan should put in its history textbooks. Which countries use history classes to present a litany of sins that each child is to feel guilty and ashamed over? As far as I know, history classes are not opportunities to roll out the Imperial flag and glory in the East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere.
 
I think some of the stuff about the textbooks has been overdone. As far as I know, the textbooks that caused all the outrage about fifteen years ago were not used by hardly any schools. Aside from that it isn't quite clear to me what people are expecting Japan should put in its history textbooks. Which countries use history classes to present a litany of sins that each child is to feel guilty and ashamed over? As far as I know, history classes are not opportunities to roll out the Imperial flag and glory in the East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere.

Well, the history book thing is good to know, but I'll still want to find further evidence of this. Not that I'm doubting you. We often have a furor in the skeptics community over some school board teaching whatever bit of woo, only to find out that it's a single school, not tax-supported, and not the standard eighth grade science text, after all.

As to the latter part? I'd like that they teach their future citizens what actually happened. Tainting that sentence with "feel guilty and ashamed over" is a tad hyperbolic, wouldn't you say? I don't want them losing sleep or losing their lunch over attrocities, but I want them to know what happened. I want them to know that their country was the "aggressor nation" and not a poor picked-upon victim of its historical allies and their new buddies. I'd like them to own up to Nanjing and Changi and the Philippines; and to comfort women and the truth in that respect - that it was "to the victors go the spoils".

As to "which countries".... I actually think the US does a pretty good job of teaching slavery and its carpetbagging/Jim Crow aftermath. I also know a lot of young-ish Germans who probably have detailed knowledge of WWII, the Nazis and the "Final Solution" that they would not likely have if "20th Century History" was an elective course and that history wasn't "crammed down their throats" (to quote a German girlfriend*) at almost every level of their education.

*She was just expressing annoyance at them thinking she had to be taught the same thing every year. "I got it! Don't make me watch those sickening films, again."
 
Oh god, the Japanese are quite ********** up, largely from the fact that the Allies didn't really reconstruct them the way they did the Nazis. I'm sure they would brag about conquest if they felt they could get away with it.

Oh, and Ahinzo Abe has really pissed off South Korea with this plane.

OB-XM116_abe_je_D_20130515015225.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom