It's just a coincidence!!!

Cool!
In any case you make your arguments very clearly. I wouldn't have been able to tell if you hadn't said that English wasn't your first language!

Maybe asking where you're from was a bit of a stupid question considering your location is displayed beneath your icon. Gimme a break, I'm tired and it's late here. :)
 
[Originally Posted by fls
Since it looks like Rodney is off in the Real World....]

I wouldn't be too sure about that.
I beg your pardon? I was vacationing in the Seattle, Washington area -- not in an astral plane or in some God-forsaken place like Sweden. ;)

[Originally Posted by fls
I don't think telling stories about interesting and unusual events and declaring that they are merely coincidences is persuasive to Rodney or any other proponent of Synchronicity. From their perspective, you are simply ignoring or missing a deeper connection - like calling mesothelioma in a dock worker a coincidence. . . I think that it would be more useful to tell your story, but place it into the appropriate context in order to guess at the probability . . .
I'm just suggesting that it would be more useful to make our reasoning explicit, since that is the step that Rodney and others seem to miss.]

You're right! It just frustrates me that my knowledge is so lacking in these subjects, I often find myself unable to explain things in a proper way. I think I understand it well enough when I read about it, and then I can't relate it in a good way to other people, especially not in English I am glad you have replied in this thread. I could never have explained things this correctly and well.
So what's the excuse for the native English speakers? :) The fact is that Linda is on to something -- a number of people here have posted coincidences for which they have no logical explanation. So they basically fall back on Isaac Asimov's old saw: "It would be far stranger if there were no coincidences." But that does nothing to resolve the issue at hand.
 
I beg your pardon? I was vacationing in the Seattle, Washington area -- not in an astral plane or in some God-forsaken place like Sweden. ;)

I thought that maybe you carried your own little universe with you where ever you went, and god has forsaken Sweden? Good, that'll hopefully mean fewer nuts ;)

a number of people here have posted coincidences for which they have no logical explanation.

This discussion is just going in circles now. That it is a coincidence IS the logical explanation!
 
I thought that maybe you carried your own little universe with you where ever you went,
Yes, but it's a great big universe. :)

and god has forsaken Sweden? Good, that'll hopefully mean fewer nuts ;)
Actually, I hope to visit Sweden one day. I'll let you know when so you can stay inside. ;) By the way, my favorite musical group is ABBA.

This discussion is just going in circles now. That it is a coincidence IS the logical explanation!
But, dearest Fran, that is the ultimate in a circular explanation. Do you have a model that explains all coincidences logically, or is it simply a matter of faith that your worldview can't possibly be wrong?

P.S. Do you ever sleep?
 
Yes, but it's a great big universe. :)

Well, yeah, it sure isn't the same as mine :)

Actually, I hope to visit Sweden one day. I'll let you know when so you can stay inside. ;) By the way, my favorite musical group is ABBA.

Why would I want to stay inside? You're big, strong, aggressive and scary? :)

But, dearest Fran, that is the ultimate in a circular explanation. Do you have a model that explains all coincidences logically, or is it simply a matter of faith that your worldview can't possibly be wrong?

Dearest, dearest Rodney... that doesn't make sense! :) And I can ask the same of your world view!

P.S. Do you ever sleep?

Not much, and never at nights. Why do you ask?
 
Last edited:
Well, yeah, it sure isn't the same as mine :)
Oh, I don't know about that, but it is interesting how perceptions can differ, isn't it?

Why would I want to stay inside? You're big, strong, aggressive and scary? :)
No, I'm a teddy bear. Isn't it obvious from my posts? ;)

Dearest, dearest Rodney... that doesn't make sense! :) And I can ask the same of your world view!
My worldview has been molded by my personal experiences, which tell me that there is such a thing as synchronicity.

Not much, and never at nights. Why do you ask?
Only because when I'm posting in the evening from the Eastern United States, you generally promptly respond, when it's 2-5 A.M. in Sweden. Do you work what we call the "graveyard shift" (about 11 P.M. to 7 A.M.), or are you just a night person?
 
Hi Rodney.

Can you give us examples of those personal experiences that prove synchronicity?

Thanks!
 
Last edited:
Oh, I don't know about that, but it is interesting how perceptions can differ, isn't it?

I'll agree on that!

No, I'm a teddy bear. Isn't it obvious from my posts? ;)

Quite! That's why the advice to stay indoors surprised me ;)

My worldview has been molded by my personal experiences, which tell me that there is such a thing as synchronicity.

Now, see... Even if people's personal experiences is very interesting in some cases, it really can't be used to prove such things. That's why I prefer to base my world-view on a source that is more reliable when it comes to things like this. That is, scientific evidence.

Only because when I'm posting in the evening from the Eastern United States, you generally promptly respond, when it's 2-5 A.M. in Sweden. Do you work what we call the "graveyard shift" (about 11 P.M. to 7 A.M.), or are you just a night person?

I am a night person, and I have a work that allows me to indulge in being one. :)
 
Hi Rodney.

Can you give us examples of those personal experiences that prove synchronicity?

Thanks!
I can, but I don't think that they would be convincing to you or anyone else here. Nevertheless, I'll throw one pretty big coincidence out for your reading pleasure:

One day a number of years ago I was looking at an atlas in my office about mid-morning when a female work colleague walked by and observed what I was doing. We had the following conversation:

She: "What are you doing, looking for the wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald?"

Me: "No, I'm planning a trip. But what do you mean by 'the wreck of
the Edmund Fitzgerald'?"

She: "Oh, you know. That song by Gordon Lightfoot."

Me: "I'm not familar with that one. How does it go?"

She: "Well, it's a real long song about a ship that sank in the Great
Lakes a few years ago."

Me: "Oh, yeah. I remember that incident, but I didn't know there was
a song about it."

She: "Well, there is. But I guess you don't hear it that much on the
radio because of its length."

Me: "Well, if I ever hear it, I'll let you know."

We then went on to talk about other things. Late that afternoon, I
got a ride home from work (back then I normally took the bus). I had
no intention of going out again once I entered my home, but my
wife was preparing dinner and she informed me that we needed some
milk. I stalled for as long as I could, hoping to delay the inevitable. But finally, I walked to my car to go to the supermarket. When I started my car, the radio came on, with the final portion of a song. Specifically, the very first words I heard were "the Edmund Fitzgerald", followed by:

"The legend lives on from the Chippewa on down
Of the big lake they call Gitche Gumee
Superior, they say, never gives up her dead
When the gales of November come early."
 
I can, but I don't think that they would be convincing to you or anyone else here. Nevertheless, I'll throw one pretty big coincidence out for your reading pleasure:

One day a number of years ago I was looking at an atlas in my office about mid-morning when a female work colleague walked by and observed what I was doing. We had the following conversation:

She: "What are you doing, looking for the wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald?"

Me: "No, I'm planning a trip. But what do you mean by 'the wreck of
the Edmund Fitzgerald'?"

She: "Oh, you know. That song by Gordon Lightfoot."

Me: "I'm not familar with that one. How does it go?"

She: "Well, it's a real long song about a ship that sank in the Great
Lakes a few years ago."

Me: "Oh, yeah. I remember that incident, but I didn't know there was
a song about it."

She: "Well, there is. But I guess you don't hear it that much on the
radio because of its length."

Me: "Well, if I ever hear it, I'll let you know."

We then went on to talk about other things. Late that afternoon, I
got a ride home from work (back then I normally took the bus). I had
no intention of going out again once I entered my home, but my
wife was preparing dinner and she informed me that we needed some
milk. I stalled for as long as I could, hoping to delay the inevitable. But finally, I walked to my car to go to the supermarket. When I started my car, the radio came on, with the final portion of a song. Specifically, the very first words I heard were "the Edmund Fitzgerald", followed by:

"The legend lives on from the Chippewa on down
Of the big lake they call Gitche Gumee
Superior, they say, never gives up her dead
When the gales of November come early."

And you've no doubt kept track of the number of times you had a conversation that made mention of a song, and did not hear it on the radio for some unspecified range of time later that day?

By the way, that song still gets plenty of airplay. I probably hear it at least once a week on the classic rock station I listen to a lot.

You still don't seem to understand that you're dealing with very large numbers (the number of times a coincidence could occur) and a very wide and flexible definition of coincidence (in other words--no one said ahead of time that you'd hear this song on the radio--what if you missed the song, but heard the DJ talking about it? What if you immediately heard another Gordon Lightfoot--one of my favorite artists, by the way--song?)

So you're taking an occurrence which is fully explained as a coincidence, denying that perfectly logical explanation, and then trying to read in some vague significance where there is none.
 
And you've no doubt kept track of the number of times you had a conversation that made mention of a song, and did not hear it on the radio for some unspecified range of time later that day?

By the way, that song still gets plenty of airplay. I probably hear it at least once a week on the classic rock station I listen to a lot.

You still don't seem to understand that you're dealing with very large numbers (the number of times a coincidence could occur) and a very wide and flexible definition of coincidence (in other words--no one said ahead of time that you'd hear this song on the radio--what if you missed the song, but heard the DJ talking about it? What if you immediately heard another Gordon Lightfoot--one of my favorite artists, by the way--song?)

So you're taking an occurrence which is fully explained as a coincidence, denying that perfectly logical explanation, and then trying to read in some vague significance where there is none.
As I stated: "I can, but I don't think that they would be convincing to you or anyone else here." Synchronicity is a personal thing. By the way, I find your reliance on Robert Todd Carroll amusing. Carroll is not a scientist, but a philosopher who has trouble keeping simple facts straight, such as his assertion that Edgar Cayce was the first to recommend the use of laetrile to treat cancer, when laetrile had not even been synthesized during Cayce's lifetime. As Richard Milton notes about Carroll's discussion of synchronicity:

"Carroll carefully neglects to mention that the theory of synchronicity was proposed not by Jung alone but jointly with Wolfgang Pauli, who was Professor of Theoretical Physics at Princeton, a member of Niels Bohr's team that laid the foundations of Quantum Theory and who won the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1945. There thus exists a reasonable probability that the originator of synchronicity theory knew somewhat more about science than Carroll does. Asking 'what evidence is there?' for an explanatory theory that has been advanced specifically to account for previously unexplained evidence is a question even Homer Simpson would blush to ask." See http://www.alternativescience.com/skeptic's_dictionary.htm
 
Originally Posted by FSM
Hi Rodney.

Can you give us examples of those personal experiences that prove synchronicity?

Thanks!

I can, but I don't think that they would be convincing to you or anyone else here. Nevertheless, I'll throw one pretty big coincidence out for your reading pleasure:

Would it still be an example of synchronicity if you found out that your colleague couldn't stop thinking about the song after your conversation, so when she got home that night, she put in a request at the radio station?

Similarly, would your previous example of finding your neighbour in Timbuktu still be synchronicity if you had both visited the travel agency down the block in preparation for your vacation and they just happened to be running a special on a trip to Timbuktu?

Linda
 
... By the way, I find your reliance on Robert Todd Carroll amusing. Carroll is not a scientist, but a philosopher who has trouble keeping simple facts straight, such as his assertion that Edgar Cayce was the first to recommend the use of laetrile to treat cancer, when laetrile had not even been synthesized during Cayce's lifetime.

Laetrile is purified amygdalin, a chemical extract of apricots and almonds since 1830. In one reading, Cayce (1877-1945) recommends eating almonds for the vitamin inside to help recovery from cancer.

As Richard Milton notes about Carroll's discussion of synchronicity:
"Carroll carefully neglects to mention that the theory of synchronicity was proposed not by Jung alone but jointly with Wolfgang Pauli, who was Professor of Theoretical Physics at Princeton, a member of Niels Bohr's team that laid the foundations of Quantum Theory and who won the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1945.

Pauli had a severe breakdown in 1931 and became a patient of Jung's. He helped critique Jung's theory. In subsequent years, Pauli came to believe that his mere presence in a laboratory, or sometimes just in the same city as the laboratory, was enough to cause lab equipment to self-destruct.

There thus exists a reasonable probability that the originator of synchronicity theory knew somewhat more about science than Carroll does.

But the vast majority of scientists, many who know more about science than Pauli, think synchronicity is bunk.

Asking 'what evidence is there?' for an explanatory theory that has been advanced specifically to account for previously unexplained evidence is a question even Homer Simpson (:homersimp "d-oh!") would blush to ask." [my italics (& smiley)]

What "previously unexplained evidence"? "Coincidences"? They're already explained, as coincidences. Synchronicity is an alternative theory: asking for evidence it explains coincidences better than statistical theory is called science.

See http://www.alternativescience.com/skeptic's_dictionary.htm

That link showcased powers of reasoning that would make Ralph Wiggum blush.
 
Would it still be an example of synchronicity if you found out that your colleague couldn't stop thinking about the song after your conversation, so when she got home that night, she put in a request at the radio station?
The coincidence would certainly have been diminished, but there would remain the matter of the uncanny timing of me immediately hearing the words "the Edmund Fitzgerald" when I started my car, plus the fact that there are dozens of radio stations in the area where we live. By the way, when this happened, as I sat in my car listening to the end of the song, it dawned on me that my work colleague (Maureen) may have played a rather elaborate trick on me. After all, Maureen was the one who made the off-the-wall comment about "the wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald", and she and my wife knew each other. So, I reasoned, perhaps she deliberately threw out that comment, then called my wife to ask her to tell me when I arrived home that we needed milk for dinner. Under that scenario, Maureen would have come to my home prior to my arrival and waited until I arrived. She then would sneak into my car, turn off the car radio, and position herself behind the front seat with a tape of "The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald" that she had recorded from a prior radio broadcast. As soon as I entered the car and started it (it was winter, and so I wouldn't have seen someone positioned behind the front seat because it was dark outside), Maureen would then activate the tape so that the first words I would hear would be "the Edmund Fitzgerald". I took that possibility seriously enough that I got out of my car and opened the back door on the driver's side to make sure that Maureen wasn't hiding there. But she wasn't, and neither did she phone in a request to any radio station to play that song. I later asked her what caused her to make the comment she did, and she said it was just something that popped into her head. (Another point is that I was not looking at a map of the Great Lakes, but rather of the Mediterranean.)

Similarly, would your previous example of finding your neighbour in Timbuktu still be synchronicity if you had both visited the travel agency down the block in preparation for your vacation and they just happened to be running a special on a trip to Timbuktu? Linda
No, because that logical possibility would have immediately occurred to me.
 
Laetrile is purified amygdalin, a chemical extract of apricots and almonds since 1830. In one reading, Cayce (1877-1945) recommends eating almonds for the vitamin inside to help recovery from cancer.
Nice try, but amygdalin is made from bitter almonds, not sweet ones. Cayce often recommended sweet almonds as a cancer preventative (not to recover from cancer), but not bitter ones. Was Cayce's recommendation sound? Check out this link: http://in.news.yahoo.com/040329/137/2c9io.html

The beginning reads:

"Vitamin E protects against at least two common forms of cancer -- prostate and bladder -- but popping supplements is probably not the best way to get the vital nutrient, researchers said on Sunday.

"Two studies found that people who either ate the most vitamin E containing food or who had the highest levels in the blood were the least likely to have cancer.

"But the researchers also noted that there are several different forms of vitamin E and the kind you eat -- in this case alpha tocopherol -- is key. And the best-absorbed form of alpha tocopherol is not found in supplements but in foods such as sunflower seeds, spinach, almonds and sweet peppers."
 
The coincidence would certainly have been diminished, but there would remain the matter of the uncanny timing of me immediately hearing the words "the Edmund Fitzgerald" when I started my car, plus the fact that there are dozens of radio stations in the area where we live. By the way, when this happened, as I sat in my car listening to the end of the song, it dawned on me that my work colleague (Maureen) may have played a rather elaborate trick on me. After all, Maureen was the one who made the off-the-wall comment about "the wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald", and she and my wife knew each other. So, I reasoned, perhaps she deliberately threw out that comment, then called my wife to ask her to tell me when I arrived home that we needed milk for dinner. Under that scenario, Maureen would have come to my home prior to my arrival and waited until I arrived. She then would sneak into my car, turn off the car radio, and position herself behind the front seat with a tape of "The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald" that she had recorded from a prior radio broadcast. As soon as I entered the car and started it (it was winter, and so I wouldn't have seen someone positioned behind the front seat because it was dark outside), Maureen would then activate the tape so that the first words I would hear would be "the Edmund Fitzgerald". I took that possibility seriously enough that I got out of my car and opened the back door on the driver's side to make sure that Maureen wasn't hiding there. But she wasn't, and neither did she phone in a request to any radio station to play that song. I later asked her what caused her to make the comment she did, and she said it was just something that popped into her head. (Another point is that I was not looking at a map of the Great Lakes, but rather of the Mediterranean.)

No, because that logical possibility would have immediately occurred to me.

So it isn't synchronicity if the connection is obvious, but as long as you don't investigate for a connection, or an incomplete investigation is not revealing, it can be called a synchronicity?

Can you tell that I find the "as long as I don't know any better, I can believe what I want" approach to knowledge particularly distasteful?

Linda
 
One of the things I dislike about Synchronicity is that it is useless. As an acausal explanation, it doesn't allow for prediction or novel connections. One of the amazing things about scientific exploration is the ability to make novel connections - connections that otherwise would never occur to us. Synchronicity is simply boring and unimaginative.

Linda
 
The coincidence would certainly have been diminished, but there would remain the matter of the uncanny timing of me immediately hearing the words "the Edmund Fitzgerald" when I started my car, plus the fact that there are dozens of radio stations in the area where we live.

How can a coincidence be "diminished"? I think you mean how unlikely it seemed or something like that.

Again, it shows that you don't really understand what coincidence is.

After the fact, you claim that it's significant that you heard the words "the Edmund Fitzgerald" right when you turned on the radio. This was some hours after your conversation right? How long would the window have been open for this to still be a remarkable occurrence to you? What if it happened the day after the conversation? What if the first words you heard were "Gordon Lightfoot"? What if the first words you heard were from the song itself?

You can't possibly know how many times you've heard the song or song title before without noticing it. So the target for a "hit" is a huge and undefined one. And unlikely events happen to people everyday.

A one in a million event will happen about a thousand times if you have a billion tries.

You dismiss Carroll's essay on the law of truly large numbers without responding to it at all. Instead you attack the person, and then try to make a bogus argument from authority by pointing out a proponent of synchronicity. I can tell you this, no scientist supports synchronicity for scientific reasons.

fls said:
Rodney said:
No, because that logical possibility would have immediately occurred to me.
So it isn't synchronicity if the connection is obvious, but as long as you don't investigate for a connection, or an incomplete investigation is not revealing, it can be called a synchronicity?
So synchronicity is admittedly nothing but an argument from ignorance, at best.

Even if there is no connection, there is a perfectly logical explanation for improbably events. It's called coincidence, and you can easily demonstrate that it happens with some regularity owing to the huge numbers involved.
 
Nice try, but amygdalin is made from bitter almonds, not sweet ones. Cayce often recommended sweet almonds as a cancer preventative (not to recover from cancer), but not bitter ones. [my bold] ...
from edgarcayce.org:
He did suggest the use of them to several people after they had a cancerous growth removed...
so, recovering from cancer treatment.

Amygdalin is present in sweet almonds as well; but I think you're right, based on this reference at least, claiming Cayce recommended laetrile against cancer seems a spurious association. (Or is it? Remember: Cayce predicted that Atlantis would surface in 1969 -- 38 years ago. Pauli became a patient of Jung 38 years prior to that -- in 1931. The chemical formula of pure amygdalin in laetrile is C20H27NO11. "HO" says Santa, and Santa has never had cancer. In laetrile: H_27 + O_11 = 38! :eek: Isn't it rather obvious that Cayce, by prophesying Atlantis would rise up 38 years after the authors of synchronicity met, and 38 years before we the authors of this post about synchronicity met, was utilizing a subtle form of psychic synchronicity to promote laetrile as a treatment for cancer? Something to think about anyway...) :)

I've written to SkepDic asking for verification or correction of the claim re laetrile. Thanks.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom